Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 [3]   Go Down

Author Topic: Push pull button number notation  (Read 8371 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Michael Eskin

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 547
    • AppCordions
Re: Push pull button number notation
« Reply #40 on: October 25, 2024, 07:05:35 PM »

OK, I've made a pass through the standalone D/G and C/G tab generator utility at:

https://michaeleskin.com/tools/mel-tab.html

and hopefully fixed the issues, which were numerous.

The tool now only creates Push/Draw style tab for 3rd button start D/G and C/G using the standard 21-button layouts with chromatics at the low end as shown elsewhere on this site:

D/G

https://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/DGwithStave.pdf

C/G

https://forum.melodeon.net/files/site/keyboards/GC_with_accidentals_showing_notes_on_stave.pdf

Of course, when you start using chords, all of this probably goes out the window and would required editing the tab for the required reversals, but it's hopefully somewhat useful for melody-only tunes.

Here's an example of Push/Draw style D/G tab generated by the tool now:

https://michaeleskin.com/abctools/abctools.html?lzw=BoLgBAjAUApDAuBLeAbApgMwPYDt5gAUBDFIpHLMAJithgGcBXAIyVU132NPMogA46iHNmx5CJMsL4AWOkRwV4U3GK6TekaHHrKMGemgAOkAAym6AW0b1EAY3pGidtGagAVcAGEsWdAE8AcnooL3B3ACciABNkRFwSKAAlcCS0NBQoAFlwGQB6OQAZcAg8wQBFEryqAF4ATgsAaXAAUWisCNgiZjsAK3oAfXosRhxotTAMFEZEaNhYMABVQzAFMABBOxHdezAAcSixwkQFSmHR6MmOsHgAC1dLDKxo-xA6LIBJABEPsCMIrAAcyiljAFhgC2WrjWm22SDs+0OlwIJwoYHOR2wERu9zAdluHWi9DecE+PzxBIi0X+QLB8xgSxWawAyv48LcwAAhIj0ejokaY653VzMHnE97fX6i3k0wFgADMgghDOZaHwRHRRjQdkQGF2REsAvwWAw6IA7sJAST6BacHLTAA6CAAVnmAB8QAAiFqWT2egZgADcAFpA-Lvf6g6HnZ7OZGQ4GY3GBs6E2BPet0wGE0mqFmo2GI9no7G3fGS5y8-7U6H0+ty4nY1mAGxpz3RBtJ6tt+vFwMyT17MtfP0DGRtgBieQb4Za04G8rbXyzNcDdf9i9rnuXndjG6X3a3vc3a+3ZbHk-nBdn85P6Z3KZ7+63D4LXcfR4bA72-vHW4nbpQN6vozkWb57n276rnW+Y5rGVZ9rOu6cue4GViuT6QU2-qtluHZ9gA7J6aD+gRbYYA2-CeoCw6jvwbZEKR5GUdRDZEa4OFtvhaGHqevZ-qeAEQFmd7bqBLS-pOz6njuPqjte3rhguS4gG6CGiSOiFFgJ6YTtJ97pnJ4lUCxgJMVuGBuoBHrAfJCbschYAABRKTxWHJmhsGhg57mmeZp6WWxxHIchCEFlRZmEcFAy4ae3FwShYm8XW87QRmqU9lmOmenpH58SJB55euF7-slGbnml6wZUe1X5ZJpVFRmLZcUFJEDGRFmmYBtmtY5Lkhb57leYGPlueFrHteRqH2dFY0JY5nF4b1k2dX2EW0f69FboxK0BX5UUcTFLWDZV9WCW6wn6WJWkSSVglXbJIE3SZa0TR1AWqephUKbd2W5RphlPT9MhugAulAUBAA&format=noten&ssp=45&name=Cooleys_DG&play=1

And an C/G example:

https://michaeleskin.com/abctools/abctools.html?lzw=BoLgBAjAUApDAuBLeAbApgMwPYDt5gAUBDFIpHLMAJithgGcBXAIyVU132NPMogA46iHNmx5CJMsL4AWOkRwV4U3GK6TekaHHrKMGemgAOkAAym6AW0b1EAY3pGidtGagAVcO4AWrgNJo9N5QAMJeAE5EACbIiLgkUABK4ABSiADmUACy4ABsAPSCADLgEIVQAIrgAMyFALwQVBZ+4ADilkQAVrBEzHad9AD69FiMOFFqYBgojIhRsLBgAKqGYApgAIJ2o7r2YK2R44SICpQjY1FTWOFg8L5glmgoWFEAniB0WQCSACJfYEZwlh0pFLGALDBFitXOstjskHZ9odLgQThQrjc7q47N5rlF6B84N8-mAcXjAcDwQsYMtVusAMqvPDeMAAISI9HoYHOR2wmPuzA5BM+v3+gs5FPSYGqgkhNPpaHwRG5RjQdkQGD2REso3EWAw3IA7sJ0oT6MacFLTAA6KgAVgWAB8QAAiVoul2DXIAbgAtN6wG7PWA-d6AOwujaen3+wOtQNe0Nx4OhiNRwZhpMu1mOl0-D2DEP+tOezOx7Mp4uRhNF8OR0tZ1me-hZqK592V70AThdaGbrf75cunq7WfSg4DLqiE8DbZdIQLtZ7fcGLaHDfLrMD+ZnU43k6bhdTkcdUCD0az7qPVfTMcn8Yv5avtZLGcbuZ317r6bLB87aZrY8f0bXc5w7L9l1A0CE1Hctx1XAc303D9FyAx9707XIXQAMWTdC42qEBT2dc8kL-L9X1-QMtygsjqNA3MF07SDBlgyd4KXXttwLNdJ2nOiKwok9SKowSX3rASaIQ9dJPwt0UP-CTRMPcSNkAm85OfIDTxEkChOAzcE142d93o6S+MY1D-RYtjAw40Nlzw8yTNk5yp0skcx07CBTBdDBPLg7jvIgF0iAC9jgtC9sCx8rNmHCuzvN8g0EpddJCNPKAoCAA&format=noten&ssp=45&name=Kesh_CG&play=1

« Last Edit: October 26, 2024, 03:22:12 AM by Michael Eskin »
Logged

Michael Eskin

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 547
    • AppCordions
Re: Push pull button number notation
« Reply #41 on: October 26, 2024, 08:24:00 PM »

If this is actually useful, I'll consider adding it as an additional option to my main ABC Transcription Tools.

My sense is that it's more of a curiosity than a useful tool since I would expect most D/G and G/C players to want to use the basses, which would pretty much make these simplistic tab solutions more or less useless.

They can easily be edited to reflect the changes required for the basses, but the automated tab solution has no idea about what bass note is being played (which would inform alternative button choices), nor am I planning on doing any more work on it beyond just fixing any bugs in the current bass-unaware solution.

There's no issue with leaving it as it's own standalone utility, and it seamlessly exchanges the results with my full ABC tools, but if it's useful, it would be pretty easy to bring it into the main tool.

I'd appreciate any thoughts on this. 

« Last Edit: October 27, 2024, 01:44:03 AM by Michael Eskin »
Logged

Howard Jones

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1203
Re: Push pull button number notation
« Reply #42 on: October 27, 2024, 03:15:03 PM »

The problem with the fourth-apart systems is that nearly all the notes are available in either direction. This means that there may be several different ways to play the same phrase.  For example, I can think of at least eight different ways to play a simple G-A-B run of notes (on D/G) using different combinations of push/pull and crossing the rows.  As Michael suggests, often the choice will be dictated by the choice of chord, but it may also be a stylistic choice between playing legato and push-pull.  Even if the automated system were able to take account of chords (and could distinguish between D-push and D-pull) I doubt it could accommodate those choices. Often these are result of trial and error by the musician to find a fingering which is both playable and musically satisfying.

Whilst I think Michael's tool is more than a "curiosity" it seems to me that it's main benefit is to help players who can't read music to figure out a tune, but I suspect that in many cases an automated tool may not suggest the best, or perhaps even a good, way to play it.  However perhaps the time is not that far off when AI will be able to replicate the sort of decisions an experienced player makes instinctively.

Michael Eskin

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 547
    • AppCordions
Re: Push pull button number notation
« Reply #43 on: October 27, 2024, 03:24:51 PM »

Thanks for the feedback, pretty much matches my thoughts.

Things are a lot more deterministic on the semitone boxes, where there are only two shared notes between the rows.

I'll leave it as a standalone utility for now, but may integrate the solution into the main tool in the future.
Logged
Pages: 1 2 [3]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal