Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2   Go Down

Author Topic: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean  (Read 3833 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

jarviw

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 156
Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« on: December 31, 2022, 04:44:38 AM »

I know this topic has been discussed in various posts and there's a lot more to it... So I will keep this simple.
On your tuning app, do you set it at equal temperament or Pythagorean temperament (or whatever else?)
Logged

Winston Smith

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4066
  • AKA Edward Jennings
    • "Our Luxor B&B" Luxor life, slice by slice.
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #1 on: December 31, 2022, 09:56:52 AM »

It depends upon which type of music you intend to play on it. Here in Britain, the 'norm' would be equal if you're going to play alongside other musicians, but there are also sweeter sounds with other temperaments, for accompanying singing possibly.
Logged
At last, broken and resigned to accept conformity.
Oh, how I LOVE Big Brother!

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #2 on: December 31, 2022, 10:11:37 AM »

As Winston says it all depends . . .

All tuning systems have compromises, it depends which compromises are less of a problem for you and your music.

Of all the melodeons I've tuned 99% were in ET.  The exceptions were cajun tuned one-rows and a few antique instruments, and a CF I turned to accompany Northumbrian small pipes which like many pipes are tuned to just intonation for the home scale of the chanter.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #3 on: December 31, 2022, 10:23:11 AM »

My experience of Anglo concertinas should also apply to melodeons in this respect. A simple instrument without accidentals such as a 20 key Anglo or a single row melodeon, or a 2 row 4th-apart melodeon with no accidentals is only ever going to be played in one or two keys and can be tuned close to Pythagorean scale; for any instrument with accidentals or capable of a fully chromatic scale, such as 30 key Anglo or semitone-apart melodeon, ET is a safer bet because it may get played in a variety of keys.
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #4 on: December 31, 2022, 10:58:24 AM »

Hi all,

This is a big topic but I'll just make a small point here, that what is usually meant these days by "Pythagorean tuning" is a tuning in which all the fifth and octave intervals are acoustically "just" (untempered).

Well, we all want our octaves tuned just in almost every modern tuning and temperament (with the slight exception of "octave stretching" of the highest and lowest notes due to inharmonicity of piano strings, etc).

Pythagorean fifths to my ear are only slightly better sounding than fifth intervals in 12ET (equal temperament with 12 tones to the octave), because 12ET fifths are only around 2 cents narrow compared to just fifths.

BUT . . .the third intervals in Pythagorean tuning become very very wide of just, and even wider than the thirds in ET. For the example of the major third interval, C-E:

In 12ET that interval is so wide of just that it sounds harsh to many ears. If C is used as a point of comparison (and using 12ET as a reference, since most of us understand that temperament the best), an acoustically just major third interval would have the E tuned flat by 13.7 cents compared to the E of 12ET.   So, C =0,  E = -13.7 sounds beautiful. C =0, E = 0 sounds wide and harsh by comparison, especially in the same octave and especially with free-reed instruments. We have learned to tolerate that 12ET major third sound but if you compare it with a just major third the difference is striking.

Back to Pythagorean tuning, its major thirds have to be even wider. That's because, relative to 12ET, in Pythagorean tuning you have this series of fifth intervals (values are approximate):

C = 0.   G = +2.  D = +4.   A = + 6.  E = + 8.

So a Pythagorean major third could be C = 0, E = +8.   That's 8 cents wider than 12ET, and  21.7 cents wide of a just major third.

For this reason I suggest that anyone who plays thirds (or sixths or tenths or major / minor triads) on a free-reed instrument would find Pythagorean tuning very harsh and noisy.  That doesn't mean it would be impossible to make music with it, but it wouldn't be my favorite sound.

The non-ET tunings and temperaments that sound best to my ear on free-reed instruments go in the other direction, with major thirds that are narrower (not wider) than ET major thirds.

PG
« Last Edit: December 31, 2022, 11:03:05 AM by pgroff »
Logged

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #5 on: December 31, 2022, 01:59:14 PM »

Hi all,

This is a big topic but I'll just make a small point here, that what is usually meant these days by "Pythagorean tuning" is a tuning in which all the fifth and octave intervals are acoustically "just" (untempered).

Well, we all want our octaves tuned just in almost every modern tuning and temperament (with the slight exception of "octave stretching" of the highest and lowest notes due to inharmonicity of piano strings, etc).

Pythagorean fifths to my ear are only slightly better sounding than fifth intervals in 12ET (equal temperament with 12 tones to the octave), because 12ET fifths are only around 2 cents narrow compared to just fifths.

BUT . . .the third intervals in Pythagorean tuning become very very wide of just, and even wider than the thirds in ET. For the example of the major third interval, C-E:

In 12ET that interval is so wide of just that it sounds harsh to many ears. If C is used as a point of comparison (and using 12ET as a reference, since most of us understand that temperament the best), an acoustically just major third interval would have the E tuned flat by 13.7 cents compared to the E of 12ET.   So, C =0,  E = -13.7 sounds beautiful. C =0, E = 0 sounds wide and harsh by comparison, especially in the same octave and especially with free-reed instruments. We have learned to tolerate that 12ET major third sound but if you compare it with a just major third the difference is striking.

Back to Pythagorean tuning, its major thirds have to be even wider. That's because, relative to 12ET, in Pythagorean tuning you have this series of fifth intervals (values are approximate):

C = 0.   G = +2.  D = +4.   A = + 6.  E = + 8.

So a Pythagorean major third could be C = 0, E = +8.   That's 8 cents wider than 12ET, and  21.7 cents wide of a just major third.

For this reason I suggest that anyone who plays thirds (or sixths or tenths or major / minor triads) on a free-reed instrument would find Pythagorean tuning very harsh and noisy.  That doesn't mean it would be impossible to make music with it, but it wouldn't be my favorite sound.

The non-ET tunings and temperaments that sound best to my ear on free-reed instruments go in the other direction, with major thirds that are narrower (not wider) than ET major thirds.

PG

I looked at this many years ago, and came up with a tuning better suited to instruments like concertina and melodeon which could only play in a few keys -- only to find some years later that I'd reinvented Aaron's quarter-comma meantone tuning 350 years later... :-(

I tuned my 30-key Anglo concertina using this and it sounded glorious played in its own, lovely sweet chords, made ET sound nasty and harsh in comparison. Couldn't be played with any other ET instrument though, the result was truly horrible (but was great with a fiddler who realised what was going on and adjusted).

The problem is not only that thirds in particular are very different to ET, but each time you move away from the "home" key (correct absolute pitch) it gets gradually sharper or flatter depending which way you go in the cycle of fifths... :-(
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #6 on: December 31, 2022, 09:45:21 PM »


I looked at this many years ago, and came up with a tuning better suited to instruments like concertina and melodeon which could only play in a few keys -- only to find some years later that I'd reinvented Aaron's quarter-comma meantone tuning 350 years later... :-(

I tuned my 30-key Anglo concertina using this and it sounded glorious played in its own, lovely sweet chords, made ET sound nasty and harsh in comparison. Couldn't be played with any other ET instrument though, the result was truly horrible (but was great with a fiddler who realised what was going on and adjusted).

The problem is not only that thirds in particular are very different to ET, but each time you move away from the "home" key (correct absolute pitch) it gets gradually sharper or flatter depending which way you go in the cycle of fifths... :-(

Hi IanD,

1/4 comma meantone temperament has the reverse problem, compared to Pythagorean tuning.  In 1/4 comma, all the major third intervals are just (if correctly spelled - i.e. Eb - G is just, but not D# - G), but all the fifth intervals are extremely narrow (around 5.4 cents narrow relative to just fifths, or around 3.4 cents narrow relative to 12ET fifths). 

But for music that uses many harmonies in thirds, few fifths, and with understanding of its limitations, 1/4 comma can be a lovely sound. I've seen very early english-system concertinas that seem to have been originally tuned in 1/4 comma and that I restored to this tuning. Wheatstone's keyboard layout allows for 14 different pitches per octave (duplicate enharmonics for D# vs Eb and G# vs Ab, tuned to different pitches), that allow playing in many keys in 1/4 comma meantone.

I myself played a 31 key anglo concertina tuned to 1/4 comma meantone for a few years and it worked better than you might expect in playing with a variety of other instruments. You need to choose carefully which note you use to center the tuning, for the reasons you describe (it becomes increasingly sharp of ET in the flat keys, and increasingly flat of ET in the sharp keys, long before you run out of appropriate notes such as Db, A# etc).

But my view is that there are better tunings than either 1/4 comma meantone or 12ET for free reed instruments that provide better compromises between sweetness of thirds, consonance of fifths, opportunity to modulate keys, and minimizing the worst clashes with other instruments. These include various modified meantone temperaments and well temperaments that have been documented for keyboard instruments (such as organs and harpsichords etc) and also some tunings that have been developed specifically for free reed instruments where there may be more than 12 notes per octave, in part because different pitches can be used for press vs draw of the bellows.

If I live long enough to retire from the work that's paid the bills here the past 20 years, I hope to write up my extensive research on free-reed tunings and temperaments, some day.

But I did want to redirect the earlier discussion that seemed to imply a misunderstanding of Pythagorean tuning.

PG
« Last Edit: December 31, 2022, 09:48:48 PM by pgroff »
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #7 on: January 01, 2023, 09:13:15 AM »


   I’m still trying to work out whether you two are “in tune”,  or otherwise? 🤔  Back to topic, I vaguely remember that Paul comes from … somewhere near Syracuse. Assuming you’ve met the fella, and to dispel my ignorance, why is this tuning scheme called “Pythagorean”?

  And what/why is a ¼-comma?
   
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Winston Smith

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4066
  • AKA Edward Jennings
    • "Our Luxor B&B" Luxor life, slice by slice.
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #8 on: January 01, 2023, 09:20:09 AM »

"If I live long enough to retire from the work that's paid the bills here the past 20 years, I hope to write up my extensive research on free-reed tunings and temperaments, some day."

I should think that there are many of us who hope to live long enough to be able to read it!
Logged
At last, broken and resigned to accept conformity.
Oh, how I LOVE Big Brother!

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #9 on: January 01, 2023, 01:05:42 PM »

I know this topic has been discussed in various posts and there's a lot more to it... So I will keep this simple.
On your tuning app, do you set it at equal temperament or Pythagorean temperament (or whatever else?)

While a number of tuning systems have loads advantages,harmonically, if you are tuning instruments to be played alongside the others you would expect to find in non-specialist sessions and group settings, these are not really the place for anything other than equal temperament. You will  be that extra bit out of tune with everybody else and just muddy the sound even more than equal temperament already does.
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #10 on: January 01, 2023, 02:20:07 PM »


   I’m still trying to work out whether you two are “in tune”,  or otherwise? 🤔  Back to topic, I vaguely remember that Paul comes from … somewhere near Syracuse. Assuming you’ve met the fella, and to dispel my ignorance, why is this tuning scheme called “Pythagorean”?

  And what/why is a ¼-comma?
 

http://www.tonalsoft.com/enc/number/1-4cmt.aspx
« Last Edit: January 01, 2023, 02:23:23 PM by IanD »
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #11 on: January 01, 2023, 03:25:36 PM »


   I’m still trying to work out whether you two are “in tune”,  or otherwise? 🤔  Back to topic, I vaguely remember that Paul comes from … somewhere near Syracuse. Assuming you’ve met the fella, and to dispel my ignorance, why is this tuning scheme called “Pythagorean”?

  And what/why is a ¼-comma?
 

http://www.tonalsoft.com/enc/number/1-4cmt.aspx

Thanks Chris and IanD, and also see:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pythagorean_tuning



TLDR for all the above:

Equal Temperament (specifically ET with 12 equally spaced pitches to the octave, = 12ET):
Fifths are not too bad ( 2 cents narrower than a pure or just fifth)
Major thirds are very wide but modern ears have learned to tolerate them (13.7 cents wider than a pure or just major third). Some still find the major thirds of 12ET very harsh, especially when played on free reed instruments.
G# = Ab and so on for all "enharmonics"   ( B = Cb, etc etc). Thus 12 pitches to the octave and the intervals are the same in every key
A modern standard for much western music since 1900, but not universal and not "objectively correct," rather 12ET is "equally out of tune in every key" and most suitable for fretted instruments, and for keyboard instruments with 12 keys to the octave when playing music that modulates into all 12 keys.

Pythagorean tuning:
Fifths are ideal (acoustically pure or just)
Major thirds are extremely wide and excessively harsh to many ears ( 20 + cents wide of an acoustically pure major third).
Thus I would never recommend this tuning for free reed instruments if major third harmonies are used.


1/4 comma Meantone temperament
:
Fifths are quite narrow and active, enough to disturb some ears (-5.4 cents narrower than an acoustically pure fifth).
Major thirds are ideal (acoustically pure or just).
Enharmonics are not tuned to the same pitch (Ab is much sharper than G#, Eb is much sharper than D#, etc). Thus many more than 12 pitches to the octave are needed to play in many keys
Moving from the key of C into the "flat keys" ( tonalities of F, Bb, Eb, Ab, etc) the overall pitches of the notes used in the scale become sharper and sharper, on the average, relative to the key of C.
Moving from the key of C into the "sharp keys" (tonalities of G, D, A, E, B, etc) the overall pitches of the notes in the scale become flatter and flatter, on the average, relative to the key of C.


Just intonation
:
All the intervals used in harmonies are acoustically pure.
This is impossible to achieve in practice for a fixed pitch instrument playing in multiple keys, unless there are many, many more than 12 tones to the octave.
But just intonation can be achieved by choral groups, unfretted strings, etc where the exact pitch of each note is finely adjustable in real time, subject to the ear training and the technique of the musicians.
Just intonation can be approximated on a fixed pitch instrument with only 12 (or even with only 7) notes per octave, that is only played in one tonality, depending on the complexity of the melody and harmony notes used.
But contrary to the assumptions of many who read about (or write about) "the diatonic scale in just intonation" or "the chromatic scale in just intonation," there is no one scale of 7 or 12 pitches that will itself keep the harmonies in just intonation no matter which notes you choose. So IMO the published "scales in just intonation" that you may find are so called inappropriately.

PG



edited to correct a mistake!

« Last Edit: January 02, 2023, 10:52:31 AM by pgroff »
Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #12 on: January 01, 2023, 03:34:47 PM »

I know this topic has been discussed in various posts and there's a lot more to it... So I will keep this simple.
On your tuning app, do you set it at equal temperament or Pythagorean temperament (or whatever else?)

While a number of tuning systems have loads advantages,harmonically, if you are tuning instruments to be played alongside the others you would expect to find in non-specialist sessions and group settings, these are not really the place for anything other than equal temperament. You will  be that extra bit out of tune with everybody else and just muddy the sound even more than equal temperament already does.

Greg,
If you've ever listened to traditional pipes (Irish pipes, Northumbrian pipes, etc) playing in a session you are hearing non-ET tunings, usually in some tension with instruments tuned otherwise. This can sound great.
If you've ever listened to Cajun accordion in a traditional tuning played with a guitar backing (spanish, fretted guitar) you are hearing that tension between instruments tuned differently. This can sound great.
If you've ever listened to a session with a non-dry-tuned box you are always hearing a tension of different pitches in the tuning of every melody note. This can sound great.
If you've ever listened to a session with flute players, fiddlers, etc who have to create the pitch of each note with embouchure or finger placement on the keyboard, you are hearing music where the actual pitch of each note only approximates the intended pitch. Pitches actually achieved in performance, by excellent musicians, have been measured and they can range pretty widely (10, 20 cents or more) from the intended pitches.

With this in mind, the anxiety over tuning differences between instruments in 12ET vs other systems should be tempered . lol.

The musicianship of the individual musicians matters much more.

PG
Logged

tirpous

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1403
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #13 on: January 01, 2023, 04:06:45 PM »

Quote
Equal Temperament (specifically ET with 12 equally spaced pitches to the octave, = 12ET):
Fifths are not too bad ( 2 cents narrower than a pure or just fifth)
Major thirds are very wide but modern ears have learned to tolerate them (13.7 cents wider than a pure or just fifth).

Wouldn't that be a pure or just third ??

Quote
1/4 comma Meantone temperament:
Fifths are quite narrow and active, enough to disturb some ears (-5.4 cents narrower than an acoustically pure fifth).
Major thirds are ideal (acoustically pure or just).
Enharmonics are not tuned to the same pitch (Ab is much sharper than G#, Eb is much sharper than D#, etc). Thus many more than 12 pitches to the octave are needed to play in many keys
Moving from the key of C into the "flat keys" ( tonalities of F, Bb, Eb, Ab, etc) the overall pitches of the notes used in the scale become sharper and sharper, on the average, relative to the key of C.
Moving from the key of C into the "sharp keys" (tonalities of G, D, A, E, B, etc) the overall pitches of the notes in the scale become flatter and flatter, on the average, relative to the key of C.

I guess the last 2 sentences would only apply for a 'C based' 1/4 comma Meantone temperament, right ?  But the same principle would hold for any base note ?

Just trying to understand - thanks for all the information !  (:)
Logged

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #14 on: January 01, 2023, 04:29:42 PM »

I know this topic has been discussed in various posts and there's a lot more to it... So I will keep this simple.
On your tuning app, do you set it at equal temperament or Pythagorean temperament (or whatever else?)

While a number of tuning systems have loads advantages,harmonically, if you are tuning instruments to be played alongside the others you would expect to find in non-specialist sessions and group settings, these are not really the place for anything other than equal temperament. You will  be that extra bit out of tune with everybody else and just muddy the sound even more than equal temperament already does.

Greg,
If you've ever listened to traditional pipes (Irish pipes, Northumbrian pipes, etc) playing in a session you are hearing non-ET tunings, usually in some tension with instruments tuned otherwise. This can sound great.
If you've ever listened to Cajun accordion in a traditional tuning played with a guitar backing (spanish, fretted guitar) you are hearing that tension between instruments tuned differently. This can sound great.
If you've ever listened to a session with a non-dry-tuned box you are always hearing a tension of different pitches in the tuning of every melody note. This can sound great.
If you've ever listened to a session with flute players, fiddlers, etc who have to create the pitch of each note with embouchure or finger placement on the keyboard, you are hearing music where the actual pitch of each note only approximates the intended pitch. Pitches actually achieved in performance, by excellent musicians, have been measured and they can range pretty widely (10, 20 cents or more) from the intended pitches.

With this in mind, the anxiety over tuning differences between instruments in 12ET vs other systems should be tempered . lol.

The musicianship of the individual musicians matters much more.

PG

All of which is true :-)

However free-reed instruments like concertina in particular (and dry-tuned melodeons/accordeons) show up mistuning more than many other instruments for two reasons: free reeds generate a lot of high harmonics compared to most instruments which makes the beats more obvious, and they are capable of playing sustained chords of multiple notes which shows this up even more, especially if the instrument is playing solo (or accompanying a song).

I tried comparing chords with different temperaments using synthesized reed sounds, and found that the slightly narrow fifths (-5 cents) of 1/4 comma MT were far less objectionable than the wide major thirds (+14 cents) of ET, both major and minor chords sounded considerably better than ET.

With a typical D/G melodeon you wouldn't use C as the "home key" (where absolute pitch is correct), you'd put the D row very slightly flat (-3 cents) and the G row very slightly sharp (+3 cents) of concert pitch. Then C would be sharper still (+8 cents) and A flatter still (-8 cents), and more remote keys worse than this.

I found this was pretty noticeable when playing along with ET, the home keys (D and G) were fine, C and A were starting to get noticeably off (especially the fifths when going flatter).

Probably this would be hard to spot in a big session, but it was quite obvious with 2 instruments, one MT and one ET. That's also what I found with the concertina I tuned that way...
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #15 on: January 01, 2023, 10:42:50 PM »


...With this in mind, the anxiety over tuning differences between instruments in 12ET vs other systems should be tempered . lol.

 ;D ;D ;D

Quote
The musicianship of the individual musicians matters much more.

That doesn't apply to the dastardly melodeonista, though. He/she's stuck with their tuning. Everybody else has to modify theirs to suit.
I take your point that it becomes irrelevant with wet tuning.

It doesn't bother me a lot as my ear isn't very critical.

It bothers my wife though. She doesn't suffer from perfect pitch, but she does have a sensitive ear. Which is probably why she hates free reeds.


« Last Edit: January 01, 2023, 10:45:11 PM by Tone Dumb Greg »
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #16 on: January 02, 2023, 09:49:59 AM »

Most of the time I don’t notice the problems of ET, but I do find the sound of the major third to be unpleasant.  For me that’s sufficient reason to be happy with a box with no major thirds in the LH chords.

When tuning boxes that do have thirds I usually sweeten the chord by lowering the pitch of the third by a few cents. Between 3 and 5 cents lower is enough to improve the sound without causing a clash with the same note played on the right.

I may have some evidence as to why the major third sounds so harsh on an ET tuned free reed instrument.  I think that the harmonic corresponding to the major third is particularly strong in free reeds.  My reason for suspecting this is that there are conditions where an electronic tuner will sometimes lock on to a harmonic instead of the fundamental, and when this happens it’s always the major third. 
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #17 on: January 02, 2023, 10:49:34 AM »

Quote
Equal Temperament (specifically ET with 12 equally spaced pitches to the octave, = 12ET):
Fifths are not too bad ( 2 cents narrower than a pure or just fifth)
Major thirds are very wide but modern ears have learned to tolerate them (13.7 cents wider than a pure or just fifth).

Wouldn't that be a pure or just third ??


Yes, thanks - I'll correct that.
Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #18 on: January 02, 2023, 10:53:09 AM »


Quote
1/4 comma Meantone temperament:
Fifths are quite narrow and active, enough to disturb some ears (-5.4 cents narrower than an acoustically pure fifth).
Major thirds are ideal (acoustically pure or just).
Enharmonics are not tuned to the same pitch (Ab is much sharper than G#, Eb is much sharper than D#, etc). Thus many more than 12 pitches to the octave are needed to play in many keys
Moving from the key of C into the "flat keys" ( tonalities of F, Bb, Eb, Ab, etc) the overall pitches of the notes used in the scale become sharper and sharper, on the average, relative to the key of C.
Moving from the key of C into the "sharp keys" (tonalities of G, D, A, E, B, etc) the overall pitches of the notes in the scale become flatter and flatter, on the average, relative to the key of C.

I guess the last 2 sentences would only apply for a 'C based' 1/4 comma Meantone temperament, right ?  But the same principle would hold for any base note ?

Just trying to understand - thanks for all the information !  (:)

Yes
Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #19 on: January 02, 2023, 10:59:12 AM »


...With this in mind, the anxiety over tuning differences between instruments in 12ET vs other systems should be tempered . lol.

 ;D ;D ;D

Quote
The musicianship of the individual musicians matters much more.

That doesn't apply to the dastardly melodeonista, though. He/she's stuck with their tuning. Everybody else has to modify theirs to suit.
I take your point that it becomes irrelevant with wet tuning.

It doesn't bother me a lot as my ear isn't very critical.

It bothers my wife though. She doesn't suffer from perfect pitch, but she does have a sensitive ear. Which is probably why she hates free reeds.

Ah, but there are other aspects of musicianship that do apply to melodeon players who can't alter the pitch (much) while playing their instruments.

Dynamics, Phrasing, Rhythm, just to name 3

When the rhythm is really precise (and often, when notes are articulated very crisply - not necessarily staccato, but with crisp dance rhythm) and players are well coordinated rhythmically, fairly wide tuning discrepancies may not bother the ear of someone who listens with an understanding of that dance music tradition. 

Some people who complain about the intonation of great dance players may not be listening to what is most meaningful in the music to those players.

Think about the inharmonic noise, or at least fairly imprecise pitch, of many sounds made by rhythm instruments . . . or the fact that we can sometimes "hear which tune" is being stepped out by a great dancer.

I like beautiful harmonies and I've explored them for decades, both inside and outside of ET, but a great player can sometimes make powerful music despite breaking the rules of beautiful harmonies - or even because s/he is breaking  rules.

I grew up listening and playing blues and other styles of music in which piano and organ players could find ways to suggest pitches "in between the keys."  That's another aspect of musicianship. At a certain level all the elements of musical sound can make a sort of magic together that transcends any of the individual elements, so the listener hears what's meant by the musician, despite minor inconsistencies or tensions that could be interpreted as flaws if considered in isolation. An analogy would be the way a good reader who knows a language may jump to understanding the author's intended meaning even if some words are misspelled. Another analogy would be the way the eye (mind) "sees movement" when presented a successive series of images in a film.


PG
« Last Edit: January 05, 2023, 03:56:42 PM by pgroff »
Logged
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal