Thanks to all for the replies to my question . There is much more to this subject than I ever imagined ! a great deal beyond my musical knowledge or capability but very interesting to read , is there anywhere published a copy of what scales are possible for a beginner on the D/G. I am at the end of Dave Mallinson Absolute Beginners . Scales in thirds and even sixths I might manage if you think it worth the effort , but I suppose I would just like to improve my fluency of finger work and bellows smoothness probably always working with tunes that are already chorded , however I know to my cost that fingering learnt wrongly is difficult to unlearn !
So keep *uggering on I suppose as Churchill would have said , but I don't suppose he ever played on 2 rows German made !
Peter
There’s another schism amongst the
corps melodeonistae Peter. Those who know what note they are playing, and those who dont.
I transitioned from type to 2 typo 1 😉 in 1995, about a decade in. I suspect that it might usually depend on having learned an instrument ‘formally’. Again both ways work. It’s a most forgiving instrument and you can knock out a passable tune with a beer bottle. Or with the fist of an infant sat on your lap. That used to be a party trick when my kids cousins stayed with us.
But always make it ‘fun’!

[edit] German Hohners started arriving here in bulk about 1960, incidentally. Fairly rare before that. But his opponent was a keen melodeonist. Here’s a bit more fun. Enjoy.
https://youtu.be/FSeSLi4RQ6s (you might have to log in, turn restricted mode=off) 🤣