Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Tuning B major to B minor (on D/G box)  (Read 2810 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Tuning B major to B minor (on D/G box)
« on: May 06, 2024, 08:49:51 PM »

Hi, this has been mentioned in passing on other recent threads, but I was wondering how many players actually have their B chord tuned to minor instead of major, and any thoughts you might have on this (without veering too much into thirdless/thirds stop/substitute minor 7th chord type discussions!..)

I was prompted by the following live performance of Tony Hall, where his boxes are tuned in exactly this way… To me it makes a lot of sense for music from around Britain and Ireland anyway, which tends in general to be more modal, and so less reliant on the dominant V chord to establish minor tonality. It also opens up another tonality ie B minor, as for example here if you go to 6:10: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=FLJ33Xmj2Sw&t=377s&pp=ygUKVG9ueSBoYWxsIA%3D%3D

It’s about the most straightforward tuning mod you can make, by just adding a bit of weight to the D# reed on the chord block… So I’m sure many people have tried it, then maybe changed back?.. I don’t think I’d have my Club box tuned like this as I like the different flavours I can get with the major chord there, but for a D/G box specifically geared to traditional music of this part of the world perhaps I would?..
« Last Edit: May 06, 2024, 08:59:47 PM by Arnold »
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

JohnAndy

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 244
  • John Barber
Re: Tuning B major to B minor (on D/G box)
« Reply #1 on: May 07, 2024, 12:28:04 AM »

All three of the D/G boxes that I have bought have come with a B-minor chord rather than B-major. And that wasn't because I specifically chose a box with that option.

So, based on that limited sample, I would tend to assume that there must be a substantial proportion of players using the layout with B-minor!

I very much like having the B-minor chord. A proper B-minor tends to sound better than a fudge Bm7 (using B bass and D major chord). And it gives you a nice Gmaj7 chord.

But I like to be able to use B-major as well, so in my main box I have a custom layout that has both B-major and B-minor chords.

If I had to choose just one, it would be B-minor.
Logged

CAB

  • Mass Debater
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1147
    • Somerset Russets Village Band
Re: Tuning B major to B minor (on D/G box)
« Reply #2 on: May 07, 2024, 07:48:34 AM »

I always go for B minor.  It's much more useful for the music I want to play and often adds a lot to tunes in D or even G, as well as the obvious E dorian/aeolian.
If I need a B major chord, it's because the tune contains a D# so I play thirdless (sorry to mention that) and let the right hand note create the majorness. 
I'm not a fan  of the fudged Bm7 either.
I guess the folks who prefer B major must be playing a lot of harmonic minor stuff.
Logged
Pas de lieu Rhone que nous

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Tuning B major to B minor (on D/G box)
« Reply #3 on: May 07, 2024, 10:12:52 AM »

On my G/C the E chord, that corresponds to the B chord of the D/G, is tuned to be a minor chord. And on my A/D/G both the B pull chord  and the F# chord. that on the standard instruments are major chords, have been tuned as a minor chords too. It's a choice that I have never find a reason to regret in more than thirty years, and yes, if I need an E major chord on the G/C, or a B major or an F# major chord on the A/D/G, I simply mute the thirds. But on the A/D/G, on which I mainly play English music, I need to mute the thirds for a couple of tunes out of two hundreds.

The reasons why to have the minor chords rather than the standard major chords makes sense has already been explained in the posts above, but I think it's worth considering why, on the other end, on the two row melodeons – or the three row instruments in three keys for the purpose – the major chords are a definitely a nonsense.

As Arnold correctly says, the E major chord on the G/C box and the B major chord on the D/G boxes are meant to give a major dominant chord to play respectively in the tonal Am or E minor melodies. Fine, as far as those melodies use the so called melodic minor scale – i. e. in the ascending passages both the seventh and the sixth degrees of the natural minor scale are sharpened -, because this implies that the subdominant must be a major chord too. And then on the G/C one could use the D major chord, and on the D/G the A major chord. But how many tunes actually use the melodic minor scale?

I've never seriously explored the musical traditions of the Northern European countries, and in principle I cannot exclude that the melodic minor scales could be widely used there, but I've been playing French and Italian music for more than forty years, and I have never found a tonal  minor tune using the melodic minor scale. I've learned along the years a number of tonal minor tunes – including a fair share of standard musette waltz, like Mon Amant de Saint Jean or Sous le ciels the Paris -, and they all use the harmonic minor scale, in which only the seventh degree of the natural minor scale is sharpened. And when the subdominant chord is used – and generally is used! -. it's always a minor chord.

If you exclude an handful of traditional tunes that just alternate between the tonic and the dominant chords, this means that to play in A minor on the G/C or in E minor on the D/G you have to use respectively a D minor or an A minor chord. In other words, on the standard instruments that have respectively an E major and an A major chord, you have to mute the thirds anyway to play the subdominant chords as minor chord. Just one of the many melodeon Catch-22s!   


Logged

nigelr

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 526
Re: Tuning B major to B minor (on D/G box)
« Reply #4 on: May 07, 2024, 10:43:26 AM »

This thread has some interesting observations, especially from highly respected players who are no longer with us (Steve and Bob):

https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=7944.msg98667
« Last Edit: May 07, 2024, 10:47:20 AM by nigelr »
Logged
DB Oakwood Super 2 (D/G), Club II (D/G Will Allen layout), Erika (Bb/Eb) and an HA114 in C

Tone Dumb Greg

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4955
    • Dartmoor Border Morris
Re: Tuning B major to B minor (on D/G box)
« Reply #5 on: May 07, 2024, 10:47:16 AM »

My 2.4 Salterelle came with B minor, rather than B major. Funny thing is I tend to use it as a conciously selected alternative to Bm7 rather than a first choice. Habit, I guess. 

It is useful if  actually playing in Bm.
Logged
Greg Smith
DG/GC Pokerwork, DG 2.4 Saltarelle, pre-war CF Hohner, Hohner 1040 Vienna style, old  BbEb Hohner that needs a lot of work.

ACCORDION, n. An instrument in harmony with the sentiments of an assassin. Ambrose Bierce

Howard Jones

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1203
Re: Tuning B major to B minor (on D/G box)
« Reply #6 on: May 07, 2024, 10:53:03 AM »

I have B min on my principal box, a Saltarelle Nuage.

Some of my other boxes have the major chord, but I can never find a use for it in the music I play and I invariably end up using the cross-row minor fudge. Presumably when the design of the melodeon was evolving the major chord suited the style of music it was intended for, but it doesn't suit the mainly British music I play.

B min belongs to the natural E minor scale, which fits more naturally on a D/G melodeon.  And of course B minor is the relative minor scale to D, and having a proper B min chord enables playing in that key, which opens up so many opportunities*. The Bm7 fudge doesn't work as well.

*including playing William Taylor's Tabletop Hornpipe correctly, albeit not in Dave Shepherd's preferred key

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Tuning B major to B minor (on D/G box)
« Reply #7 on: May 07, 2024, 11:30:30 AM »



  "Depends on what you play" as ever.  Should your repertoire be wholly occidental folk music, it's a very logical adjustment. Bmin is the correct chord V in both aeolian (containing C)  and dorian (containing C#) melodies. So it even works if you like to bebop between the two!   😎

  Composers have sought a stronger V=>i harmonic resolution for over 500 years, and a large part of "classical" music is based on that "leading" D# note; the one that's expressed in the B major chord. But if you don't play those tunes, or a lot of Scandanavian, Central European, or Klesmer music … go ahead!

  There are workarounds if you engage in both styles. First is to tape that awkward 3rd out. You can than express the harmonic cadence by putting a spare right finger on push Eb(aka D#) accidental … it's probably in your tune anyway! But the taped {B+F#} remaining is OK. 

  Your melody's "occidental folk"? Simple modal? You've lost nothing! Play push D chord with the B bass. That's Bmin7, but no one will notice! Ditto {B+F#}

  edit:  Concur with Howard wrt those lovely but more difficult B minor tunes.
« Last Edit: May 07, 2024, 11:33:16 AM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Gena Crisman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1108
  • 🇬🇧
Re: Tuning B major to B minor (on D/G box)
« Reply #8 on: May 07, 2024, 03:41:41 PM »

A D/G box with no B major is, imo, just... kinda sad?

Like, if you know what you play, you have your repertoire, then, obviously it's your box etc. I get it. But, that's one thing - I simply hope it wouldn't be something that catches the zeitgeist and became the norm. For me, the point of the instrument is to ride the line of what is feasible and make manageable compromises to broaden ones horizons, and I think there is plenty of space in English music for the non diatonic chords and notes that we have access to. I, certainly, use them.

If you might consider picking a low note layout, with pull D & A over having accidentals, then, dropping B to a Bm is imo a similar kind of choice of direction - a more 'perfect' diatonic lightning rod.

But as a composer, most of my fondest tunes either have B major as their tonic, or are in a flavour of E minor which includes it, or, borrow from all of the above. It's just too good.

And, as an, idk, a pundit I guess? I don't think that this choice is one people should have to make - I just kinda think that we know at this point that a thirds stop is just the best solution. But, if you are living life with thirds in, like, yeah, a clean Bm triad is very good for B minor... but we can't apply that same change to the A major chord, can we? To match our similar desire to play in A minor / A dorian? And I play far more tunes in those keys (though not for want of trying). In principal, a conventional layout (with A major and B major) would actually have much the same issue with making either Am, or Bm, your tonic - you have the fundamental, but no plain minor triad. So, I think, those skills you can build up & use to make Am-ish tunes as compelling as possible? Those can also be used to help out B minor. Perhaps it comes down to - can you build those skills and, if you do, are the results compelling enough for you?
Logged

Howard Jones

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1203
Re: Tuning B major to B minor (on D/G box)
« Reply #9 on: May 07, 2024, 08:24:40 PM »

This is the nature of our instrument. There is no right or wrong answer, only choices to be made. A choice in one direction means making compromises in another. Somehow we manage to find ways to make it work (more or less, and to the annoyance of those who play proper musical instruments with all the notes).

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Tuning B major to B minor (on D/G box)
« Reply #10 on: May 08, 2024, 05:49:32 PM »

Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this. I didn’t realise there were so many playing this set up… There are certainly advantages/disadvantages either way… I wouldn’t change the E major on the G/C, or the A major on the Club for all of those different minor flavours and the little harmonic chromaticism allowing for perhaps a broader repertoire. But for the D/G, I decided to take a less melodeon-centric view for the casting vote, and consult Robin Williamson’s (of the Incredible String Band) The Penny Whistle Book to see how a non melodeonist harmonises such tunes. Lots of B minors and zero B majors, so I think I’ll go with that and see how I get on. Only a small piece of blu-tac required, and easily reversible!..
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal