Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2] 3   Go Down

Author Topic: Thirds in or Thirds out.  (Read 5190 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #20 on: November 16, 2022, 09:14:51 PM »


I think any such "limitations" come as much from users as from instruments...or more...and should be classified as "perceived" limitations.  But we've had this discussion before...

No, what we are discussing is the use of one of the available chords on the instrument when it's not a diatonic chords according to the scale of the tune.

The limitatioms of the instruments, percieved or real, aren't relevant in this contest. Yet I agre that the limitations of the users, when someone says that a C major chord must clash if the tune is in D because the C note in the scale is a sharpened note, are a real problem.
Logged

Becci Pamely-Bast

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 122
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #21 on: November 16, 2022, 09:43:05 PM »


Compare each bass chord to the scale the music is played on. For example, your A chord with thirds in is A - C# - E. Without is A - E. Does the melody have a C# in it? If yes, the full chord will fit. If the melody has an C natural in it, it will clash horribly so best to play with thirds out. Repeat for each bass chord and you’ll have an answer.


Are you sure? Seriuosly, such a drastic statement reminds me of the myth of the bumblebee!

I actually use the C major chord in a number of tunes in D, and occasionally the E major chord too, and it works perfecty. it's called chromatic harmony you know...  you simply have to learn the theory!

I think you may have missed my disclaimer regarding exceptions. ;)
I could sit here and write lots about different types of harmonisation and chord progressions but given the OP, I didn’t think that would be helpful. I was attempting to offer a simple starting point for someone who wanted an answer without lots of theory.
Logged
Find me playing on YouTube

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #22 on: November 16, 2022, 10:37:22 PM »


Compare each bass chord to the scale the music is played on. For example, your A chord with thirds in is A - C# - E. Without is A - E. Does the melody have a C# in it? If yes, the full chord will fit. If the melody has an C natural in it, it will clash horribly so best to play with thirds out. Repeat for each bass chord and you’ll have an answer.


Are you sure? Seriuosly, such a drastic statement reminds me of the myth of the bumblebee!

I actually use the C major chord in a number of tunes in D, and occasionally the E major chord too, and it works perfecty. it's called chromatic harmony you know...  you simply have to learn the theory!

I think you may have missed my disclaimer regarding exceptions. ;)
I could sit here and write lots about different types of harmonisation and chord progressions but given the OP, I didn’t think that would be helpful. I was attempting to offer a simple starting point for someone who wanted an answer without lots of theory.

I didn't missed your disclaimer.
I simply think that your statement that if you use a chord that has one note, or for the matter more than one, that isn't/aren't part of the scale of the tune, then it will clash horribly, taking it as it was written, is pure nonsense. And we aren't talking about some odde exceptions.
It's just like telling that cars must have two wheels because you look at them from a side.
You can suggest someone who hasn't a trained musical ear, or a basic music knowledge, preferably both, to stick to the diatonic chords until he has learned how to use the non diatonic ones can be of help. Telling him that the chromatic chords should be avoided because they sound dissonant, while in fact this is far from being true, will definitely not help him to progress.
Logged

Dick Rees

  • Neo-Luddite
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1640
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #23 on: November 17, 2022, 12:36:11 AM »

GB...

As Monk said, "You're making the wrong mistakes."😁
Logged
"You're making the wrong mistakes."
...Thelonius Monk

"I never made one of my discoveries through the process of rational thinking."
...Albert Einstein

"If Art Tatum took up classical music seriously, I'd quit my job the next day."
...Vladimir Horowitz

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #24 on: November 17, 2022, 10:50:37 AM »

I actually use the C major chord in a number of tunes in D, and occasionally the E major chord too, and it works perfecty. it's called chromatic harmony you know...  you simply have to learn the theory!

Er, the term “chromatic” harmony is usually used where the chord surprises the ear … but somehow still works! It’s discussed here, with a couple of nice midi examples.  In the circles that I move in we’d call what you describe as a modal interchange, or a “functional” harmony … something that doesn’t assert a change of key centre. And it is very “functional” in the word’s other sense. I have repeatedly seen whole sessions where all of the melodeons and guitars play the slightly ‘out’ C major chord during a dorian Em tune. It’s become a sort of cliché 🤔 But when I self accompany a song I have switched to the pull A chord as it asserts dorian’s characteristic #6.

That is to go for beauty rather than cadence 🙂  … but nothing is wrong in harmony, provided that it takes you from where you are now to where you want to be in a few bars time. The same applies to your E chord. E7 is the dominant of A7, and as such I’d see it as a simply passing cadence, again not asserting a key change.

What’s in this for our original poster? I think we’re back to trusting his ears. On 2 rows, he can achieve your E=>A=>D trick by taking those 3rds out (if he likes that).  But a melodeon is set up for straightforward modal  accompaniment, to tunes played on those main two rows. And large numbers of folk orientated players prefer it that way.
« Last Edit: November 17, 2022, 10:55:56 AM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Dick Rees

  • Neo-Luddite
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1640
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #25 on: November 17, 2022, 01:54:35 PM »

Simple question, complex answer...considering that both hands figure in to the "color" of the sound.

« Last Edit: November 17, 2022, 04:49:21 PM by Dick Rees »
Logged
"You're making the wrong mistakes."
...Thelonius Monk

"I never made one of my discoveries through the process of rational thinking."
...Albert Einstein

"If Art Tatum took up classical music seriously, I'd quit my job the next day."
...Vladimir Horowitz

Becci Pamely-Bast

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 122
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #26 on: November 17, 2022, 03:36:45 PM »

I didn't missed your disclaimer.
I simply think that your statement that if you use a chord that has one note, or for the matter more than one, that isn't/aren't part of the scale of the tune, then it will clash horribly, taking it as it was written, is pure nonsense. And we aren't talking about some odde exceptions.
It's just like telling that cars must have two wheels because you look at them from a side.
You can suggest someone who hasn't a trained musical ear, or a basic music knowledge, preferably both, to stick to the diatonic chords until he has learned how to use the non diatonic ones can be of help. Telling him that the chromatic chords should be avoided because they sound dissonant, while in fact this is far from being true, will definitely not help him to progress.

Honestly, at this point I think we’re talking at cross purposes and perhaps that’s because I wasn’t clear enough in my original statement. Yes, I was recommending sticking to the diatonic chords for now. And I wasn’t making up rules to follow now and forevermore, just suggesting an easily understood guideline for someone starting out.
When I mentioned clashing, I meant at the particular point in the melody that you’re trying to harmonise with, not the whole tune. If you’re playing in Em and have a phrase with a C natural in it, it’s much more likely that an Am will sound good rather than an Amaj. However… if you come to a phrase without a C in it, but with an A or an E… by all means stick a Amaj in there. It can sound delightful.
Logged
Find me playing on YouTube

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #27 on: November 17, 2022, 10:08:33 PM »


Er, the term “chromatic” harmony is usually used where the chord surprises the ear …

A nice bit of poetry, that might mean everything.. or nothing at all.

Sorry, I admit I am a concrete, limited person, with no inclinations for poetry and romance. I like the clear, understandable definitions. Then, although I fear I am repeating myself, let me say that the expression diatonic harmony is used to describe the chord progressions built using the so called diatonic chords – i.e. the chords built using notes that belong to the melody scale. The expression chromatic harmony describes the use of chords with one or more notes – eventually all of them – that do note belong to the melody scale, and might not appear in the melody at all.

The expression functional harmony, for the record, is used to describe the use of some of the diatonic minor triads in place of the major ones. As far as the theory goes, if one of the minor triads ha two notes in common with the tonic, the subdominant or the dominant, you can use it as a functional replacement for them. This actually means that you can build a whole chord progression based on the functional substitution without entering the realm of the chromatic harmony.

The idea that the chromatic harmony can be used only to introduce an element of surprise can be true if we are thinking of fully chromatic instruments. Thinking as a melodeon player, put it as it is is the sterile, intellectual assumption made by someone who can't see the forest for the trees.

Since I am a concrete person, let me show what I mean with a real life example. This are two bars of a jig in D that I learned on the D/G box. On the A/D/G I play now I can use the D pull note on the A row to play The E minor chord like this
X:1
T:Example
L:1/8
M:6/8
K:D
|"Em" e2 f e2 d |"G" B3- B3 |
on the D/G box I wasn't obviously able to play an  E minor chord over a D pull note.. If the chord in the following bar had not been a G, I would have used the G major chord to suggest an E minor7 chord, but it actually is a G. Then I used a C major as a passing chord between the E minor and the G.
|"Em" e2 f "C"e2 d |"G" B3- B3 |
A theoretically correct choice that solves the problem, and it sounds pleasant to the ear, that's an added bonus of course, but not the main reason to use it.

I suppose the modal interchange can in fact lead into the realm of the chromatic harmony. But there's much more about it. For instance, it's related to the so called modal modulation. And since the terms is used in a number of different accept ions,. It's worth explaining how I sue it here. For modal modulation I intend the temporary change of mode in a melody, that suggests a modulation/key change that in fact doesn't happen, since the melody still use the  notes of the scale of the rest of the tunes.

Again, let me show an example:
http://www.boesstrings.com/celtic_tunes/jigs/Moon%20and%20Seven%20Stars.jpg
This is an arrangement of the well know jig The Moon and the Seven Stars. It appears in a number of web pages, and the chord progression actually works, even if it's not melodeon friendly. You can play a G chord on the whole third bar of the first part – using a D bass on the second beat -, but in the following bar you can't play an A chord, that on a D/G melodeon is pull only, over the D note in The melody, since it's pull only. I used an E minor chord on the second beat of the third bar – this is a school case of functional substitution – and them a D chord on the first beat of the fourth bar, and finally an A chord over the second.
Anyway what is relevant is the E major chord in the fourth bar of the second part. No G# in sight, so non key change, just a shift from the tonal major/C (aka Ionian) mode to the G (aka myxolydian) mode, but since our ears are trained to the alternation between the tonic and the dominant, and here the tonal centre of the melody is shifted to the A note, the use of the E major chords is perceived as correct, and sounds pleasant.

A note for Becci – this is a tune that I play using the E major chord, but not on the first beat of the fourth bar of the second part. I use it on the first beat of the second.
 My chord progression for the first four bars of the second part is
|A  - |E  F#m| A  D |A -|
If you'll look at the score, you will realize that I use the E major chord – full triad, with the G# sharp in its full glory! - over a G natural note in the melody. IT. DOES. NOT. CLASH!
Just to confirm that, if the chord enchainment is strong enough, you can really build a chord progression almost independently from the notes of the melody.

And beyond the modal modulation, we still have the special relation between the major and minor triads that are build on root notes that are a third apart, and it could lead us everywhere.

In a few words, I'm just talking about the use of the chromatic harmony in relation to the melodeons, and that means that I am just scratching the surface of the sphere.

But a melodeon is set up for straightforward modal  accompaniment, to tunes played on those main two rows. And large numbers of folk orientated players prefer it that way

And this is definitely a false statement. The two row melodeon  is an instrument conceived in the tonal system, and it's set up to play in two tonal major keys, and in one of the relative minor keys, using the harmonic and the melodic minor tonal scales. On the D/G melodeon you are given the tonic, the subdominant and the dominant chords to paly in G – G, C, D -, to play in D – D, G, A -, and to play in E minor – Em, A, B. The fact that incidentally the E minor chord is a diatonic triad for both the G and the D key – respectively the superdominant and the submediant – is just an added bonus.

What you are describing is actually the approach of the French and the English traditional players to the instrument. The French and in general the continental revival players have developed a different, harmonic wise approach. Definitely a large number of the English revival players hasn't, but judging by the YouTube videos I have seen so far I'm glad to say that there is a consistent minority that actually did.


Logged

Pete Dunk

  • Typo Expert
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3706
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #28 on: November 18, 2022, 02:43:09 PM »

I have no desire to enter into a discussion about music theory, indeed I am not qualified to do so, but what on earth is a “superdominant”???
Logged
Squeezing on the Isle of Oxney, UK
Primo (Serenellini) D/G
Isis D/G
Hohner B/E, G/C, C/F, Bb/Eb G/C/F
Liliputs D/G (G scale), C/F, Bb/Eb, Albrecht Custom D/G (G scale)

Graham Spencer

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3548
  • MAD as a wet Hohner........
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #29 on: November 18, 2022, 02:54:42 PM »

I have no desire to enter into a discussion about music theory, indeed I am not qualified to do so, but what on earth is a “superdominant”???

More impressive than a "subdominant"!  Personally I feel this discussion is getting out of hand and I won't be "contributing" any further.
Logged
Among others, Saltarelle Pastourelle II D/G; Hohner 4-stop 1-rows in C & G; assorted Hohners; 3-voice German (?) G/C of uncertain parentage; lovely little Hlavacek 1-row Heligonka; Bâ™­/Eâ™­ Koch. Newly acquired G/C Hohner Viktoria. Also Fender Jazz bass, Telecaster, Stratocaster, Epiphone Sheraton, Charvel-Jackson 00-style acoustic guitar, Danelectro 12-string and other stuff..........

Squeezing in the Cyprus sunshine

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #30 on: November 18, 2022, 03:42:47 PM »

I have no desire to enter into a discussion about music theory, indeed I am not qualified to do so, but what on earth is a “superdominant”???
Judging from context (E related to D) "the dominant of the dominant". I've never seen the term used before.

Personally I feel this discussion is getting out of hand and I won't be "contributing" any further.
I'm trying to stay away too.
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

Pete Dunk

  • Typo Expert
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3706
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #31 on: November 18, 2022, 03:54:40 PM »


Judging from context (E related to D) "the dominant of the dominant". I've never seen the term used before.

That would make it a moveable feast!

Quote
I'm trying to stay away too.

Yes, I’m done here.
Logged
Squeezing on the Isle of Oxney, UK
Primo (Serenellini) D/G
Isis D/G
Hohner B/E, G/C, C/F, Bb/Eb G/C/F
Liliputs D/G (G scale), C/F, Bb/Eb, Albrecht Custom D/G (G scale)

Dick Rees

  • Neo-Luddite
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1640
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #32 on: November 18, 2022, 04:05:38 PM »

Re theory vs sound:

"There are no wrong notes on the piano."

...T. Monk
Logged
"You're making the wrong mistakes."
...Thelonius Monk

"I never made one of my discoveries through the process of rational thinking."
...Albert Einstein

"If Art Tatum took up classical music seriously, I'd quit my job the next day."
...Vladimir Horowitz

Dick Sadler

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 62
  • Pt.
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #33 on: November 18, 2022, 04:31:53 PM »

I’m just sorry I asked the question in the first place.
How naive of me.....
Logged
If I didn’t have bad luck, I wouldn’t have any luck at all.....

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #34 on: November 18, 2022, 05:12:29 PM »

I’m just sorry I asked the question in the first place.
How naive of me.....

 ;D Cheer up. Where's the can of worms icon?  >:E
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #35 on: November 18, 2022, 05:23:10 PM »

I once had a Hohner 1040 with a C chord, a G chord and an F chord, but I decided that I didn’t need the third so I got myself a HA112 instead. Hope that helps!..  ;D
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #36 on: November 18, 2022, 05:28:37 PM »

I have no desire to enter into a discussion about music theory, indeed I am not qualified to do so, but what on earth is a “superdominant”???

As far as the theory goes, the superdominant is simply the sixth degree of the scale, i.e. the note above the dominant  - like in fact the subdominant is the fourth, the note below the dominant.

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/superdominant

I thought the meaning osf the definitinon was intuitive, but you proved I am wrong. Although, before asking, a simple Google search would have given you the answer.

@ DICK. No, you haven't been naive. You simply asked a question that requires some basic music theory to answer... as someone once said; there are three kinds of people: those who understand math, and those who don't.   ;)








« Last Edit: November 18, 2022, 05:47:20 PM by GBbox »
Logged

Dick Rees

  • Neo-Luddite
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1640
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #37 on: November 18, 2022, 06:26:22 PM »

For practical purposes, time and experience trump theory every time.
Logged
"You're making the wrong mistakes."
...Thelonius Monk

"I never made one of my discoveries through the process of rational thinking."
...Albert Einstein

"If Art Tatum took up classical music seriously, I'd quit my job the next day."
...Vladimir Horowitz

Becci Pamely-Bast

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 122
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #38 on: November 18, 2022, 06:42:19 PM »

I’m just sorry I asked the question in the first place.
How naive of me.....

I thought it was a shame how quickly the thread went way beyond answering your question. If I was a beginner melodeon player I would have found it very confusing. I hope you got some use out of the replies!
Logged
Find me playing on YouTube

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Thirds in or Thirds out.
« Reply #39 on: November 18, 2022, 07:08:34 PM »

For practical purposes, time and experience trump theory every time.

Time and and experience help to learn. Theory serves not only to explain what you've learned, to quote Anahata, but also, above all, to share it with other people.

DICK:

I think you are making the correct mistakes!
Logged
Pages: 1 [2] 3   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal