Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2] 3   Go Down

Author Topic: Historical intonation and temperament  (Read 2478 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Peadar

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2039
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #20 on: July 23, 2022, 01:41:22 PM »

It is possible to construct a tuning scheme for a one row that takes advantage of the fact that only 1 3 and 5 can sound together on push and the other 4 notes on pull.  Paul Groff put me onto this.  Many older German one rows are tuned rather like this.

And of it is in C it will marcg perfectly with a set of Scottish Small pipes in C....
Logged

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #21 on: July 23, 2022, 02:05:04 PM »

I don't know what tuning Oscar's instruments used, but it just made my springer spaniel howl. He has a sensitive ear.
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

Gav Wood

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 99
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #22 on: July 23, 2022, 02:45:18 PM »

An example of tuning i would like to play in but people look at me strangely. Ignore the tennis bat.

https://youtu.be/wDJK_GeLyGU

Thats so far out of et, and a sign of what you should be able to play in. So a fiddle player can play just intonation in any key, and will be able to play with a just tuned box, but the box will only be able to play in home key or maybe one either side.

My box is tuned in quarter comma meantone in D but is a bc box. This gives me best sound in d, then g and a ok, then further you get from the home tuning the worse it sounds. Supposedly.
Logged

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #23 on: July 23, 2022, 03:39:23 PM »

So I’ve been listening to some recordings of Oscar Woods playing (Hohner 114s in G, D and C) from the 60s, and one of the things that strikes me is how warm and mellow his melodeon sounds, in comparison to the more loud and brash sound I associate with modern one row playing…


A question nobody has asked so far: whether now they sound warm and mellow or not, are we sure that the recordings made in the 60s in themselves are reflecting the real way the instruments sounded like?

Most of those recordings weren't made using professional equipments, and the professional equipments at the time had a number of limitations in comparison with the ones we use today..

Also, those I've listened to were in mono, and the recording of a melodeon is really influenced by the position of the microphone.

Don't forget that a number of the albums of the professional performers of the British folk revival still in the early 70s were recorded in mono without any multi track equipment, and the balance of the instruments volumes was left to the distance of the perfomers from the microphone.
« Last Edit: July 23, 2022, 04:02:38 PM by GBbox »
Logged

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #24 on: July 23, 2022, 06:56:08 PM »

I miss those inbetween notes from my blues harmonica days. I remember a recording engineer asking me if I was playing a note flat or maybe sharp when I was bending a tonic down to its flat 7 I think. I’m thinking it sounds fine, and I’m pretty sure it does, but he’s looking at a computer screen telling him it’s off relative to equal. He probably ‘fixed it in the mix’… Hmm, I wonder if some of these older ITM guys were actually sneaking a bit of blues in, if I’m allowed to say that?..

It’s a good point about the recordings but I think the limitations, at least with regards to reasonably decent technology of the day, and competent sound engineers, lend a desirable quality to the sound that is now much sought after. Things like tape saturation and valve pre-amps give that ‘warm’ sound…

A lot is also down to the player as well for sure. Oscar Woods just tends to coax the notes out of the instrument rather than hammering them out…
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #25 on: July 23, 2022, 07:11:12 PM »

... are we sure that the recordings made in the 60s in themselves are reflecting the real way the instruments sounded like?...

The only recordings I know of, first hand, are the nineteen on The Pigeon On The Gate album.These are clearly amateur and date from the 70s, back in the days when the portable recording studio was a tape cassette with a built in mic (we were easier to please back then).  For all their limitations they convey a reasonable idea of what the instruments sounded like,  I have to agree that mellow is a good description for Oscar Wood's  contributions, though I wouldn't use that description for all the material on there. I expect that musicians were as interested than as they now in sounding the way they wanted to. I can't imagine they would rely on factory tuning any more than we do. Fettling isn't a 21st C invention.
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #26 on: July 23, 2022, 07:55:17 PM »


The only recordings I know of, first hand, are the nineteen on The Pigeon On The Gate album.These are clearly amateur and date from the 70s, back in the days when the portable recording studio was a tape cassette with a built in mic (we were easier to please back then).  For all their limitations they convey a reasonable idea of what the instruments sounded like,  I have to agree that mellow is a good description for Oscar Wood's  contributions, though I wouldn't use that description for all the material on there. I expect that musicians were as interested than as they now in sounding the way they wanted to. I can't imagine they would rely on factory tuning any more than we do. Fettling isn't a 21st C invention.

Yes, the earliest of the recordings on that album were made in 1959, tucked at the end of disc 2, and demonstrate Percy Brown’s recorded playing at its finest. Those guys were already getting pretty old even then, for the time… There are also some lovely recordings of Oscar Woods from 1968, with some of the best being in D, so I’ll be learning those… A master of the waltz for sure… A few other hidden gems too, once you’ve sifted through the countless renditions of ‘Manchester Hornpipe’!..

But it’s the album English Country Music from East Anglia recorded between 1972 and 1973 and released by Topic that probably raised awareness amongst the folk crowd and became the blueprint for that style… I would say the sound quality on that album is pretty much flawless…
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #27 on: July 23, 2022, 08:23:45 PM »


It’s a good point about the recordings but I think the limitations, at least with regards to reasonably decent technology of the day, and competent sound engineers, lend a desirable quality to the sound that is now much sought after. Things like tape saturation and valve pre-amps give that ‘warm’ sound…


No doubt, in the early days of the digital recordings we had reasons to regret the warmth of some the older analogue ones. Yet, today there are dozens of software plug ins that are able to mimic the behaviour of the analogic hardware equipments. I've a friend that runs a home studio, and I can witness that what you can to add smoothness and warmth to a digital recording today in DAW is amazing.

The problem, really, is how much of the character of a recording is to be credited to the magic of a sound engineer and the tools he uses, and how much to its fidelity to the real performance. Try to compare, as far the commercial artists are concerned, the studio albums with the live ones. In general, the sound of the live recordings is definitely lower than that of the ones made in the studio, and that means that in the end what we really appreciate in the studio recordings is the editing. In other words, an illusion...

Yet, my point was really about the reliability of the recordings of the traditional player quoted by Arnold in terms of audio fidelity. If they were made with cassette tape recorders with a built in microphone, like Greg suggests, and eventually in a crowded pub, than the idea of a a comparison with the sound of the instruments today we listen to is little more than a joke. If the recordings had been made with a Nagra, or some other top quality potable recorder, and in an acoustically neutral room – and I guess some of them actually were -, than a comparison would make sense.
Logged

Winston Smith

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4066
  • AKA Edward Jennings
    • "Our Luxor B&B" Luxor life, slice by slice.
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #28 on: July 23, 2022, 08:36:29 PM »

"what we really appreciate in the studio recordings is the editing. In other words, an illusion..."

Well said that man! Even in a 'live' performance we can be deceived.

At a recent concert by the Spookymen (whom I admire greatly, by the way) the Spookmeister several times asked the sound engineer to give them a "little bit more reverb" on a couple of particular songs. Thereby doctoring the actual sound that they were producing.
Logged
At last, broken and resigned to accept conformity.
Oh, how I LOVE Big Brother!

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #29 on: July 23, 2022, 09:07:39 PM »

The audio quality of the recordings on English Country Music from East Anglia is very high quality and I believe gives an honest representation of how the instruments sounded at that time and place. There are no background noises, no other instruments or added effects, not even reverb… I would guess what I am hearing is around 95% performance, 3% mastering magic dust and 2% vinyl ‘warmth’. I think it’s really just the way Oscar plays with style and grace that sets him apart for me…
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #30 on: July 23, 2022, 10:12:38 PM »

The audio quality of the recordings on English Country Music from East Anglia is very high quality and I believe gives an honest representation of how the instruments sounded at that time and place. There are no background noises, no other instruments or added effects, not even reverb… I would guess what I am hearing is around 95% performance, 3% mastering magic dust and 2% vinyl ‘warmth’. I think it’s really just the way Oscar plays with style and grace that sets him apart for me…

The average audio quality of recordings of English Country Music form East Anglia was decent for the period, but  if I'm not wrong they are mono recordings, and what I am questioning is not the fact that they could have been edited, but how the equipment used was reliable in terms of audio fidelity. And this has nothing to do with the playing style of Oscar Woods, that was an excellent musician.

Let me tell you a story. When I got interested in English music, and I started to play the D/G melodeon, I bought a copy of the Bob Cann Topic LP. He was another excellent performer, and while a number of the available recordings of English traditional players, not just on the melodeon, had the hallmarks of the valuable documents, but nothing more, those on that album to me sounded as accomplished performances.

A few months later, while on holiday in England, I met a melodeon player that had seen Bob Cann playing a number of times, and I told him that I intended to took him as a model. He shook his head, and simply told me: that's unrealistic, too much emphasis on the left hand, Bob doesn't sound like on that record at all.

I've never heard Bob Cann playing live, so I'll never know if he was right or wrong, but that gave me a lot of food for thoughts. A recording that sounds realistic is not necessarily a high fidelity one...
Logged

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #31 on: July 24, 2022, 07:52:24 AM »

Since the left hand does sound quite quiet I guess it’s possible that the recordings were made with two mics directed at either end of the instrument, then mixed to mono with the right hand higher in the mix?..

Anyway, this is the only video recording of Oscar Woods that I’m aware of, although not solo it gives some idea:

https://vimeo.com/11033996/description
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #32 on: July 24, 2022, 10:43:11 AM »

Since the left hand does sound quite quiet I guess it’s possible that the recordings were made with two mics directed at either end of the instrument, then mixed to mono with the right hand higher in the mix?..

https://vimeo.com/11033996/description

Picked up the old LP I had not used in ages. I was wrong, the recording were made by Tony Engle in the early seventies, and they are stereophonic.

I still would like to know which recorder was used and how the microphones were positioned, since  this could really make a huge difference in terms of audio fidelity, and to be totally honest I can't tell that to me the sound of the melodeon used by Oscar Wood sound radically different from the sound of those I can listen to today.

Given but not granted there was/is the difference you perceive, I would say it should be attributed not to the pitch of the notes, but to the degree of vibrato and, above all, the quality of the reeds.

In the 70s and in the 80s I remember that here in Italy the melodeon and the accordeon players were concerned with the pretended superior quality of the so called hand made reeds above the industrial reeds. And I say pretended superior quality because the difference in terms of quality had been evident up to twenty years earlier, but definitely wasn't that relevant then. The cheap reeds of a Honher Pokerwork like the ones I played at the time had a noticeable faster attack than the expensive hand made reeds that were used, on request, on the Castagnari instruments. Irrelevant for those who played cross row style, but an handicap for the press and draw players, who paid more - a lot more!-  to get less.



Logged

penn

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 574
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #33 on: July 24, 2022, 05:34:04 PM »


Picked up the old LP I had not used in ages. I was wrong, the recording were made by Tony Engle in the early seventies, and they are stereophonic.
I still would like to know which recorder was used and how the microphones were positioned, since  this could really make a huge difference in terms of audio fidelity, and to be totally honest I can't tell that to me the sound of the melodeon used by Oscar Wood sound radically different from the sound of those I can listen to today.


This articlehttps://theses.ncl.ac.uk/jspui/bitstream/10443/3720/1/Ord%2C%20M.%202017.pdf

(I cannot claim to have read it in full ) may have some answers.
It’s a (substantial) paper about Recording practices in the folk revival between 1950 and 75 and seems to have had some input from Bill Leader , Tony Engle and others, all experienced and professional recording engineers of their time and the genre. Personally I would think that the fact that Tony Engle worked on a recording is probably more significant than the manufacturer of the microphone and tape recorder - from his great experience he would know the best and most practical positioning of the microphones for a melodeon. I can’t think of anyone better qualified to provide a realistic recording.
Gren
« Last Edit: July 25, 2022, 07:13:08 PM by penn »
Logged
Hohners, Dino Baffetti, Lilly, Benny + a lot of junk.

Dennis Steckley

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 77
  • Club System!
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #34 on: July 25, 2022, 07:08:07 PM »

"My box is tuned in quarter comma meantone in D but is a bc box. This gives me best sound in d, then g and a ok, then further you get from the home tuning the worse it sounds. Supposedly."

In tuning pipe organs, those that are farther away are called "wolf keys."  How good they sound depends upon your ear.  I find, for example, that to many non-musician people, a piano that hasn't been tuned in 20 years sounds fine while it absolutely drives musicians up the wall because it is so out of tune.
Logged
Hohner Victoria Club ii, Hohner Club III M, Hohner Liliput, Hohner Preciosa, Hohner Piccoletta, Hohner Overture LMMM (and three PA's, including one that is the same size as a Preciosa)

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #35 on: July 25, 2022, 08:05:29 PM »


This articlehttps://theses.ncl.ac.uk/jspui/bitstream/10443/3720/1/Ord%2C%20M.%202017.pdf

(I cannot claim to have read it in full ) may have some answers.
It’s a (substantial) paper about Recording practices in the folk revival between 1950 and 75 and seems to have had some input from Bill Leader , Tony Engle and others, all experienced and professional recording engineers of their time and the genre. Personally I would think that the fact that Tony Engle worked on a recording is probably more significant than the manufacturer of the microphone and tape recorder - from his great experience he would know the best and most practical positioning of the microphones for a melodeon. I can’t think of anyone better qualified to provide a realistic recording.
Gren

Thanks for the link, looks interesting.

Talking about Tony Engle, if you have read my previous posts you have seen that I did mention a comment about the Bob Cann topic LP. As I made clear I'm not able to deny or confirm, but the album was recored and produced by Engle.

Anyway, there are a number of recordings of Oscar Wood. I wonder if Arnold has made a comparison with the ones on English Country Music from East Anglia.
Logged

penn

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 574
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #36 on: July 26, 2022, 03:37:52 PM »

……….

Talking, about Tony Engle, if you have read my previous posts you have seen that I did mention a comment about the Bob Cann topic LP. As I made clear I'm not able to deny or confirm, but the album was recored and produced by Engle…...

Yes thanks I did see that comment, I’m not sure what to make of it. I can imagine that a recording engineer would try to capture the best sound based on their own experience, and that if Bob was a little bass heavy, he might be inclined to position a microphone(s) to better balance the two sides. I don’t think that would be exactly unrealistic though - an audience member in certain positions might hear the same effect.
I can’t see how an engineer could make Bob a better player but maybe that’s not what the moral of the story was meant to be  (:)
Logged
Hohners, Dino Baffetti, Lilly, Benny + a lot of junk.

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #37 on: July 26, 2022, 07:39:18 PM »



Yes thanks I did see that comment, I’m not sure what to make of it. I can imagine that a recording engineer would try to capture the best sound based on their own experience, and that if Bob was a little bass heavy, he might be inclined to position a microphone(s) to better balance the two sides. I don’t think that would be exactly unrealistic though - an audience member in certain positions might hear the same effect.
I can’t see how an engineer could make Bob a better player but maybe that’s not what the moral of the story was meant to be  (:)

The moral is, quite simply, that given the limitations we face when we record audio and reproduce it, even with an expensive hi fi system, what we consider realistic is not necessarily faithful to the original performance. And this has nothing to do with an attempt to make the musician that is recorded a better player.

With a long lasting interest in both the music production – I mean from the recording to the mixing and mastering – and in the hi fi reproduction, when Arnold describes the Oscar wood's melodeon recordings using terms like warm and mellow, and says that the “modern” instruments in comparison to his ear produce a brash sound, I can't help translating his statements in technical terms. And in technical terms what he's talking about is the emphasis, or lack of, in some frequency ranges. 

That could well be ascribed to the instruments, or to the recordings and/or the hi fi system he uses to reproduce the vinyl or both. Using the good old Occam's razor – the simplest explanation is likely the true one – I tend to think that the problems lay with the recordings and/or the equipment he uses to listen to them. The list of the factors that can dramatically influence the quality of a recording and alter the fidelity of its reproduction is loooong...

Unfortunately the only way to confirm this would be to listen to the Oscar Wood's instrument and to a modern melodeon played live side by side. Yet, to know if Arnold is making a comparison of the Oscar Wood's recording with the instruments he ears played live now, and which is the hi fi system he uses, would give us some hints. And, like in fact I asked in my last post, considering Arnold clearly appreciates Oscar Woods, it would be interesting to know if he has made a comparison between the 1973 Tony Engle recordings and the nineteen 1968  tracks  that can be found on the Veteran Tapes compilation The Pigeon on the Gate.
Logged

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #38 on: July 26, 2022, 07:57:41 PM »

I do indeed own copies of both of those albums and to me the same feel and mellowness comes across, although the quality of the recording is clearly better on ECMfEA. I have been reading some artist profiles and of Oscar Woods it was mentioned that he was fairly economical with bellows movement. This to me suggests he wasn’t blasting air through the reeds as often tends to be the case. So really I think all I am hearing is bellows control and restraint… Ah, I just found this quote in Before the Night was Out from Roger Digby: “…he did not pump the bellows vigorously with waving arms but employed a remarkably short travel…”
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Historical intonation and temperament
« Reply #39 on: July 26, 2022, 08:19:42 PM »

The video you posted previously featuring Oscar playing with Katie Howson shows this clearly.  Katie gives the bellows much more of a workout.

So this suggests another clue.  Reeds go slightly flat when pushed hard, lower pitch reeds more than higher.   So with LMMH voicing the tuning will tend to be less exact when played hard than when played quietly. The L reeds will drop more than the M and the M more than the H.  This could be one explanation of of a harsher sound when a box is played more energetically.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning
Pages: 1 [2] 3   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal