Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2]   Go Down

Author Topic: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean  (Read 3848 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #20 on: January 02, 2023, 11:25:17 AM »


Greg,
If you've ever listened to traditional pipes (Irish pipes, Northumbrian pipes, etc) playing in a session you are hearing non-ET tunings, usually in some tension with instruments tuned otherwise. This can sound great.
If you've ever listened to Cajun accordion in a traditional tuning played with a guitar backing (spanish, fretted guitar) you are hearing that tension between instruments tuned differently. This can sound great.
If you've ever listened to a session with a non-dry-tuned box you are always hearing a tension of different pitches in the tuning of every melody note. This can sound great.
If you've ever listened to a session with flute players, fiddlers, etc who have to create the pitch of each note with embouchure or finger placement on the keyboard, you are hearing music where the actual pitch of each note only approximates the intended pitch. Pitches actually achieved in performance, by excellent musicians, have been measured and they can range pretty widely (10, 20 cents or more) from the intended pitches.

With this in mind, the anxiety over tuning differences between instruments in 12ET vs other systems should be tempered . lol.

The musicianship of the individual musicians matters much more.

PG

All of which is true :-)

However free-reed instruments like concertina in particular (and dry-tuned melodeons/accordeons) show up mistuning more than many other instruments for two reasons: free reeds generate a lot of high harmonics compared to most instruments which makes the beats more obvious, and they are capable of playing sustained chords of multiple notes which shows this up even more, especially if the instrument is playing solo (or accompanying a song).

I tried comparing chords with different temperaments using synthesized reed sounds, and found that the slightly narrow fifths (-5 cents) of 1/4 comma MT were far less objectionable than the wide major thirds (+14 cents) of ET, both major and minor chords sounded considerably better than ET.

With a typical D/G melodeon you wouldn't use C as the "home key" (where absolute pitch is correct), you'd put the D row very slightly flat (-3 cents) and the G row very slightly sharp (+3 cents) of concert pitch. Then C would be sharper still (+8 cents) and A flatter still (-8 cents), and more remote keys worse than this.

I found this was pretty noticeable when playing along with ET, the home keys (D and G) were fine, C and A were starting to get noticeably off (especially the fifths when going flatter).

Probably this would be hard to spot in a big session, but it was quite obvious with 2 instruments, one MT and one ET. That's also what I found with the concertina I tuned that way...

Yes, I used "C" as an example. All depends on the most common keys in your repertoire, but I did center my CG concertina in 1/4 comma meantone around D, at my favorite pitch, to minimize the clashes with tunes played in ET by other musicians in the keys of A,D, and G and their modes. I agree that by the time you get out to the keys of C, F, and Bb the concertina is getting to sound  substantially sharp relative to the ET instruments and in E, B, and F# the concertina is getting to sound substantially flat relative to ET instruments. I did have both a D# and an Eb in 2 octaves (as did many of the original Jeffries and Crabb anglos) which helped with internal tuning, within the concertina itself, and allowed for "correctly spelled" and beautiful major third intervals for the B and Eb chords.


« Last Edit: January 02, 2023, 11:28:29 AM by pgroff »
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Temperament setting: Equal vs Pythagorean
« Reply #21 on: January 02, 2023, 11:35:17 AM »

Ah, but there are other aspects of musicianship that do apply to melodeon players who can't alter the pitch (much) while playing their instruments.

Dynamics, Phrasing, Rhythm, just to name 3

When the rhythm is really precise (and often, when notes are articulated very crisply - not necessarily staccato, but with crisp dance rhythm) and players are well coordinated rhythmically, fairly wide tuning discrepancies may not bother the ear of someone who listens with an understanding of that dance music tradition. 

Some people who complain about the intonation of great dance players may not be listening to what is most meaningful in the music to those players.

Think about the inharmonic noise, or at least fairly imprecise pitch, of many sounds made by rhythm instruments . . . or the fact that we can sometimes "hear which tune" is being stepped out by a great dancer.

I like beautiful harmonies and I've explored them for decades, both inside and outside of ET, but a great player can sometimes make powerful music despite breaking the rules of beautiful harmonies - or even because s/he is breaking  rules.

I grew up listening and playing blues and other styles of music in which piano and organ players could find ways to suggest pitches "in between the keys."  That's another aspect of musicianship. At a certain level all the elements of musical sound can make a sort of magic together that transcends any of the individual elements, so the listener hears what's meant by the musician, despite minor inconsistencies or tensions that could be interpreted as flaws if considered in isolation. An analogy would be the way a good reader who knows a language may jump to understanding the author's intended meaning even if some words are misspelled.  PG

Agree totally Paul. In improvisation circles,  a soloist might commonly play notes from eg the diminished scale semitone below their comping support’s tonic, or even eg Db across a G chord … and *can’t get more “out” than that! 🥴

  How do they get away with it? Essentially, same techniques that you use. Precise rhythm and sensitive phrasing. Of course, they only have to get back to the right note at the end of the solo. I have to treck up to Tyneside to get my kit back in tune 😉

  *you really haven’t lived til you’ve heard Vincent Boniface improvise on a NW Italy folk tune on bagpipes 😳 (He plays melodeon too)
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 
Pages: 1 [2]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal