Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2 3 4 5 6 7   Go Down

Author Topic: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...  (Read 11696 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« on: February 08, 2025, 11:34:23 AM »

I've read all the threads that I could find on the origin of D/G as the de facto box for English Trad and it seems to come down to this (admittedly over-simplistic) summary - some dude went around collecting trad folk tunes, noticed that a lot were in D or G (possibly due to fiddle predominance), ordered a consignment of D/G boxes from Hohner and put them into circulation, thereby cementing the D/G as the English box. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong.

All well and good. Except, it's not:

- The D/G isn't the nicest sounding box.
- Half the G row is unusable due to being too high pitched.
- This leads to 4th (or even 5th) button starts.
- Leading to a partial loss of the upper octave on the G row.
- Leading to reluctantance to play in the upper register.
- Et cetera...
(I'm ignoring Bandoneon tuned boxes because it's not at all widespread).

Yeah, I know, I've been playing for two minutes and here I am again challenging convention. Ha! Of course, these are just my opinions, but from reading around it would seem that a fair few folk would agree. Who knows, some folk may even like the high octaves - my ear certainly doesn't.

So, why can't English Trad be played on another tuning? Of course it can, you can play the tunes in whatever key you like, it comes down to "acceptance". Clearly playing an oddball key like Bb/Eb would be a struggle. G/C would be OK. But of all the options, it would seem that A/D is the best bet. It sounds good, makes full use of the keyboard, half of the popular tunes can be played in their usual keys (D and Em) and it chimes well with other instruments (particularly fiddle).

So, come on you old stagers, tell me why I'm crazy and should just shut up and get on with learning D/G!

PS - Theo, I put this in here, as opposed to the instruments section, because I feel it's a multi-faceted discussion and not just relating to particular boxes.
Logged

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #1 on: February 08, 2025, 12:03:47 PM »

The concept of key is relative anyway. Bbmaj in A=440hz is C maj in "baroque" A=415hz.

If the English trad scene revolves around D - G melodeon, then that's what's being played.

But you don't really learn to play a d-g. You learn to play a bisonoric quint box and you pick its key.
Ok, you'll need some upskilling in sight-reading sheet music in another key, but all fingerings will be transposable.

Europe & post-soviet space are a lot more relaxed about it - you can play a tune transposed to the key of your box without being chased out of the village by angry pitchfork-wielding traditionalists. Also, there's a lot more singing accompanied by melodeon, so players will pick a box key to match the vocal range.

In regard to quint D-G, I agree that it's not the nicest sounding box, particularly for solo playing. Half of it is castrato-range notes and a lot of tunes sound too squeaky.
When I only had a C-F club, I'd say that a good 80% of D tunes sound better in C.
When I had a Bb-Eb club and a A-E hromka, I'd say that maybe 50% of tunes written in Amin sound great in Gmin or F#min.
So go ahead, knock yourself out with A-D quint as long as you like the sound.

There's another side to the melodeon key & range debate: free reed instruments are capable of playing in about 7 octaves I believe , but only about 3 octaves actually sound & play nice and are practical & economic enough to mass produce. I'd say A=110 to A=880.
Go below low F on the treble side and you cannot (practically) fit reeds long enough to make that range to be very responsive & sound balanced. In fact, Low F - Low C range is OK at best, unless you have oversized bayan reeds in the treble. Go to A=880, and the piccolos start getting very tricky to make, gap & tune - these ranges tend to only play well on very expensive, no costs spared concert PAs and CBAs.
So if your starting point in MM box is, say, F=174, and the range is 3 octaves, you very quickly run into the castrato range in your highest octave. If you start an octave lower, F=87, then you'd struggle to get good response from the lowest half a dozen reeds, unless you go for a longer scale, which adds size & bulk to the box (not something that many folks would want to accept).
Logged

CAB

  • Mass Debater
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1147
    • Somerset Russets Village Band
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #2 on: February 08, 2025, 12:33:36 PM »

Apart from wincing at the description of the great Peter Kennedy as some dude (who) went around collecting trad folk tunes...  :D ... I agree with much of what you say but it's largely a matter of whether you want to play with other instruments, which usually include fiddles.  You can play the music at any pitch you like for your own pleasure but you'll be less welcome in sessions or bands if you can't play in the same keys that everyone else uses.  The repertoire sounds fine to my ear in a range of two octaves from middle C up. 

It depends a lot on the instrument, too.  My first melodeon, back in the '70s, was a Hohner 110 in G but I rarely played it because that low G scale with tremolo really grated on my ears.  By contrast, I love using the same pitch on my current swing-tuned DG Castagnari.

True, the top octave of a DG is an acquired taste but, if you have a 4th button start with a low G scale, you gain as much at the bottom as you lose at the top.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Kennedy_(folklorist)
Logged
Pas de lieu Rhone que nous

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #3 on: February 08, 2025, 01:21:16 PM »


   It's "achievable", but due to the way instruments are set out in two diatonic scales, if you fight against that either your right end chords fail (e.g you get tonic+5 only)  or your melody lines become really awkward. Having to change button and direction of bellows simultaneously is a pig to achieve smoothly.  Especially in a crowded pub with jostling from a neighbour.

   Many more options if you have a 3rd row. The Anglesey weekend (about 20 years ago) had a particularly wide congregation of instruments and styles and the second time I got there they played in every diatonic scale apart from Ab.  I was on a C#DG Oakwood at the time, and managed to join in with everything. But in about half those keys I was simply chording along on the right end.

  On a 2-row 8-bass your options are quite constricted. And it is much more relaxing and enjoyable to "go with the instrument".  In that Kennedy made the correct choice IMHO for 1960's session repertoire.  Unfortunately (and as I've said before) the sweet spot for steel reeds with respect to folk music seems to be ±G/C. A G/C plays very happily across both of its octaves. You can go for a low sound with adventures into the upper octave. Or play the tune in the upper octave and dot in nice bass runs with your index finger, as Frédéric Paris and others do.

   D/G and C/F are both 2½ semitones away from the ideal, nearly as far as you can get. And that is essentially what makes MM upper octave too shrill to use. They were much better with a LM setup. but I imagine that it would be difficult to cheaply manufacture Hohner type blocks for that?

   Improvising, using 3 rows, it's fine but that's completely different learning curve.  I've learnt that it's best to take a box with a D/G basis to English sessions, and my G/C when I'm in France.   i.e "Go with the flow" 😉

   
« Last Edit: February 08, 2025, 01:25:28 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #4 on: February 08, 2025, 01:31:06 PM »

It’s ironic that the DG wax introduced to fit in with existing repertoire and possible to suit fiddle players.  Now the DG is now so ubiquitous that good fiddle players can feel constrained. 
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #5 on: February 08, 2025, 02:10:58 PM »

The D/G came about so that the melodeon could fall into line with established folk instruments and their generally favoured keys (or else if the other instruments were to tune down to C/F say, it would be a case of the tail wagging the dog). The fiddle is capable of playing in any key of course and other keys are often favoured for various reasons (eg Bb for 2 octave tunes), but usually the open strings are preferred as the tonic/dominant notes. The irony is that the dominance of the melodeon in English traditional music has now compelled other instruments to use only those 2 keys (by which I mean also their related modes), arguably to the detriment of the music more generally (so now those 2 octave Bb tunes are played in the murkier G range). There are various reasons for preferring other key combinations, but for fitting into the tradition of English music within a group setting, D/G is absolutely the right choice. FWIW I find that a vast majority of English tunes fit into the range of D4-G5, which I think is well within the sweet spot..

Edit: I just happened to independently make the same point as Theo  8)
« Last Edit: February 08, 2025, 02:13:22 PM by Arnold »
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Julian S

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1628
  • D/G Pastourelle 2, Dony, Pokerwork, G/C Pariselle
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #6 on: February 08, 2025, 02:51:31 PM »

I met Peter Kennedy just once, some years ago whilst on a particularly memorable holiday in Collioure, in France close to the Spanish border. Strolling around the port, I heard Morris tunes being played on a Pokerwork (which of course attracted my attention) - I'm sure it was in D/G. We had a chat, and I borrowed his box to play something or other, which he seemed to like. Clearly, in retrospect I should have asked him about his choice of keys !

Julian
Logged
Old Bones Dance Band

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #7 on: February 08, 2025, 03:42:14 PM »

Good stuff peeps, very interesting.

Castrato - ha! I like that.

I knew someone would pick me up on that - absolutely no disrespect to Mr Kennedy, of course. Shame he picked the wrong key though. This prompts another question - how can it be that the de facto box choice was so heavily influenced by just one individual? That's bizarre to me.

There was obviously a time when the tunes were played in different keys depending on where you were. It's a shame that's mostly been lost (if I'm understanding that correctly). It's also a shame that there is so much inflexibility in the session culture that it's not possible to turn up and play a familiar tune in a different key without people getting the 'ump - which is what I'm lead to believe. Again, correct me if i'm wrong.

To my mind, any half-decent musician should be able to play in any number of keys, within the limitations of the instrument. By which I mean, instruments have a certain number of keys that they are comfortable in - I don't expect a session fiddle/guitar player to be able to immediately play a tune in an obscure (sharp/flat) key, but the home keys, why not?

Obviously, with melodeon this is slightly different, as if one is intending to play with a gaggle of other box players, then everyone must have the ability to play in the required key on their box, or sit out the tune. Which is why I wouldn't say Bb/Eb would be good, but with A/D there is sufficient overlap that you wouldn't be sat out in the cold most of the time (assuming you have only one box, which is anathema to many folk).

This leads me on to another question - beyond the world of Morris dancing and melodeon seminars (or whatever you call them), do people really want to play with great gangs of other box players? I'm not sure I do. I got disillusioned with that type of thing years ago, very early on into my ukulele career. In fact, one of the main drivers for me starting the box was that I wanted an instrument, specifically a melody instrument, that I could play with other (varied) musicians.

Anyway, this wasn't really about what I'm going to do, it was just my thoughts in general. But, on a personal note, I can't wrap my head around the notion of spending many hundreds (thousands?) of pounds on an instrument, the pitch of which i'm not enamored with, just so that I can blend with the homogenous whole. The vast majority of the time playing an instrument, you are your own audience of one, why would you want to listen to something you don't like?
Logged

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #8 on: February 08, 2025, 04:55:51 PM »

Apologies for being a bit late to the party:
There is a thread which you might have caught up with Bill, from 'Inventor' of this parish.
He was a very young chap at the time and bought one of the original first small batch of DG's that Hohner produced. The thread is interesting reading. Peter Kennedy was collecting 'tunes from the north of the country' and as they mostly were in D and G that drove him the contact Hohner. The rest is history.
Recently, Paedar of this parish alludes to the collecting trip of Peter Kennedy, and from memory, hints that at the time the people Kennedy collected from were starting to listen to radio broadcasts from Ireland and it was these tunes they learnt that were mainly D and G.
Who knows exactly... it is all water under the bridge and we are where we are.

As an aside, about a year ago friends were invited to run a 'Welcome to a session' workshop for the Intervarsity Folk Festival run here. I joined in and at one point a friend firmly said 'you only need to work out the keys of D and G because *all English tunes* are in D or G!'

Me being me was uneasy about this statement.
I went home and looked at my tune books.
'John of the Greeny' tunes from the Lancashire area in 1700's.
Only 58% of the tunes are in D or G, the rest in other keys.

'William Winter's Quantock Tune book', a Somerset fiddler who's manuscript is dates 1850.
Here 70% are in D or G, the rest spread across other keys

'Playford', all the tunes from the publications from 1651 - 1758.
Possibly the most interesting of all.
Only 33% in D or G, more tunes are in C or F!

The English music revival really only got going in earnest in the mid 1970's.
We are now mining old manuscripts and bands such as Leveret will play in any key they choose, or any key it's written in.
In my opinion we are drifting away from the DG straitjacket.
One of my sessions is an absolute DG only one, the other session has fiddlers, wind and English concertinas frequently play in Gm, Dm, F, Am and C. With a 12 bass/2.5 row box I try and join in but it is new territory for me and so a very steep learning curve.

Irrespective of my opinions or wishes, D and G is the universal English session keys.
It's written in stone if you wish to join in.

Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #9 on: February 08, 2025, 05:04:47 PM »

I don’t think the D/G key choice was heavily influenced by Peter Kennedy, it was just the obvious solution and he happened to have sufficient influence to implement it. If you looked at English manuscripts from the 19th century say, you’d no doubt draw the same conclusion that it is the correct choice.

English sessions are usually very open and you can start a tune in whichever key you like...

Perhaps the solution you are looking for is an A/D/G melodeon? Great in theory, but in practice difficult to implement with the same push/pull style, so it hasn’t really caught on.

You don’t have to play in a group. The button accordion was designed primarily as a solo instrument. However, the chords of a (A)/D/G box match nicely the open chords available to a guitarist, so that would be a good match.

Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #10 on: February 08, 2025, 05:56:34 PM »

Apologies for being a bit late to the party:
There is a thread which you might have caught up with Bill, from 'Inventor' of this parish...
Recently, Paedar of this parish alludes to the collecting trip of Peter Kennedy...
In my opinion we are drifting away from the DG straitjacket.

Indeed, Thrupenny Bit, that thread (Rise of the DG since 1949) is a mine of information. Good to hear that you think DG bias is waning.

As for playing a musical typewriter (3 row) - no chance, 2 is quite enough. In fact, I'm still convinced that 1 is enough, but accept that 2 offers more/different possibilities. But that's an entirely different, and equally contentious, topic.
Logged

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #11 on: February 08, 2025, 06:04:49 PM »

As for playing a musical typewriter (3 row)

 :||: >:E :|||:

Screenshot-2025-02-08-18-03-36" border="0
Logged

rees

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5055
  • Windjammer
    • Wesson Accordions
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #12 on: February 08, 2025, 06:23:02 PM »

If I'm in a session with one or two melodeon players (I avoid massed melodeon sessions) I take along D/G and G/C melodeons.
At most of the sessions I go to I am the only melodeon player with loads of fiddle players and a few guitars, banjos, etc.
I usually take C/F, Bb/Eb, a one-row in any key and a reluctant D/G. Everyone joins in no matter what key I'm playing in.
Anglo concertina players are a problem, but then again they always have been  >:E
Logged
Rees Wesson (accordion builder and mechanic)
Gungrog, Welshpool, Wales, UK
www.melodeons.com

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #13 on: February 08, 2025, 06:41:48 PM »


   Went to the Chester Sunday session once. 14 guitars!  They played everything in G, so Reese would be OK whichever melodeon he brought along. 

   One guy did tell me that he was "interested in learning melodeon". But that was the fiddler. There were 16 of us in total 😉
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #14 on: February 08, 2025, 06:44:38 PM »

Haha mChavez! That looks like the bastard lovechild of a typewriter and an electric foil razor! An absolute beast. No concerns over which key there.

Sessions I've been to in the past had only one or two box players too. In fact, only one or two of each instrument and this seemed ideal from a musicality point of view.

Chris, if I walk through the door and see 14 guitars, I'm turning round and going straight back out again.

Expanding on the original thought, if the D/G were to be replaced as the default box for English, what should it be replaced by - G/C or A/D? And why?

Not knowing what I'm talking about, I'd thought A/D, because it would allow lots of tunes to instantly be played in the keys that people are familiar with. Also because it may be more straight forward for fiddle, although not being a fiddle player, that was mainly an assumption based on how the fiddle is tuned. As always, happy to be corrected.
Logged

Stotty

  • Stotty
  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 191
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #15 on: February 08, 2025, 06:45:40 PM »

One way to dull the "pain" of DG is to play a three voice LMM.  I personally prefer the richer tone, although I do note that the sound doesn't  seem to carry as well (as 2 voice MM) if you are playing outside for morris/sword dancing.
If I was mainly playing for my own pleasure I would probably opt for CG.
« Last Edit: February 08, 2025, 07:42:47 PM by Stotty »
Logged

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #16 on: February 08, 2025, 06:47:52 PM »

Bill, perhaps not waning exactly, more others are becoming adventurous.
There is a circular argument about DG. As mentioned above, some fiddlers only learn tunes in D and G therefore that's all they play. I did ask a couple of fiddlers in one session about playing in other keys and got a blank look.
I suppose it comes down to your journey. If classically trained or influenced then a fiddler can play in any key.
Also the ethos of the session comes into play. One of mine is very influenced by Cornish and Breton tunes, plus unusual English tunes. Two main fiddlers are classically trained and run a local violin shop and are very competent players in any key.
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #17 on: February 08, 2025, 07:45:21 PM »

Yeah, not waning, incorrect word there, D/G is obviously too entrenched.

Logged

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #18 on: February 08, 2025, 08:43:25 PM »

When you say A/D as an alternative, do you mean playing everything down a fourth, ie G tunes down to D, and G tunes down to D? I think that would all sound a little too low. Also, generally when fiddle players play in A, they are playing tunes that might be played in G a whole tone higher, so that doesn’t really help with the perception of ‘too high’ either…

Although G/C has a lower range, many tunes are played at the higher end of the C row, and when they are transferred to the D/G box, they are played at the lower end of the G row and come out a fourth lower, so it’s not that straightforward!..
 
C/F might be a better alternative, because all those familiar tunes can be played a tone lower, not too low, and suit a wide range of instruments more suited to those keys such as recorders, reeded woodwind and perhaps brass…




Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #19 on: February 08, 2025, 09:19:50 PM »

This was just random thinking on my behalf and a way to prompt an interesting discussion and learn. I guess I'm talking about simply taking a D/G out of people's hands and putting a lower tuned box in, keeping the same fingerings and thereby transposing everything. However, it also struck me that having an A/D would mean that D row tunes could be played in their original key and probably with the original fingering.

I guess this opens up yet another aspect which is, how important is the key that a tune is in?
Logged
Pages: [1] 2 3 4 5 6 7   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal