Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2]   Go Down

Author Topic: GC Lessons & Resources  (Read 4323 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: GC Lessons & Resources
« Reply #20 on: November 26, 2024, 02:22:33 PM »

Having the Bb on the push in favour of G# on Hohner boxes makes sense in context, given that their instruments would have been manufactured for predominantly Germanic music with major tonality. The Bb note over the C chord gives the dominant 7th chord leading to the F chord. This harmony must have been considered particularly important to Hohner, since the first extra buttons they thought to add to the Club box left hand were for dominant 7th chords (Club X). Hohner didn’t even bother adding the (equivalent to) G# on the push when they could have done on the accidentals row, opting instead for push A in order to extend the C major scale on the push. I think the E chord was possibly made major as much as to provide harmonic colour than to offer the player minor tonality.

However, in the context of French traditional music, yes you do want the G# on push for sure. FWIW, not that I’m recommending it, I flipped G/A on the inside row (Dutch reversal), and then tuned the A down to G#, so now I have it both ways  8) I can’t pretend C major is quite so straightforward this way, but it’s manageable.
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

tirpous

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1403
Re: GC Lessons & Resources
« Reply #21 on: November 26, 2024, 02:33:05 PM »

Quote
Sorry, can't understand what you mean. If the G# is on the beat... then what? And what if not?

Maybe something to do with availability of a matching bass or chord ??
Logged

jarviw

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 156
Re: GC Lessons & Resources
« Reply #22 on: November 26, 2024, 02:47:26 PM »

I’ve been tinkering for 3-4 years.  I am interested in French and Canadian folk music but, more importantly, I am interested in getting up and running with the basics.  Any help will be appreciated.  Thanks!

I would recommend Stephane Milleret's teaching videos. The 3rd and 4th seasons cover basic techniques, while the other ones teach a song each with related techniques. 
https://mustradem.com/boutique/en/94-diatonic-accordion

I have been learning/playing on my own, not having a lot of free time to really dedicate myself to lessons. But after checking the first video out I was totally sold. Milleret's playing is very clear and intentional, and his music covers a lot of different rhythms that you don't find in the typical sheet music/tablature. His teaching style is probably more classical school, but you will learn the techniques as well as the music!

Logged

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: GC Lessons & Resources
« Reply #23 on: November 26, 2024, 07:51:58 PM »

Having the Bb on the push in favour of G# on Hohner boxes makes sense in context, given that their instruments would have been manufactured for predominantly Germanic music with major tonality. The Bb note over the C chord gives the dominant 7th chord leading to the F chord. This harmony must have been considered particularly important to Hohner, since the first extra buttons they thought to add to the Club box left hand were for dominant 7th chords (Club X). Hohner didn’t even bother adding the (equivalent to) G# on the push when they could have done on the accidentals row, opting instead for push A in order to extend the C major scale on the push. I think the E chord was possibly made major as much as to provide harmonic colour than to offer the player minor tonality.

Sorry, I'm a bit confused...

The Bb over a C chord gives you the dominant7 chord  to you play in F major, that's not a key in which a two row G/C box is meant to play in, given the subdominant, the Bb chord, is missing.

The Am/E bass-chord couple is clearly a tonic/dominant couple, and in fact with the D chord you have the tonic, the subdominant an the dominant to play in the Am  minor scale, Well, at least in theory, since tunes that use the harmonic minor scale rather than the melodic one - i.e. the sixth degree of the scale isn't sharpened – usually require a D minor chord rather than a D major one. But that's another story.

And. last but not least, what would be the sense of an E major chord if the instrument is meant to play in C and G major, when the diatonic triad would be an E minor chord for both, and it would add far more harmonic colour, since it could be used freely without risking dissonances? And I can tell it because on my G/C box the E is a minor chord! When I (rarely!) need an E major chord, I simply mute the thirds.

I appreciate the attempt to explain the oddity of the G# sharp on the  pull on the Hohner G/C keybord layout, but using the good old Occam's razor – the simplest explanation is usually the best one – I fear that it's simply lacking any logic at all.
Logged

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: GC Lessons & Resources
« Reply #24 on: November 26, 2024, 08:19:51 PM »

Quote
Sorry, can't understand what you mean. If the G# is on the beat... then what? And what if not?

Maybe something to do with availability of a matching bass or chord ??

Another statement that means everything and nothing.

If, when you say “if the G# is on the beat” you mean “if the G# in a melody appears in an accented position”, since in a tune using the harmonic minor scale the obvious match for it in general is an E major chord, then flipping chin accidental on the Hohners makes sense. You can't play a correct chord progression for a tune like Esperanza without a G# on the push, although if I had a G# duplicated on the push and on the pull in the lower octave on my G/C box, I would probably use both.

If you mean something else, maybe you could explain it better.
Logged

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: GC Lessons & Resources
« Reply #25 on: November 26, 2024, 09:13:00 PM »

Having the Bb on the push in favour of G# on Hohner boxes makes sense in context, given that their instruments would have been manufactured for predominantly Germanic music with major tonality. The Bb note over the C chord gives the dominant 7th chord leading to the F chord. This harmony must have been considered particularly important to Hohner, since the first extra buttons they thought to add to the Club box left hand were for dominant 7th chords (Club X). Hohner didn’t even bother adding the (equivalent to) G# on the push when they could have done on the accidentals row, opting instead for push A in order to extend the C major scale on the push. I think the E chord was possibly made major as much as to provide harmonic colour than to offer the player minor tonality.

Sorry, I'm a bit confused...

The Bb over a C chord gives you the dominant7 chord  to you play in F major, that's not a key in which a two row G/C box is meant to play in, given the subdominant, the Bb chord, is missing.

The Am/E bass-chord couple is clearly a tonic/dominant couple, and in fact with the D chord you have the tonic, the subdominant an the dominant to play in the Am  minor scale, Well, at least in theory, since tunes that use the harmonic minor scale rather than the melodic one - i.e. the sixth degree of the scale isn't sharpened – usually require a D minor chord rather than a D major one. But that's another story.

And. last but not least, what would be the sense of an E major chord if the instrument is meant to play in C and G major, when the diatonic triad would be an E minor chord for both, and it would add far more harmonic colour, since it could be used freely without risking dissonances? And I can tell it because on my G/C box the E is a minor chord! When I (rarely!) need an E major chord, I simply mute the thirds.

I appreciate the attempt to explain the oddity of the G# sharp on the  pull on the Hohner G/C keybord layout, but using the good old Occam's razor – the simplest explanation is usually the best one – I fear that it's simply lacking any logic at all.

The C dominant 7th chord can be used just to get to the F chord, without moving into the key of F major. It’s a fairly common devise. Take a simple 3 chord song like ‘Silent Night’ played in the key of C major. Changing the C chord to C7 over the word ‘bright’ (English version) before moving to the F chord creates a satisfactory progression that keeps the harmony moving, but there is no hint of a key change... Similarly, borrowing the E major chord instead of minor creates a nice lead to the A minor chord, when the melody permits, and can sound more sophisticated (you still have a kind of Em chord with G/E ie Em7). I’m prepared to speculate that traditional and perhaps late Romantic German tunes are littered with these borrowed chords, ie I7 and III…

I agree with the observations about playing in A minor, but every layout comes with compromises that are agreed upon according to musical priorities.
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: GC Lessons & Resources
« Reply #26 on: November 27, 2024, 06:48:21 PM »


The C dominant 7th chord can be used just to get to the F chord, without moving into the key of F major. It’s a fairly common devise. Take a simple 3 chord song like ‘Silent Night’ played in the key of C major. Changing the C chord to C7 over the word ‘bright’ (English version) before moving to the F chord creates a satisfactory progression that keeps the harmony moving, but there is no hint of a key change... Similarly, borrowing the E major chord instead of minor creates a nice lead to the A minor chord, when the melody permits, and can sound more sophisticated (you still have a kind of Em chord with G/E ie Em7). I’m prepared to speculate that traditional and perhaps late Romantic German tunes are littered with these borrowed chords, ie I7 and III…

I agree with the observations about playing in A minor, but every layout comes with compromises that are agreed upon according to musical priorities.

An interesting intellectual exercise, but I can't help finding it unconvincing.

First, we are talking of a G/C melodeon, not of a chromatic accordion. You don't have a C major7 chord, just a C major chord and a Bb accidental. And that makes a huge difference.

Second: I agree that the use of an E major chord in place of an E minor chord -  and eventually the use of any chromatic chord - can add sophistication to a standard diatonic harmonic progression. The point is that it can be used just occasionally, while you can easily progress the way you like to the E minor chord, that playing in C major is a stable chord, and anyway naturally can move from it  down a fifth to the A minor chord.

As you said: musical priorities... if I were asked to choose between what I can use most of the times and what I could use just occasionally, I would definitely choose the former, no matter how much the latter could impress my listeners once or twice in a lifetime.

Third, I've no idea if the German melodeon players in the old days used the I7 and III chords, and/or actually played late Romantic German melodies beyond their traditional tunes. The closer I can get to the German traditional music is listening to the Norteno players, that inherited from the German immigrants both the C/F (not the G/C) box, and their earlier repertoire. Polkas, maurkas, waltzes and redowers.  Not really my idea of sophisticated music.  :(


Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: GC Lessons & Resources
« Reply #27 on: November 27, 2024, 09:23:52 PM »


I would recommend Stephane Milleret's teaching videos. The 3rd and 4th seasons cover basic techniques, while the other ones teach a song each with related techniques. 

https://mustradem.com/boutique/en/94-diatonic-accordion

I have been learning/playing on my own, not having a lot of free time to really dedicate myself to lessons. But after checking the first video out I was totally sold. Milleret's playing is very clear and intentional, and his music covers a lot of different rhythms that you don't find in the typical sheet music/tablature. His teaching style is probably more classical school, but you will learn the techniques as well as the music!

   Stephane is a very patient, qualified teacher. I think there are three series of videos in all. Each one takes you through a specific melody, phrase by phrase and chord by chord, with a general theme of getting the rhythm right. His teaching is in the French style so very much based on right hand cord structures, but the first two series stick very much to what is available onto two rows.

  Everything is in French, but there are English subtitles. I did the first series and much of the second, with someone else taking over when I had a delayed post-surgical disaster in 2017. I … thought there were Italian and Spanish subtitles too but can't see any on the website just now. 

  The good news is that Steph is now cutting the prices of his early videos, and there's a 40% discount when you buy a series. The first video is available at only €4, as a trial and others follow very much the same pattern. Then  €6 for each 1:1 hour long lesson that you can stream again, and again …isn't exorbitant?

  It's a bit of a commitment, but signing up a music tutor for 1:1 lessons here in Britain would cost a lot more?

 [edit]  Six series!
« Last Edit: November 27, 2024, 09:27:44 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: GC Lessons & Resources
« Reply #28 on: November 27, 2024, 11:25:24 PM »


An interesting intellectual exercise, but I can't help finding it unconvincing.

First, we are talking of a G/C melodeon, not of a chromatic accordion. You don't have a C major7 chord, just a C major chord and a Bb accidental. And that makes a huge difference.

Second: I agree that the use of an E major chord in place of an E minor chord -  and eventually the use of any chromatic chord - can add sophistication to a standard diatonic harmonic progression. The point is that it can be used just occasionally, while you can easily progress the way you like to the E minor chord, that playing in C major is a stable chord, and anyway naturally can move from it  down a fifth to the A minor chord.

As you said: musical priorities... if I were asked to choose between what I can use most of the times and what I could use just occasionally, I would definitely choose the former, no matter how much the latter could impress my listeners once or twice in a lifetime.

Third, I've no idea if the German melodeon players in the old days used the I7 and III chords, and/or actually played late Romantic German melodies beyond their traditional tunes. The closer I can get to the German traditional music is listening to the Norteno players, that inherited from the German immigrants both the C/F (not the G/C) box, and their earlier repertoire. Polkas, maurkas, waltzes and redowers.  Not really my idea of sophisticated music.  :(

I’m thinking in C/F but translating to G/C for consistency… I basically agree with you, except that I believe that there must be some logic supporting Hohner’s arrangement of accidentals that favours a certain kind of music. This is based on speculation since I’m not very familiar with that style, so I don’t know for example if players would have played Bb over the C chord, although it’s the only left hand chord that the note fits in any way with… Once you get to the Club layout then the push Bb becomes essential, or else the Bb push chord is virtually useless… It could be that Hohner placed the accidentals primarily to optimise their use as chromatic notes of decoration, so for example the pull G# can be used as an auxiliary note between two A notes over a pull D chord…



Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: GC Lessons & Resources
« Reply #29 on: November 28, 2024, 11:41:56 AM »


… I basically agree with you, except that I believe that there must be some logic supporting Hohner’s arrangement of accidentals that favours a certain kind of music...


Straight to the point... I don't!

If a G/C instrument is meant play in C, G and A minor – and I think this is the case -, then to have the G# accidental on the push, to be played with the E major chord, is the only choice that really makes sense.

If we assume that the G/C is meant to play only in C and G major, than the E major chords make no sense, and it should be replaced with an E minor.

No doubt you can use occasionally the E major to play in C and in G, like in fact you can use the D major chord to play in C and the F chord to play in G. But if we agree that the melodeon is intrinsically a diatonic instrument, having the tonic, the subdominant and the dominant chords for eacxh key/scale, and have the notes they are based upon in the same bellows direction of the chords, is the only thing that sounds logic to me.

But then, there are/were a lot of inconsistencies in the layouts of the instruments of different makers. For instance, historically the Italian two row boxes were supplied just with major chords and without chin accidentals – if you can find some logic support to this choice, please let me know about it!
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: GC Lessons & Resources
« Reply #30 on: November 28, 2024, 06:18:34 PM »



   Hohner's layout, and addiction to 4th start makes no sense at all. The accidentals  the opposite way from virtually every other manufacturer. And something like 500 mainly British players voted massively on this forum that 4th start made a lot more sense on a D/G. Otherwise the top end is virtually useless?

   they did get a letter, and unlike other manufacturers they didn't bother to reply.
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: GC Lessons & Resources
« Reply #31 on: November 28, 2024, 07:12:52 PM »

I think a lot of it comes down to standardisation, as you’d expect with any mass produced machine, so for example the D/G box goes too high, and the G/C box too low (arguably). The clearest error in this regard is the one row in G, which should surely be a 2nd button start!..

Maybe Hohner could have changed the layout for each tuning, as their usage became more clear eg G/C for playing French A minor tunes having a push G# accidental, D/G for English fiddle tunes with low notes to G…

I can’t get on board with the idea that Hohner somehow didn’t know what they were doing when the note layout was initially decided upon though… They wouldn’t have been bothered about matching the range of a fiddle (given the key preferences), or considering the best arrangement of accidentals if you were to remove thirds from chords, for example…

So I’m starting from the reasonable assumption that they did know what they were doing… So for whatever reason, some of which I’ve speculated on, the push Bb is given priority over push G#… Regarding the other accidentals, I think it can be argued that they work better as chromatic passing notes or auxiliary notes the way that Hohner has them… This has been covered in other threads on flipping accidentals…

It would be great to have some input from someone with expertise in German traditional music…
« Last Edit: November 28, 2024, 07:25:49 PM by Arnold »
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: GC Lessons & Resources
« Reply #32 on: November 28, 2024, 07:27:18 PM »

Plenty of evidence that Hohner didn’t understand or care about how their instruments are used.  For example
Basses on Hohner Double Ray set up for playing in B and C.
BCC# Compadre (a rare beast). With “accidentals” at the start of each row. It’s fully chromatic without accidentals!
DG being simple a transposed layout of CF ignoring the need of DG players for additional low notes.
There could be more.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: GC Lessons & Resources
« Reply #33 on: November 28, 2024, 08:35:10 PM »

Plenty of evidence that Hohner didn’t understand or care about how their instruments are used.  For example
Basses on Hohner Double Ray set up for playing in B and C.
BCC# Compadre (a rare beast). With “accidentals” at the start of each row. It’s fully chromatic without accidentals!
DG being simple a transposed layout of CF ignoring the need of DG players for additional low notes.
There could be more.

Good points Theo, hmmm, I’ll attempt to hold my position for now…

There isn’t really a totally satisfactory way to set up the 8 basses of a semitone box, or else we would all be playing them, but yes that seems quite wide of the mark!.. So I’ll attempt to find some logic since I’ve dug myself in  ;D… I see it’s the same layout as C/C# but transposed down a semitone, so again standardisation comes into it… Let’s assume players would have expected to be able to play both rows as a one row (not unreasonable listening to all those old recordings!), and in that respect the chord pairs on the outside buttons make sense… Players would perhaps regard the outside row as the home row, and so the rest of the chords are optimised for that key, in this case B. Chord III on the push (major again), chord vi on the pull… Chord V also on the push makes sense because it’s root is only available  as push on the right hand, and finally chord IV on the pull with all corresponding notes on right hand pull… It wasn’t designed to be played cross rows in other sharp keys, but when Hohner realised it was, they offered it with Stradella 12 bass, which doesn’t seem to have sold particularly well!.. Hohner’s home market had long since realised that fourth apart was the way to go!..

The Compadre doesn’t really count since that was released after Hohner cheaped out, and I’m mostly thinking about 100 years ago when the standard was set…

I think simply transposed is just part of the Hohner system of standardisation, these being mass produced instruments…


Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997
Pages: 1 [2]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal