you are definitely on the right board. We’ve discussed the issue hundreds of times
The underlying issue is that the basis accordion design was G/C and woodwork, read plates, the lot reflect that. Those technologies also suit the physical properties of real steel reeds. , A G/C, played in A minor, is a thing of beauty, with rich tones in both octaves. It’s a “sweet spotâ€
Because makers have to work with real reeds, any other tonality basically uses notes that are sharp of the original design. The notes become more higher pitched on the upper octave, ie less pleasant, as you move away from G/C in either direction. The most distant tonality from C musically is F#, corresponding to a C#/F# machine.
So your C/F, (and the British D/G) are about as close to that ‘bad spiot’ as possible, without playing in a silly key. The upper octave will always be sound high-pitched. That’s because of the way melodeons were designed in the first place.
A workaround, which you might like to explore in our archives, is to move all the notes by 1 space toward the feet. “4th button startâ€. That gives you the ‘on row’ low notes that seek. It ‘can’ be done as a modification, but any 3rd row would then feel rather strange to the fingers
The club system is a massive step towards chromaticity, most of those scales are on the pull, but you will always be one note short. However Club is fantastic when played in the modal scales of its 2 main rows, or in a scale closely related to those. that is how Melodeons work!
If chromaticity is important to you, are you basically need a continental button accordion. Much more expensive and much heavier.