Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2]   Go Down

Author Topic: Filling the 3rds gap.  (Read 2740 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris
Re: Filling the 3rds gap.
« Reply #20 on: February 02, 2023, 04:43:46 PM »

There are 🤔 three ‘B’s on a D/G 8 basser…
...  B/Gbass is Gmaj7, again bass is in charge. My point was that it needs 3rds out. Otherwise its D# becomes a #5th! 🥴

That sounds like an argument for flattening the third to give a Bm triad.  But I know you like your Bmajor. ;D

As ever, it comes to down to compromises. Sometimes I think that every change to strengthen one aspect weakens another. But that's melodeons for you.



« Last Edit: February 02, 2023, 04:47:04 PM by Tone Dumb Greg »
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Filling the 3rds gap.
« Reply #21 on: February 02, 2023, 06:19:54 PM »

...I have replaced the thirds in my A pull chord on the A/D/G and on the D chord on my G/C with a second fith. Abd I have tuned the B push  and the F# chords on the A/D/G and the E chord on the G/C to be minor chords.

Of course, you need an harmonically well trained musical ear to perceive the difference.

I'm not convinced that a particularly well traned ear is necessary to hear the difference between major and minor chords in a tune. They stick out like the proverbial sore thumb in the wrong places.

[or am I misunderstanding? If this is the Bminor v Bmajor on a DG thing, I'm with you a lot of the way.]

I think that in a tune what sticks out like the proverbial sore thumb in the wrong places, to use your own words, is the use of a minor chord that sounds dissonant when the correspondent major chord doesn't, or the opposite. Taking into account that there are chances, if the enchainments in a chord progression are well conceived, that both the major and the minor chords might work, the difference lies in the perception of the chords in themselves.

Anyway, if we agree that major and minor chords sound different, then we cannot agree that there’s virtually no “harmonic” loss in taking out thirds, like Chris says, no matter if you look at the melodeon as an instrument as a whole or as two different ones, than in itself is an abstract distinction that practically means nothing. And one may like the indefinitness of the 'thirds out' more than the distinctive moods of the 'thirds in', but this is again in itself irrelevant, since the difference both between the major and the minor chords and between the fulltriads and those without the thirds, remains.

By the way, what do you mean when you talk about the B minor v B najor on a D/G thing?

 
Logged

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris
Re: Filling the 3rds gap.
« Reply #22 on: February 02, 2023, 10:33:49 PM »

...By the way, what do you mean when you talk about the B minor v B najor on a D/G thing?

The recurring discussion about why 8 bass melodeons have the relative minor chord to outer row tonic as a major chord, rather than a minor chord. i.e., on a DG you have a B major, rather than a B minor.

Two answers I have seen are that it adds "crunch" and that it is useful in certain keys (harmonic minor? Klezmer?). I don't see how how that compensates for having to use the m7 fudge as the tonic chord for the relative minor. e.g., On a DG you have Bmajor instead of Bminor so you are forced to either use the B bass with  Dmajor fudge, or tape out the third. I am not that sophisticated a player, so I have a D natural as a third in my B chord on my 2.4 DG and live without that Klezmer crunch, that I rarely, if ever, miss. I think you do the same.

I haven't modified the A chord on my 2 row CF yet. I am expecting it to atrophy and fall off one day soon, for lack of use.
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Filling the 3rds gap.
« Reply #23 on: February 03, 2023, 12:19:38 PM »


  It adds ‘cadence’ technically. The English D/G was designed … in a bit of a hurry, “to work with fiddle keys” and they simply transposed the French G/C layout up a 5th.  Harmonic minor is much more common in their repertoire, and the V or “turnaround” or “dominant” chord for Am is E7. That would be B7 for E harmonic minor.

   Melodeon bass chords are 3 note, so that’s truncated B7 -> B triad.  Mysteriously …  our ear still perceives that as a dominant, and it feels wrong against dorian (with C#) tunes.  The “fix” of playing D/B (Bmin7) has been much discussed in these pages!

   You should also play your A chord v. Em dorian tunes incidentally. Much better than C … it pick up on the scale’s C# 😉

 
« Last Edit: February 03, 2023, 12:21:14 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Filling the 3rds gap.
« Reply #24 on: February 03, 2023, 03:52:54 PM »


I  think you do the same.


Yes, I do.

That the B chord in a D/G box is in general major to add crunch it's unlikely, although it can be used for that purpose. The idea that this was made to make the instrument playable in one minor key sounds logic. In the tonal domain the minor tunes use the natural minor scale with a sharpened 7th degree, to mirror the attraction between the tonic and the dominant (the harmonic minor scale). Eventually both the 6th and 7th degrees can be sharpened (the melodic minor scale). Then the tonic chord in E minor is in fact a minor chord, but both the subdominant and the dominant, the A and B chords, are major chords.

Too bad on the Hohners the D# at the top of the G row is available as a pull note, even if it's the third of the B minor chord, that's push chord. The continental makers usually wisely invert the two notes of the Hohner standard, but in the end that might result irrelevant, since considering the pitch range of the D# to use it is a rather hit or miss affair.

A caveat: as far as my experience goes, talking about the instruments of the melodeon/button accordion family to tell that something seems logic doesn't necessarily mean it's true. All the chords in the older Italian two row instruments, for instance, were major chords.

Anyway, the use you can do of a B major chord on a D/G box depends on the music you play. If on one hand you play English music, you can never find use for it in your whole life. If on hte other you play French music, you'll probably learn a few minor tonal tunes that require it, but the tonal major/modal ones in which a B minor chord could come in handy will outnumber them, and by far.

My decision to replace the C# reed in the A pull chord and of the F# chord on my A/D/G is based on similar considerations. The F# major chord is needed to play in B tonal minor, but the F# minor chord is a diatonic chord both in D and in A, and there are a number of tunes in G, or in the related modal scales, where I find use for the A minor chord, and muting all the third to play the A chord both as major and as a minor chord for me makes no sense. An A chord without the third is an acceptable compromise.

Of course, if you like the crunch, or simply like some variety, on a standard D/G box you have quite a few chces to use a B major chords playing both in D and G, and to use an A major chord to play in G, or a C chord to play in D. You just need to learn how to build your chord progressions. But to have the A and B chords available as minor chords adds a lot of harmonic flexibility to the instrument.

Then, for a D/G instrument with the stop to mute the thirds, my advice is to mute/replace the C# reed of the A chord, and retune the B to a minor chord. On an instrument without the stop, I would tape/replace the thirds on the A, the B and eventually the E chord, that can be used as a major chords in some of the tunes with the sharpened fourth if needed.

Beyond the fact that I like to hear the different moods between the major and the minor chords, my advice not to mute all the thirds is related to the major for minor7/minor for Major6 substitutions you have mentioned,  but this is a thread about the opportunity of the substitution of the thirds with other notes of the chords, so I fear we've already gone off topic.

Logged

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Filling the 3rds gap.
« Reply #25 on: February 03, 2023, 06:38:51 PM »


  It adds ‘cadence’ technically. The English D/G was designed … in a bit of a hurry, “to work with fiddle keys” and they simply transposed the French G/C layout up a 5th.  Harmonic minor is much more common in their repertoire, and the V or “turnaround” or “dominant” chord for Am is E7. That would be B7 for E harmonic minor.

   Melodeon bass chords are 3 note, so that’s truncated B7 -> B triad.  Mysteriously …  our ear still perceives that as a dominant, and it feels wrong against dorian (with C#) tunes.  The “fix” of playing D/B (Bmin7) has been much discussed in these pages!

   You should also play your A chord v. Em dorian tunes incidentally. Much better than C … it pick up on the scale’s C# 😉
 

Wow,  Chris! I'm sorry, but this post of yours to me sounds pretty confusing.

In first place: was the D/G designed – a term that for me implies the standard keyboard layout of the two row instruments has been reworked – or is it just an in instrument tuned in two of the keys favoured by the fiddlers? I think the latter option is the correct one, since in fact its keyboard layout is not only that of a G/C box transposed up a fifth, but also that of the C/F (the standard German two row box) transposed up a whole tone, or for the matter of any other standard two row melodeon.

Now, if you argue that a fourth button start D/G is probably a better choice for an English player, I agree, since it offers the low G (the G below middle C), that's the lowest note on the fiddler in standard tuning. I play a short row A/D/G, and while on one hand to deceive a four button start layout for it was impossible (even if we grant for the sake of the argument that on a three row instrument in three keys a four button start makes sense), on the other  I can play a low A in A, so I don't regret the note is missing. But yes, on a standard high pitched two row instrument, the fourth button start is probably the ideal choice.

But then, the standard G/C layout is far from being totally functional, no matter the music you play on it. The D note available pushing the bellows on the second button of the outside row (the D in the octave below middle C), for example,  is so low in pitch, even in a MM configurations, to be melodically of no use at all. A number of experienced G/C player I know use that button to locate an additional accidental on the push. 

Given this, the dominant chord in a major key is the major triad built on the fifth degree of the scale, and its attracted to the tonic chord, the major built on the first degree of the scale, because its third is the seventh degree of the scale, that in English is called the leading tone because it leads back to the tonic (in Italy we call it sensibile, and in French it's called note sensible).

The dominant 7 chords are four note chords that, in the music theory, are often placed in a class on their  own, rather than among the other 7 chords. The dominat7 Is an unstable chord, that differently from the dominant, that can be followed by any other chord, as a rule resolves on the tonic. And in fact a number of Italian and French accordion players who play for ballroom dancing always use the dominant7 chord before the tonic, to increase the harmonic tension, no matter if the seventh is present in the melody or not (I don't know what the English accordion players do, but...).

In E minor, in the tonal domain, since the seventh degree of the  natural minor scale is a whole tone below the tonic, it gets sharpened, turning the D natural into a D sharp, and the diatonic triad built on the fifth degree of scale, the B minor, becomes a major chord,  the B major, to harmonically mirror the major scale.

Then, if we perceive the E chord as the dominant, this isn't mysterious at all. The E chord is in fact the dominant chord. And to tell that a B7 chord is a truncated B triad is simply a nonsense, although I suspect that you, considering you pretend that there isn't any harmonic loss playing without the thirds, will probably disagree.  Triads and four or more note chords are different beasts!

Finally, there isn't any Em dorian tune. The are simply E Dorian tunes – aka D mode in D tunes, for us on the continent. They implicitely sound minor because the tonic – i.e. the diatonic triad built on the first degree of the scale – is a minor triad. And the traditional Dorian tunes, and most of the recently composed ones, are based on double tonic patterns that alternate between minor tonic chord, in this case the E minor, and the major chord a whole tone below it, in this case the D major. with the occasional use of a third chord, that generally is not a chromatic one, even if you can use any to built more articulated progressions. But this last point is definitely off topic,
« Last Edit: February 03, 2023, 06:50:10 PM by GBbox »
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Filling the 3rds gap.
« Reply #26 on: February 03, 2023, 08:19:29 PM »


  Sorry, but it’s impossible to play a 4 note dominant chord on an 8-bass setup, which is what we’re discussing. I ‘can’ do it on my 18-bass kit, but even there it’s always an inversion … not very “dominant”?  But by the ‘magic of melodeonism’ playing the B triad in Em works. (You can dot in the D# as rt-end accidental, if it’s on the push) …. 🙂

   D/G 4th start as being a better layout was settled a decade ago. We voted on that, decisively.

   A note sensible = sensitive note, in French refers to the notes that distinguishes a scale from similar parallel (same tonic) ones. ie the sharp 6th that distinguishes dorian EF#GABC#DE from aolian EF#GABCDE. Or the major/minor 3rd. In harmonic minor D# distinguishes  EF#GABCD#E from aolian EF#GABCDE. Yes, it’s “sensitive”, but the term being more general … I prefer “leadng note”. 

   I don’t see any melodeon layout as totally functional. They are all compromises, but work amazingly well in the modes of their main rows. Anyone who wants ‘total functionality’ should buy a CBA with Stradella bass. They are about 3x the weight 😉

   Yes, you can chord most E dorian tunes with Em and D (the Irish set do it all the time), and it works 👍 But after about 5 minutes … it gets … a bit boring? Which is why I use the dorian IV chord,  which is A triad on a D/G. It really lifts a tune when used ‘judicially’. Don’t knock it unless you’ve tried it? 🙂

  And B7 is the ‘natural’ dominant of any E scale. B triad works as a substitute; It’s as simple as that. There are many others eg Ab or F triads, or the ‘backdoor’ dominant D7, all of which … resolve to E. But very off topic here!

   
« Last Edit: February 03, 2023, 08:23:45 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: Filling the 3rds gap.
« Reply #27 on: February 03, 2023, 11:13:16 PM »

  And B7 is the ‘natural’ dominant of any E scale. B triad works as a substitute; It’s as simple as that.

You're coming a little off the rails here - there is a dominant note (i.e. the fifth) and a dominant key, but a dominant chord does not have to have a 7th in it, though the addition of the 7th makes it work well in a perfect (dominant - tonic) cadence.
See Wikipedia: dominant(music) for example. "The triad built on the dominant note is called the dominant chord. "


Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Filling the 3rds gap.
« Reply #28 on: February 04, 2023, 11:16:33 AM »


  Concur. But the same Wiki article also has the attached as “dominants”, and refers to raising of the 7th interval in minor harmony?

   â€œAbsolute” dominance require a tritone interval, in this case Eb+A. Miss out either of those notes and you are using a functional harmony approach … perfectly ok in most folk music and … entirely correct in a dorian melody. That’s why E minor dorian likes its fifth chord to be Dm?

    It’s the aolian ones where musical styles, and traditions diverge. But … we’ve diverged from what to put in the vacant 3rd reed slot. I was in essence saying that in the case of  B push, that it is best left empty.
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Filling the 3rds gap.
« Reply #29 on: February 04, 2023, 01:12:32 PM »


  Sorry, but it’s impossible to play a 4 note dominant chord on an 8-bass setup, which is what we’re discussing. I ‘can’ do it on my 18-bass kit, but even there it’s always an inversion … not very “dominant”?  But by the ‘magic of melodeonism’ playing the B triad in Em works. (You can dot in the D# as rt-end accidental, if it’s on the push) …. 🙂

   D/G 4th start as being a better layout was settled a decade ago. We voted on that, decisively.

   A note sensible = sensitive note, in French refers to the notes that distinguishes a scale from similar parallel (same tonic) ones. ie the sharp 6th that distinguishes dorian EF#GABC#DE from aolian EF#GABCDE. Or the major/minor 3rd. In harmonic minor D# distinguishes  EF#GABCD#E from aolian EF#GABCDE. Yes, it’s “sensitive”, but the term being more general … I prefer “leadng note”. 

   I don’t see any melodeon layout as totally functional. They are all compromises, but work amazingly well in the modes of their main rows. Anyone who wants ‘total functionality’ should buy a CBA with Stradella bass. They are about 3x the weight 😉

   Yes, you can chord most E dorian tunes with Em and D (the Irish set do it all the time), and it works 👍 But after about 5 minutes … it gets … a bit boring? Which is why I use the dorian IV chord,  which is A triad on a D/G. It really lifts a tune when used ‘judicially’. Don’t knock it unless you’ve tried it? 🙂

  And B7 is the ‘natural’ dominant of any E scale. B triad works as a substitute; It’s as simple as that. There are many others eg Ab or F triads, or the ‘backdoor’ dominant D7, all of which … resolve to E. But very off topic here!
 

I'm glad Anahata confirmed what, anyway, anybody with even a sketchy knowledge of musical theory should know. The fifth degree of the major scale is called the dominant, and the dominant chord is the triad built on it. If you add  the seventh to the chord you increase the harmonic tension between it and the tonic that already exists, and that is due to the fact that the third of the dominant triad is the seventh degree of the scale. This is not a matter for discussion, we are talking about worldwide accepted and shared concepts and definitions, and the Wikipedia page linked by Anahata clearly states it..

By the way, in the tonal major scale – or for our purpose in any scale in which it is an half tone below the tonic -  the seventh degree is called leading tone (aka leading-tone). If in a a scale, like the natural minor scale, the seventh degree of the scale is a whole tone below the tonic, it is called subtonic. Is to recreate the tension between the tonic and the dominant of the major scales that in the harmonic minor scale it is then sharpened, and the triad built over the fifth degree of the scale turned into a major chord. Again, this is a matter of definitions. More about this in the Wikipedia page (link below). And those who will open the Wikipedia page in French will see that leading tone translates as note sensible, ou sensible.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leading-tone

The fact that  in this forum ten years ago the fourth button start was decisively voted as the best possible layout for a D/G melodeon just means that the subscribers, that are mainly English players who plays English music, did agree about it. With all my respect for them, I think it's worth remembering that there is a whole continent on the our side of Channel!

Where the fiddle is one the leading instruments, like in Ireland, to play on instrument that can reach the low G is compulsory. That's why the RH keyboard of the instruments played by the top Irish performers has 23 buttons, rather than the 21 buttons usually associated to the two row melodeons and the cheap Hohners two row button acordions.

There are a few tunes in the manuscripts of the English fiddlers that require the low G, but I've heard some of them satisfactorily played on a third button start melodeon, with minimal changes to the melody, and the melodeon players, that since the sixties have played on two row third button start instrument, in England outnumber by far the fiddlers. Then yes, I already said that for an English player a four button start D/G is probably an ideal choice, but a number or respected English players stick to the C/F - D/G third button start layout, and this doesn't seem to affect the quality of the music they play, so I wouldn't start a crusade about it.

Then, what about the French players? And there are a number of them than alternate the D/G to the G/C playing with the bagpipes and the hurdy-gurdies tuned in D. Since the traditional French tunes you can play on the pipes use a limited pitch range, they have no need to reach the low G. I personally use my G/C to play French music, but I have learned a few French on the A/D/G, and if I had to play French music on a D/G I couldn't care less if its' a third or four button start, as far as I could play it in LMM configuration.

A friend of mine used to say: any coin has two sides... and a dice has six faces! To be able to consider the different perspectives each one of us might have is crucial, if we wish to learn one from the other, rather than simply try to steal the stage pretending we have the truth in our pocket..

As a final note, the so called double tonic pattern – i.e. the alternation between two chords, the first major of minor, the second always major, a tone below  – it's a modal pattern that was well known before the rise of the tonal system,

In her seminal book Scottish fiddlers and their Music (Gollancz, 1983) Mary Ann Albuger suggested a connection with the Scottish bagpipes, on which “two major triad on A and G occur naturally”. I think this makes sense, since the pattern can be found where the bagpipes are/were played, and not only in Ireland, where it could have been brought in from Scotland, but in France as well..

As an English example take The Sportsmen Hornpipe, that shows clearly the pattern even if there isn't any evident connection with the bagpipes, with an alternation – if you play in G – between the A minor and the G major chords, with the occasional use of a D major chord in the second part.

The reason the pattern works so well to our musical ears, that are tonally trained, lies probably in the fact that the harmonic tension between the two chords, even if you can't compare it to the attraction between the dominant and the tonic, is high because they have no note in common.

On the melodeon it's an alternation that comes natural. There are a lot of original minor modal composition in the current French repertoire that alternate between the Am minor, played pulling the bellows, and the G major chord, played on the push It's definitely a cliché.

The alternation between these two chords, after five minutes you play a tune, becomes boring? Not necessarily, at least for me, but then what about the traditional tonal major/Ionian tunes that mainly alternate between the tonic and the dominant/dominant7? The solution is to build more articulated chord progressions (as far as it fits the style, of course). I learned The Sportsmen HP on the D/G, and still play it using all the six chords available on it, changing two chords each bar (with the exception of the ending ones). It's fun – great fun, really! -, but it's just a matter of using the functional substitutions to enrich the basic two chord pattern. 
Logged
Pages: 1 [2]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal