Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Extended diatonic button layout - am I missing something?  (Read 1369 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Ben Hudson

  • New Starter
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3
Extended diatonic button layout - am I missing something?
« on: May 29, 2023, 06:28:57 PM »

My D/G Double Ray has to go in for some tuning and I thought that I might have it changed to fourth button start at the same time. As usual I like the low end and get not much use out of the high end. I've given some thought to the different layouts and come up with something which seems to tick the boxes for me. But it seems like such an obvious layout that I wonder if I've missed something, otherwise it would be in more common use.

As evidenced by the fact that it's in D/G, my Double Ray has been significantly tinkered with before I got it, and has a few idiosyncrasies. For one, my button 3 on the G row is E/F# rather than D/F#. This caused some early confusion (I've only been playing about a year) but got me into the mindset of crossing rows. And recently I've been very much appreciating having both a push and pull E4 and wishing that I had a pull D4 too. I'm breaking out of the beginner oom-pah bass patterns and introducing more drones in my playing, so appreciate the reversals where I have them and kind of thinking that I should rework the layout to maximise them further.

I'm thinking about a layout which continues the diatonic theme into the lower octave (changes from the normal layout in bold):
   Eb/F      C/D   E/F#    G/A    B/C    E/D  G/F#    B/A     D/C    G/E
Bb/G#   G/A   B/C#   D/E   F#/G   A/B   D/C#   F#/E   A/G   D/B   F#/C#

The pros as I see them are:

  * Keeps consistent 4ths between rows
  * Maximises reversals, adding push E and pull D in low and middle octave which is nice for different bass techniques. D and G scales are possible solely on the push or pull nearly the whole way up with a few missing notes.
  * 3 full octaves of G so works with fiddle tunes 
  * Some nice low RH chords now available:
   C push (G row)
   Em push (G row)
   D pull (G row)
   D7 pull (G row)   
   G push (D row)
   Bm push (D row)
   A pull (D row)
   A7 pull (D row)
   G7 pull (across rows)
   Dm pull (across rows)
   C pull (across rows)
   * Dutch reversal gives a push E and a pull D in the middle octave. This will need a bit of relearning but I frequently read that it's a good thing to get used to quite early on. Does anyone do a high Dutch reversal on the D row D/B to get B5 and D6 in both directions? (made a mistake - you already have the B in both directions so flipping this reed doesn't make any sense - I'm aware of the ukebert Super Preciosa setup which has the Dutch reversal and also retunes the G row D/C to E/C)

Cons (either versus standard layout or Anahata layout):
* The low B breaks the usual 3rd button repeat pattern. However having an easy Bm chord as a result is handy, and there's no shortage of inverted D chords on the push on the D row still.
* Low octave G scale is different fingering (Anahata layout is better in this respect). However with the Dutch reversal it’s only the C which has bellow direction reversed so not masses different.
* No push A3

Obviously the Anahata layout is very popular for getting the low G scale but it means no reversals in the low octave, except for the A3. So although I appreciate the logic I think it's not for me.

To be honest this is quite similar to what I think I'd come up with if I was designing a melodeon from scratch so it seems like I must have overlooked something silly otherwise the current layouts would never have evolved their delightful oddities.

I'm very uncommitted on accidentals as don't use them much at present. At the moment I have Eb4/F4 where you'd ordinarily have F5/Eb5. Definitely seems better to have these accidentals in the 5th octave but not sure which way around.

Likewise I currently have G#4/Bb4 but considering reversing.

I quite like the idea of having accidentals at both ends of the row (eg. F4/Eb4 chin end, F5/Eb5 knee end etc) but on a 21 button machine that means cutting off the ends of the third octaves in both scales which seems wrong somehow. Perhaps this is an idea to shelve for a future 23 button box. That said I rarely see anything going as high as C#6 and higher and I know some people here have enjoyed a 5th button start on a 21 button box which has the same limitations...

Thoughts? Obviously every layout is a compromise especially with only 21 buttons and 8 basses, but this seems to do a good job on my two objectives - extend the range down to G3, and add the reversals I miss at the moment.
« Last Edit: May 31, 2023, 12:56:51 PM by Ben Hudson »
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Extended diatonic button layout - am I missing something?
« Reply #1 on: May 29, 2023, 07:42:59 PM »


   We debated this at some length 12 years ago.

   Strong consensus that a standard English box should have its D and G scales start on button 4

    There were 4 strong contenders for what reeds those extra 2 buttons at head end should carry 

        http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php/topic,7727.0.html

    Anhata’s won the poll, because its great for English music in G, but “it depends what you play”  …

   Alternatives are listed in the 2011 post. sorry, going out to watch the Whitsun Morris and can’t compare now  :M
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Extended diatonic button layout - am I missing something?
« Reply #2 on: May 29, 2023, 08:58:35 PM »

General principles of designing your own layout:
1When you change a note to gain something you also loose something.
2 if you come to depend on an unconventional layout you make it harder to play other more standard layouts,  and makes it harder for you to borrow an instrument or upgrade to a better instrument.
3 all melodeons are limited in some way, getting round the limitations makes you more creative.
4 in theory the melodeon is a fairly daft, even stupid and illogical instrument. In practice it works for certain types of music.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Squeaky Pete

  • Squeaky Pete
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1327
  • Re-hohn a Hohner
Re: Extended diatonic button layout - am I missing something?
« Reply #3 on: May 29, 2023, 09:08:36 PM »

What Chris said about the low sales and accidentals.
But that push E near the chin is great and costs nothing.
Dutch reversal is only one plate flipped and no tuning required so again cheap to do and easily returned to standard if you can't cope with it.
The reversal in the next octave up is much more intrusive - it needs the physical retuning of two reeds to complete the sequence and in this position (for me) is far less intuitive.
Logged
Poker work DG.
Pariselle 2.6 DG, Ex-Club IIIBS CF,
Matching Liliputs in CF and DG,
Lots of sickly Hohners needing TLC,
Bassoon, Various Bagpipes........

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: Extended diatonic button layout - am I missing something?
« Reply #4 on: May 30, 2023, 12:01:52 AM »

my prefered dg layout is to ditch the reeds on the highest button on both rows   and move all reeds up one the 2nd button on each row being replaced  with low reeds   whiost retaing the chin end accidentals,  on the normal dg layout the top (highest) 2 buttons are rearely used and this layout gives two full octaves.  It suits me and in my opinion should be the standard DG setup

george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris
Re: Extended diatonic button layout - am I missing something?
« Reply #5 on: May 30, 2023, 07:42:04 AM »

my prefered dg layout is to ditch the reeds on the highest button on both rows   and move all reeds up one the 2nd button on each row being replaced  with low reeds   whiost retaing the chin end accidentals,  on the normal dg layout the top (highest) 2 buttons are rearely used and this layout gives two full octaves.  It suits me and in my opinion should be the standard DG setup

george

What low notes do you recommend with your 4th button start, George? Does it include pull C and D?
 
[also, while 4th button start is the bees knees for MM, it's not needed for LMM]
« Last Edit: May 30, 2023, 10:33:26 AM by Tone Dumb Greg »
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Extended diatonic button layout - am I missing something?
« Reply #6 on: May 30, 2023, 10:48:02 AM »


   I got Theo to do similar to my 1986 D/G Lilly 5 years back. Basically it went “4th start Anahata”, but I also clubbed the mid range D/E to E/D. This gives you very fluent scales in G, D, Em dorian and aolian, Bm and even C.  and an astonishing number of chords. Noting that if you can play at a scale right through on the pull, you can also play all of its 7 chords 🙂 if the schedule is partial, you tend to get about half its chords. In Rodec notation:

Code: [Select]
name: Clubbed 'Anahata' 2-row 8-bass 4th-start D/Gaccs
index: 1
blacknotes: C# Eb F# Ab Bb
transpose: 0
left:
                             G4/D4   G0/D0   C4/G4   C0/G0
                             E4/a4   E0/A0   F4/F4   F0/F0
right:
     F4/Eb4   B3/C4  D4/F#4  G4/A4   B4/C5   D5/D5   G5/F#5  B5/A5   D6/C6   G6/E6
Ab4/Bb4  G3/A3   A3/C#4  D4/E4  F#4/G4   A4/B4   D5/C#5 F#5/E5   A5/G5   D6/B5  F#6/C#6

Code: [Select]
name: Ben's proposed 2-row 8-bass 4th-start Dutch inversion D/Gaccs
index: 2
blacknotes: C# Eb F# Ab Bb
transpose: 0
left:
                             G4/D4   G0/D0   C4/G4   C0/G0
                             E4/a4   E0/A0   F4/F4   F0/F0
right:
     F4/Eb4 *C4/*D4   D4/F#4  G4/A4   B4/C5   E5/D5   G5/F#5  B5/A5   D6/C6   G6/E6
Ab4/Bb4  G3/A3  *B3/C#4  D4/E4  F#4/G4   A4/B4   D5/C#5 F#5/E5   A5/G5   D6/B5  F#6/C#6

  I like it! Especially that C4/D4 on the inner row. it gives you a true D7 chord when playing in G, and in a sense extends the clubbing of D5 down into octave 3. There might even be a case for doing something in the upper octave but only the Dutch ever seems to do that?

   Having your pull G scale go all the way down to D=note5 will be very useful, though you can sometimes achieve that using bases The C and F scales aren’t so fluent though? How about those rt end chords?

   Rt end 4 note chords in G …  where ➡️=push  ⬅️=pull ↔️=both ways 🤔

    Gmaj7↔️  Amin7 ⬅️  Bm7↔️  Cmaj7↔️  D7↔️   Em7↔️  F#ø⬅️ 

   Rt end 4 note chords in D … also Bm

    Dmaj7➡️  Emin7 ↔️  F#m7⬅️  Gmaj7↔️  A7⬅️   Bm7↔️  C#ø⬅️ 
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Ben Hudson

  • New Starter
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3
Re: Extended diatonic button layout - am I missing something?
« Reply #7 on: May 31, 2023, 01:19:58 PM »

Lots to think about! Thanks for the comments. 12 years ago I don't know if I even knew what a melodeon was but it's been interesting reading through the two threads on the subject of a new British standard layout which luckily preserve the debate for future reference. I made my way through the vote thread but haven't fully read the first one yet; interested to see if anyone considered and rejected something similar to what I've been imagining.


I like it! Especially that C4/D4 on the inner row. it gives you a true D7 chord when playing in G, and in a sense extends the clubbing of D5 down into octave 3. There might even be a case for doing something in the upper octave but only the Dutch ever seems to do that?

An example of the upper octave tweak is Ukebert's layout, which I think is what you're talking about, SqueakyPete: https://ukebert.wordpress.com/2012/02/18/inside-and-out-part-1-the-super-preciosa/. It's definitely got something going for it but I'm wary of getting carried away. The characteristics of the standard layout are what make D/G fun to play for the kinds of music it's naturally suited to, so I don't want to go too far looking for a theoretical perfection. As you say, Theo, it looks downright illogical in places until you realise how elegant it is in practice. Changing accidentals and low notes seems like fair play as they're "extras" but I mostly want to leave the normal range alone. I don't feel precious about doing the Dutch reversal as it's easily flipped back, and conceptually it only moves the push/pull high/low flip one step further to the left.

my prefered dg layout is to ditch the reeds on the highest button on both rows   and move all reeds up one the 2nd button on each row being replaced  with low reeds   whiost retaing the chin end accidentals,  on the normal dg layout the top (highest) 2 buttons are rearely used and this layout gives two full octaves.  It suits me and in my opinion should be the standard DG setup

george

What low notes do you recommend with your 4th button start, George? Does it include pull C and D?
 


Would be interested to know too - sounds like everyone likes the 4th button start but the low notes are more of a matter of taste.
Logged

Gena Crisman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1108
  • 🇬🇧
Re: Extended diatonic button layout - am I missing something?
« Reply #8 on: May 31, 2023, 01:26:58 PM »

As a serial low octave enjoyer, I do think this Ben's idea here has has some legs. But, only because of that low push E4 (I think you missed this in your rodec, Chris). I always think about C as a pull note, but you often deal with the low G being push only anyway with any melody you might be playing down there. Maybe the C being push as well wouldn't be a stretch?

The push A is my least used of the buttons, but, I do use it. Half the reasons I can think of for wanting it are due to not having a pull D, though. And you better believe I would use the snot out of a low pull D.

If also offers some better fluency for playing in low octave D, as the scale just runs up the outside row buttons, and if you want a low A with a D, use the pull scale instead. The G octave progression isn't as smooth but could make up for that by having that massive push sequence of bcdefgab, especially if you're already used to your push E4.

I don't really like push E, though, as a rule. Not my jam.
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal