I prefer the hook. The lifter on your photo bends the reeds in a way that is too violent to my taste.
but since they're an accepted tool it's probably just my imagination that's too strong.
But hooks take some practise to use, and you'll need various sizes.
I have a bunch of reed blocks taken from two accordions I used as wall decoration.
I practised using both types of reed lifters on them.
These scrap reeds are also great for getting a feel for tuning. I've tuned reeds up and down a few times just to see how much they can take before they stop functioning. I also tried how far they can be bended before their position changes.
So I would advise you to make a few reed hooks and try for yourself which option you prefer.