Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: which key signature with a relative minor  (Read 1973 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
which key signature with a relative minor
« on: December 15, 2022, 05:32:41 PM »

Hi Peeps,
I'm just transcribing a tune.
The key signature has 2 flats.
The first chord is Gm over a melody note of G4.

I'm assuming that with 2 flats, it is Bb, but with lots of Gm's in it, and the first chord/note being Gm chord over G melody, it is therefore in the relative minor of Gm.
What key signature would be the correct one to use, Bb or Gm?
cheers
Q

Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Lester

  • MADman
  • Mods and volunteers
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 9327
  • Hohners'R'me
    • Lester's Melodeon Emporium and Tune-a-Rama
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #1 on: December 15, 2022, 05:47:12 PM »

Gm and Bb have the same key signature - two flats

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #2 on: December 15, 2022, 05:53:19 PM »

Thanks Lester.
I realise I wasn't accurate in my question:
What K: should I use, Bb or Gm?
Is there a definitive or proper way of expressing this?
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Roger Hare

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 949
  • Urmston, Lancashire, U.K. éééé
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #3 on: December 15, 2022, 05:58:47 PM »

...What key signature would be the correct one to use, Bb or Gm?...
As it happens, I've just been through exactly the same discussion on another forum. I had a tune
with a key sig. of Bbmaj, and it was pointed out to me that it was actually Gmin.

I guess there's a sense in which it 'doesn't matter'(?), but the pedant in me says that I should really
have used Gmin - in practice, I do tend to 'correct' tunes in Cmaj/Gmaj/w.h.y. to Amin/Emin/etc. if
it seems to be 'necessary'.

I freely admit, this key sig. business does my head in, particularly when it's difficult to decide what
the key sig. really is...

It gets really nasty when trying to decide what the actual key sig. is for stuff like (some) Klezmer tunes...

As a result of the recent discussion about pipe tunes, I'm experimenting with coding 'pipe' tunes using
two key sigs: Hp and 'the nearest conventional key sig.'. I can't quite decide whether this is a great idea,
or complete rubbish...
« Last Edit: December 15, 2022, 06:09:50 PM by Roger Hare »
Logged
My ABC tune collections can be found here (GoogleDrive) & here (Dropbox).

For more about Manchester Morris, The Beech Band Folk Club or anything else,  please use the private messaging facility.

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #4 on: December 15, 2022, 06:16:27 PM »

Thanks Roger, good to know I'm not the only pedant in the parish!
I suppose I just want to get it right too.

After posting, and munching my tea, I was coming round to the idea of using the 'major' signature and leaving it at that.
I do wonder if there is a formal answer to this.
I'm sure someone with much greater knowledge will tell us... I hope  ;)
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Lester

  • MADman
  • Mods and volunteers
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 9327
  • Hohners'R'me
    • Lester's Melodeon Emporium and Tune-a-Rama
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #5 on: December 15, 2022, 06:51:26 PM »

My simple rule (it's mine so well may be wrong :) ) is to look at the last chord. So if a 1 sharp tune ends on a GMaj it's probably in G, if it ends on an Emin its probably in Emin

Roger Hare

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 949
  • Urmston, Lancashire, U.K. éééé
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #6 on: December 15, 2022, 06:59:44 PM »

Here's an example of what I meant in respect of Klezmer tunes:

Code: [Select]
X:516
T:Araber Tanz
%A lightly edited tune from the ABCEdit database.
O:Klezmer (yemenite jewish orgin?)
M:4/4
L:1/8
Q:1/4=130 %was 120
R:Terkish
K:Amin
E2 | "E" ^GA B2 B2 B2 | "Am" c6 BA | "E" ^GA B2 "F" cB AB | "E" A ^G3 z2 E2 |
"E" ^GA B2 B2 B2 | "Dm" (d4 d)c BA | "E" ^GA B2 "F" cB AB | "E" A ^G3 z4 |
E e2 ^d e2 B2 | "Am" c3 d e2 d/c/B/A/ | "E" ^G(A3 A)G FG | F E3 zE (3cBA |
|: "E" ^G8 | "Am" A8 | "E" ^GA B(G G)E "Dm" FD | "E" EF ^GA Be BA |
^G8 | "Am" A4 zE (3cBA | "E" ^GA B(G G)E "Dm" FD |1 "E" E4 zE (3cBA :|2 E4 ze "Dm" d/c/B/A/ |]
|: "E" ^GA BG GE "Dm" F/E/F/D/ | "E" EF ^GA Be "Dm" d/c/B/A/ |
"E" ^GA B(G G)E "Dm" F/E/F/D/ |1 "E" E E2 B,E B, E2 :|2 "E" E6 |]


Didn't look 'right', so after a lot of fannying around, I came up with a key sig. of K:Ephr exp ^G - whether it's
right is another matter. It's the Freygish scale (I think) - nightmare territory...

« Last Edit: December 15, 2022, 07:34:35 PM by Roger Hare »
Logged
My ABC tune collections can be found here (GoogleDrive) & here (Dropbox).

For more about Manchester Morris, The Beech Band Folk Club or anything else,  please use the private messaging facility.

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #7 on: December 15, 2022, 07:06:01 PM »

Thanks Lester.
I often thought if the first chord was G then it'd be in G, whereas if the first chord was Em then it would be in Em.
Sort of opposite to you but similar.

Sorry Roger, I have no experience of Klezmer tunes  :(
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Becci Pamely-Bast

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 122
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #8 on: December 15, 2022, 08:10:10 PM »

My simple rule (it's mine so well may be wrong :) ) is to look at the last chord. So if a 1 sharp tune ends on a GMaj it's probably in G, if it ends on an Emin its probably in Emin

I agree with Lester - this is a good rule that will work for the vast majority of tunes. If it’s one of those funny ones that doesn’t resolve, then go for the chord that it naturally wants to resolve on.

Another way to look at it is to examine the range of chords used in the tune. It’s common to see the 1st, 4th, and 5th chords used in tunes. So if it’s in Bb, then you might see Bb, Eb, and F used a lot. If it’s Gm, then you might see Gm, Cm, and Dm (or D) chords.

And one more thing to throw in the pot is that a lot of folk tunes are modal… so they may not be major or minor. But I don’t think it applies in this case, given your description of the tune.
Logged
Find me playing on YouTube

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #9 on: December 15, 2022, 09:05:24 PM »

...I'm assuming that with 2 flats, it is Bb, but with lots of Gm's in it, and the first chord/note being Gm chord over G melody, it is therefore in the relative minor of Gm.
What key signature would be the correct one to use, Bb or Gm?
cheers
Q

I agree with Lester. Plenty of tunes start with a different harmony to the tonic of the key [e.g., the B part of Rochdale Coconut]. It's quite common, really. The resolution is more significant.  Are you able to post enough of an abc to give a clue?

[Edit, I may have exagerated the lack of rarity  :D but it does happen]
« Last Edit: December 15, 2022, 09:15:19 PM by Tone Dumb Greg »
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #10 on: December 15, 2022, 10:11:23 PM »

...What key signature would be the correct one to use, Bb or Gm?...
As it happens, I've just been through exactly the same discussion on another forum. I had a tune
with a key sig. of Bbmaj, and it was pointed out to me that it was actually Gmin.

I guess there's a sense in which it 'doesn't matter'(?), but the pedant in me says that I should really
have used Gmin
Absolutely right. If you are sure a tune in in G minor the ABC key signature should reflect that. Image someone doing a text search though an ABC file (or many  files) looking for tunes in G minor... (or any minor key)

Quote
I freely admit, this key sig. business does my head in, particularly when it's difficult to decide what
the key sig. really is...
It may not be obvious what the key is - then you can only put your best guess in the ABC K: header.

Quote
It gets really nasty when trying to decide what the actual key sig. is for stuff like (some) Klezmer tunes...
ABC has a notation for specifying sharps and flats explicitly. From the ABC 2.1 specification:

" It is possible to use the format K:<tonic> exp <accidentals> to explicitly define all the accidentals of a key signature. Thus K:D Phr ^f could also be notated as K:D exp _b _e ^f, where 'exp' is an abbreviation of 'explicit'. Again, the case of the letter is used to determine on which line the accidental is placed.

Software that does not support explicit key signatures should mark the individual notes in the tune with the accidentals that apply to them. "


My simple rule (it's mine so well may be wrong :) ) is to look at the last chord. So if a 1 sharp tune ends on a GMaj it's probably in G, if it ends on an Emin its probably in Emin
It's almost always right! I do the same.
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #11 on: December 15, 2022, 10:29:38 PM »

Thanks for all your replies.
Just back from Morris practice so no more transcribing tonight!

I shall avert my gaze from the beginning of the tune to the end, keep an eye on the chords used and give it my best shot. That all sounds entirely reasonable and a good set of guide lines to base the decision on.
All good stuff to think on...
Thanks peeps (:)

Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

CAB

  • Mass Debater
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1147
    • Somerset Russets Village Band
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #12 on: December 15, 2022, 11:22:13 PM »

I'm in the "it doesn't matter" camp as long as the key signature is right.  There are plenty of tunes that move between major and minor, including, for example, some which are partly in Bb major but also have passages in G minor.  So I'd say it's the two flats that matter. not the label.  The final chord rule is a safe bet though.
Logged
Pas de lieu Rhone que nous

Roger Hare

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 949
  • Urmston, Lancashire, U.K. éééé
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #13 on: December 16, 2022, 04:17:50 AM »

[1] Absolutely right. If you are sure a tune in in G minor the ABC key signature should reflect that. Image someone doing a text search though an ABC file (or many  files) looking for tunes in G minor... (or any minor key)
  .
[2] It may not be obvious what the key is - then you can only put your best guess in the ABC K: header.
  .
[3] ABC has a notation for specifying sharps and flats explicitly. From the ABC 2.1 specification:

" It is possible to use the format K:<tonic> exp <accidentals> to explicitly define all the accidentals of a key signature. Thus K:D Phr ^f could also be notated as K:D exp _b _e ^f, where 'exp' is an abbreviation of 'explicit'. Again, the case of the letter is used to determine on which line the accidental is placed.

Software that does not support explicit key signatures should mark the individual notes in the tune with the accidentals that apply to them. "

  .
[4]
My simple rule (it's mine so well may be wrong :) ) is to look at the last chord. So if a 1 sharp tune ends on a GMaj it's probably in G, if it ends on an Emin its probably in Emin
It's almost always right! I do the same.

[1] It's good to know that I'm not completely over-the-top with my slightly pedantic approach.
I already get round the text search problem in my own programs by tagging (say) Bb and Gmin
with '2-flats'. I do this for all keys and all modes, so I then just do a simple search for 'naturals',
'1-sharp', '2-flats', or whatever, and pick up all tunes in (say) '2-flats', whatever the actual
ABC key sig..

The alternative is to use Unix-style regular expressions such as:

K:.*(Cmaj|Ddor|Amin)

to explicitly pick up the different key sigs...

[2] ...which is precisely what I do...

[3] ...It was messing around with Klezmer which led me to discover this modification of K:. It's 'nice'
because it allows one to specify 'odd' scales like that Freygish without littering the ABC with lots of
explicit accidentals (which is what I was trying to illustrate in my not very well chosen/badly explained
example)...

[4] That's my 'rule' too. It's almost always right...8) It's when it goes belly-up that the fun starts... 8)
« Last Edit: December 16, 2022, 04:34:23 AM by Roger Hare »
Logged
My ABC tune collections can be found here (GoogleDrive) & here (Dropbox).

For more about Manchester Morris, The Beech Band Folk Club or anything else,  please use the private messaging facility.

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #14 on: December 16, 2022, 11:33:03 AM »


   While ‘major’ is a very stable term in music - there is no single “minor” entity. In straightforward folk, they all have a flattened 3rd note, no problem, but that 6th is also important, and you should always look to that too …

   â€œG minor” 🙂 G A Bb C D Eb F G … as discussed above, uses the notes of Bb major. It’s a ‘mode’ of Bb

   â€œG minor” 🙄 G A Bb C D E F G … also has tunes ending on G, but it uses the notes from F major It likes different chords too!

    Klesmer? Well, go anywhere east of ± Prague and it gets even more complicated! Technically Ashkenazi, it has borrowed loads from Eastern Europe where they like “harmonic’ minors with raised 7th. The wierdness arises from min6 => maj7 (Eb=>F# here) being a jump of 1½ semitones.

   â€œG minor” 😳 G Ab B C D Eb F G … again ends on G 🤔 Sounds … sort of minor? Yet its 3rd is major! What’s going on?

  The simple minor that “Freygish“  most resembles ‘was’ C … DEbGAbBbC.” But where’s the Bb gone? It’s been raised to semitone to make it a leading note. To make matters worse Klesmer musicians are very fluid in the upper half of the scale and might substitute E for Eb (Melodic) or even sharpen the F if approaching G from below. ABC was designed for the modes of the simple diatonic scale. Anything else is … a bit of a musical expedition, but is no less valid than our occidental music.
« Last Edit: December 16, 2022, 11:35:52 AM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Roger Hare

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 949
  • Urmston, Lancashire, U.K. éééé
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #15 on: December 16, 2022, 05:50:36 PM »

...The simple minor that “Freygish“  most resembles ‘was’ C … DEbGAbBbC.”...a bit of a musical
expedition, but is no less valid than our occidental music.
Thank you for that lucid explanation!

I don't have any particular 'interest' in Klezmer (great music though), but I recently spotted a couple
of 'grey areas' whilst editing tunes in a legacy file which included a few Klezmer tunes, and tried to
sort out the key sig. in a way which was comprehensible (to me at least!). The above helps greatly!

See also:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phrygian_dominant_scale

Edit: Dumb idea about extra key sig. for Klezmer deleted - it wouldn't work...
« Last Edit: December 17, 2022, 03:35:48 AM by Roger Hare »
Logged
My ABC tune collections can be found here (GoogleDrive) & here (Dropbox).

For more about Manchester Morris, The Beech Band Folk Club or anything else,  please use the private messaging facility.

Howard Jones

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1203
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #16 on: December 16, 2022, 09:52:55 PM »

I'm in the "it doesn't matter" camp as long as the key signature is right...So I'd say it's the two flats that matter. not the label.  The final chord rule is a safe bet though.

Up to a point. Conventional notation only shows the key signature of course, and the musician must work out for themselves which key that represents, especially if they're going to add harmonies.

If all you're concerned to do is force two flats then any value of K: which results in those will do the job.  However surely it is more useful for the K: field to provide some information about the tonality of the tune? I feel it's worth spending a bit of time to do that, especially if it turns out to be neither of the more obvious keys but a modal key eg C dorian or F mixolydian. Recording that information in the K: field may save you time when you come to revisit the tune.

Of course some tunes can't easily be pinned down and then it may be a matter of personal choice. As for Klezmer, western notation is not good at coping with scales which don't follow the conventional intervals of the western scale. ABC does allow customised key signatures and you can even mix sharps and flats, but that may not entirely solve the problem.

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #17 on: December 17, 2022, 12:11:28 AM »

Of course some tunes can't easily be pinned down and then it may be a matter of personal choice. As for Klezmer, western notation is not good at coping with scales which don't follow the conventional intervals of the western scale. ABC does allow customised key signatures and you can even mix sharps and flats, but that may not entirely solve the problem.

As long as we're sticking to the conventional 12 semitones per octave, I think staff notation copes pretty well. Any note can be made sharp or flat in a key signature, and accidentals embedded in the music can make temporary changes. It needs to be understood that a so-called key signature does not actually specify a key; it's just a shorthand to show which notes are played sharp or flat, but it's doesn't say why. ABC attempts to go a step further by suggesting minors and modes, even though that isn't reflected in the notation it produces. It can get somewhat unstuck with this; it doesn't have a name for a scale with a B♭ and a C♯ in it, so instead it has the "explicit" option to describe such key signatures.
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #18 on: December 17, 2022, 10:13:51 AM »


  Go even further East, say China, Japan, Thailand and most of the traditional music is pentatonic. Some Buddhist traditions can make do with just one note! Other traditions, eg Persian add in ¼-tones and even finer divisions

 There are a vast oceans of music outwith our Western European roots. Jazz musicians will (listen to Paul Desmond‘s “take 5”) commonly use 11 of the 12 available notes, when improvising on a minor chord. Shoenberg’s dodecaphony disciple Hauer …  never repeated a note until he’d used all 12!

   John Cage wrote a celebrated piece of music with no notes at all. Now, there’s a challenge for ABC notation? 😉
« Last Edit: December 17, 2022, 10:15:43 AM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: which key signature with a relative minor
« Reply #19 on: December 17, 2022, 10:31:11 AM »

... and our fiddler used to play for our Silent Rapper.
Another interesting score to notate  ;D
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal