Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2 3 4   Go Down

Author Topic: B/C Brain  (Read 18699 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

melodeon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1732
B/C Brain
« on: November 18, 2009, 03:29:27 AM »

A friend and fellow box player asserts that there are those who have 1/2 step minds... more specifically he says that some folks are just
suited to the B/C style.  He believes that someone is more suited to the B/C  (specifically and not referring to the push pull orientation  of the C#/D) because of a way of thinking, ie more analytical than intutive and would be  more apt to learn and appreciate the B/C.
He also suggested that I am that type of person...
I can't agree or disagree as I owned a B/C for a very short while so cannot verify or deny the assertion.

I believe that there are those that are more suited to specific occupations and tasks in life than to other endeavours. I am wondering if this is true of the B/C system or are all box players equally capable of learning B/C  given the time and exposure

Who plays B/C and do you agree with this
Who has tried it and gave it up and for what reason ?
Anyone agree or disagree with the premise. ?

Just curious.
« Last Edit: November 18, 2009, 03:57:43 AM by melodeon »
Logged

nfldbox

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 492
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #1 on: November 18, 2009, 03:48:18 AM »

I started off on an ADG and migrated to the BC. In the middle I tried the C#D. I suppose the ADG is not really relevant as I could tell it didn't suit my interests--primarily Irish--and was just waiting until I could find something else. In the beginning I was like most basic box players in Newfoundland: I played the instrument that happened to be around. Then I ran into someone who had a Saltarelle Bouebe C#D and I realized what I was missing.
But the C#D is relevant to my process. I found that the lack of integration--is that the right word?--didn't make sense to me. In D it was like a one row and in A it was like D+ and in G it was confusing.
Now anyone who doesn't play BC probably thinks confusing is its middle name. But I find it does live up to its "chromatic" claim. I have played nothing in B or C but in D,G, A, F and the minors, it makes sense to me. I like the way it moves back and forth and when playing by ear I find I often don't really know which row I am on until I stop and think about it.
Someone else claimed I like the BC because I use the dots. But while I can sightread quite well in D, G and A, I often pick up tunes by ear and they tend to fall into my fingers.
There is no question I am more analytical than intuitive but I'm not sure that's the explanation.
Logged
BC Cairdin
BC Hohner Double Ray
Bouchard en Ré

melodeon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1732
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #2 on: November 18, 2009, 04:05:01 AM »

Interesting
I also tried C#/D and it was ok but not my "thing"
I much prefer one row to C#/D

I think that the issue is one not io intelligence or intellect but of wiring.
And I suppose there are the ocassional Tim Eadys out there... but we are not speaking of musical genius
but of players with a very specific aptitude for a specific style.

And also not speaking of the way a C#/D sounds with its punch and drive or the fluidity of the B/C ( given its usual application) but the system itself

Granted you could play, and some do play, the C#/D in the B/C style and the reverse
But again  refeering to playing in the usual applications.

I very much enjoy listening to C#/D but I listen more to B/C players and did before I knew anything about "systems".

Thanks for the input.

Logged

Christopher K.

  • Content Manager
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 894
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #3 on: November 18, 2009, 09:24:47 AM »

Maybe true...  I tried the B/C system and I wasn't very good at it.  I knew plenty of tunes from playing strings but just couldn't wrap my head around the half-step way of playing them on the box.  It seemed somehow counterintuitive, like a lot of stop and go.  Now I play a quint system and find things much easier, although I don't think my playing is very good, but at least it's coming along. I'm learning by myself and I find the placement of the reversals and approach to cross-row strategies much easier to hammer out on a G/C than on a B/C.  It's also fun to shelve all that and play along each row using only one set of bass buttons for the whole tune.  So I guess that I am getting more out of a quint system than I could out of a B/C.

I read some interesting essays from Oliver Sacks last year, about mental plasticity if you would like to call it that.  It's possible that while the half-step system doesn't make sense to me now, it could, quite suddenly and inexplicably, become the system that my mind feels is most natural later on.  Like a door opening up.  

My father, for instance, is starting to listen to jazz after half a century of country and rock music listening.  He says, "I get it!" and I make copies of Coltrane and Ornette Coleman albums for him.  I never thought I'd be sending him that stuff.  I also struggled desperately with mathematics as a child, and when I got to college, found myself taking high math electives for fun.  I don't doubt that some people struggle with one system or another, but I do believe that it's possible for the brain to change itself with no assistance from the owner.

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #4 on: November 18, 2009, 09:48:13 AM »

These postings raise a number of interesting questions.  The simple lightweight 2 row DG.CF etc boxes are very good at doing what the maker intended i.e. playing in the 'home keys'  and can provide as much 'bang for the buck' as a 120 bass box, possibly even more  which is why I use a bog standard 2 row box for ceilidh band stuff.  The problems start  when you want/need to play in other keys. For some the answer is an extra part or full row of accidentals ( including perhaps a C# row)  This immediately loses the simplicity of the DG etc and involves ever increasing andd totally illogical  cross rowing and consequential changes that are needed in bellows direction.

 It can be argued that a C#D  if played mainly on the D row is either a hybrid or is pointless!  If on the other hand it is played as a chromatic box it can be useful as eg  A fingering is the same as G on a BC box, D = E, A = B etc. Other than having bouncy bass for the straight D row playing I can't really see its aadvantage over a BC.

The BC is not difficult to learn   but requires a little bit more thought  than   the  mouthorgan like playing on the row on a DG.  Also all keys are different! ( unlike the do it the same on the other row on DG etc boxes.)  However  it can be argued that it is substantially different - but only just!  Provided you  develop the knack of playing scales along the row from bottom to top of a DG or whatever (or on the C row on a BC which is just the same process ) you have the basic fingering for the other keys. Its just a question of starting somewhere else on the continuum & potting the appropriate accidentals which are always readily positioned to hand.  On this basis you can have a small light 2 row with readily available CGDEF & all otheres possible with more difficulty.  The downside, for some but not all, is the lack of rhythm driving bass.  The only answer to this being to have left hand stradella or some other format of same direction bass.  The increasing difficulty of getting all 12 major keys on a aBC is can be neatly circumnaavigated by the addition of a C# row which adds the flat keys without any furthur learning!


Hopefully this has raised more questions than its answered!

george ;)

Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

waldoB

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 126
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #5 on: November 18, 2009, 10:13:59 AM »

Spot on George. As soon as you start adding to say a D/G, weight wise you're well on the way to a BCA. And although there's lot of buttons is correct to say a 12 by 4   stradella base has 12 notes, so not too many heavy reeds for the poor old left hand to waggle about ? DB 
Logged

TomB-R

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 598
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #6 on: November 18, 2009, 01:12:41 PM »

Spot on George. As soon as you start adding to say a D/G, weight wise you're well on the way to a BCA. And although there's lot of buttons is correct to say a 12 by 4   stradella base has 12 notes, so not too many heavy reeds for the poor old left hand to waggle about ? DB 

Slightly splitting hairs, I believe "Stradella" is properly the mechanism that selects all the basses and chords from two sets of chromatic reeds.  Naturally enough "Stradella" is used, (particularly in the melodeon world, I think) to refer to all "same both ways" basses.

48 bass Stradella probably has just as many reeds as 120 bass, just fewer linkages.  Below 32 bass I think you're looking at a fixed relationship of reeds to basses, ie a given reed is only ever used by one button. (Linked bass reeds aside, as found on some 8 bass "melodeons")
Logged

graememackay

  • Graeme Mackay
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 596
  • B/C/C# Pleeeeeeeeeeeeeze
    • Graeme's homepage
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #7 on: November 18, 2009, 01:36:10 PM »

The way I see it is that if you play a quint box and haven't tried or don't understand the semi, you have to treat it as learning a new instrument.

In the beginning you could treat the rows independantly. Playing in C as you would on whatever tuning your quint would be.  Gradually adding in notes from the B row as you go whenever you may need them.

I do think your brain needs to be tuned into the box, but I think the trick is not to anylize it too much.  I was suprised at my workshop at the amount of effort all the guys had gone into to know so much about the keyboard, looking for a logical path round the keys.

There is no logical path, yet they are all in the right place whenever you need them.

All those who would like to give semi boxes a go, come to my workshop in March.  Do it under supervision with the advice on tap amongst others in the same situation.   If you don't have a box suitable, I'll make sure there is one available.
Logged
Black Shand Morino

Steve_freereeder

  • Content Manager
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7511
  • MAD is inevitable. Keep Calm and Carry On
    • Lizzie Dripping
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #8 on: November 18, 2009, 01:43:47 PM »

There is no logical path, yet they are all in the right place whenever you need them.
I think this sounds like the Zen of Melodeon Playing.
I just wish it would apply to me.  :o
Logged
Steve
Sheffield, UK.
www.lizziedripping.org.uk

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #9 on: November 18, 2009, 02:29:29 PM »

Speaking as someone who weighed up the pros and cons of D/G, B/C and C#/D before settling on the last, and who has participated over the past five years in several forums where the respective merits of these systems are chewed over, I would say that there is a typical B/C mindset. It's what in other contexts would be called snobbery.

I notice this particularly in discussions comparing B/C and C#/D. (I would, wouldn't I?) What B/C players seem to overlook is that these two systems are really the same, separated by a tone. And the longer you play and the more you explore, the more you are using the fingerings and playing styles of the other. Indeed many of today's top Irish players are equally at home with either system - Sharon S, Dermot B, Damien Connolly for example.

You play in F? No big deal, I use that scale every single time I pick up the box play - it's G for me. G for you is A for me. Your A major is my B major, which has new challenges for me, but then when I play in C it's the equivalent of Bb for you fellows, which B/C players seem to think is very weird. And nfldbox, as for not using C - have a look around. Joe Burke plays his celebrated rendition of Bonnie Kate in C because it would be a total bear in the fiddle key of D on B/C. Martin Mulhaire plays his composition O'Mahony's reel in C for the same reason. And many other examples.

So climb off your high horses, lads (and it is always the lads who convey this kind of attitude) and recognize all members of the halfstep brotherhood as equals!

PS I'm glad to note that George is nuancing his opinions - after writing about 15 times over the last five years that he "can't see the point" of C#/D, he now says that "it could be argued" that the system was pointless. ;D  (What a pity that Tony McMahon, Mairtin O'Connor, Jackie Daly, Seamus Begley and all those other poor unfortunates have wasted their playing careers on such a pointless system.)

[Edited to re-display - the text was hidden because of accented characters]
« Last Edit: December 11, 2013, 09:07:22 PM by Steve Jones »
Logged

Keithypete.

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 917
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #10 on: November 18, 2009, 02:38:28 PM »

I don't know about C#/D, as I've never played one, but having looked at some of the threads on here and the keyboard layouts I was beginning to edge towards it, mainly to play more easily in D & A, obviously at the expense of an easy G. I don't know what that says about my brain. However, I really like playing the B/C. Now I am making progress in D I am finding it a great deal of fun. As far as being intuitive goes - sometimes fingers just fall to the right key naturally, sometimes the note isn't quite where you thought it would be (i.e) the higher note is backward, of where it should be -nearer ones chin, not nearer ones knees as one would expect.

  Playing in C - easy-peasy. E minor - great. C minor - total nightmare. Try playing Jumpat the Sun in every key starting with C minor. C# minor a doddle, D minor the same. Good exercise

 I have to agree with 'graememackay'  it's like learning a new instrument. Fortunately I knew a few tunes before I started learning the B/C.


The O.P. asks if any box player could get to grips with this system - I think that yes they could, given time and appropriate tuition. Apparently there are some very good  workshops & tutors available hereabouts. Can't get to Aviemore myself - skint. Boo-hoo.
   Still not inclined to go B/C/C# though.
« Last Edit: November 18, 2009, 02:50:12 PM by Keithypete. »
Logged
Beltuna Sara II - B/C flavour.
Borsini - G,D,A.
Pokerwork B/C.
PRIMATONA IV, B/C.

melodeon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1732
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #11 on: November 18, 2009, 03:59:39 PM »

Another thought

For a moment  throw out the notion of the B/C or C#/D as it relates to playing in D , the "common" key for Irish music..

I think,  that if you really know a box... whether B/C or C#/D  and NOT specifically playing in D or specifically playing Irish music.. there really is NO B/C or C#/D  system.. there is only the 1/2 step system.

I believe that would level the playing field ... and therefore... learning or knowing the B/C has no specific advantage or disadvantage or
specific set of mechanics that would differentiate it from even C/C# or D/D#  or G/G#....

If you can play in all the keys on a B/C   you can play in all the keys on a C#/D.. I don't see a difference.

If choosing the B/C or C#/D  for Irish Trad... I think this largely depends on your personal appreciation of the push/pull bounce or B/C fluidity  and of course that goes out the window with the choice of other keys. I don't see one as more exhalted than the other.
Virtuousity I think would be  tough on either.

I believe it was Billy Mac  that said  .. if you can play the B/C you can play anything..   
Some folks thought this was a bit of snobbery .. but I don't think so...on face value,  it is true.  And the same can be said if you are accomplished on the C#/D

I see a current trend of reverse snobbery, ie  getting a  C#/D box to one up by a personal choice of being the under dog.
Similar to buying a Bentley instead of a Rolls   (I worked at a Rolls, Bentely dealership in another life)

I think that if there should be a snobbishness involved in box playing, it should be those that have learned to get along with their choice of "system";  the more simplistic the system and the more accomplished on that system, the more entitled to bragging rights in my opinion...  and the reason I am not in awe of piano accordeon playing as its all there mqapped out.. I applaud piano accordeon players when they don't sound like piano accordeons.   ( thread drift)



Logged

graememackay

  • Graeme Mackay
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 596
  • B/C/C# Pleeeeeeeeeeeeeze
    • Graeme's homepage
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #12 on: November 18, 2009, 04:03:16 PM »

For the purpose of this discussion, any semitone system will qualify, being fully chromatic & designed for lots of cross rowing.  The differences between the semi systems can be argued in another thread I am sure.  

You can call us whatever you like there.

I agree with everything melodeon says
Logged
Black Shand Morino

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #13 on: November 18, 2009, 04:38:13 PM »

I see a current trend of reverse snobbery, ie  getting a  C#/D box to one up by a personal choice of being the under dog

Cripes! For that to be the case you'd have to subscribe to the notion that the C#/D was an underdog. I don't see it like that. Anyway sorry for the thread drift.

To address the original question, rather than supposing the B/C brain (or halfstep brain if you like) was special, I'd say that coming at it from the other angle, the quint-box brain is just as special. That has become clear to me watching all the TOTM videos. It seems to me that you can't master the cross-rowing possibilities without just as much analysis as you would need to learn B/C and the others.

At some point in our development I think analysis has to take a backseat to musicality though.

Gandy

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 407
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #14 on: November 18, 2009, 05:24:40 PM »

  .. Provided you  develop the knack of playing scales along the row from bottom to top of a DG or whatever (or on the C row on a BC which is just the same process ) you have the basic fingering for the other keys. Its just a question of starting somewhere else on the continuum & potting the appropriate accidentals which are always readily positioned to hand.  ...
The fact that those sharps/flats may be in a different direction to the naturals sort of spoils that a little, as the push-pull sequence is different.
Logged
Tony S

MandoC

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 266
    • Swing Dogs Contra Dance Band
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #15 on: November 18, 2009, 06:20:49 PM »

When I decided to get into squeezedom, I ordered a Crane Duet concertina.  It appealed to me because it was fully chromatic (I am a mandolin player, no capos, plays in all keys) and very logically laid out. I liked the concept of the same note on push and pull. I worked on it for about 3 years with little progress. The B/C system appealed to me because it was also more or less chromatic.  I was doubtful about the different notes on the push pull.  Much to my surprise, I liked it and tunes started pouring out of the box (although played slowly with a lot of errors).  I used to play harmonica, and dabbled with chromatic harmonicas, so I think somewhere down in the reptilian part of my brain, the push pull thing was established.  Charlie
Logged
Charlie Hunt
Mandolins and now, B/C Button Accordion)

Swing Dogs Contra Dance Band, Facebook Page:https://www.facebook.com/SwingDogs

triskel

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3290
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #16 on: November 19, 2009, 12:28:47 AM »

I see a current trend of reverse snobbery, ie  getting a  C#/D box to one up by a personal choice of being the under dog
Similar to buying a Bentley instead of a Rolls   (I worked at a Rolls, Bentely dealership in another life)

Cripes! For that to be the case you'd have to subscribe to the notion that the C#/D was an underdog. I don't see it like that.

Me neither, in fact (in the British Isles) it used to be that a Rolls Royce was considered "new money" (flashy and "showing off") whilst a Bentley was considered "old money" (classier), and a Daimler was for Royalty.

Anyway, Bentleys are faster, like C#/Ds...  ;)

Keithypete.

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 917
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #17 on: November 19, 2009, 01:30:27 AM »

I don't know about Prestige cars in general because I've never had one, but as for system snobbery I think I understand; maybe some people think they're better because they've mastered the system of their choice. I've had it from P.A. players. But why is the semi-tone system considered less logical than a D/G, C/F etc? Just because the notes are layed out in a single row doesn't mean you will play the button next to the one you've just played. Once you know where all the notes on a B/C or C#/D are, which direction etc, it becomes logical to play a scale of D major by starting at D and ending up at D one octave higher via E, F#, G, etc. I'm going to have to try C#/D now for sure.
Logged
Beltuna Sara II - B/C flavour.
Borsini - G,D,A.
Pokerwork B/C.
PRIMATONA IV, B/C.

melodeon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1732
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #18 on: November 19, 2009, 01:33:04 AM »

I should calrify that it is not my opinion but an observation that the C#/D was a "lesser" choice  seemingly made by those who did want to face the popular notion that the learning curve on a B/C was prohibitive.  Virtuosity is hard won on any system

Bentley's were chosen exactly as you describe, to give the allusion you were old money and did not need the flash of a Rolls.
I lost interest I Rolls when they went to a V8 and dual headlights.. the end of an era; when the valve cover gasket was a piece of purple silk thread....
And as for Bentleys... a 30's Blower would be a fine daily driver.


Just as there are artists that do it by the numbers and don't quite get it...same goes for furniture makers, comedians, bankers, mechanics.and of course box players.   I admire technical skill... but it all comes down to.... please,just one soulful note.

And to this day my favorite players are still one row players .... then 2 row, then 3



« Last Edit: November 19, 2009, 01:34:52 AM by melodeon »
Logged

nfldbox

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 492
Re: B/C Brain
« Reply #19 on: November 19, 2009, 03:32:23 AM »

I have the impression that I was the one accused of "B/C snobbery". i really don't see why. My teacher, a much much better player than I, plays C#/D. I just find the B/C suits me. And I don't not play in C because I am averse to playing on one row, but because no tunes have attracted me and/or people with whom I was playing didn't bring one up.
I still think there is some prime difference between C#/D and B/C players, perhaps just the "push-pull" and the "flow," but I think it is more to do with some assumptions we enter the game with. And of course the established players  that we wish to emulate.
Logged
BC Cairdin
BC Hohner Double Ray
Bouchard en Ré
Pages: [1] 2 3 4   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal