I just stumbled onto this video which explores this concept. The pipe organ, which is quite modern has split 😳 keyboard black keys with D# and Eb available, and tuned differently. I didn't know that such beasts existed. Several other keys are split but the white notes are all "as normal"
They explore the effect on chords. logically … I think that these effects might only matter when he plays in scales A,B,C,D,E,F or G, because … otherwise the white note key presses would have to be split as well?
The issue of temperament in tuning melodeons has come up several times here but this is one of the clearest demonstrations that I've seen of it at work. As an equal tone fella, I think I should leave further comment to our skilled tuning fraternity.
https://youtu.be/A9Enpt8hREg
Fascinating and potentially madness inducing topic!.. The way I understand it, meantone temperament causes the circle of fifths to spiral inwards, with each following fifth being flat by 3.5 cents (relative to equal temperament), which allows the major 3rd to be pure ie -14 cents, and resulting in a D# being something like 40 cents flat of Eb!.. This spiral theoretically goes on forever, so you'd just need to keep splitting keys all the way if you wanted to modulate freely...
On the other hand, tuning in pure Pythagorean fifths (ratio 2:3), causes the circle of fifths to spiral outward, as each pure fifth is +2 cents sharp of equal temperament, resulting in D# being around 24 cents sharp of Eb (ie a Pythagorean Comma). Major 3rds are 8 cents sharp of equal temperament in this tuning, ie 22 cents sharp of pure!..
Equal temperament has fifths slightly flat of pure to allow for a perfect circle of fifths, but the major 3rds remain rather sharp (+14 cents). This is more noticeable on certain instruments, like I only noticed something amiss when I played harmonica...
Another way of closing the circle of fifths is well temperament. This basically involves flattening the fifths starting around C to obtain purer 3rds in the common keys, followed by a series of pure fifths around the back end of the circle of fifths to close the circle again...
I'm definitely not a skilled tuner!.. But I have so far tuned 2 boxes with the first 8 fifths 1 cent flat (1/8 Pythagorean comma!), resulting in major thirds of -4 cents. The remaining 4 fifths are tuned pure to close the circle, so it's basically a type of 'well temperament'... The idea in theory is to just give the sound an indiscernible edge if that makes sense!..