To the OP: do you have something like a tuning table or are you trying to tune "in the box"?
Here in southern gernoney and switzerland are trillions cheap boxes to sell (hohner club) maybe you should import one to the US. Hohner has a online shop for spare parts were you can get a complete pretuned set of reedblocks for about 150€, dont know how to get them to the US but either way, ruining your old reeds is not the end of the world.
btw way, scratching can be done with a cheap scalpel but me too avoid excessive scratching and do use a dremel.
My understanding is still, scratching is for fine tuning, if the reeds are removed, there is no need for scraching, sandpaper glued toma fine woodstick is fine.
Does excessive scratching affect the integrity of the reed? This question is debatable (at least for us village idiots

).
The question is if your goal is just to get your box tuned, let it be done by an expert, if you want to stumble into the whole adventure, get some cheap boxes to learn, at least you can use the bellows to make something like a tuning table.
You will open a box of wormsof course, soon you have to buy valves, wax, tools....