Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2]   Go Down

Author Topic: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?  (Read 5518 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Paul Young

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 72
    • paulyoungfolk.co.uk
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #20 on: May 04, 2024, 08:37:48 AM »

Hi all.

A related question while I'm ruminating over converting a C-F club into D-G:
If you had two extra spare buttons at the chin end, what notes would you add to this layout?

Attached is the layout one of my pupils has on his Hohner Club VII (with extra basses Rowbothamed onto it). My usual but with one extra button higher up on each row. If you like playing in other keys high up then it's nice having the accidentals all the way up to the high F. Also nice having the regular keys go all the way up to B so any folk tune in the standard range can be shifted up an octave without losing any bits at the top.

smiley

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1021
  • Folk music: it's not as bad as it sounds
    • a few sound clips
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #21 on: May 05, 2024, 09:46:13 AM »

Hello. Just found this thread. For the record, I've had pupils with 21+4 boxes and my recommendation has been exactly what Gena suggested above. Move F/F down to the bottom of the G row, Eb/D down to the bottom of the D row and lose the low Bb/B.

After playing an Erika D/G (with a 4 button half row) for several years, I've found that having the Eb4/F4 combination at the bottom of the G row works well.
It feels fairly natural now to reach the push Eb or the pull Fnat at the chin end of the G row. It might just be my personal ergonomics, but I don't find the reach to the chin end of the D row as easy. I also use the low B on the pull a lot - but mine is G3/B3 on the 2nd button of the D row.
Logged

Ellison

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 442
    • A few tunes here:
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #22 on: May 05, 2024, 01:02:12 PM »

My two penneth.

I think I must be fairly unusual (or unadventurous!) because whenever I've tried boxes with more than two rows and eight, I've always looked for ways to enhance the home keys. I have no desire, nor the skill, to play in Gminor, Bflat, F, Eflat etc etc etc on a D/G box. I'll use a box in a different key - that way you keep the logic of the melodeon system and, therefore, the sound we all love (or most of us).
I look for reversals, relative chords etc to beef out the home keys. Of course, this suits my style and the sort of repertoire I like, not for everyone, I know.

I have a box on order as an experiment and, if I can make this link work, this is what I think is my ideal system within the framework of the limits of my skill and musical choices.

https://docs.google.com/drawings/d/1I48dqT68tlsShQWkYZG39hSpEM4YydPqPdoSV7z8l8A/edit

Martin (:)
« Last Edit: May 05, 2024, 01:08:35 PM by Ellison »
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #23 on: May 05, 2024, 01:45:10 PM »


  That link is "restricted", Martin. Any chance of a screen shot or text version?

   Edit: works find now 👍
« Last Edit: May 05, 2024, 03:09:59 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Ellison

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 442
    • A few tunes here:
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #24 on: May 05, 2024, 02:32:12 PM »


  That link is "restricted", Martin. Any chance of a screen shot or text version?

I think I may have removed the restriction now.
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #25 on: May 05, 2024, 04:21:28 PM »


  Responding to Martin's choices (it always depends on what you play!) He's gone 4th start, and optimised it for the modes of D and G diatonic scales

   The choice of a Bm chord on left basically rules out harmonic Em (the reason for D# defaulting to push). i'm not sure what he is going to use pullD# for?  He seems to value F both ways in octave 5, so why not in octave 4?

   If that works I would personally have chosen 2 F/F buttons and a simple E/D reversal (unless he clubs it). 

   I use my F's mainly for playing in C or 'relative' Am. But will he?  If so, there's no F chord on bass.

  I think he'll use F#m/C#m pair a lot, given his style of music, and there are also some useful bass runs available too.

   Not sure what the Bb/G# will achieve on right end. I use them mainly for blues! He could perhaps extend the scale instead?

   3rd-less chords are always be more flexible. He definitely has the skills to dab in the desired 3rd with a spare right finger as he goes along! Against that Bm on G bass is a nice Gmaj7. which is a perfectly legal folk cord even though it sounds a bit jazzy. 

  F#m/D is D maj7 👍 C#m/A is Amaj7 👍 Em/C is Cmaj7 so lots to explore there  Minor chord on new bass is always sweeter.

  Just initial thoughts …
 
« Last Edit: May 05, 2024, 04:24:49 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Ellison

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 442
    • A few tunes here:
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #26 on: May 06, 2024, 11:28:11 AM »

Interesting to read Chris's analysis of my proposed system on my new box (which is many months away!).

I'll try to address some of the thoughts (in my musically illiterate way) . . .

There will be a thirds stop on the chords.
I don't know what ruling out harmonic Em means, I just know that when I changed from Bmajor to minor decades ago, I began to use the chord frequently because I found it fit so many things. In fact I can't remember what I used Bmajor for at all!
Pull D# is handy for quite a few tunes and as very speedy passing grace note - I have been influenced by a fair few fiddlers in my time and I find that I like a little slur up to the note. The same can be said of the Bb and G#. I don't 'slur' as frequently now.
The D# is also invaluable for playing tunes like "Roses for the Lady", "Moll Peatly", Purcell's "Minuet" lots of others I can't think of at the moment and anything which strays into Amajor or related modes.
I agree that the F notes may look a little confusing but I learnt on a two row with one F push and no F chord. I learnt workarounds to disguise (or enhance!) tunes which called for an F chord. I actually did have an F chord on an earlier 12 bass experiment but found that I was using it so infrequently and it was taking up 2 precious buttons.
I use the F#min a lot while playing in Dmaj, it's the same relation to Dmaj as Bminor is to Gmaj.
I confess that I use the C#min chord infrequently (of course, as above, the relationship between this and Amaj is the same as Bmin to G and F#min to D but I don't stray into Amaj very often.
However - the inclusion of the bass notes F# and C# gives you whole Gmaj and Dmaj scales on the bass. Really good for falling bass runs and the like.
On this new experiment I've included low F and D# on the right hand - never had these before and I'll confess it's a bit of a punt so we'll see . . .

As I've stated, I really don't want a box which allows some access to other keys, I want one which expands the possibilities of the home keys. I'll use other boxes in other keys should I feel the need.

None of this should be read as recommendations or advice - I have my style, my preferences and, though they may make others scratch (or even shake) their heads, it's how my brain works. However, I hope this has been at least interesting - I don't often analyse my playing, choices etc so I've found it fairly interesting.

Keep squeezing
Martin  (:)
Logged

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #27 on: May 06, 2024, 12:17:02 PM »


...whenever I've tried boxes with more than two rows and eight, I've always looked for ways to enhance the home keys. I have no desire, nor the skill, to play in Gminor, Bflat, F, Eflat etc etc etc on a D/G box. I'll use a box in a different key - that way you keep the logic of the melodeon system and, therefore, the sound we all love (or most of us).
I look for reversals, relative chords etc to beef out the home keys. Of course, this suits my style and the sort of repertoire I like, not for everyone, I know.



Martin, you're right: playing a 2 ½ row instrument outside the home keys requires a different approach that the one one develops on a 2 row box. It can be fun, but is anyway not something I do everyday. But mind about it: with an instrument with an half row that's four buttons long – or to say better, four buttons short! - you won't have many chances to succeed.

Yet, such an instrument with the right keyboard layout could be easily played in a third major key, and still offer room to “beef up” the home ones.  For a D/G that key is C. You already have six notes of the C major scale available on the G row, and with an F chord on the pull, and an F note among the accidentals both pulling and pushing the bellows, playing in C would be a breeze.

I understand you had an F chord on an earlier 12 bass experiment and you find it of little use, but I wonder if if the layout of the RH keyboard had been optimized to play in C. 

Yes, you'll have to use the tonic chord on the pull and the dominant on the push, but on a standard D/G box you already do that playing the minor modal tunes – Em on the pull, and most of the times D on the push -, so you'll stick to the logic of the melodeon system.

A few more notes about the chords I've seen on your layout.

I don't see much use for a C# chord. No doubt, it would be useful to play in A major, but to play in C  I would replace it with an F chord. And to easily use that F chord, it should be preferably placed below the C and the G chords. One good reason to add the additional chords at the bottom rather that at the top of the LH keyboard.

The F#m chord, if the B chord is tuned to be minor too, is a functional choice, You'll have all the six diatonic triad in D available. But please note, with the F# minor and the A chords on the pull, you should consider the use of a C# note on the push too among the reversals.

I've learned from my own experience on the A/D/G that an A chord on the pull playing in D is really useful. In fact the idea to place it above the A push chord in theory makes sense, so this seems a good reason to add the extra basses at the top of the LH keyboard, but to have it close to the F, the F#m and the C chords, and therefore be able to built a number of harmonic progressions on the thirds, should definitely be considered.

I don't think that having a G pull chord will change your life, especially if you chose to have a C note on the push among the reversals. The I6 chord retains the tonic function that the I7 chord looses, so really you can use a G6 on the pull (i.e. the Em chord, that's  in fact is a G6 played omitting the fifth) playing in G, and if you have all the six diatonic triad to play in D, plus the C and the F chords and you don't mind to go chromatic, playing in D you can do without a G pull chord. But if you choose to have a G chord on the pull, then it would be easier to use if placed below the G push chord. Then we have two and a half good reasons to add the additional basses at the bottom of the LH keyboard, against half a good reasons to place it at the top.

A final thing to consider: it would be nice to have an Am chord to play in G, and a B chord to play tunes that use the E minor harmonic minor scale. With a stop to mute the thirds, the occasional use of a B major chord isn't a problem, but I use the Am chord a lot, and I don't like to mute all the thirds. Yes, I could play an Am7 using the C chord and the A bass, but the use of the unstable minor7 chords is limiting, and adding a bass to a chord on one of my instruments ends up in a really harsh sound (the other has a stop to mute the lower reeds of the basses). My solution on the A/D/G, , that I consider an acceptable compromise, is to use an A5 chord on the pull, leaving the A major triad on the push untouched. And if you do not plan to use a stop for the thirds, and you wish to frequently play Jump at the Sun, you could use a B5 chord as well!

A final note: when I say that on my A/D/G the A pull chord is an A5 I don't mean I have taped the third. It was replaced with a second E reed. This way I have a chord that can be used both as major and a minor chord, but has the full three reed sound of the rest of the chords. 

Hope I've offered you some food for thoughts... ;D




 
« Last Edit: May 06, 2024, 05:39:57 PM by GBbox »
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #28 on: May 06, 2024, 12:58:03 PM »


   Thanks Martin. I know and admire your style and a lot of ideas there will enhance it.  I could sort of "sense" bass runs. It's totally D/G-ness, apart from the Bb and to a lesser extent F notes. The latter are a nice blue note in G, and very much needed to play in C (which would be achievable on your kit).

   👍 to the 3rds out stop. You lose nothing,  you gain a lot!

   Harmonic Em = E harmonic minor. The relative Em of G scale with D# replacing D. A mid European or Klezmer feel. Not your style!

   A lot of the other comments were just to exemplify pros and cons of various notes, depending on style of play. In your case - very much a diatonic approach.  Good choices!    BW Chris

Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #29 on: May 06, 2024, 01:56:22 PM »



   Concur with GBboxabout the C#m chord!  It isn't actually part of the diatonic set in D. It's vii chord is C#EGB (half diminished).
   So I suspect that you might use it just for bass?  Though an alternative is C#/F# (inverted) The F# is then in the right
   direction for the F# Blues scale "built in" to every D/G melodeon. The push C# then works as your turnaround chord?
                   
   That's why I chose  pull F#, in my own set of 12 basses 😎

 
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #30 on: May 06, 2024, 06:14:01 PM »



   Concur with GBboxabout the C#m chord!  It isn't actually part of the diatonic set in D. It's vii chord is C#EGB (half diminished).
   So I suspect that you might use it just for bass?


I guess there has been a bit of  misunderstanding here.
If you think “chromatically”, on an instrument with a keyboard layout like the one conceived by Martin you can always go to a C# chord from an A chord or from an E chord, no matter if the thirds are in or out, and no matter the key you are playing in.
I don't see much use for the C# chord not because it isn't a diatonic triad in G or D, but rather because– like in fact happens on a standard D/G two row box -, you can do the same thing using the C chord, and that is available both on the push and on the pull.

« Last Edit: May 06, 2024, 06:18:40 PM by GBbox »
Logged

Julian S

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1628
  • D/G Pastourelle 2, Dony, Pokerwork, G/C Pariselle
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #31 on: May 07, 2024, 08:28:26 AM »

Martin's part row layout has the same notes as that on my old third button start Pastourelle 2, with the difference that I have a unisonoric F - the reverse E is paired with the Eb. I have to say that I hardly use the top button C/D and if I redesigned it I'd opt for top Bb/G#. I have low Bb/G# on first button D row.

What I lack (and miss very much) is a low F nat - which I'd need fourth button start to get, which I've thought about.

As for chords - I've got pull G and push F, pull Am and push Em. All in all I really like the layout - but it's certainly not quite as flexible in 'off- piste' keys as that of my Mory (never mind my new D/G acc three row). And the most used button on the part row, personally,
is the E/D reversal.

Julian
Logged
Old Bones Dance Band

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Which accidentals to lose on a 4 button half row Paul Young layout?
« Reply #32 on: May 07, 2024, 09:41:37 AM »


   I use my unisonoric F massively when playing in C, or mixolydian G =Cmode5.  It's the characteristic note of the latter, so it works with anything you do. Having it on a button both ways sort of frees up your brain, in practice I hover a spare finger there, and dab it in on a "feels right" basis.   

   If you are into tunes that have major and minor bits on same tonic, the 4th of your scale is a great way to cadence between the two, as it carries no Maj/min colouring. eg I sing Caddick's Unicorns in C (I have Eb on pull) and using Csus4.   CEG<=>CEF<=>CEbF<=CEbG.  The F acts as a sort of placeholder in an otherwise unstable run.

   Holding F down as I move about in Gmixo between rt hand G7, C, Dm, and F chords is the same. F works with all of them 👍

    You can do similar holding C bass down playing in G, but the effect is stronger if "same octave". It's like … painting in pastels
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 
Pages: 1 [2]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal