Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2 3   Go Down

Author Topic: Historical intonation and temperament  (Read 2496 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Historical intonation and temperament
« on: July 22, 2022, 08:38:29 AM »

So I’ve been listening to some recordings of Oscar Woods playing (Hohner 114s in G, D and C) from the 60s, and one of the things that strikes me is how warm and mellow his melodeon sounds, in comparison to the more loud and brash sound I associate with modern one row playing…

Seeing as I will be getting my own one row tuned up soon, I would be interested to know how they used to be tuned in old times, as I would like to get closer to that sound (It is currently ‘Cajun’ tuned so closer to ‘just’ than equal anyway…). I wonder therefore if anyone has had access to an untainted old Hohner 114 and checked the pitches against a tuner, or knows for a fact how they were tuned?..

My guess is, since they were tuned by regular folks, some reference pitch was given, say ‘C’, and the rest of the notes tuned beatless… i.e. ‘E’ 14 cents flat of equal, ‘G’ 2 cents sharp, then pull ‘G’ to match the push, ‘B’ 12 cents flat, ‘D’ 4 cents sharp… ‘F’ is a bit of a mystery but if it were tuned harmonically to ‘G’ it would be considerably flat (over 30 cents) so probably not (although harmonicas were), Finally the stray ‘A’ tuned a pure 5 above ‘D’ (6 cents sharp)

I don’t really want this turning into a discussion about the benefits and what not of equal temperament (I’ve been through that with the harmonica), but I think it’s something of a shame that the vast majority of vintage one rows that have been restored will have been corrupted at the final stage to play ‘in tune’ with certain other instruments, especially since the melodeon was conceived as a solo instrument…

I’m interested to hear your thoughts and observations…

*Edit: with the original reference pitch ‘C’, the ‘F’ could be tuned a pure 4th above ie 2 cents flat relative to equal temperament.

*all notes rounded to the nearest cent.
« Last Edit: July 22, 2022, 08:52:31 AM by Arnold »
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Lester

  • MADman
  • Mods and volunteers
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 9327
  • Hohners'R'me
    • Lester's Melodeon Emporium and Tune-a-Rama
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #1 on: July 22, 2022, 09:41:59 AM »

The problem with an 'untainted old Hohner 114' is it will be in Hohner factory tuning which is just poor so any box that sounds 'good' will have almost certainly have been visited by a tuner at sometime since it left the factory.

Winston Smith

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4066
  • AKA Edward Jennings
    • "Our Luxor B&B" Luxor life, slice by slice.
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #2 on: July 22, 2022, 10:05:47 AM »

I have to wonder, has Hohner factory tuning always been judged to be poor?
Logged
At last, broken and resigned to accept conformity.
Oh, how I LOVE Big Brother!

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #3 on: July 22, 2022, 10:12:38 AM »

I don’t think that is the case. Even harmonicas costing pennies were tuned to a high standard to just intonation. Old recordings are testament to this. Regular folks weren’t tuning them, they were throwing them away after a few months of use, and they likely had no idea how to, or the tools required…
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #4 on: July 22, 2022, 10:31:39 AM »

Also, even if you accept a certain margin of error, it would still be in relation to a certain underlying standard…
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #5 on: July 22, 2022, 12:34:51 PM »

As a point of reference, I have an old Hohner ‘Echo’ tremolo harmonica in C which is tuned exactly as I described, (and with the F tuned over 30 cents ‘flat’). The reedplates and cover plates are nailed together, so I can be sure that it remains in factory tuned condition, probably untouched for over 50 years…
« Last Edit: July 22, 2022, 12:37:26 PM by Arnold »
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #6 on: July 22, 2022, 05:22:43 PM »

I’ve seen and tuned a lot of Hohners from 1930s onwards, and I can’t recall finding an unrestored one that was bit tuned in ET.  Older makes of German melodeons are often tuned to make most intervals  purer than ET.  Do you know what makes and models of box the old recordings used?
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

stevejay

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 709
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #7 on: July 22, 2022, 06:27:28 PM »

How does a melodeon sound in meantone?

I would imagine very nice thirds, especially when alone.
Logged

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #8 on: July 22, 2022, 06:52:00 PM »

I’ve seen and tuned a lot of Hohners from 1930s onwards, and I can’t recall finding an unrestored one that was bit tuned in ET.  Older makes of German melodeons are often tuned to make most intervals  purer than ET.  Do you know what makes and models of box the old recordings used?

Hmm, ok, that’s interesting. Could just be a combination of my ears playing tricks on me and confirmation bias, as I was looking for a reason why Oscar Woods’ melodeon sounded so mellow and good (could also be the vinyl effect) and thought I’d sussed it!.. He played Hohner 114 in all his recordings in the key of G and D, and latterly C (unless any earlier evidence crops up). For example, when I listened to the opening notes of Oscar Woods’ Jig - EDC EDC, I heard the E slightly ‘flat’… It should be clearer on a slow waltz if this is the case, or maybe my ears just aren’t that good!.. 🤔
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #9 on: July 22, 2022, 06:57:20 PM »

How does a melodeon sound in meantone?

I would imagine very nice thirds, especially when alone.

I found some interesting posts on a concertina website about this. 1/4 comma perhaps a little drastic, 1/5 comma less so but pretty sweet… Early Wheatstones apparently have different buttons for sharps and flats suggesting they were indeed different pitches. My personal preference, with some background in baroque music, would be for some kind of circulating temperament assuming all chromatic notes present, ie meantone 5ths around the white notes, and pure 5ths around the black to join everything back up again…
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Squeaky Pete

  • Squeaky Pete
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1327
  • Re-hohn a Hohner
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #10 on: July 22, 2022, 07:39:29 PM »

Mel Stevens turned up to a session with a one row he'd tunes to just intonation.
Everybody stopped to listen because a Melodeon had never sounded so good, than Alan Day joined in on Anglo and it all went to pot. It sounded awful.
Back to the drawing board.
The compromise I have made is 3rds and 7ths 10 cents flat. Not enough to sound bad with PAs and Anglos, but goes well with fiddles who probably flatten those notes without realising.
People do remark that this sounds different to the usual 114 and wonder how it has been improved.
Logged
Poker work DG.
Pariselle 2.6 DG, Ex-Club IIIBS CF,
Matching Liliputs in CF and DG,
Lots of sickly Hohners needing TLC,
Bassoon, Various Bagpipes........

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #11 on: July 22, 2022, 07:39:56 PM »

It is possible to construct a tuning scheme for a one row that takes advantage of the fact that only 1 3 and 5 can sound together on push and the other 4 notes on pull.  Paul Groff put me onto this.  Many older German one rows are tuned rather like this.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #12 on: July 22, 2022, 08:52:50 PM »

Mel Stevens turned up to a session with a one row he'd tunes to just intonation.
Everybody stopped to listen because a Melodeon had never sounded so good, than Alan Day joined in on Anglo and it all went to pot. It sounded awful.
Back to the drawing board.
The compromise I have made is 3rds and 7ths 10 cents flat. Not enough to sound bad with PAs and Anglos, but goes well with fiddles who probably flatten those notes without realising.
People do remark that this sounds different to the usual 114 and wonder how it has been improved.

And that's the basic problem. I tuned a Lachenal C/G concertina to just/mean temperament many years ago and it sounded fantastic on its own, but awful as soon as any equal-tempered instrument joined in.

I also spent ages thinking about what notes and keys you actually had on a two-row concertina/melodeon and eventually came up with a temperament that sounded better still in all the keys you could realistically play in. It wasn't until years later I found I'd reinvented Aaron's quarter-comma temperament 400 years later than originally devised... :-(
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Squeaky Pete

  • Squeaky Pete
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1327
  • Re-hohn a Hohner
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #13 on: July 22, 2022, 09:09:30 PM »

And it's much the same problem on nsp
Playing in (nominal) G and D on a standard 7 keyed set, isweetening one scale buggers the other. So it's slightly wrong in both keys. The only true scale is on a simple keyless set, and that's not quite right in the relative minor.
Logged
Poker work DG.
Pariselle 2.6 DG, Ex-Club IIIBS CF,
Matching Liliputs in CF and DG,
Lots of sickly Hohners needing TLC,
Bassoon, Various Bagpipes........

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #14 on: July 22, 2022, 09:16:58 PM »

1/4 comma meantone moves drastically away from equal temperament pretty quickly as you go around the circle (spiral?!) of fifths, and so would sound pretty bad in relation to equally tempered instruments. Other compromises or ‘well’ temperaments are available that sweeten certain keys but wouldn’t clash so badly or possibly barely even noticeably, such as Valotti (6x1/6 comma 5ths and 6x pure fifths).

I’m viewing the melodeon as purely a solo instrument though, so I just want it to have that sweet and mellow ‘vintage’ sound. Some other instruments just about always use some kind of just intonation, such as Irish bagpipes, or any bagpipe or drone type instrument for that matter…

So the original question was just basically asking how old one row Melodeons, say in the 1950s, which I love the sound of, were actually tuned. I came with the assumption that they would be tuned to ‘just intonation’, since that’s how harmonicas were tuned, but it seems this may not be the case after all!..
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Gav Wood

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 99
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #15 on: July 23, 2022, 07:23:59 AM »

It would be useful to have a clip to be able to tell what you mean.
I have little experience of lots of melodeons like others however have gone down my own road of tuning my playing box in quarter comma meantone. I did this because it sounded better than equal temperament.
I however play irish, and in my sessions there are vey few box players, mostly fiddles and flutes. I have also tuned it wetter than the now standard dry galliard tuning you find in itm, so is a bit more forgiving when you do meet other box players.
I think i could not play in the box heavy english sessions i used to frequent due to the tuning.
It has however been noted that my box is not in tune with a concertina player i play with occasionally.

In my opinion it is well worth trying these things out to see if you like it if you can tune yourself. If not you need to find someone with non et tuned instruments and borrow one to see what the advantages and disadvantages are.

This way MADness lies.

Logged

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #16 on: July 23, 2022, 09:26:33 AM »

That’s interesting. Do violinists and flute players automatically and instinctively adjust their intonation to match yours then do you think, or do you have to let them know?..

It certainly would be one of many routes to MADness, yes I agree, which is why I am happy to accept the authority of iconic players on the matter, particularly Oscar Woods, who it would seem did play in equal temperament after all (would help if I had a melodeon that matched his key on the recording I was listening to for comparison, ie the later ones in C, since the earlier ones are slightly ‘in-between’ keys, perhaps A=335HZ)

Having said that I do like the sound of the Cajun tuning box so maybe some sort of compromise…
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Rog

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2525
  • Repair and tuning in Hants
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #17 on: July 23, 2022, 09:30:09 AM »

Obvs fiddles are fretless, so can a decent player can adjust the notes to fall in line with meantone tuned melodoen?

Gav Wood

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 99
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #18 on: July 23, 2022, 09:39:12 AM »

Now this is somewhere i do have experience being a decent fiddle player myself. Toot toot own trumpet etc.
i can fit my fiddle playing to any tuning, and often have to. Flutes are often/ usually tuned sharp even in sessions with good players, and pipes are not tuned in et. Even in the same session you can have different tunings depending who starts and any fiddle player should be able to fit with that, flutes also can play to different tunings on the fly. The clash comes when two boxes are together, but you will also find anglo concertinas are often or usually not in et.
Logged

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #19 on: July 23, 2022, 10:07:20 AM »

Thanks Gav, I’ve been wanting to know that for ages. I guess just like how choir singers naturally adjust to the temperament of Church organs (quite often in ‘well’ rather than equal temperament) without even knowing it, to a competent fiddle player these microtonal adjustments become just as natural and subconscious…

Anyway, apologies to everyone for opening this can of worms based on a false assumption lol but getting melodeons tuned is not cheap, so I want to make sure I’m happy with my choices!..
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997
Pages: [1] 2 3   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal