Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion  (Read 3103 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Elizabeth Moran

  • Either that B-word or that C-word
  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
  • Why, yes, I will have some cheese with that whine.
    • Bookface
New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« on: July 19, 2023, 09:32:43 PM »

I would like OPINIONS on the brand and quality of reeds I should have installed in my 21/8 LMM 3v PAOLO SOPRANI B/C to convert it into a C#/D MMM instrument.

If I have any druthers or fantasies it is that I'm looking for a quality most resembling the sound of the late 1940s type of Paolo reeds.

I would appreciate it if suggestions would be limited to reeds in current manufacture and availability. Any country of origin.

Thank you.
Logged
C#/D Paolo Soprani/Busilacchio MMM
A/Bb Hohner Presswood MM

FS: HoHner Swiss-made Primatona D/D# with Paolo basses with F# push for Finbar Dwyer music.
FS: Paolo Soprani 21/8 LMM B/C 2-coupler, recently revalved, terrific sound.

tirpous

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1403
Re: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« Reply #1 on: July 19, 2023, 11:47:05 PM »

Was your Paolo originally in B/C or has it been converted from another tuning ?  If original I would suggest leave it as-is and look for another box    in C#/D.

I may be wrong but I suspect the 'late 1940s' sound is more a matter of voicing (how the 3 reed banks are tuned with respect to each other) than exact reed brand and quality.  Probably any reputable Tipo a Mano or a Mano reeds could be made to work reasonably well by a skilled tuner.

These are just quick ideas to get the ball rolling, really.  This is a complex topic and the devil is in the details - you may have heard about a well-known player who had his 1940s Holy Grail Old Grey Paolo overhauled to replace original reeds by Bincis, to his entire satisfaction but many people felt it took the magic out of the box...

Opinions, you asked ?!  ;)
Logged

mselic

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1683
Re: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« Reply #2 on: July 20, 2023, 05:33:22 AM »

Correct me if I’m wrong, but I believe the Paolo in the OP’s photo would have originally been a 4th apart box with a stepped keyboard that someone converted. Failing the use of 1940/50s original Paolo reeds, something like Voci Armoniche reeds would make a good substitute.
Logged
C#/D player

Elizabeth Moran

  • Either that B-word or that C-word
  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
  • Why, yes, I will have some cheese with that whine.
    • Bookface
Re: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« Reply #3 on: July 20, 2023, 07:45:18 PM »

Was your Paolo originally in B/C or has it been converted from another tuning ?  If original I would suggest leave it as-is and look for another box    in C#/D.

I may be wrong but I suspect the 'late 1940s' sound is more a matter of voicing (how the 3 reed banks are tuned with respect to each other) than exact reed brand and quality.  Probably any reputable Tipo a Mano or a Mano reeds could be made to work reasonably well by a skilled tuner.

These are just quick ideas to get the ball rolling, really.  This is a complex topic and the devil is in the details - you may have heard about a well-known player who had his 1940s Holy Grail Old Grey Paolo overhauled to replace original reeds by Bincis, to his entire satisfaction but many people felt it took the magic out of the box...

Opinions, you asked ?!  ;)

Yes, thank you. I am looking for opinions. I DO know which the depths I step! :)

It may have been a stepped 4th-tuned box originally. I can't hold that against it. It has a lot to recommend it as a box in generaL. Nice tone chamber and wooden soundboard, nice action, good weight, compact. And ... it's paid for and didn't cost me $3K.

The reeds in it right now are very good and the two MM reeds may well be original Paolo B/C, I don not know. They sound great.

Here is a vid of a C#/D conversion of a similar box https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TVbJwnMRBiU

Even though I love BINCI A Mano reeds and have sought them for this conversion, I am aware that they may not be the best replica of the sound profile I am looking for. Reeds made in factories for production accordions carry their own unique character of manufacture which we may see as flaws, but which ultimately turn out to be the crucial acoustical elements off the Holy Grail we seek. Thus the Magic. The Japanese call it "sawari".

There is a particular "jangle" in the 1940s boxes which I don't hear in the 50s gray Paolo's. The 1930s Paolo's have the same quality, although with less volume. It's really subtle, but it is there. Possibly a difference in the pallets .... zinc? aluminum? pot metal? or the quality of the ribbon or even the rivets?

... Maybe the tuning is offset differently? Asymmetrical? Anyone with tuning experience in that direction? It would explain the 'separation' I hear. I can really tell that I'm hearing three reeds, whereas more modern boxes have a thicker homogenous tremolo.

(And that will lead me to another future topic: Musette tuning types and degrees. For another time.)

What changed in 1950? We know what changed around 1960: the metal soundboard.

More to chew on and imagine.

I'm going to get under the hood and look at the blocks when I get closer to raising funds for the conversion. In the meantime, I'm open to suggestions about reed types and grades.

And then I watch videos of Johnny Connolly playing gorgeous melodeon on a threadbare Hohner 3-stop 10-key with a bare galvanized steel soundboard ....

Thanks, all! Please feel free to think out loud with me.


« Last Edit: July 21, 2023, 03:25:15 AM by Elizabeth Moran »
Logged
C#/D Paolo Soprani/Busilacchio MMM
A/Bb Hohner Presswood MM

FS: HoHner Swiss-made Primatona D/D# with Paolo basses with F# push for Finbar Dwyer music.
FS: Paolo Soprani 21/8 LMM B/C 2-coupler, recently revalved, terrific sound.

Elizabeth Moran

  • Either that B-word or that C-word
  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
  • Why, yes, I will have some cheese with that whine.
    • Bookface
Re: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« Reply #4 on: July 21, 2023, 03:14:17 AM »

Correct me if I’m wrong, but I believe the Paolo in the OP’s photo would have originally been a 4th apart box with a stepped keyboard that someone converted. Failing the use of 1940/50s original Paolo reeds, something like Voci Armoniche reeds would make a good substitute.

I think that makes sense.

I also just heard the tuning on one of Paddy Clancy's new C#/D MMM accordions and that's probably as close as I could imagine to the sound I'm looking for. Very likely +8/ 0 /-8 or +10/ 0 /-10. It has a spacious, bright quality.
« Last Edit: July 21, 2023, 03:26:47 AM by Elizabeth Moran »
Logged
C#/D Paolo Soprani/Busilacchio MMM
A/Bb Hohner Presswood MM

FS: HoHner Swiss-made Primatona D/D# with Paolo basses with F# push for Finbar Dwyer music.
FS: Paolo Soprani 21/8 LMM B/C 2-coupler, recently revalved, terrific sound.

odonovanchris

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 276
    • Instagram Accordion Profile: chris0donovan
Re: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« Reply #5 on: July 21, 2023, 04:00:25 PM »

I agree with Matt's comment above. Most likely a conversion from G/C or similar and the keyboard was flattened.

Original paolo soprani reeds from the 1940s/50s were standard machine made reeds on aluminium plates and rolled (swedish?) steel tongues. I had a metallurgist analyse an original paolo reed tongue and he said there were lots of impurities in the steel which indicated that it wasn't particularly high quality. I might do a separate post on that topic sometime.

You could go with the mid-tier on any of the modern reed makers and it should work out fine. Good reed voicing and tuning are what make the biggest difference, provided the reed has good gap tolerances etc. What sort of sound are you after for this box? Any examples of tunes or a particular musician's instrument you're trying to emulate?
Logged
See my accordion projects on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/chris0donovan/

gettabettabox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 684
Re: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« Reply #6 on: July 21, 2023, 04:57:59 PM »

Got a Clancy C#/D 3 voice here, ciccarelli reeds, minus plus 10 cents. Jangly nice.  (:)
Logged

Paul Bryan

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 37
Re: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« Reply #7 on: July 22, 2023, 02:58:52 PM »

  hi i have done a lot of work on paolos and original reeds were not great quality but sound great  tipo a mano reeds would be fine for conversion with plastic valves once tuned to produce the sound you want  italian reed makers will only deal with makers and tuners who order lots of sets at a time my advice is to speek to a tuner first then decide reed make, tuning across the reed blocks ,eg +/-10 cents each make of box has its own sound owing to the construction methods and material used so its not always possible to achive the sound you want  best of luck with the project
Logged

mselic

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1683
Re: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« Reply #8 on: July 24, 2023, 12:44:29 AM »

Replicating the sound/tone/timbre of the old Paolos greys from the 40s/50s is more than just a case of getting original Paolo reeds from that era and tuning them a particular way; as others have mentioned, the final sound of an instrument is a combination of factors which include the construction/materials of a particular box.  You're probably not going to be able to replicate the sound of one of those old 'greys' unless you get yourself an old grey! You can get near enough, though, with a Paolo such as yours and any modern Italian reed.
Logged
C#/D player

Elizabeth Moran

  • Either that B-word or that C-word
  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
  • Why, yes, I will have some cheese with that whine.
    • Bookface
Re: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« Reply #9 on: July 24, 2023, 09:08:30 AM »

Got a Clancy C#/D 3 voice here, ciccarelli reeds, minus plus 10 cents. Jangly nice.  (:)

That's great. That is probably the box I heard on FB, recently. That's the best new 3-v MMM C#/D I've heard. I sold the first Cairdin 2-v in the States around the turn of the century and I used to embarrass Paddy by saying what a tuning genius I thought he was. He just said it was all numbers, but I always felt he had a very special ear. I still hold to that particularly after hearing that C#/D MMM this past week.

(I know because my ear, while WHOLLY untrained, is so discerning it drives me crazy.)
Logged
C#/D Paolo Soprani/Busilacchio MMM
A/Bb Hohner Presswood MM

FS: HoHner Swiss-made Primatona D/D# with Paolo basses with F# push for Finbar Dwyer music.
FS: Paolo Soprani 21/8 LMM B/C 2-coupler, recently revalved, terrific sound.

Elizabeth Moran

  • Either that B-word or that C-word
  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
  • Why, yes, I will have some cheese with that whine.
    • Bookface
Re: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« Reply #10 on: July 24, 2023, 09:27:11 AM »

Replicating the sound/tone/timbre of the old Paolos greys from the 40s/50s is more than just a case of getting original Paolo reeds from that era and tuning them a particular way; as others have mentioned, the final sound of an instrument is a combination of factors which include the construction/materials of a particular box.  You're probably not going to be able to replicate the sound of one of those old 'greys' unless you get yourself an old grey! You can get near enough, though, with a Paolo such as yours and any modern Italian reed.

Yes, I do understand how Quixotic my current box fantasies have become. Close enough will be quite good enough. Here is a vid of a C#/D conversion of a similar 21/8 Paolo that Connor Connolly did: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TVbJwnMRBiU

A lot of the mystery that I hear in the old instruments is, as you and others surmise, the fact that they were just a particular confluence of elements coming together at a certain point in history: thick, soft wood chambers, particular thicknesses of wooden soundboards, metallurgical flaws in mass produced steel ribbon, and a unique manual flair and sense of style for imagining and making accordions. Have you ever heard Billy McComiskey talk about the marvels of the B/C system, "Old man Paolo Soprani" and guys like Paddy O'Brien of Tipperary and Sonny Brogan? If you haven't you should. It's almost Biblical.
Logged
C#/D Paolo Soprani/Busilacchio MMM
A/Bb Hohner Presswood MM

FS: HoHner Swiss-made Primatona D/D# with Paolo basses with F# push for Finbar Dwyer music.
FS: Paolo Soprani 21/8 LMM B/C 2-coupler, recently revalved, terrific sound.

Rog

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2525
  • Repair and tuning in Hants
Re: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« Reply #11 on: July 24, 2023, 11:34:40 AM »

The key ingredient though is the musician. It’s easy to get the sound and the technical aspect of how it’s achieved (reeds, fondo etc) confused with the abilities of a great player to make any box sound great.

Elizabeth Moran

  • Either that B-word or that C-word
  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
  • Why, yes, I will have some cheese with that whine.
    • Bookface
Re: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« Reply #12 on: July 25, 2023, 06:06:29 PM »

Replicating the sound/tone/timbre of the old Paolos greys from the 40s/50s is more than just a case of getting original Paolo reeds from that era and tuning them a particular way; as others have mentioned, the final sound of an instrument is a combination of factors which include the construction/materials of a particular box.  You're probably not going to be able to replicate the sound of one of those old 'greys' unless you get yourself an old grey! You can get near enough, though, with a Paolo such as yours and any modern Italian reed.

And the more I listen to current recordings of players using these boxes made in the 1940s, the more I hear those unique "imperfections" that would have been natural for instruments made in the postwar era, particularly Italy which was originally serving the Fascist war effort and then occupied by the Allies until 1945/46. The black or gray celluloid was likely all they had for a good while. Red was a luxury pigment (it was also the pigment of a target). I would think that Swedish steel was co-opted by Germany for their use during the war as they used Sweden as an easement to occupied Norway. So that "jangling" sound I'm so fond of just may well be 2nd rate steel or perhaps prewar NOS material or reeds in the basements of Paolo workshops? The stories these accordions could tell would fill many books, I'm sure. Enough for a nerd like me for a good many months or years.
Logged
C#/D Paolo Soprani/Busilacchio MMM
A/Bb Hohner Presswood MM

FS: HoHner Swiss-made Primatona D/D# with Paolo basses with F# push for Finbar Dwyer music.
FS: Paolo Soprani 21/8 LMM B/C 2-coupler, recently revalved, terrific sound.

Elizabeth Moran

  • Either that B-word or that C-word
  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
  • Why, yes, I will have some cheese with that whine.
    • Bookface
Re: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« Reply #13 on: July 25, 2023, 06:50:43 PM »

The key ingredient though is the musician. It’s easy to get the sound and the technical aspect of how it’s achieved (reeds, fondo etc) confused with the abilities of a great player to make any box sound great.

Yes, these are just musings of a gear nerd. But my fascination and spiritual attachment to these boxes goes back to first hearing Tony McMahon play his old D/D# in the 1970s. When I went to Ireland in 1976, I was a 19-yo college student with only a brass D generation whistle in my bag. My first week was in Dublin where I discovered Donohue's near St. Stephen's Green on my second night in town. There, Paddy O'Brien from Offaly was sitting at at the front table playing his gray B/C. I sat down there with my Smithwick's Ale and listened attentively to him spinning reels until Paddy spotted the top of my whistle peaking out from the top of my bag, then he entreated me to join him. When I replied that my repertoire was VERY limited, he just nodded and told me to call the tunes. LARK IN THE MORNING JIG/A FIG FOR A KISS, THE CHANTER'S SONG/MARCH OF THE KING OF LAOIS, BOYS OF BLUEHILL/THE WIND THAT SHAKES THE BARLEY, WHELEN'S/THE WALLS OF LISCARROLL, DROWSY MAGGIE/THE LARK ON THE STRAND, MOUNTAIN ROADS/MISS McM's, maybe SI BHEAG, SI MHOR and TABHAIR DOM DO LÁMH. I think that was all I knew, but I played them with proper phrasing and decent ornamentation because I had a good Irish music teacher, fiddler Richard Twomey, and I woodshedded all through later high school and my freshman year in college. When I lamented to Paddy that I didn't know more, he replied generously, "Ah, but you know good ones!" and I BLUSHED. He was such a gentleman.

I later recorded Tony MacMahon playing at Slattery's on Capel Street, and Joe Burke. As I was left-handed I didn't see any future for me in accordion at the time. Twenty years later I bought the Joe Cooley album, COOLEY, on Gael-Linn and a few years after than I bought a 60's Paolo D/D# 9-coupler from Paul Groff and turned it upside down and started playing it southpaw. Later I purchased a Saltarelle Irish Bouebe in C#/D from Billy McComiskey who really tried to convert me to B/C, but I couldn't figure out how to use my left pinkie and ringfinger in proper order. A couple of years ago I rededicated myself to box again and my left hand is far more teachable at 67 than it was at 42! I'm playing a bit more B/C, mainly because Jackie Daly throws that fingering into his playing more than I like, but also because it's such a great sound. As Billy says, "B/C has BALLS!"

But I'm still predominantly a press/draw (C#/D, D/D#) person.
« Last Edit: July 25, 2023, 07:04:13 PM by Elizabeth Moran »
Logged
C#/D Paolo Soprani/Busilacchio MMM
A/Bb Hohner Presswood MM

FS: HoHner Swiss-made Primatona D/D# with Paolo basses with F# push for Finbar Dwyer music.
FS: Paolo Soprani 21/8 LMM B/C 2-coupler, recently revalved, terrific sound.

Lars

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 797
Re: New reeds for a PAOLO SOPRANI conversion
« Reply #14 on: August 11, 2023, 12:55:02 PM »

I've fitted new reeds in about 15 of these small 21 button 8 bass Paolo Sopranis, and I've tried various brands, materials, and grades.

To me, the ones that worked 'best' (to my ears, others might disagree) for a somewhat wet classic Paolo tuning (MMM, -14/0/+14 or wetter) were Tipo A Mano from Harmonikas. They're readily available (if you order 12-14 weeks in advance), they're not crazy expensive, and to my ears, the timbre works well for that classic Paolo tone, especially after hours and hours of playing. 

I found that higher grade reeds (A MANO etc) often had a somewhat 'harder' tone in this kind of box. That's nice too, and works very well for many other boxes, but to me, the TAM just has a little extra something in getting closer to 50's italians reeds.

Original Paolo reeds changed a bit between the late 40's and the early 60's. This past week I had three sets of reeds out on the table from a grey 40's, a red mid 50's and a red early 60's Paolo, and they were pretty different. The older seemed to be softer and thinner aluminium plates (pretty crudely stamped out too) with shorter, thinner steel reeds than the later ones. The early 60's were the thickest plates, with the longest scale reed, most similar to a new TAM reeds IMO. Common for all three kinds were, that they were not fancy reeds. Quickly made, 'cheap' factory reeds. Could you get better response by using fancy handmade reeds? Yep. Would it sound better? Maybe to your ears - but I know what I'd prefer.

Anyways, long winded rant - and not all might agree, as we luckily all have our own set of ears. But in terms of availability, price, and TONE, I think TAM-grade reeds are the best choice for the job.
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal