Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2 3   Go Down

Author Topic: Thirds in or Thirds out.  (Read 5183 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Dick Sadler

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 62
  • Pt.
Thirds in or Thirds out.
« on: November 15, 2022, 02:11:18 PM »

As I have the facility for thirds in or out on my DG Pokerwork is there a general rule of thumb to guide someone with little musical knowledge/theory.
At the moment and as a beginner, my decision as to whether in or out rests solely as to how I think the overall tune sounds, which may be good enough, but is there some musical theory that might be best followed.

Logged
If I didn’t have bad luck, I wouldn’t have any luck at all.....

mselic

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1683
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #1 on: November 15, 2022, 02:25:48 PM »

Thirds ‘out’ allows chords to be either major in minor, which is a must for players such as myself. Leaving the third in allows for a more full sound when playing major chords but is a drawback otherwise. Mine are taped off in all of my boxes and will stay that way always.
Logged
C#/D player

Graham Spencer

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3548
  • MAD as a wet Hohner........
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #2 on: November 15, 2022, 02:26:39 PM »

The only theory I can think of is to go with what sounds good to you.  Musical academicians may differ, but I'm primarily about gut reaction. If it sounds right, it is right......
Logged
Among others, Saltarelle Pastourelle II D/G; Hohner 4-stop 1-rows in C & G; assorted Hohners; 3-voice German (?) G/C of uncertain parentage; lovely little Hlavacek 1-row Heligonka; Bâ™­/Eâ™­ Koch. Newly acquired G/C Hohner Viktoria. Also Fender Jazz bass, Telecaster, Stratocaster, Epiphone Sheraton, Charvel-Jackson 00-style acoustic guitar, Danelectro 12-string and other stuff..........

Squeezing in the Cyprus sunshine

Graham Spencer

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3548
  • MAD as a wet Hohner........
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #3 on: November 15, 2022, 02:29:22 PM »

Thirds ‘out’ allows chords to be either major in minor,

Technically, neither major nor minor - oops, the phantom musical academician must be looking over my shoulder! :D
Logged
Among others, Saltarelle Pastourelle II D/G; Hohner 4-stop 1-rows in C & G; assorted Hohners; 3-voice German (?) G/C of uncertain parentage; lovely little Hlavacek 1-row Heligonka; Bâ™­/Eâ™­ Koch. Newly acquired G/C Hohner Viktoria. Also Fender Jazz bass, Telecaster, Stratocaster, Epiphone Sheraton, Charvel-Jackson 00-style acoustic guitar, Danelectro 12-string and other stuff..........

Squeezing in the Cyprus sunshine

Pete Dunk

  • Typo Expert
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3706
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #4 on: November 15, 2022, 02:41:32 PM »

This is a question that comes up time and again, my best advice is to go with what you hear. Lots of boxes don’t have the option to take the thirds out, if this was terribly wrong nobody would buy them! Most of my boxes either have a stop or have thirdless chords with doubled up fifths, none simply have thirds taped up. The couple of boxes that are without a stop and still have the thirds in have the thirds tuned a few cents flat because I like them that way.
Logged
Squeezing on the Isle of Oxney, UK
Primo (Serenellini) D/G
Isis D/G
Hohner B/E, G/C, C/F, Bb/Eb G/C/F
Liliputs D/G (G scale), C/F, Bb/Eb, Albrecht Custom D/G (G scale)

JohnAndy

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 244
  • John Barber
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #5 on: November 15, 2022, 02:46:18 PM »

Thirds ‘out’ allows chords to be either major in minor,

Technically, neither major nor minor - oops, the phantom musical academician must be looking over my shoulder! :D

Well yes, the left hand chord itself is neither major nor minor, but when combined with an appropriate right hand note, this may result in a major or minor chord, depending on the choice of right hand note.

So I think mselic's statement is in fact correct.
Logged

nigelr

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 526
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #6 on: November 15, 2022, 03:06:40 PM »

My view is it depends on what you're playing as mentioned in this thread previously:

https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=25012.msg297631#msg297631

N :||: :M
Logged
DB Oakwood Super 2 (D/G), Club II (D/G Will Allen layout), Erika (Bb/Eb) and an HA114 in C

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #7 on: November 15, 2022, 03:23:29 PM »

The couple of boxes that are without a stop and still have the thirds in have the thirds tuned a few cents flat because I like them that way.

Yes indeed major thirds in equal temperament are pretty hard on the ear and are much sweeter when the thirds are flattened slightly.  Not minor thirds though, they will sound worse if flattened.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #8 on: November 15, 2022, 03:24:20 PM »

All of the above!!!
If there isn't a musical reason for taking them out, then it is up to you.
I'm definitely a 'thirds in' person, liking the full fat sound to the chords. My very accomplished melodeon playing friend is a 'thirds out' person as he prefers that sound.

Having a recent new box that allows me to play in other keys I'm finding I frequently need to remove thirds cos I haven't got the chords required for the tune.
i.e. for a new tune in Gm I need but haven't got Dm, Gm or Cm but do have Dmaj, Gmaj and Cmaj.
Taking thirds out gives the open chords of D, G and C and I can play the tune requiring these minor chords that I don't have.
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Julian S

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1628
  • D/G Pastourelle 2, Dony, Pokerwork, G/C Pariselle
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #9 on: November 15, 2022, 03:58:37 PM »

One other point (minor or major !) - I reckon thirds in makes bass end sound louder.
For me mostly thirds out but I'm still trying to get the hang of switching thirds in - and extra bass reed mid tune on my Mory...though to my ears it sometimes feels like it's overwhelming the melody. A listener might disagree of course.


Julian




Logged
Old Bones Dance Band

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #10 on: November 15, 2022, 04:12:15 PM »

Definitely go with what sounds right. Everything else is basically a technical explanation of WHY it "sounds right".  ;)

Not mentioned yet: I take thirds out for playing in minor keys. In A minor on a D/G I can substitute Amin and Dmin chords, and put a E fifth under a RH G♯ making E major.
For bouncy dance music, I definitely prefer thirds in for more bass and chord "thump"
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #11 on: November 15, 2022, 04:56:54 PM »

I'm a “thirds in” person too, since the major triads express a different mood than the minor ones, and in an articulated chord progression the contrast between the major and the minor chords add shades that are lost if you mute all the thirds. Yet, there are chances to play a satisfactory chord progression you might need to do it.

Beyond this obvious statement, it's worth remembering that there are usually a number of different possible harmonic progressions for a tune. You might like one more than the others, but they all remain all correct, and sound better than the one you prefer to the ear of another player.

As anybody who has learned at least the foundations of harmony knows, what really matters are not the chords you choose in themselves, but the relation between them. If the enchainments are strong enough, a chord progression can be developed almost independently from the notes of the melody and, even if the limitations of the melodeons mainly lead to use the diatonic triads – i.e. those built using the notes of the scale – there's nothing wrong to go chromatic at least a bit. You really can use a C major chord playing in D major, or – if you haven't hacked those chords, or you can't mute the thirds – an A major chord playing in G, or a B major chord playing in both keys.

In other words: yes, there's some musical theory that might be best followed. Actually... plenty of it! And here I am sorry to tell that, even if this happens rarely, I disagree with Anahata: what sounds right is right if you have an harmonically trained musical era. Dick, if you aren't one of the lucky players who have been blessed by mother nature with a natural musical ear – and considering the question you've asked you probably aren't, just like I wasn't when I picked up the box -, don't give up. The relevant theory can be learn, and the  musical ear can be trained, both melodically and harmonically. Find a good teacher, and take some lessons!



.   
Logged

Becci Pamely-Bast

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 122
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #12 on: November 16, 2022, 06:02:33 AM »

I agree that listening for what sounds right will be the quickest way to decide whether to have thirds in or out, so I reckon you’re doing just fine. If it’s of interest, there is some very simple music theory that will help confirm what your ear is telling you.

Compare each bass chord to the scale the music is played on. For example, your A chord with thirds in is A - C# - E. Without is A - E. Does the melody have a C# in it? If yes, the full chord will fit. If the melody has an C natural in it, it will clash horribly so best to play with thirds out. Repeat for each bass chord and you’ll have an answer.

Of course there are always exceptions, and there are some nice workarounds for certain chords if you prefer to leave thirds in, but the above is a good foundation.
Logged
Find me playing on YouTube

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #13 on: November 16, 2022, 03:16:16 PM »


  On 2 rows it is a minor issue. The only chord that “needs” 3rds out is pull A. That is only if you want tunes in A major, and minor

  A second rank decision  is your push B chord. It is “major” by default, to work with E harmonic minor. If you like that sort of stuff, or Klesmer, or central European and Scandinavian stuff … 3rds out for those tunes.

  The rest depends on whether you like the softer sound of major and minor 7th chords. I call these “cross chords”

   Majors: Try playing pull C chord on an E bass = Cmaj7, or (3rds out), or push Bno 3 on G bass: Gmaj7

   Minors: Try push D on a B bass = Bmin7,   and pull C on an A bass = Am7 (3rds out doesn’t matter here)

  Do you like these, do they suit your music? Go with 3rds out. It’s more flexible. If you perceive them as slushy, then you’re a folky and should keep 3rds in,  other than for special tunes. Which is a long-winded way of saying “trust your ears” 😉
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #14 on: November 16, 2022, 06:15:24 PM »

Some people prefer the thinner sounds of chords thirds  out. Some the more complete sound of thirds in. That's a bit irrelevant, really as all work more, or less, with thirds out, but thirds are an assett. Why waste them?

The real deciders are (for DG players, for other tunings, transpose according to taste):
1. will a chord set clash with the scale you are playing. If all the chords you want are available with thirds in then play that way. If not (e.g., if you need a minor and there is only a major, or vice versa) play thirds out. So, for example, if you're playing a tune in G major, D major or Em you're ok thirds in. If you're playing a tune in A major you need E major, but you only have an E minor, so it's thirds out.

2. Am and Bm are missing from the chord set. C with bass A (Am7ish) and D with Bass B (Bm7ish) make reasonable work arounds in most situations but, they don't  really work where they are the chord of the root note. That is, in A minor keys and B minor keys the A5 and B5 make better options so it's  thirds out.

The further you stray from the home keys of the instrument, the more likely you are be playing thirds out, but don't play that way without understanding why it's best.

And don't get me started on the weirdness of having a B major on if you don't play in keys like E harmonic minor.  I recommend retuning to Bm, but that's another well argued topic.
« Last Edit: November 16, 2022, 06:19:01 PM by Tone Dumb Greg »
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #15 on: November 16, 2022, 07:43:29 PM »


Compare each bass chord to the scale the music is played on. For example, your A chord with thirds in is A - C# - E. Without is A - E. Does the melody have a C# in it? If yes, the full chord will fit. If the melody has an C natural in it, it will clash horribly so best to play with thirds out. Repeat for each bass chord and you’ll have an answer.


Are you sure? Seriuosly, such a drastic statement reminds me of the myth of the bumblebee!

I actually use the C major chord in a number of tunes in D, and occasionally the E major chord too, and it works perfecty. it's called chromatic harmony you know...  you simply have to learn the theory!


« Last Edit: November 16, 2022, 07:48:29 PM by GBbox »
Logged

Dick Rees

  • Neo-Luddite
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1640
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #16 on: November 16, 2022, 07:50:06 PM »


Compare each bass chord to the scale the music is played on. For example, your A chord with thirds in is A - C# - E. Without is A - E. Does the melody have a C# in it? If yes, the full chord will fit. If the melody has an C natural in it, it will clash horribly so best to play with thirds out. Repeat for each bass chord and you’ll have an answer.


Are you sure? Seriuosly, such a drastic statement reminds me of the myth of the bumblebee!

I actually use the C major chord in a number of tunes in D, and occasionally the E major chord too, and it works perfecty. it's called chromatic harmony you know...  you simply have to learn the theory!


1.  Learn the music.
2.  Derive the theory.
Logged
"You're making the wrong mistakes."
...Thelonius Monk

"I never made one of my discoveries through the process of rational thinking."
...Albert Einstein

"If Art Tatum took up classical music seriously, I'd quit my job the next day."
...Vladimir Horowitz

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #17 on: November 16, 2022, 07:56:42 PM »


Compare each bass chord to the scale the music is played on. For example, your A chord with thirds in is A - C# - E. Without is A - E. Does the melody have a C# in it? If yes, the full chord will fit. If the melody has an C natural in it, it will clash horribly so best to play with thirds out. Repeat for each bass chord and you’ll have an answer.


Are you sure? Seriuosly, such a drastic statement reminds me of the myth of the bumblebee!

I actually use the C major chord in a number of tunes in D, and occasionally the E major chord too, and it works perfecty. it's called chromatic harmony you know...  you simply have to learn the theory!


1.  Learn the music.
2.  Derive the theory.

Exactly!

Rules of music are derived by observing music as it is performed. It's not provided by an outside authority. And it varies between musical genres and cultures.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #18 on: November 16, 2022, 08:19:10 PM »


Rules of music are derived by observing music as it is performed. It's not provided by an outside authority. And it varies between musical genres and cultures.

We are actually all living in the 21st century, or at least I hope so  ;D!

If the melodeons offer a chance to go beyond the diatonic harmony as a way round to their limitations, I see no reason not to axploit their full potential.

And no, if you know how to use the non diatonic chords to build a chord progression for a diatonic melody, nobody will actually lament a clash! Our ears heve been trained by tons of pop song to listen to such progressions.
« Last Edit: November 16, 2022, 08:29:20 PM by GBbox »
Logged

Dick Rees

  • Neo-Luddite
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1640
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #19 on: November 16, 2022, 08:55:35 PM »


I think any such "limitations" come as much from users as from instruments...or more...and should be classified as "perceived" limitations.  But we've had this discussion before...

« Last Edit: November 16, 2022, 08:57:41 PM by Dick Rees »
Logged
"You're making the wrong mistakes."
...Thelonius Monk

"I never made one of my discoveries through the process of rational thinking."
...Albert Einstein

"If Art Tatum took up classical music seriously, I'd quit my job the next day."
...Vladimir Horowitz
Pages: [1] 2 3   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal