Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Hohner Club IIIB S: Info, Pics, and ... Project?  (Read 2487 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Ben

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 61
  • Hohner G/C, Pokerwork D/G, B/E, Club IIIB S C/F,
Hohner Club IIIB S: Info, Pics, and ... Project?
« on: December 16, 2024, 07:23:32 PM »

I just picked up a Hohner Club IIIB S.  In my research, there was shockingly little information on the innards of the box (pictures, etc).  There are a couple things that I wanted to adjust with the box, some things that need attention, etc etc.  So, I figured I would start a thread to document my findings and adjustment for posterity, feedback, and for my own reference. 

So with the preamble out of the way...


The box in question is a C/F 30 button 8 bass, pretty standard for a Hohner Club. The box is not clubbed; it does have a dutch reversal though.  My other boxes are dutched (if that is a word?), and I find it is just a wonderful system, making for easy flowing passages. 

Photos
For reference throughout this post: https://photos.app.goo.gl/kNt6wGmW8PW6PYiB8

General Playability
Having only played pokerworks, ooph, this is a big box. It feels heavier in the hand (I believe 12lbs vs the pokerworks 6lbs), but the bass end - while heavier - is still easy to manipulate for reasonably fast phrases.  (Disclaimer: I have only played for ~3yrs and mostly by myself/along with videos, so take my playing comments with a grain of salt).  The biggest difference, however, is the physical size of the keyboards.  The Club's keyboard is markedly larger than the pokerwork's, which is taking some getting used to.  The muscle memory stretches/movements I have made in the past I am finding no longer get me to the button I think they will on both the treble and bass side. 

The buttons on both side sink into the case - uncomfortably so, though no as bad as an un-hotroded pokerwork - so, this will need to be addressed.  The bass side especially I find to be uncomfortable and borderline painful as my fingers catch the rather pronounced edges of the button holes as they are depressed. 

I haven't explored the half row yet, but the little bit I have when trying to play in D and Bb, I often find the accidentals to be right where I want them (though sometimes in a different direction than expected).  I intend to try to learn scales in the non-standard keys of Bb, E (that'll be fun), and A, since those are keys we often play at my church, where I intended to play this most. 

Another oddity of the box is the air button. I am very used to the pokerwork's toggle switch, and man, the air button is very different.  I am surprised at how much I am struggling to push it.  It isn't stiff, it's just a different muscle movement than I am used to.  It did have some slight annoying squeaks, so I lubed that up with some PTFE (from a spray can... how bad is that?). 

I replaced the bass strap, since it was in... usable... condition.  Being a bit short on cash, I opted for an old leather guitar strap that I have had for an unknown number of years for an unknown reason (to this day, I still have no idea where it came from!).  It feels much better, and, maybe it's just a placebo effect, but the air button felt easier to press with the wider strap.  At some point in the future, I intend to replace the strap with a proper adjustable strap.


Sound
All of those nitpicks can be forgiven, because the tone.  The tone.  Wow.  Again, having only played pokerworks and listened to numerous different kind of boxes on the internet, I have a pretty limited experience with in-personal tonal quality.  As a point of reference, I have tuned my pokerworks to a swing tuning (+8cents), though very amateurly.  In reality, there is a +-4c variation between the 2 reeds.  One box (my first one my friend gave to me years ago which started me into this black abyss of melodeons) is a CF with old Zinc plates, similar to the Club, and the other, a newer DG.  The DG IMO had the better tuning job from the start, and sounded less brash than the CF.  But I digress. 

Let's start with treble side.  I expected the Club, with its similar zinc reeds, to have that same brashness as my CF.  Boy was I wrong.  The M setting sounds surprisingly smooth and rich compared my CF and my friends M register on his Piano Accordion (which sounds more concertina-ish; thin, nasal almost).  I find I greatly enjoy the box's M register.  Adding in the L register, wow, it sounds surprisingly full and thicker than one would expect (again, compared to my friends piano accordion).  Playing MM or LMM, the tremelo set - tuned to +20c IIRC -  sounds shockingly round.  I don't have the vocabular to describe it any other way.  It isn't displeasing at all as I expected from my other experience with 'standard Hohner tuning' I have heard on the internet or with my own boxes.  Shockingly, my wife actually likes it.  I think I still may tune it a bit closer (maybe +10c) at some point down the line, but we will see how we get on.  It is hard for me to envision me using the MM setting anywhere but by myself; I am not sure how well it will mesh with the other instruments I play with.  Time will tell!

The bass side is just as big a revelation.  It is BIG.  Even just playing the chords*, it sounds thick.  Adding in the root, and holy guacamole it is like a flipping organ.  I did not know a sound like that could emanate from a little (?) accordion.  When suspended/inverted chords are played (e.g. Bb/G, C/A), it sounds absolutely gorgeous.  Indescribably so.  I just.. I just want to keep playing it.  I thought the little pokerworks sounded good doing these - which they absolutely do, mind you - but this is next level.  I don't know if it is just good tuning, good reeds, a good box, or all of the above, but wow.
*one of the first things I did was remove thirds.  See the below for details on that.


Treble Voices/Registers
The Treble side is LMM, and unique to the B S in the Club III lineup is its ability to switch the L and M+ reeds on and off.  The registers are located behind the keyboard toward the chin, and are turned on when they are pushed down toward the knee.  The top switch engages the M+ reed, while the bottom switch engages the L.  Additionally, though only tangentially related, the treble fingerboard has a thumbgroove! I thought I would like it more than I actually do (I find my thumb resting on the bottom edge of the groove vs in the middle of it, since its easier to move my thumb to the register switches from there, but I am sure my positioning will adjust as I play more).  Honestly, from my experience so far, it's... fine.  I don't think I would pay extra for it, but I can't complain about having it.

I have never played a box with multiple voices/registers before, so I decided top open up the box and see how the mechanism worked (again, I have found shockingly few pictures or video about how registers actually function).  Each reedblock has an additional 'foot' (Melnet, what is the actual name here?) glued on to the bottom of the blocks with a slot cut in it to sandwich a sliding brass (?) register.  Interestingly, the holes for the M reeds and the M+ reeds are different shapes.  The M reeds (non-registered) have circular openings, while the registered M+s' are rectangular.  I have not noticed a difference in tone/volume with the different shaped holes. See the pictures in the link below to get a better idea what I am talking about.  It is a bit hard to describe.

The register switches are connected to little armatures inside the case that poke through the slides on the end.  Initially I opened up the box to investigate why the M+ slide was not engaging, and kept hearing a scratching sound when pushing the lever.  It turned out to be the bottom reedblock's armature just scratching the top of the slide, and not actually moving it.  In this I learned (through error) the correct 'open' and 'closed' initial position of the slides: When the slide is in the open position, the slide should extend out quite a bit beyond the reedblock (see images for reference).

I noticed that while playing, the L register would start to drop down behind the keyboard on its own, and create this interesting chorus/overtone effect.  Not unpleasant, but certainly not wanted in many scenarios.  Plus, that's not how its supposed to function. So while, the box was open, I loosened up the bracket holding the armatures in place, and slipped in a small piece of paper folded in half to increase the friction on the armature.  It has, so far, worked like a charm.


Bass Voices/Registers
There are no registers on the bass side.  When played together, the bass/chords spans 4 octaves (2 low octaves on the root button, and 2 higher octaves on the I, III, V, e.g. F/A/C.  Nothing super special to say here that hasn't already been said.  A more in-depth look at the bass mechanism etc is below. I did very soon take out the IIIs of the box.  I find this to be a much more pleasing/cleaner tone, and - critically - much more versatile with the tunes I like to play.  One thing to note here, is this does have the Club bass setup:  the IV chord (e.g. Bb) is only Bb on the pull, with the Eb on the push.  This has caught me out a couple times, but thankfully, with the dutch reversal and the pull C on the low end of the box, I find this is pretty easy to work around.  Air management is slightly more of a task though since I am playing on the pull more now.

Bass Mechanism
I was expecting the bass mechanism to be pretty similar to a Corona, or the same as the Hohner Club IV with a direct connection between the button and the pallets being lifted.  However, the mechanism is much closer to a stradella mechanism, with the buttons actuating rotating rods that push down on a set of pins which opens the pallets (please correct me on terminology!).  One can easily see the progression from the simple direction connection to this to the modern stradella mechanism.  Quite fascinating indeed. 

I wanted to take out the thirds, but with the 'matrix decoder' I have heard it referred to, I was unsure what reeds were being activated on which button, and more importantly, if it was even possible to tape off the thirds due to reed sharing.  I mapped out which pallets where what notes, and what buttons actuated which pallets (see the attached PDF), and found that most of the 3rds were not shared with other chords. Great! Thusly, I taped off reeds 1, 12, the F on reed 3, and the C# on reed 2.  But reed #9 (G/D) was both a III for Eb/Bb and the V/I for the C/G chord! Ahh! No taping possible here.  I noodled on what to do, and decided to remove the pin that actuated reed #9 when pushing the Eb/Bb chord button, with the intent of being able to restore the pin if I so desired at a later time.  After trying to pull, push, and twist it out with no avail, I lightly filed the peened end of the pin and pulled it out of the rod, and safely stored it in a baggy.  Reassembling the rod into the mechanism, I tried it out. Holy smokes, it all works! And not a third to be heard! Woohoo!

Project List
There are still a couple things I plan to do to the box, some of them more needed than others.  So, in no particular order...

1) Limit button travel on the treble side (likely taking off the top of the keyboard and slotting some thick felt under the buttons) Completed 12/30
2) Limit button travel on the bass side. No idea how to go about this at this time... Any ideas? Completed 12/30
3) Retape the bellows.  As you can see in the pictures, the bellows have been retaped... er, taped.  It looks like a combination of duct tape, electrical, and gaff tape?  It's hideous.  Plus the bellows are leakier than one would hope.  It's not bad - it still plays reasonably well - but it is far from ideal.  Lifting the treble end without supporting the bass end, and the bellows open without too much fuss...  My hope is that retaping the bellows will help improve the air-tightness, and allow the knee side bellows strap to actually fasten.  Currently... this isn't possible due to the mass of tape down there.  Worse comes to worst, I will save up to get a new set of bellows.  They are the same bellows as the Corona II/III, Corso, Compadre, etc at 310 x 190mm.  I might find an old panther, Club IIIB project box, or similar to replace the bellows if the price is right.  Anyone have thoughts here?  Should I just bite the bullet and get a new set of bellows or will retaping help with the airtightness? New findings in Update #2
4) Fix the broken celluloid on the fingerboard.  I need to do some more research on how to do this (glue? acetone?)
5) Repaint the bass grill
6) Replace the bass strap with a proper adjustable strap Completed 1/16
7) Retune the M+ down to +10c... maybe?
8) Add a couple more bass buttons, E/B, and maybe a reversal D/A.  Making a new fondo and cutting up a box are a little intimidating - there is no going back if you mess up.  I will certainly want to prototype it out on an old case first.  Plus, I would need to find where to source these reeds.  Maybe in a couple years....



Till the next update, happy squeezing everyone!
« Last Edit: January 16, 2025, 03:46:09 PM by Ben »
Logged

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Hohner Club IIIB S: Info, Pics, and ... Project?
« Reply #1 on: December 16, 2024, 08:42:07 PM »

What a super machine (from a fellow fan of Club boxes). I don’t have much to offer except for perhaps the bass button limiting…

I have a Victoria Club, although not quite as elaborate, with those same little rubber tubes all in a line at the base of the button rods (probably poor terminology!). The thing I did was to limit those where they move toward the case. A block of wood with the correct thickness stuck to the inside of the case, with a layer of felt that the rubber tubes rest against should do the trick... This gives a couple of mm of movement that is usually enough (I can make a photo if this explanation is not clear)

Also, I’m sure you’re aware, but having Dutch reversal means that with a little retuning you can get both C# and Eb on push and pull. which is a very good idea!..
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Ben

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 61
  • Hohner G/C, Pokerwork D/G, B/E, Club IIIB S C/F,
Re: Hohner Club IIIB S: Info, Pics, and ... Project?
« Reply #2 on: December 16, 2024, 09:22:25 PM »

I have a Victoria Club, although not quite as elaborate, with those same little rubber tubes all in a line at the base of the button rods (probably poor terminology!). The thing I did was to limit those where they move toward the case. A block of wood with the correct thickness stuck to the inside of the case, with a layer of felt that the rubber tubes rest against should do the trick... This gives a couple of mm of movement that is usually enough (I can make a photo if this explanation is not clear)

Also, I’m sure you’re aware, but having Dutch reversal means that with a little retuning you can get both C# and Eb on push and pull. which is a very good idea!..

Actually I am not aware! Please enlighten me!  Are you suggesting to tune the D/Eb on the helper row to C#/Eb? Interesting proposition...

Once I become more familiar with the helper row (in practice; in theory I understand it) i may do this; I can't imagine ever needing the push D since I have it on the F row.

I think I understand what you are saying with the rubber tubes etc.  I should give that a shot putting a piece of felt-topped wood underneath the button rods/pallet rod things.  I will be interested to see if/how that impacts those low bass reeds; hopefully they won't get starved for air with the limited travel.
Logged

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Hohner Club IIIB S: Info, Pics, and ... Project?
« Reply #3 on: December 16, 2024, 09:37:06 PM »

You could retune the D to C#, but I had a spare set of Hohner PA reeds, so I swapped in a unisonoric pair of both C# and Eb. This was on a Club II whose reedplates were easily matched, but some Club boxes are of higher quality I think, so you’d want to find a match…

Good thinking, I did recently encounter the problem when I limited the button travel on a HA114C, but the clearance was minute… What I tend to do is find a block of wood that is a little too thin, and gradually thicken it by adding layers of masking tape until I am happy with the amount of limiting, before sticking it down semi permanently…
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Pete Dunk

  • Typo Expert
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3706
Re: Hohner Club IIIB S: Info, Pics, and ... Project?
« Reply #4 on: December 16, 2024, 10:03:16 PM »

I have a partially refurbished/retuned Club IIIBS C/F in very tidy condition. It’s a glorious sounding, if ponderously heavy old beast that remains a long term ‘work in progress’. For sentimental reasons it will remain a Club box as built but it was worth spending some time cleaning up and adjusting the selector mechanism for the L and M+ reed blocks so that the levers work smoothly. Good luck with yours, it sounds like you are making good progress.
Logged
Squeezing on the Isle of Oxney, UK
Primo (Serenellini) D/G
Isis D/G
Hohner B/E, G/C, C/F, Bb/Eb G/C/F
Liliputs D/G (G scale), C/F, Bb/Eb, Albrecht Custom D/G (G scale)

JNM SY

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 227
Re: Hohner Club IIIB S: Info, Pics, and ... Project?
« Reply #5 on: December 17, 2024, 01:28:52 PM »

Hi,you might find something interesting in this thread.
 I eventually built a whole new bass end for my club 3 bs ( possibly newer model). The treble end is very similar though.
http://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=25700.msg305844#msg305844
                       Good luck,  John.
Logged

Ben

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 61
  • Hohner G/C, Pokerwork D/G, B/E, Club IIIB S C/F,
Re: Hohner Club IIIB S: Info, Pics, and ... Project?
« Reply #6 on: December 30, 2024, 08:50:18 PM »

Update #1

I found some time to do a little bit of work on the box over the holidays!

I fabbed up a spacer about 7/8" tall to limit the bass button travel as per Arnold's recommendation, see the picture <Bass travel limited.jpg> below.  After playing it for week or so, I think I may cut this down to closer to 5/8".  I have noticed that the deep bass doesn't seem as rich as it did before the modification.  Also, I think the little folded aluminum (?) feet that push down the rubber tubed pallet lifters are compressing a bit from me pushing the buttons down; the buttons certainly feel like they are going deeper than when I first put in the spacer.  I haven't opened the bass end back up to compare to my earlier pictures, but that is on the agenda.

Likewise, I added in a 3/16" felt pad under the treble keyboard, <treble keyboard padding.jpg>.  I thought that would be an easy task, considering the attachment mechanism looked pretty similar to how pokerworks are assembled.  Boy was I wrong.  I unscrewed the keyboard, as expected, and pulled out those long screws - cool, nothing new so far.  But the keyboard still wouldn't budge.  Hmm, oh, of course, the register switches under the keyboard need to be undone.  Unscrewed that mechanism (man are those tiny screws!), but it still wouldn't move.  I started look around at what else it could be, but couldn't find any screws, dowels, anything.  Maybe it is attached to the treble pallet mechanisms mounting blocks?  That would be odd, but it is a different box... After some gentle movement of the keyboard, it popped off - along with the treble mechanism mounting blocks.  Uh oh. It looks like the keyboard has 2 little pegs that mount into the treble mechanism blocks, and at one point, those blocks were possibly glued or waxed onto the fondo?  I am not sure.  Regardless, now that the keyboard (and mechanism) were off, i removed the pitifully thin felt strips under the keyboard, and carpet-taped in the felt, and started to reassemble the front end.  It took quite a bit of finessing to get the mechanism back into place; I ended up putting the keyboard screws back through the fondo and using those to screw the mounting blocks (and the mechanism) back into position <treble keyboard.jpg>, then putting the keyboard onto the screws and again screwing it on tight.  All of those springs on the mechanism exert quite a bit of force onto the fondo! Wow!

So! Mark off Task #1 and half cross off Task #2 (still need to do some final adjustments).


Question:
Can anyone comment on if those treble mounting blocks are supposed to be glued/waxed into place onto the fondo?  One of the blocks fits snug against it, but the other one has a 2-3mm gap.  Very odd..

I know there are some posts about people taking old PAs and repurposing the reeds.  A couple of questions for those of you who have done that:
1) On the bass side, should I look for old Hohners to use their reeds for additional bass buttons or will (most) any accordion work?  Will there be a large tonal difference on the bass side?  I assume there will be, and that weighted bass reeds are less preferred... but what are your thoughts?
2) To get the PA (unisonoric) reeds to be the normal bisonoric bass, I have read that one would want to add some solder on the tip of the reed I am lowering to lower the pitch significantly.  How does this impact tone/response?  Is tuning them a fifth apart (e.g. E/B and Bb/F) too big of a gap for a soldered tip to be advisable? Or would it be better to do a E/F (DG world: F#/G) button and a B/Bb (DG world: C#/C) button?




Next Up:
Adjust the bass side a bit more
Fix the celluloid on the keyboard
Repaint the bass grill.


Other Notes:
Man, this box is just a joy to play.  It certainly is a bit heavier than the pokerwork; I was playing it last night for a couple hours and my left arm was getting a pretty tired by the end of it.  I have found I really did not play the MM+ tuning much over the last couple weeks, it is just too wet.  But last night, I decided to try to play some german polka (lots of chords etc), and holy smokes that thick round MM+ tuning (+20cents?) sounded absolutely wonderful when playing chords.  It may not suite melody lines as well (e.g. Hartwin, Cutting, etc), but for thick happy chords, ooph, it is right at home.

I have also gotten pretty comfortable with the air button vs the pokerworks lever, and the overall keyboard spacing.  I can (mostly) move between the boxes without much issue, though the Club's push Eb bass does catch me out on occasion.

I have hardly picked up the pokerwork since getting this one (aside from at a gig a week ago), which is pretty surprising considering how much I love that tighter tuning +8-10c (and DG vs CF).  But the M and LM on the club just sounds so good.

I also started learning a couple scales (sans bass), Cm, D, G, E, Eb, and Bb.  D and G aren't too bad, but E... that one is going to take a lot of practice to have any hope of playing fluently.  Honestly, I am beginning to understand why people just say hang it all and get a bunch of boxes in all of the different keys.  Maybe one day when the kiddos are grown and outta college!
Logged

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Hohner Club IIIB S: Info, Pics, and ... Project?
« Reply #7 on: January 05, 2025, 05:13:37 PM »

Nice work! Hmm, I see those folded aluminium feet now… My Viktoria doesn’t have them so is not prone to bending, but yes just the slightest additional bend will affect button travel… A felt topper on the spacer could help but might not eliminate the problem completely…

With regards to repurposing reeds, I think some clubs use a different scale length to some of the ‘lower’ end models. I would compare lengths of the bass reeds to ones in your Pokerwork, then you will know if they are the same lady standard…
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Ben

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 61
  • Hohner G/C, Pokerwork D/G, B/E, Club IIIB S C/F,
Re: Hohner Club IIIB S: Info, Pics, and ... Project?
« Reply #8 on: January 16, 2025, 10:25:29 PM »

EDIT: updated Bass End with tone thoughts.
Update #2


I was able to get my hands on a Panther to try out fitting the bellows, as well as seeing if the panther bass end would be an acceptable option... Here are my findings.

Bellows
Ok, so technically, the bellows of the Panther and Club IIIB S are indeed the same size, 190mm x 310mm.  However, the bellows frame and the corners are substantially different.  The Club's bellows use 52AP corners (as best as I can figure/measure), whereas the Panther/Corona II uses 35ME corners, quite a bit smaller radius corners.  Likewise, the frames are slightly different but important ways.  The Panther/Corona bellows frame have a sharp corner, see below <Panther Bellows Dims.jpg>, while the Club's frame is chamfered over, see <Club Bellows Dims.jpg>.  Lastly, the center-to-center distance of the pins is about 3mm different, meaning that even chamfering the frame corners would still not suffice.  The pins are pretty similar, with the Club having a washer and being 1mm longer, see <Panther Club Pin Dims.jpg>.

Strap
I was able to get my hands on an adjustable Bellow Strap, and man it feels good. However, it is substantially thicker than what the Club's feet can handle, so the whole box rests on the strap and kinda leans over a bit.  Hmm. I am not sure if I will keep the new strap on there or if I will get taller feet to fit.  Time will tell.

Bass End
I was able to try playing the Panther's 12bass.  I don't know if its just me, but the basses are uncomfortably far apart and/or the buttons are too small.  I can't put my finger on which - or both - but either way, not super pleasant.  I had an opportunity to play a Pariselle box (14bass) and that felt (shocking) much better in terms of spacing/button size.   That being said, after playing around more with the Club bass, I am not convinced that I actually want to modify the bass end. Maybe in the future if/when I get a project club box I can try it out on that, but I can't imagine at this point messing around and screwing up the bass end.  Its just too nice sounding as is.  Tonally, the bass end of the Panther sounds like a Pokerwork.  I can certainly see getting a Panther's GCF bass block set or 2 to use in the future, but I think I would lean toward a Corona III set just to have that multiple octave bass/chord like what the Club natively has.

Next Up
so... I didn't do what I had planned on doing from the last post... so still next on the agenda
Adjust the bass side a bit more
Fix the celluloid on the keyboard
Repaint the bass grill.
« Last Edit: January 16, 2025, 11:11:33 PM by Ben »
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal