Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 6 7   Go Down

Author Topic: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...  (Read 11637 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #20 on: February 08, 2025, 09:48:17 PM »

If everything was just moved down like that, then it would put most of the tunes out of the range of many other instruments including flutes and (descant/tenor) recorders, and also A is not a particular friendly key for fiddle players in the lower range… On the other hand, if you were to play D tunes on the D row, then presumably you’d play G tunes on the A row, and then they’d actually come out a whole tone higher (or else almost an octave lower!)…

I don’t think it really matters what key a tune is played in per se, but like the human voice, each instrument has a range and keys to which it is particularly suited, and where it really sings (but this is to some extent subjective)… This is partly why there are transposing instruments…
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #21 on: February 08, 2025, 10:09:57 PM »


Expanding on the original thought, if the D/G were to be replaced as the default box for English, what should it be replaced by - G/C or A/D? And why?


Have you considered getting the best of both worlds? When I got tired to struggle against the limitations of the D/G I switched to a short row 10/9/8 A/D/G melodeon, a reasonably light instruments with three banks of reeds that I can use in any combination. More than thirty years later I haven't found a reason to regret.

I also replaced my G/C with a 2 ½ row instrument that's fully chromatic for two octaves, and on it I can play tunes in a number of different major and both tonal and modal minor scales, although with the exception of tunes based in the F scale – but not in the D minor tonal scale, since both the tonic and the dominant chords are pull only – the fingerings became awkward and the melodeon logic quickly fades, while the harmonic flexibility in the home keys remains limited.

On the A/D/G all the notes of the D scale are available both pushing and pulling the bellows, so I can easily use all the chords available, and while there are a few limitations when playing in G and A, usually a tune that is hard to harmonize in one of this two keys works pretty well in the other. The flexibility of a three row instrument in three keys is terrific, an the extra button available for the chin accidentals is an added bonus.
Logged

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #22 on: February 08, 2025, 10:18:44 PM »

I don't think about keys very often.

Usually I just leave my melodeon case unlocked.
Logged

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #23 on: February 08, 2025, 10:32:11 PM »

 ;D  my cases are in the loft and a gig bag stowed under the stairs.
My boxes live under a fleece and stood on the floor, within easy reach!
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #24 on: February 09, 2025, 08:24:08 AM »

GB, 3 row is not on the radar. I'm a simple man. I like simple things.

Arnold, why don't they just play in A in the higher register then? Not familiar with fiddles, but do they play mostly on the lowest 2 strings?
Logged

CAB

  • Mass Debater
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1147
    • Somerset Russets Village Band
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #25 on: February 09, 2025, 09:21:08 AM »

There is a circular argument about DG. As mentioned above, some fiddlers only learn tunes in D and G therefore that's all they play. I did ask a couple of fiddlers in one session about playing in other keys and got a blank look.
I suppose it comes down to your journey. If classically trained or influenced then a fiddler can play in any key.
Fiddlers' preferences are interesting here, and vital to the way things have developed, I'd say. My understanding is that classically trained violinists prefer the control and vibrato potential of fingered  notes whereas fiddle players, as someone mentioned, enjoy exploiting the ring of open strings on tonics and dominants, hence the preference for G, D and A.   But, as Thrupenny Bit points out, some of the older collections have  lot of tunes in flatter keys. Were they less fiddle-influenced, I wonder?  Of course, Playford wasn't selling music to folk fiddlers and the folk-classical distinction wasn't there in the seventeenth century, when yer average peasant was too busy trying to stay alive to play musical instruments!
On the matter of preferring lower pitches, it's interesting that many Irish musicians like playing a semitone up, so flute players use an Eb flute and fiddle players tune their instruments up a semitone. It just sounds a bit brighter.  Plenty of recordings are at that pitch.
Logged
Pas de lieu Rhone que nous

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #26 on: February 09, 2025, 09:51:01 AM »

Morning CAB. You have a greater understanding of fiddlers players than I do and I'm aware I've probably made gross generalisations with our stringed brethren.
I see some with a lovely relaxed action that somehow transfers into their playing style irrespective of the tune speed. Others have an action like mine when sawing wood.
I'm sure the opposite is true when the fiddle players view melodeon players. Some fluid and smooth, others stuttering along the rows frantically pushing and pulling bellows in an effort to get a tune out, and as ever, everything in between for both instruments.

Yes, Playford was for musicians and the idea of 'folk music' hadn't been defined at that point. I find it interesting that William Winter in the Quantocks was the village shoemaker. In my neck of the woods Fred Pidgeon of Stockland Devon was the village Baker. These are not peasants scraping a living, but musically litterate people and their manuscripts show an ability to go beyond D and G.

It comes around again, the latter 'invention' of the fixed keys of D and G for English melodeons seem to have focused and confined us to these keys and is a recent trend set in the 1950's.
« Last Edit: February 09, 2025, 09:53:01 AM by Thrupenny Bit »
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #27 on: February 09, 2025, 10:49:28 AM »

It's a trend that needs to change, man.

I'm most familiar with the ukulele world and it's almost exactly the same as everyone tuning their (different sized) ukes to the same tuning (gCEA - C6). Then they play the same chords in the same position on the neck. What results ain't music, as far as I'm concerned. It's monotony.

Historically, ukes were all tuned different, much the same as the violin family. Recently, the uke has had a huge resurgence, analogous to the English trad folk revival, and to make it easier for more people to get involved, the tuning was "standardised". The overwhelming percentage of ukulele players are incapable of playing a different tuning. Some may argue that there's nothing wrong with that, and there's probably not, but my take is that it's doing the instrument a disservice and contributing to the negative associations that it has.

Anyway, I digress...
Logged

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #28 on: February 09, 2025, 11:00:31 AM »


GB, 3 row is not on the radar. I'm a simple man. I like simple things.


The choice is up to you.

But please remember that simple is the opposite of complex, not of large. A larger instrument isn't necessarily complex, or more difficult to play, than a small one. Actually a D/G based three row instrument is complex, and if you play it outside the home keys it can be fairly difficult to master. A three row instrument in three keys remains a simple instrument, and unless you are playing the two row boxes mainly press and draw on one row, it's definitely easier to play in the three home keys than a two row instrument is in the two home keys.

To switch from a D/G to an A/D/G instrument is a straightforward process, since the the keyboard layout of the A/D/G is built around the keyboard layout of the D/G. You don't have to re-learn the tunes you already play on the D/G, and you can take your time to explore the different possibilities offered by the additional chords and the A row to find easier and more satisfactory ways to play them.

The reason the G/C/F isn't popular on the continent is that the keyboard layout is built around the C/F keyboard layout, not around the G/C keyboard layout. The G/C player would have to re-learn most of the tunes they have learned in C using the F chord, the unisonoric chord, mainly on the pull, because the F chord on the G/C/F is available just on the push. Where the C/F was the standard two row instrument in the past, like among the Norteno players or the Colombian vallenato players, it has been replaced today by the G/C/F.

Logged

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #29 on: February 09, 2025, 11:15:37 AM »

I don't see the advantage because it doesn't do away with the high pitched G row. I guess I could just play G tunes across the row with few notes on the G row itself, but couldn't that be done satisfactorily on an A/D?
Logged

Geoff P.

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 27
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #30 on: February 09, 2025, 11:41:17 AM »

Get an LMM box. My Castagnari Fazzy DG sounds lovely on any part of either row with the L reeds in.
Logged

CAB

  • Mass Debater
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1147
    • Somerset Russets Village Band
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #31 on: February 09, 2025, 11:41:52 AM »

I find it interesting that William Winter in the Quantocks was the village shoemaker. In my neck of the woods Fred Pidgeon of Stockland Devon was the village Baker. These are not peasants scraping a living, but musically litterate people and their manuscripts show an ability to go beyond D and G.

It's strange how many of these old musicians were shoe and boot makers - Winter in the Quantocks, Jas. Higgins in Shepton Mallet, Michael Turner in Sussex.  (No cobblers jokes please!)  Just to develop your point before getting back to the topic, Rollo Woods, writing about village bands, notes that:

"the members were independent skilled artisans.  Similarly, Thomas Hardy’s family were masons, and the Winterbourne Abbas band included a thatcher and a shepherd.  Other musicians are known to have been shoemakers, weavers, farmers, tailors, shipwrights etc.  Such people had serious advantages: work, which provided a steady income through the year, mostly in cash; enough education to be able to read, write and calculate; their own private work-place.  Thus they could afford to buy an instrument and instruction book, or pay for a few lessons; read and understand a printed tutor, and find somewhere to practise without disturbing the family and neighbours. "
Logged
Pas de lieu Rhone que nous

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #32 on: February 09, 2025, 11:44:49 AM »

Get an LMM box. My Castagnari Fazzy DG sounds lovely on any part of either row with the L reeds in.

Yes, that would appear to be the only solution if sticking with D/G. I acknowledged that in my initial post.
« Last Edit: February 09, 2025, 11:48:41 AM by Bill_S »
Logged

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #33 on: February 09, 2025, 11:49:58 AM »

Thanks CAB for expanding my point.
The artisan community had more time and money to spare, and were not living hand to mouth, exactly as Rollo Woods says.

Bill - an interesting parallel between the two communities of ukelele and melodeon.

... and regarding a 3 row melodeon, I listen to GBBox and other players as I have no experience of them so cannot meaningfully comment on them.
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #34 on: February 09, 2025, 11:55:49 AM »

I dig it man, I wasn't being dismissive of GB's suggestion, hope it didn't come across that way.

Like I said before though, this isn't a thread about which box I should buy. But on that, I'm pretty sure it won't be a D/G.
Logged

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #35 on: February 09, 2025, 12:08:12 PM »

No I didn't take it that way... the intricacies of a 3 row are beyond my experience that's all.

A while ago BbEb boxes became a trend, and several members here like to play them at home, and even 'flat sessions' occur sometimes at festivals.
We can all play whatever we want in the privacy of our own homes, that changes if we wish to play tunes with others.

... and in a 'feeling the muse' moments last weekend I played my own BbEb box, something just haven't done for ages.
It was just a lovely, rich sound, so much so I missed the rugby starting!
« Last Edit: February 09, 2025, 12:28:08 PM by Thrupenny Bit »
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #36 on: February 09, 2025, 12:45:21 PM »

I don't see the advantage because it doesn't do away with the high pitched G row. I guess I could just play G tunes across the row with few notes on the G row itself, but couldn't that be done satisfactorily on an A/D?

The problem of the high pitched G row on a D/G can easily be solved, like Geoff suggests, choosing an instrument with three banks of reeds. But I wonder if the problem is real...

I mean, my A/D/G has a short keyboard with a G row of just eight buttons, and playing tunes in G I rarely need to play in LMM or LM configuration. And when I do is usually not because the G tunes, as far as they are played like on a standard two row D/G, insist on the higher pitch range, but rather because I play them along tunes in D and A that insist on an even higher pitch range. And for the record I've never found a reason to regret the two missing button at the bottom of the G row. I've satisfactorily done without them for more thatn thirthy years.

And no, considering the missing C major chord, and the availability of the C natural note in just one octave among the chin accidentals, to play satisfactorily in G on a A/D instrument is out of question.   

Logged

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #37 on: February 09, 2025, 12:48:38 PM »

GB, 3 row is not on the radar. I'm a simple man. I like simple things.

Arnold, why don't they just play in A in the higher register then? Not familiar with fiddles, but do they play mostly on the lowest 2 strings?

I was replying in the context of moving D tunes down to A, where fiddles would then need to play more on the lower 2 strings. They prefer the higher strings for A because of the slightly more awkward position of the G# and C# notes on the lower 2 strings. Fiddle traditions where A is common tend to often omit the G# (eg Scotland) or tune the strings differently eg AEAE (USA)
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #38 on: February 09, 2025, 01:01:25 PM »

GB box is spot on. Why dwell on the notes that are too high? Just don’t use them, and if you need lower notes go for 4th button start. Anahata’s Dino Baffetti has fourth button start and with one less button on each row, effectively the offending highest 4 buttons are chopped off!

Another thing not mentioned is minor keys. On a standard melodeon you only get one. English tunes tend to use the Dorian mode, with the subtonic as the low note (eg E minor, low note D), so E minor gives a nice range for this mode - D4 and up. On a G/C box this will come out in A Dorian, where it will likely sound either too high or too low. On the other hand harmonic minor type tunes more common in French trad usually have the low not as the 5th of the scale (eg A minor, low note E) and so A minor gives a nice range for this tonality - E4 and up (and another example of the G/C being played in a higher range than the D/G)
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #39 on: February 09, 2025, 02:33:34 PM »

ff!

.. English tunes tend to use the Dorian mode...


Actually, they tend to use either the D or the A modes, or if you like to use the funny Greek names the Dorian and Aeolian modes.

Archetypal examples, both played on the melodeon using the G scale: The sportsman's Hornpipe and Jacky Tar. The former is in the D mode in G, or A Dorian, while the second is in the A mode in G, or E Aeolian. A nice pair to make a set!

The chord progression for both is mainly bases on the alternation between the minor tonic chords and the major chords down a grade in the scale: Am and G for the former (too bad it's often used an Am7!), Em and D for the  latter. A a fairly common pattern for the modal minor tunes in Scottish and irish traditional music too.

Just for the record... ;)

Updated to correct what was formerly E Dorian in E Aeolian

« Last Edit: February 09, 2025, 03:25:24 PM by GBbox »
Logged
Pages: 1 [2] 3 4 5 6 7   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal