Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?  (Read 3539 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Ben

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 61
  • Hohner G/C, Pokerwork D/G, B/E, Club IIIB S C/F,
Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« on: May 15, 2024, 03:03:37 PM »

Hey All,

I was musing over the different 2.5row layouts, comparing Castag's and Salt's etc.  The Castagnari layout seems pretty solid to me, especially having the additional low buttons, the reversed D on the helper row, and Eb and Bb bass and chords - helpful for playing all sorts of minors and other keys.

By comparison, the Saltarelle layout has a the low octave options for accidentals, which seems marginally useful, and the bass differences just give reversals on your A and G basses, which likewise seems to have limited usefulness.  Most of the reversals I wish I had tend to be on the treble side, not the basses.

I have been fanaticizing about obtaining a 2.5-3 row melodeon (do I have MAD? absolutely), and having the option to play in the occasional other keys as well as smooth out some sections would be quite nice.

2.5+row players, what is your experience here?  What do you see as the primary advantage in Saltarelle's layout over Castagnaris'?  Over vice versa?
Logged

Andy Goldfinch

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 150
    • Andy Goldfinch Melodeon (YouTube)
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #1 on: May 15, 2024, 03:48:21 PM »

One benefit of having G/A basses in both directions is being able to play drone accompaniments, which can make for a nice variation or starting accompaniment for a tune before putting more varied chords in. Although personally I find a push E chord more useful than I would a push A, because I particularly like drones under E minor tunes.

There are of course other possible layouts, I think Paul Young's layout is particularly logical for playing in different keys (F in both directions is especially handy). I've got a push E chord instead of the Eb, because I never really stray far enough from the home keys to really need Eb.
Logged
D/G Castagnari Dony, D/G Hohner Club VII (9 bass), D/G Serenellini Maestro, C/F Hohner Club II (DIY restoration in progress...)

https://www.youtube.com/@andymelodeon

Clive Williams

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3936
    • Home Page
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #2 on: May 15, 2024, 03:53:12 PM »

I've always generalised it as the Saltarelle layout improves the ability to play in home keys; Castagnari's improves the ability to play in other keys. Depends what sort of things you like to play. I'm a home key chap myself.

Ben

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 61
  • Hohner G/C, Pokerwork D/G, B/E, Club IIIB S C/F,
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #3 on: May 15, 2024, 05:30:05 PM »

Paul Young's layout is fascinating with the push/pull Fs.  I will have to do some thinking on that.  I trust Paul's experience - one day I will posses 1/10th his skill and musicality! - but had not considered a modification to the layout like that.  The full anahata layout is very appealing though! I can count the number of times I have touched the top buttons of my G row on one hand, and thats mostly because I had to start higher due to not having the lows, which would have been preferably.... ah... c'est le vie!

Getting a somewhat custom layout like that might be a bit tricky, however, as I am hoping to find one on the used market in a couple years once I have saved up enough pennies to actually purchase one, and I assume a non-factory layout would be challenging to obtain on the used market (Mory's are hard enough to find on the used market as it is!), and well-stocked fettlers capable of doing such a modification here in the USA seem to be less common than in the UK, sadly.  But another year or so of saving would result in enough for a new one w/o any fuss over a fettler...


The Salterelle's layout is a bit puzzling, the treble certainly seems to have the accidental range, suggesting it is more chromatic-oriented, but the basses don't seem to line up with that.  I would have expected the Castagnari and Salterelles bass layouts to have been swapped!!
Logged

penn

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 574
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #4 on: May 15, 2024, 07:05:37 PM »

I think there are other factors that can influence the layout decision.
Ie 3 voice or 2 voice?
2.5 or a full 3 row?
What music do you want to be able to play? (That you can’t on a 2 row)

I went thru some of this a year or so ago.
FWIW my thought processes went something like this…
D/G cos all me mates play D/G and I play mostly English
2 voice - I’ve always preferred the perky and bright sound of 2 voice D/G.
3 row - why not have more buttons? it doesn’t add weight when the right side is sitting on your knees.
By default I play on the row but cross-row when it feels appropriate - I like to be able choose the fingering to suit the articulation of the tune.

I went for a 3 row Castagnari Benny in Bob Ellis layout.
It’s quite light. It has accidentals and reversals on the third row.
In the year I’ve had it, I haven’t really played in wild keys, but it’s great to have accidentals in the same area as the related notes in the main rows. I really like the reversals of c c# d and e and use them lot to allow a chord / bass to be held longer.
I recently learnt a tune in Bb which blew the dust off the Bb Eb left hand. I was pleased that it seems to work with some fluidity.
The Bob Ellis layout adds an extra button below the G scale layout which makes it possible to play some tunes an octave down to avoid squeakiness or need for a low voice.

I have seen arguments here that the melodeon is a limited instrument and a lot of the pleasure comes embracing the limitations. To some extent I agree, and recently added another 2 row which is just pure and simple fun.

My Benny is great and MAD-aside I wouldn’t need another box and I feel I have many more years of exploration ahead of me.

But this is where I ended up - I think everyone will have different needs and wishes. Of course another reason I went with the Benny (and the recent Lilly) was that they sounded and felt great when I first picked them up - yeah!!!
Logged
Hohners, Dino Baffetti, Lilly, Benny + a lot of junk.

Gena Crisman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1108
  • 🇬🇧
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #5 on: May 15, 2024, 07:17:09 PM »

The Salterelle's layout is a bit puzzling, the treble certainly seems to have the accidental range, suggesting it is more chromatic-oriented, but the basses don't seem to line up with that.  I would have expected the Castagnari and Salterelles bass layouts to have been swapped!!

Covering a broader range with accs isn't much help if you can't use it to meaningfully play other scales in the manner in which you play your home scales. I agree with Clive - the salterelle style layouts simplify barriers you'll experience on a 2 row but don't broaden your as horizons much, and the castagnari style ones do broaden your horizons to nearby, particularly flatter, key signatures, but add little in the way of conveniences.

If you pay attention to accidental directions, have a ponder of, are you going to be able to meaningfully play in the key of F if you only have 1 F in the same direction as your F chord? Does playing in A major with your G# in a different direction to all your E notes & chords sound like a good time? Flipping them to make sense from this perspective is independent of your choice of bass end, but it is very important if you want those outcomes.

Also note that (most likely) the Salterelle layout adds a low G#/Bb, and a high F/Eb. These fall right at the very bottom, and right at the tippy top, of a 4th start's instrument's range, sandwiching the range noted on the castagnari diagram, rather than the extras being wholly underneath it. With the way we play D/G, you already know how we value those parts of the instrument - 'very low' often isn't even on the box, and 'very high' is often removed from the box so we can put those 'very low' notes on, lol.

I'd caution though that I'd have very little expectation that any 2nd hand box you bought with either Saltarelle or Castagnari badge could be assumed to have either of these specific 'factory' layouts, though.
Logged

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #6 on: May 15, 2024, 08:53:50 PM »

As said here, I've always considered a Saltarelle as a 'super DG', the bass reversals supporting and complimenting the home keys, whereas a Castagnari allows you to go beyond those home keys if that is what you want to do.

After much consideration, I eventually went for a Castagnari Mory, as I wanted to investigate English tunes in other keys.
It took me 2 goes to get the layout right, eventually going for the Paul Young layout.
It took me a while to realise, you need F's both ways and Paul's layout allows a good stab at tunes in Bb, Gm etc. where at times you do need a push Fnat.
I recommend his layout especially if heading towards the flat keys.

If you do eventually head towards one, look carefully at what tunes you might want to play.
Something I didn't do, probably because I wastn't sure exactly which direction I was heading!

Gena is right, talking to Pete from Acorn Instruments, he rarely supplies a Castagnari 2.5 or 3 row with a standard Castagnari layout, so second hand standard layouts aren't that common.
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #7 on: May 15, 2024, 08:58:43 PM »


   Playing in off-piste scales is generally quite/very awkward unless you have all of the notes in a single direction. And that is always on the pull.

   The general logic of two diatonic, plus a helper row doesn't leave space for all 12 notes unless you change something. The best examples being the Dutch inversion (D/E plate turned over on G row) or the Grenoble system which would replace G row's D's with D#'s.

   my main rows are Simple diatonic. that's always means that a note has to be on the Push. Im my case Ab. 

   However there is a workaround to increase the fluency of these odd scales. I have an Ab/Bb button in accs. A lot of the flat scales have both notes in them so you can press that button and flick the Bellows to get a usable "play through'. Opens up Bb minor/blues and Cminor/Blue nicely 👍 Both of which suit my voice.

  The actual path of these pull scales along your keyboard can become a bit of a drunkards walk. you just have to learn them!
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Ben

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 61
  • Hohner G/C, Pokerwork D/G, B/E, Club IIIB S C/F,
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #8 on: May 15, 2024, 10:12:09 PM »

I think there are other factors that can influence the layout decision.
Ie 3 voice or 2 voice?
2.5 or a full 3 row?
What music do you want to be able to play? (That you can’t on a 2 row)


I absolutely want a LMM, ideally with registers to at minimum drop the low reeds, ideally be able to select any combination of the 3.  And while we are dreaming, the option to drop 3rds and the bass octaves...

The majority of the tunes I play are, true enough, pretty easily accomplished on a 2 row w/o too much trouble (ITM, English, American Bluegrass, etc) however, in another group that I play with I often need to sit out on tunes in B and C major/minor and to a lesser degree Gmin and Dmin (gospel, hymns etc), even with the 3rds taped.

I am by no means opposed to a full 3 row, but I do want to keep the box to an at least a tamable size and weight. 

My current pokerwork does an amiable job at a good chunk of the tunes, and it is hard to justify spending ~2K USD (or more in the case of a 2.5+row) on a box that doesn't allow me to play all of the things I want to play.  My old CBA hardly gets played at all these days since first playing my pokerwork 2 years ago (and thus will likely be going up for sale soon), the melodeon is just such a more pleasant, interactive, playful, and not to mention light instrument.  The CBA is wonderfully versatile, true, but its a beast to handle by comparison and I never could get my head and fingers reliably around that stradella bass...  (yes, I realize the 3 voice 2.5+ row boxes are substantially heavier than a 2 voice 2 row).  I am hoping to get out to the my nearest accordion shop later this year - a wonderful 500mi drive - to actually try out a Mory etc.
« Last Edit: May 15, 2024, 10:59:42 PM by Ben Eckerson »
Logged

Julian S

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1628
  • D/G Pastourelle 2, Dony, Pokerwork, G/C Pariselle
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #9 on: May 16, 2024, 07:57:06 AM »

Before I bought my three row MM I spent many hours looking at possible layouts, from the experience of having a 2.4 Saltarelle with a part row layout of C/D,E/Eb, F/F and E/Eb, and a Mory with Eb/F, Bb/G#,E/D, Eb/F, Bb/G#. I had a chart showing all the layouts I'd found online and thought about how they worked with my repertoire, which is pretty broad keywise. The Casta layout definitely suits me better.

Saying that, I tried to come up with a layout which gave me the advantages of my existing instruments and reduced the cons and didn't quite succeed - I have Eb and Fs in both directions on the three row, the D/E reversals, but not the push C which would have needed me to opt for a Dutch reversal on the G row. A step too far personally - I'd already rejected a three voice three row instrument having decided the Mory was quite heavy enough. It sounds lovely, but I don't take it to sessions because I find it too tiring to play for long periods - the Rik I bought after much consideration (original thought was a Mas LM 18 bass) has the Mory bass options and is much lighter.

My conclusions - no perfect layout, always pros and cons, playability and sound of the box is fundamental, and the more instruments you try (and for as long as possible) the better. And there will always be tunes which might well have been easier with a different layout !

Julian











Logged
Old Bones Dance Band

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #10 on: May 16, 2024, 08:49:45 AM »

Julian's conclusions are bang on.
Nothing is perfect.

As John Kirkpatrick said last weekend at a workshop, whatever layout - 2.5/3 row, 12/18 bass or more - sooner or later you'll come up against the limitations of your layout. Embrace the imperfection!
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

CAB

  • Mass Debater
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1147
    • Somerset Russets Village Band
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #11 on: May 16, 2024, 10:35:50 AM »

I play a Castagnari 3 row and a Saltarelle 2.5 row, both DG.  The Castagnari is a Benny and does exactly what I want it to, including, for example, playing in A major and in G minor.  It's fun playing tunes an octave down, too.  I'd second everything Penn has said about the Bob Ellis layout Benny (with one exception - I decided I didn't need the pushed C# so I went for a unisonoric D#/Eb button which is useful for both B major and C minor chords.  The only real compromise for me is that small instrument = small bellows and some of those tunes in A are mostly on the pull.

My Connemara III is a lovely  instrument but ultimately less versatile.  I had a few modifications made when I bought it - essentially Castagnari-ising it - but, if I decided to use it more, I'd want to have a few more changes made to the half row and the chin end to finish the job.  As others have said, it aims to be completely chromatic, but at some cost in terms of matching right-hand note to left-hand bass.



Logged
Pas de lieu Rhone que nous

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #12 on: May 16, 2024, 11:05:11 AM »

Julian's conclusions are bang on.
Nothing is perfect.

As John Kirkpatrick said last weekend at a workshop, whatever layout - 2.5/3 row, 12/18 bass or more - sooner or later you'll come up against the limitations of your layout. Embrace the imperfection!

Ben, I definitely agree with Julian, Thrupenny Bit, and of course with John Kirkpatrick: any layout you choose will have some limitations. But at the same time is worth considering that the limitations of the Castagnari-or-similar layout(s) are different from the ones of the saltarelle-or-similar layout(s), and one of them will definitely fit your repertoire better than the other.

Given this, a few things I have learned from my own experience.

In principle the Castagnari type of layouts are meant to play in a few different additional keys, while the Saltarelle types layouts are optimised to play mainly in the home keys, but what they should have in common is that they should be easily playable in a third major key.

That third major key on a G/C based instrument is F, on an A/D is G, and on a D/G is C.  Yet to be able to comfortably play in that third major key you need an instrument with the additional basses at the bottom than rather at the top of the LH keyboard, to avoid jumping up and down to reach the subdominant chord.

Another thing to consider: if you play music that is mainly diatonic in nature – major and modal tunes with only an occasional use of the accidentals - and you would be satisfied to play mainly in a third major key, than a 2 ½ row instrument is definitely not the best choice. A three row instrument in three keys will offer four times the harmonic flexibility of a Saltarelle type layout.

Please note, a three row instrument with a 10/9/8 RH keyboard  can be a compact,  light  and agile to play instrument. I am satisfied with my Serenellini A/D/G 273 box,that's in LMM configuration, and my 2 1/2 row G/C is in fact the same instrument with a customised RH keyboard layout. Not sure Castagnari has a similar model in catalogue, but in the Saltarelle catalogue today there is the Mantique - an updated and hopefully working version of the old Cheviot/Nordsud models - although it is offered just in MM configuration.

A final thought: if you chose a 2 1/2 row Castagnari type of layout in order to play in a few different keys, 4 or even 5 buttons in your half row might not offer you the needed flexibility. My first G/C 2 1/2 row box had 5 additional buttons, and after struggling for a couple of years with it I switched to the one I play now, that has 6. And that additional button, believe me, actually makes a substantial difference!

Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #13 on: May 16, 2024, 12:32:06 PM »


   I started with a 2+5 Mory. But it really didn't make me play like Andy Cutting!

   If you want to go-off-piste … in any direction … but especially if you like tonal music you should strongly consider going to a full three rows. The weight overhead isn't very much and is on your shoulders, rather than your left arm?  And the price overhead is … not terrible.

   C on a D/G/accs (F on G/C/accs) is actually very straightforward, and some Club systems even cater for that with an F base.

   By 😳 coincidence I have just fed that into my family group as an idea for my mother's funeral. The youngest cousin is a gifted jazz musician, and we will be playing for the hymns. She loved his music!  "Abide with me" has straightforward chords, so I can chord for him as people go out? Maybe have a go myself?  And we can finish on my favourite chord 🙂 All doable, on most 2½ layouts.

 That is to say that if you fancy anything the way of improvisation, you don't play in the main row keys. But as always it depends on your style of music. and I think that anyone who wants full chromaticity should be advised to get a CBA, early in his career. Melodeons are only comfortable in scales that are modes of main rows or a couple of #/b's away from there,

Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #14 on: May 16, 2024, 03:12:48 PM »


   I started with a 2+5 Mory. But it really didn't make me play like Andy Cutting!


Yes, in the end it's the player, not the instrument, that makes the difference. Yet it's true as well, as Klaus Schulze wrote in the sleeve notes of one of his records, that perfection is a matter of quantity, not of quality.

To put in other words one might not be able to play like Andy Cutting all the tunes Andy Cutting plays, but a competent player who chooses to concentrate on the ones he likes can anyway make a good impression.  ;)
« Last Edit: May 16, 2024, 05:17:03 PM by GBbox »
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Advantage of Saltarelle vs Castagnari's 2.5row layouts?
« Reply #15 on: May 16, 2024, 04:52:38 PM »


   I started with a 2+5 Mory. But it really didn't make me play like Andy Cutting!

Yes, in the end it's the player, not the instrument, that makes the difference. Yet it's true as well, as Klaus Schulze wrote in the sleeve notes of one of his records, that perfection is a matter of quantity, not of quality.

 So kind!  🙂
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal