Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 3 4 [5] 6 7   Go Down

Author Topic: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...  (Read 11679 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #80 on: February 10, 2025, 05:29:38 PM »

It also depends on the players in a session though Hugh.
As I've said before, in one session I go to it is all D and G and very confused looks if anyone plays anything different. As they are long standing friends I'm quite happy with that arrangement and we belt out standard stuff ( and odd ones too ) with gusto.
The other session I go to the Presbyterian HP regularly comes out and in Gm... and I'm almost there playing along so long as I have a following wind!
The excellent fiddlers will play in whatever key they've seen the tune in so it can be ' seat of the pants interesting' but always very enjoyable.

I have a Dony and using Paul Young's layout which is biased towards such flat keys which means only one box to carry around.
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #81 on: February 10, 2025, 05:40:13 PM »

Apologies if someone has already suggested this (I haven't read every response), but Bill, would a D/G pitched an octave lower than standard, i.e. with two (or three) L voices, solve your problem?

Maybe that would press your buttons. You must be having fun pressing everybody else's in this thread.  8) 
« Last Edit: February 10, 2025, 07:10:45 PM by Stiamh »
Logged

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #82 on: February 10, 2025, 05:48:43 PM »

Quote from: Thrupenny Bit
The lowest note on a 3rd button start is A on the D row, the Low G scale goes to the G below it.

Thank you for actually explaining that instead of being snarky.

Anahata - as per the title, these are just my musings. This whole thread came out of me realising that I'm not a big fan of the G row and wondering out loud why it has to be that way and if there was another way.

I don't know what the answer is, I'm in it for the discussion and the opportunity to learn. This thread, like others, has lots of great info which helps me in my journey to understanding. And to those who have added their knowledge and helpful comments, I'm very grateful.

Yes, I think a different tuning is needed, based purely on the fact that D/G is not the best sounding box, in my opinion and others. However, as has been adequately demonstrated, it's not that simple, especially when you want to (easily and seamlessly) play with others. As you rightly point out, the actual solution is the one that exists already - just play a D/G! Or, move to East Anglia and play a one row in C.

Quote from: Anahata
...even if you don't like those notes because you think that they don't sound nice!

It's this bit that I can't get my head round. Playing an instrument one isn't keen on the sound of just to fit in with others. Especially if there is another option - which was the original thought I was exploring.

Hugh - I guess there are all sorts of sessions, some very staid and others more flexible. I think sessions are one aspect, but the other is the notion that anyone starting to learn box for English must have a D/G. It's tantamount to saying that all the tunes can only be played on that box, which is patently nonsense. However, it does make sense when you consider it provides the easiest route to progressing, given that everyone plays one and the overwhelming amount of learning material is in D/G.

Stiamh - Hahaha! Yeah, I'm enjoying the joust, but honestly, I think it's a useful discussion with lots of good thoughts. And yeah, either that or a 3 voice would work.
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #83 on: February 10, 2025, 06:16:17 PM »


   The 2-row melodeon is a "restricted" instrument, Bill. Designed to play in its main row keys, and a few of their modes. It's set up to suit "Western" music and works with folk music too, provided you are playing solo, or that your chosen kit offers the scales actually used in your local session.

   The 8-button left end is a thing of genius, but is very much matched to main rows, and of limited utility in some of their modal scales.

   Mainly due to reed technology, this works best in a tonality somewhere close to G/C. It is most disadvantaged ± 6 semitones away from there C#/F#. Your problematic G-row is very close to that, but there is no getting away from how melodeon's work. 

    We've explained the 4th-start fix (which was very much popularised by a consensus view within this group about 15 years ago).

  That is how it is I'm afraid, like it or not. And if you don't like, it you would be advised to take up a different instrument? The 3,4 or 5 row CBA … can handle anything; but it's rather heavy.  A ½-tone system (e.g B/C) to play in any key with practice, but the left end won't be cooperative; a lot of its aficionado's don't use it at all. Perhaps you might consider buying a guitar? Or a portable piano? Or 12 mouth organs?   

  I'm afraid that it won't help to continually ask for solutions that … just aren't there.  :(
« Last Edit: February 10, 2025, 06:18:51 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Howard Jones

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1203
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #84 on: February 10, 2025, 06:28:12 PM »

I think sessions are one aspect, but the other is the notion that anyone starting to learn box for English must have a D/G. It's tantamount to saying that all the tunes can only be played on that box, which is patently nonsense.

With respect, I think that is a misinterpretation of the usual advice, which assumes that sooner or later most people who wish to play English tunes will want to join in sessions with others. As you've recognised, you're then in the situation that everyone else plays D/G and the overwhelming amount of learning material is in D/G. It certainly won't let you play all the tunes (no diatonic will) but for a beginner wondering what to buy and who doesn't yet know where it will take them it's the best option.

The problem does have a simple answer: buy lots of melodeons  >:E

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #85 on: February 10, 2025, 06:51:16 PM »

It's this bit that I can't get my head round. Playing an instrument one isn't keen on the sound of just to fit in with others. Especially if there is another option - which was the original thought I was exploring.

A G played on a D/G melodeon will sound essentially the same as the same G played on a C/G or A/D melodeon (as long as you don't jump down an octave)
So I still don't understand how you think that a lower pitched instrument played higher up the keyboard to get the same notes will sound any better than a D/G.
Of course, it might be a box of different make that sounds better anyway, in which case you might find the same maker does a D/G box that's better sounding to your ears.

Stiamh suggests an instrument that plays an octave lower - that might work for you if you can find one, or one with LM tuning which is overall more mellow sounding, and easier to find. I personally know two good players who have Bernard Loffet boxes voiced LM.

Other that that - what was the "other option" that you were exploring?
« Last Edit: February 10, 2025, 06:59:16 PM by Anahata »
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #86 on: February 10, 2025, 07:01:59 PM »

Chris - the melodeon is for me, I'm loving it. And the limitations make it all the more compelling. Guitar?! Perish the thought!

Interesting what you say about ~G/C being the optimum considering reed technology. Are we talking specifically about the materials the reeds are made from or the manufacturing/tuning processes involved?

As for looking for answers that don't exist - story of my life, man...

Howard - No need for respect, if i'm talking crap just come right out and tell me. You won't offend, I can assure you. If I have unwittingly misrepresented you, or anybody else, in this thread or elsewhere, my apologies. And yes, box acquisition syndrome (or what you lot call MAD) appears to be both an illness and a panacea!

Anahata - I'm only partially talking about playing the tunes in the exact same register. Obviously, that would be handy, especially if one wanted to play a lower box but have less hassle playing the usual stuff, in the usual keys, with the usual suspects. Mainly I'm talking about just transposing them down and playing in lower keys.

There was no other option - playing a lower tuned box was the only option I was thinking about. However, Stiamh, and another guy who originally mentioned it (sorry, I forgot who it was), have suggested lower reed combos which is definitely worth thinking about - for me and anyone else who dislikes the G row.

However, to say again, this wasn't really about what I might buy, this was more a general thought on the D/G box, English music, and the whys and wherefores.
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #87 on: February 10, 2025, 07:25:07 PM »

Sessions are sessions, of course, and fitting in with others is the name of the game. But there is something very attractive about playing in lower pitches. Back in the 19th century, in Irish music, the Irish pipes were not pitched in D as they mostly are today, but in anything from Bb to C#. Many years ago I spent a lot of time playing with the owner of a superb set from around 1840, pitched in C. Playing a fiddle tuned down a tone was really very pleasant, almost addictive.

In the world of boxes, I had a B/C for a while and enjoyed playing it as if it were a C#/D. It procured the same pleasure as can be had from tuning the fiddle down a tone, or listening to a set of C pipes. Playing tunes D/G style on a C/F would have exactly this effect.

Recently I bought a CD by the Irish fiddler Séamus McGuire on which he plays traditional tunes on a viola, with everything pitched down a fifth. It's just gorgeous. Jackie Daly had an accordion built in F#/G for the same purpose. I suppose the same effect could be had by playing tunes D/G style on a G/C. You wouldn't make many converts, but you could just enjoy yourself at home...

 

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #88 on: February 10, 2025, 07:42:11 PM »

Now you're talking my language, man.

I dabbled with mandolin for a while. I found that I liked it much better tuned open and down to GDgd. Loads of possibility for drones and sympathetic vibration. It took the edge off, mellowed it out and gave it a nicer texture. It was nicer still tuned to F.
Logged

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #89 on: February 10, 2025, 09:46:07 PM »

A 4th button start D/G box gives you the keys you need the most, and the range you need (unless you want to go lower than G3?..). I’m not really sure if there’s much else to add… A standard 3rd button start A/D might give a better range but it doesn’t give you the key of G which is the key for about 70% of English session tunes…

If you want freedom to move between multiple keys, which is fair enough, then this is simply the wrong instrument. A better choice might be a b/c with Stradella bass (unfortunately rare) or a chromatic accordion…
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #90 on: February 11, 2025, 08:17:35 AM »

Quote from: Arnold
A standard 3rd button start A/D might give a better range but it doesn’t give you the key of G which is the key for about 70% of English session tunes…

What about G/C?

Either way, it's easy to solve - one (not necessarily me) simply plays the tunes in whatever key one likes and anyone who wants to/is capable can join in. Anyone else can sit it out, just the same as a box player without the right key would sit out tunes they can't play.

This ain't bluegrass; the G tune monopoly must end!
Logged

CAB

  • Mass Debater
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1147
    • Somerset Russets Village Band
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #91 on: February 11, 2025, 08:27:45 AM »

A 4th button start D/G box gives you the keys you need the most, and the range you need (unless you want to go lower than G3?..).

One of the things I love about the Ellis Benny is that it goes a 4th below that - down to the D below middle C.  So you can play most G tunes an octave down if you choose to.
Logged
Pas de lieu Rhone que nous

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #92 on: February 11, 2025, 11:57:33 AM »


   Don't forget that you can extend the range of your right end downwards by dabbing in a bass on the left. I first started doing that for mazurka régale in Em, with a low B.   I then extended that trick to other tunes, but don't use it much now that I have moved to 4th start.

   In G scale a low C, B, and A are available. Play your instrument "as a whole" !
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Howard Jones

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1203
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #93 on: February 11, 2025, 12:00:59 PM »

What about G/C?

Either way, it's easy to solve - one (not necessarily me) simply plays the tunes in whatever key one likes and anyone who wants to/is capable can join in. Anyone else can sit it out, just the same as a box player without the right key would sit out tunes they can't play.

That's not really how sessions work. They are communal affairs, not opportunities for solos. What you suggest may be just about acceptable for the occasional tune, but session ettiquette (usually unwritten and even unspoken) usually expects that as many people as possible can join in.

With a G/C you would of course be able to join in with tunes in G. Depending on the session, you might find others with C melodeons or C/G anglos who would be happy to join in tunes in C or A min. More often they will be mainly D/G players, and you will find yourself playing solos in C and having to sit out tunes in D, A and B min. That's not very satisfactory for anyone. Sessions by their nature should be as inclusive as possible and should aim to play mostly in keys which suit the majority. Even players of chromatic instruments such as fiddles are not always happy to play in less usual keys.

Of course sessions vary considerably, and depending on the range of instruments and ability of the players some sessions may play in a wider range of keys than others.  You may get away with G/C if you're willing to sit out quite a lot, but in most sessions if you were to try to impose C/F or Bb/Eb you would soon find yourself unpopular.

The answer for most players is to take several instruments to cover the keys they will find most useful. The original motivation for the Streb MIDI melodeon was to act as a "melodeon capo" to play in any key. Another approach is to get an instrument with a helper row which will allow it to play in a wider range of keys, although you may still be limited by the available chords.

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #94 on: February 11, 2025, 12:10:43 PM »

Thanks Howard, many good points made there, and reflect my experiences here.
The odd solo, often a new-to-the-session tune, is welcome and can act as a welcome rest if the session is frantic, but if tunes become flights of fancy for one or two players the session breaks down into chatter. The point made by a fiddler friend recently, who then got us back onto communal tunes.
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #95 on: February 11, 2025, 12:30:20 PM »

Sorry Howard, to clarify, I didn't mean that they should become solo affairs and fully intended/expected that as many people as possible would join in.

The few sessions I went to years ago had enough people that the odd few sitting out didn't make much difference. Although they were pretty casual with only a couple of box players, one or two fiddles etc. And how many people wouldn't be able to play in the "usual" keys anyway, which I would tentatively suggest were C, G, D and A.

But I certainly take your point about being as accommodating as possible and despite my truculence in this thread, it wouldn't be my intention to go in and derail a session by insisting on playing keys that nobody wants to/can. Especially as a new inductee. That just ain't polite.
Logged

Helena Handcart

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2452
  • Saltarelle Nell
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #96 on: February 11, 2025, 12:59:09 PM »


Either way, it's easy to solve - one (not necessarily me) simply plays the tunes in whatever key one likes and anyone who wants to/is capable can join in. Anyone else can sit it out, just the same as a box player without the right key would sit out tunes they can't play.


Looks like you already have your answer, and I think that since this is your innovation you absolutely should be the one to make it a reality.
Logged
Saltarelle Le Romané  | Saltarelle Nuage | Oakwood | various elderly Hohners

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #97 on: February 11, 2025, 01:16:04 PM »

As a non-English player it was good fun reading the comments on this thread. I wonder if there's not some sort of habits bias in various comments: as a French player, I've always played the G/C, which I don't particularly like (except in the lower section of the keyboard with the L reeds) because I find it sort of muddy, sluggish, compared to even 1 tone higher (A/D). And several English players stated that they didn't really like D/G. Would the grass always be greener on the other side of the fence  ;D ?
When thinking of keys, my ideal tuning for the music I play nowadays would perhaps be... a D/G, with the Anahata setting (wich covers roughly the same ambitus than the typical G/C). I find that accordions reeds have a better response the higher you go in pitch. I quite like A/D but as I'm playing with a lot of fiddlers, for the traditional music that I play they always pull a sort of funny face when asked to play in A (and always seem more at ease in D or, better, G).

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #98 on: February 11, 2025, 01:44:57 PM »

Quote from: Helena Handcart
Looks like you already have your answer, and I think that since this is your innovation you absolutely should be the one to make it a reality.

It's hardly my innovation is it. That would mean I'm the first person to want to get away from D/G, potentially play a different key box at a session and wonder as to the feasibility of this. Even in my limited experience of melodeons, I know that to be false. But thanks for the suggestion, your third useful contribution to this thread.

Quote from: -Y-
As a non-English player it was good fun reading the comments on this thread. I wonder if there's not some sort of habits bias in various comments: as a French player, I've always played the G/C, which I don't particularly like (except in the lower section of the keyboard with the L reeds) because I find it sort of muddy, sluggish, compared to even 1 tone higher (A/D). And several English players stated that they didn't really like D/G. Would the grass always be greener on the other side of the fence  ;D ?

I'm glad someone's enjoying it. I'm absolutely sure there is a habits bias and, I guess, that's only natural. And you touch upon yet another consideration -  reed response. The consequences of which I'm not really familiar with, other than low reeds are slower to speak, meaning certain passages may be less crisp and clear.

Coughlin's Law - "Anything else is always something better."
Logged

Howard Jones

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1203
Re: Further musings of a recalcitrant neophyte...
« Reply #99 on: February 11, 2025, 02:36:01 PM »

Sorry Howard, to clarify, I didn't mean that they should become solo affairs and fully intended/expected that as many people as possible would join in.

Yes, I understand that is not your intention, but it's likely to be the outcome if you play in keys which the others can't play. 

Quote
how many people wouldn't be able to play in the "usual" keys anyway, which I would tentatively suggest were C, G, D and A.

That will of course depend on the session. I agree that those (and their associated minors) are probably the "usual" keys, but with a strong emphasis on the last three. As I'm sure you now understand, D/G has become the standard box not because it sounds best but because it is the best fit for most people most of the time.  You could get by with a G/C, but a lot of the time you wouldn't be able to join in.

D and A are theoretically possible on a G/C with accidentals, but you have those only at one pitch, and in practice they are quite challenging. Similarly C can be fudged on a D/G if you can avoid the F natural and F chord, but it's not ideal and will challenge a lot of players.  You'd be surprised how many fiddlers object to playing in C.

Pages: 1 2 3 4 [5] 6 7   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal