Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2   Go Down

Author Topic: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?  (Read 5508 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Michael Weir

  • New Starter
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3

Hello All,

If I may I would like to tap into the hive mind here, to assist with a choice I am making that my musical inexperience is hindering.

The Background.

I am a relative beginner on the melodeon and my musical theory is limited to knowing that a chord is made of 1st, 3rd, 5th notes.  So please keep answers simple for a musical idiot.
My wife and I are setting off next year on a sailing adventure, that will include the British isles, Europe, Atlantic and further afield as wind and tides allow.  It would be nice to be able to collect some tunes along the way, which is why I am looking for a versatile layout that allows me plenty of options and I can grow into.  Living on a boat means space is limited so the less boxes the better and ideally one.  My musical tastes to play are very varied, English, Irish, Scottish, French, Scandi, and many others.

My solution is a Liliput 12 bass conversion using Paul Youngs layout, however, his layout uses 5 buttons on the half row and a liliput only has 4.  But with my lack of understanding/experience I don't know which accidentals to lose.

Another option is to go for a conventional liliput DG layout or a CF as I already have a small 2 row DG, and when I eventually know what I need change it then.

I welcome your thoughts.
Logged
Hohner Pokerwork DG,

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #1 on: August 12, 2023, 10:18:15 PM »


   Paul’s website gives this as his 12 bass layout. It will have been carefully thought through to suit his own music, but with your rather catholic tastes it is difficult to suggest changes to finesse it further. It does have those 5 buttons on the inner row, what are yours?

   As you won’t be playing with … all that many other people, I would suggest that you keep the instrument in whatever key it has presently.  I wouldn’t personally take more than one accordion on a long journey. it would be prudent to take a small toolkit, and a little wax.

   if your own machine has a different layout, please let the forum know and we can advise what sort of music might work best on it.
« Last Edit: August 12, 2023, 10:45:48 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Michael Weir

  • New Starter
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #2 on: August 12, 2023, 11:00:02 PM »

Thank you for your input Chris,

I apologise for not making it clear that this is a potential purchase, that is currently in renovation and thus can be tuned to my preference.  I like Pauls description of his layout as he has developed it to be a pretty good 1 box fits a lot of situations. (Obviously he has the skills to make it do so, of which if I ever have a fraction of his ability I'll be happy).

I mentioned my current tastes as a starter, but they are always changing and as I explore the world they will probably continue to do so.  And it is that exploring of the world and the variety of folk music that I want to be able to take a tune or two from here or there, that drives me to desire a versatile layout.

As the liliput meets my compact instrument desires, and Pauls layout is a good potential, I just need to work out which accidentals to drop, that still gives me flexibility to play (some of ) the music we meet on our travels.
Logged
Hohner Pokerwork DG,

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #3 on: August 12, 2023, 11:02:58 PM »

If it’s DG then you can make a nice layout with 4th button start and put two more accidentals in the first buttons of the main rows.  No need to loose anything except two higher pitch buttons that you won’t miss.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Gena Crisman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1108
  • 🇬🇧
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #4 on: August 12, 2023, 11:11:02 PM »

Was there any particular reason that you settled on Paul Young's layout?
« Last Edit: August 13, 2023, 02:21:18 AM by Gena Crisman »
Logged

Squeaky Pete

  • Squeaky Pete
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1327
  • Re-hohn a Hohner
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #5 on: August 12, 2023, 11:26:07 PM »

Will Allen's layout for a 4 button helper row is well thought out too.
He plays a 25 button Club II/Erika type which is exactly the same layout as a Liliput/Preciosa. This layout is to get the best out of 8 bass.
12 bass will expand the possibilities but make sure the extra basses fit with bellows directions. And do you want to have an instrument that can play in more exotic keys, or make near the home keys easier?
Logged
Poker work DG.
Pariselle 2.6 DG, Ex-Club IIIBS CF,
Matching Liliputs in CF and DG,
Lots of sickly Hohners needing TLC,
Bassoon, Various Bagpipes........

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #6 on: August 13, 2023, 12:20:10 AM »


   As do you intend to explore musically … in unknown directions, and expect those directions to veer from the simple modes of the 2 main row scales …

  in practice most of the fancy stuff is done on the pull, as there are more differing main-row notes in that direction. Your G scale is complete apart from absence of a pull D note. A push E is less important, at least in the tunes that I attempt

  I would tend to go to address that by “clubbing” the instrument. Which is probably how it started out! basically the middle inner row D/E becomes D/D. It makes a whole load of scales play fluently through the mid part of the keyboard, and you get a handy rt end pull G chord or arpegio.

  Others here will differ. The main reason not to do this is if you want to play G, or its modal minors Am and Em, in a straightforward way along the G row. from your original post, I don’t think that is where you are headed? In the end, your fingers will get used to either system.

  You have lost your pull E note if you do that. I’m afraid that the maths of keyboards means that you have to lose something! The lower F/F is very handy; Many forum members have stated that. The octave 5 one will not be so critical. You will commonly be passing through that note on the on the pull, playing scale.

  I would be tempted to specify that as an Eb/F (an easy retune). The reason is that the most useful harmonic minor on this kit will be Em.  The “turnaround’ or “dominant” chord in that scale is unavoidably (sorry) B7 = BEbF#A and a lot of tunes will pass through that note sequence, or part of it

   If you intend to play any harmonic minor stuff, and that includes most of Eastern Europe, Scandinavian, Klesmer, and many classical pieces, that would be a strong move in the right direction.  Paul’s layout has a Bm chord on left however, which will clash with it. The simple fix is simply to leave the third out your push B chord => B+F#.  You have both major (Eb) and minor (D) notes on push on the other end, and with a bit of practice you will just stick a finger on one of those if you want to assert major or minor chord within your tune.

   I think that might cover a lot of bases for you.
   
« Last Edit: August 13, 2023, 12:27:19 AM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #7 on: August 13, 2023, 08:32:33 AM »

Over the last year I've gone through a couple of layout changes before settling on Paul's layout, though I do have a five button accidental row.
I'd been wanting to try to play tunes in Bb and Gm.  I often wanted to play a push Fnat in the melody against a Bb chord and couldn't do it. Paul's layout allows such a choice.
I regard it as going off piste for most DG tunes where you simply want accidentals near your fingers.
A quick glance at Chris's mutated layout might be a good compromise.
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #8 on: August 13, 2023, 09:35:48 AM »


    One of the reasons for the extra push Eb is to open up flat keys It fits in nicely with the left end Bb chord, and mutual compatibility of the 2 ends is very important on our instrument.

    F isn’t an important note in the musical “colour” of a Bb scale. It’s just a 3rd harmonic  of the tonic, and in Bb chords can be emitted completely. But we stray off topic.

   Bb scale is useful because it is a basis for Cm and Gm tunes.

    Note thay it throws Eb/F onto same button.  Not all the off piste (melnet term for not on the main rows) scale run all the way through on a single bellows movement, but  if your “wrong-way” note is paired with an in-scale note you can play the tune through it with a bellows flick. which is the same principle as the “magic button” on B/C boxes.  But that is off topic too!  The Eb “mutation” is just a suggestion, and Michael will soon have discovered that that ideal layout always depends on what sort of music you like to play. As we have all also discovered in our journeys 😉
« Last Edit: August 13, 2023, 09:38:44 AM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #9 on: August 13, 2023, 09:52:32 AM »

"Michael will soon have discovered that that ideal layout always depends on what sort of music you like to play. As we have all also discovered in our journeys"
The key to everything - what do you want to play?

... and that may well change over time, as I have found out.
Therefore a choice of layout, or even choice of melodeon, can change as we go along the road.
Meandering along the road, happily following our nose and no idea where the road goes  (:)

Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #10 on: August 13, 2023, 11:35:52 AM »


  Analysing  the various right hand scales, and tonic, dominant and subdominant chords, which are your arpeggios in music. This layout seems to have been optimised for play in scales within 2 #s, or 2 b’s of G. If we use my push Eb suggestion, and “club” G-row D/E => D/D

Bb = BbCDEbFGA scale is awkward but Eb, F7 chords 👍

F = FGABbCDEF semi fluent push=>pull, Bb, C7 chords 👍

C = CDEFGABC  fluent on pull, all chords👍
G = GABCDEF#G fluent on pull, all chords👍
D  = DEF#GABC#D fluent on pull, all chords👍
A = ABC#DEF#G#A  fluent on pull, all chords 👍

E = EF#G#ABC#D#E semi-fluent on pull (D# is awkward),  chords: A👍 pull, B7=👍 push

B = BC#D#EF#GA#B awkward

So there are plenty of play possibilities … it’s a clever design
« Last Edit: August 13, 2023, 11:38:37 AM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Squeaky Pete

  • Squeaky Pete
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1327
  • Re-hohn a Hohner
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #11 on: August 13, 2023, 12:54:05 PM »

Good analysis Chris.
Logged
Poker work DG.
Pariselle 2.6 DG, Ex-Club IIIBS CF,
Matching Liliputs in CF and DG,
Lots of sickly Hohners needing TLC,
Bassoon, Various Bagpipes........

Gena Crisman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1108
  • 🇬🇧
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #12 on: August 13, 2023, 02:37:10 PM »

I apologise for not making it clear that this is a potential purchase, that is currently in renovation and thus can be tuned to my preference.  I like Pauls description of his layout as he has developed it to be a pretty good 1 box fits a lot of situations. (Obviously he has the skills to make it do so, of which if I ever have a fraction of his ability I'll be happy).

Ah, I saw Theo's post when melnet informed me posts had been made before mine, but, not yours. So, this is your reasoning for it.

The button that the liliput doesn't have is the one physically located between the 3rd and 4th button of the middle (G) row. In Paul's layout, this is the F4/F4.

The most basic solution for 'I want to play in more keys' are the 4 buttons: Eb4/F4 Bb4/G#4 Eb5/F5 Bb5/G#5 - 'both' 'pairs' of accidentals in 'both' octaves. Paul expands this to 7 buttons (5 half row, and 2 chin end), by including the very useful pull D4 and D5, adds a push F4 and push F5, and adds a low Bb3/B3. He has an explanation of why he chooses these things on his website: https://www.paulyoungfolk.co.uk/layouts - and also note, the 2021 update where he mentions (for those with long memories) the change from Bb3/G#3.

Effectively though, my conclusion is that his choices are influenced by the desire to have competency of bass end accompaniment in the broad range of keys he wants to play in, rather than say, chromaticism on the pull, or, more reversals for smoother/more comfortable playing. This is basically my view, too, and if you feel like it lines up with yours, perhaps my advice would be useful?

My suggestion is that, the low Bb/B button, on the D row, offers a reversal for a low pull B, as well as a low octave Bb3. These seems to me as probably the least valuable buttons of the set, as while I can see it being useful, I can't see it being game changing. However, this would be working from my experience which doesn't really include significant amounts of playing in F and Bb & related minor keys. The times I have done this, on a 2.6 row/12b instrument but which doesn't have the F both ways, instantly cemented in my mind that both Fs both ways was very important to me, for exactly the reason Thrupenny Bit posted here; http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=29600.msg350556#msg350556 - and that Paul mentions on his page there: being able to play the F melody note with the push D and Bb basses. (Latter is like not being able to play a G note with your C basses, for those stuck in D/G land).

Probably then, I would keep the F4/F4 and relocate it to the chin end, either in that spot, or by shuffling the Eb4/D4 down. There really are a great number of options available to you, but they will be informed by the notes you'll have to figure out if you do or don't use. Given you do have other melodeons, though, I wouldn't pursue either dutch reversing or clubbing, unless that idea is one you find particularly inspiring.

Perhaps it might be worth it to try emailing Paul via his website, and asking him what he'd do?
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #13 on: August 13, 2023, 03:49:01 PM »


   Wise thoughts as ever, Gina. I don’t think many would be try to play this in F. even I don’t do that. 

   But as we well know you don’t have to play a scale, based on its original tonic note. There are seven notes and you can start on any of them, the so-called modes.  The simple minor mode of F is D minor, and I’m surprised that you haven’t had to use it in your own music. It gets rather more complicated should Michael, want to play any of the classic blues stuff.  I usually sing “15 tons” in Dm.  And “nobody loves you when you’re down and out” has runs of about 5 chords, each one the dominant of the next eg D7>G7>Cm>F7>Bb.  This kit would be great for that sort of thing?

   Push B-flat is also a great way to play in the sumptuous Gm key, just substitute Bb for D (±Eb according to the tune). It’s hard to say how useful that would be without knowing Michaels repertoire. it’s also requires taking the third out of the G chord as well, which is why I didn’t mention it. 

     @Michael - taking the thirds out of the chords makes them neither major nor minor. With a box like yours, you can usually dot in the required note to assert that, using a spare right finger.  Later in your journey, you will pick up that you don’t have to play a chord with its own base. Eg Em-pull,  on bass C => C minor chord. Taking the thirds out facilitates that, and is strongly recommended for your push B chord.

    A strip of tape suffices, and it is reversible.  I don’t have any thirds at all in my own kit and I never miss them. But if you’d like to dum-cha while playing on the main rows, you will probably want to leave the thirds in on the other 7 chords toward the front end. EIther way you don’t have to make that decision now 🙂

   Gina 👍👍 to F both ways. So many members of our group have said that! I use it mostly in “lower” octave 4, for which is why I wondered about having 2 E-flats. Neither is without compromises and it will as ever “depend on repertoire”.

   I agree with you about the very low Bb/B.  A low pull B doesn’t get used very much unless you like messing about in pentatonic stuff against a D tune.  And I don’t think the very low B-flat will get used much.  It could be used a in octave 4 as different accidentals, or to provide a push E. That would need some adjustment to the resonance chamber, but the machine is with a fettler anyway. Any ideas?

 
« Last Edit: August 13, 2023, 04:01:39 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Michael Weir

  • New Starter
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #14 on: August 13, 2023, 09:19:02 PM »

Wow!  Thank you all for your consideration and time in solving my dilemma. I am very grateful and amazed by your efforts based on my limited information.  Firstly an apology for not replying sooner, but today is our first day back working on the aforementioned boat after SFF.

I'll try to answer/comment as appropriate.

3. Theo, that is one idea I had as the squeaky end is not my preferred one.

5. Pete, I had looked at Wills layout, but was unsure what to do with the extra basses I'll get with the conversion.  I am making a sweeping assumption that his layout favours the more English traditional tunes.

6, 8, 10. Chris, I like the look of your suggested layout and the clubbing of D makes sense.  Early in my learning I made sure I was comfortable playing across the rows. My current weakness is the lefthand end, which is why I am back at twinkle twinkle! The boat refit has taken priority, but we are close to finishing so more squeezing is on the horizon :).  One of the F/F's was my first instinct to drop, but after reading other discussions about Pauls layout, I quickly realised how valuable more experienced players find them. 
I wish I knew, what tunes I'm likely to pick up in my travels, however, this has made me ponder the topic and I should really focus on the more maritimey ones.

12.  Gena, some good ideas that I will have to ponder how my current small 'abattoir' of tunes affects.  Although I have another box at the moment, my intention is to only have one box due to the limited space onboard, MAD will have to wait until we retire to a narrow boat ;).  I hadn't thought of contacting Paul, so may pursue that.

13. Chris, definitely no blues for me, not my vibe.  Maybe some metal riffs from my youth ;).  I had also noted Pauls comment on the thirds, as the Liliput has no bass stop, thus I am already intending to tape the thirds.  As you recommend no third on the B chord, is it worth using that reed to enhance the chord? or would that be adding unnecessary complexity.

In summary I like Chris's suggested layout as it presents most options as I see it.  Pauls layout is a good option as well, losing a squeaky button or the low B to accommodate the more useful accidentals.  I have been trying hard to collate what I like to play or want to play and in no particular order it is reels, jigs, polkas, mazurkas, hornpipes, marches, waltzes for a start.  Pretty much anything Paul Youngs puts on his YouTube channel, along with Cutting and Spiers originals, more recently some balfolk is interesting me.

Once again thank you for your help, you have given me plenty to consider, and some of it I understood :).  I think my next step is to chat with the restorer to discuss the feasibility of these suggestions.
« Last Edit: August 13, 2023, 09:55:41 PM by Michael Weir »
Logged
Hohner Pokerwork DG,

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #15 on: August 14, 2023, 11:08:00 AM »


  I’m not sure what you meant about enhancing the B chord. The underlying logic is that you need a B Major if you are playing a harmonic minor, (and it is also the correct chord in E blues). 

  I hinted at cross-fingering chords onto different basses. Bm is a convenient push D on B bass. The 3rds are irrelevant  when you are constructing a minor chord.

   Should you want to cross-bass a major chord, then you must have 3rds out. eg B on G bass is G,B,D#,F#. The augmented 5th making your Gmaj7 sound “wrong” in folk context.

  I’m also “out” now. Thanks for the feedback, and acknowledging the many contributers to this discussion.

   A freebie … Bass run for Em tunes 🙂  I’ve used this one to death, so a bit of a cliche. Mostly pull

    | Em | Em/Dbass | Em/Cbass | B push | … resolves back to E minor
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Luke Hillman

  • MAD hatter
  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 77
  • Berkeley, CA
    • Anglo Piano
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #16 on: February 20, 2024, 06:43:48 PM »

Half a year late to the party, but I actually went through the same thought process last year, for the same reason, and came up with the attached layout.

Paul posted this update to his layout in 2021:
Quote
the lowest button on the D row used to be Bb/G#, which made the accidentals pleasingly logical and repetitive and meant the box was chromatic right down to low G. However, in practice I found I just never needed the low G# so I had it changed to a low pull B, which does come in handy.

To me, that reads as an indication that this button in the pull direction is the lowest priority and most amenable to change (which is already true for my repertoire in the layout I'm used to playing). Since Paul's layout already has a B3 on the push direction in the G row, I figured I'd split the difference and keep Bb3 on the push and have an F4 on the pull. That keeps the Bb3 in the same direction as the Bb chord and the F4 in the same direction as the F chord.

For me it's still theoretical, but I'll let you know if I eventually suffer for it.

« Last Edit: February 20, 2024, 06:47:49 PM by Luke Hillman »
Logged

Paul Young

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 72
    • paulyoungfolk.co.uk
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #17 on: April 30, 2024, 02:06:55 PM »

Hello. Just found this thread. For the record, I've had pupils with 21+4 boxes and my recommendation has been exactly what Gena suggested above. Move F/F down to the bottom of the G row, Eb/D down to the bottom of the D row and lose the low Bb/B.

Basically I think of the chin end buttons plus half row as one continuous "curved round accidentals row".

I do find I use that pull low B on my box quite a lot though. Especially when playing GC repertoire in the original key on DG, there's lots of low B against E chords. Quite a lot of Irish tunes also have low Bs against E minor. But if you don't have it this can always be acceptably substituted with the push B.

One day I'll get round to updating my website with all the altered versions of my layout I've made for people with different numbers of buttons...

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #18 on: May 02, 2024, 02:48:37 PM »

Hi all.

A related question while I'm ruminating over converting a C-F club into D-G:
If you had two extra spare buttons at the chin end, what notes would you add to this layout?
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #19 on: May 02, 2024, 03:40:07 PM »

.
A related question while I'm ruminating over converting a C-F club into D-G:
If you had two extra spare buttons at the chin end, what notes would you add to this layout?

    Classically Eb/C# (or t'other way up) and F#/Ab
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal