Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: do melodeons have "projection"?  (Read 1280 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Al Cramer

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 98
do melodeons have "projection"?
« on: March 05, 2025, 02:27:50 AM »

Have been working several weeks with a vintage Hohner club, converted to d/g by Mike Rothambotten & fettled by Theo (who shipped it to me here in New England). It's an amazing instrument. It definitely wants a different touch than is required by my other 2 boxes (Salterelle Boube d/g and Loffet g/c). At first I thought its voice was smaller, then I realized  I just wasn't starting my pushes & pulls with the right force (the Hohner wants a smarter attack).

Something else I realized is that if I tilted the Hohner a bit to the left, and my head a little to the right, I heard this amazing rich sound. Which gets into the question of how an instrument sounds to you (as the player) compared to how it sounds to someone sitting 12 feet away. Back when I was fixing up old violins, I used to hang out on Maestronet, on the forum concerned with violin setup & repair. All the people there believed that violins had something called "projection", which means how it sounds to listeners rather than the player.  It always seemed a bit occult to me -- never understood the acoustic science that would account for it -- but I've no reason to think it's not a real thing.

So am wondering: is this something that is true of melodeons as well?
Logged

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: do melodeons have "projection"?
« Reply #1 on: March 05, 2025, 07:26:30 AM »

It's true of all acoustic instruments, is it not? How much of it is down to the specific instrument or the player, I don't know. I reckon it's a combination of the two.

I notice a difference in how the sound comes out dependent on how i'm holding the box. If sat legs crossed with it braced up against my leg, it's quieter and more muted. Legs not crossed, more sound. This makes sense since the leg will absorb some vibration. Very similar to
open back vs resonator banjos.

Regarding the Hohner vs others, maybe it's just a little harder to play and get the sound out of. (Not harder, but you know what I mean). Possibly due to a number of factors; differences in reeds, differences in construction, age etc. I don't know. I'm sure an experienced practitioner will be along soon to lift the fog.

One thing is certain, in my experience, each individual instruments require a different approach. Which is why I've always been a fan of just sticking to one instrument (heresy, I know). You get to know it intimately and develop a relationship with it whereby you can get the very best out of it. Having multiple instruments, or constantly changing, runs counter to this. Just a theory anyway.
Logged

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: do melodeons have "projection"?
« Reply #2 on: March 05, 2025, 08:28:40 AM »

something called "projection", which means how it sounds to listeners rather than the player.  It always seemed a bit occult to me -- never understood the acoustic science that would account for it -- but I've no reason to think it's not a real thing.

So am wondering: is this something that is true of melodeons as well?

As a classical guitar maker, I know a thing or two about projection. It's a sound quality, nothing to do with instrument types. It's how well it "cuts" through the mix and through the air.
When you're listening to an instrument 10m away, you only hear a fraction of the harmonic content that the player can hear.

In essence, our human ears hear certain frequencies more than others, and our brain masks some frequencies against a background of other frequencies. When you are building a strung instrument, where the strings drive the wooden soundboard, you can modify the soundboard & bracing design to favour some frequencies over others.
As a rule of thumb,  sounds with rich harmonic content, especially lower frequencies that are considered "warm", don't project at all - to the point that you can lose 70% of overtones if you're listening from 3 meters away. Sharper sounds with higher-frequency harmonic content project better (can be heard better against background music/noise/over longer distances). However, such sounds are also perceived by most people as unpleasant. I'm yet to meet a man who'd like to listen to a concerto played by a circular saw orchestra. But you can hear the damn things half a mile away when your neighbour is cutting wood in his garden.
The trick is to produce an instrument that projects well, yet does not sound unpleasantly sharp.

As squeezeboxes are loud af and full of higher harmonics, projection is not a primary concern (it is with a nylon-strung classical guitar though!).
But, say, prewar hohners (very rich harmonic content) don't project nearly as well as a high end soviet bayan (very biased towards the fundamental). Yet, the soviet bayan sound is smooth as a baby's bum, so they definitely did something right in their reeds design.
« Last Edit: March 05, 2025, 08:33:51 AM by mChavez »
Logged

Bill_S

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 267
Re: do melodeons have "projection"?
« Reply #3 on: March 05, 2025, 09:01:05 AM »

How does tremolo affect projection? I've read a few historic threads that suggest that it helps the sound carry more. Yet, there are other threads saying that a Lilly, with it's concertina-esque sound, can be heard beyond the range of other boxes (in an outdoors/band situation).
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: do melodeons have "projection"?
« Reply #4 on: March 05, 2025, 09:25:18 AM »



  I learned this rather abruptly when a Morris man commented how nice my Lilly sounded and asked if he might play it.

  He launched into the tune that we had just done, and it sounded completely different, facing it rather than behind. Different "tone"

  I understand that the sound emitted is also very directional and mainly to the left and the right, but others can advise on that
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Al Cramer

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 98
Re: do melodeons have "projection"?
« Reply #5 on: March 06, 2025, 01:15:31 AM »

Thanks mchavez! That was a great explanation of the science.

Something else I've been wondering about concerns the impact of the grill on the sound. A lot of the Cajun guys play 4-stop 1-rows that don't have a grill (or if it's a Hohner they take it off).  But I've seen a few youtube videos where someone is playing a 2-row MM box and has also removed the grill.  Would like to know more about how grills affect sound&projection.


Logged

mselic

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1683
Re: do melodeons have "projection"?
« Reply #6 on: March 06, 2025, 03:54:58 AM »

I remove the grill on all my boxes. My experience has been that the grill just muffles the sound/volume to some extent (this is more prominent on some boxes than others). With the grill off the sound is clearer, at least to my ear. I know that some people claim that the grill itself (and the material of the grill) affects tone, but I’ve never found that to be the case, and I’ve done all kinds of blind tests to see! YMMV, etc.
Logged
C#/D player

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: do melodeons have "projection"?
« Reply #7 on: March 06, 2025, 07:47:04 AM »

The timbre production on any musical instrument is an extremely complex topic. With string instruments there's been an incredible amount of research documented over the years, with Trevor Gore's work being of particular significance, and it's still very hard to reliably apply most of it to practice.

With squeezeboxes there's none. In fact, I'm yet to meet a person who can explain how the overtone content is produced by the reed. There's various guesses, and a lot of them contradict each other and can often be proved wrong empirically. So when it comes to effects of a particular feature of box design, imho, we're in complete darkness. Too many factors and too little knowledge.

In general terms:
The sound waves travel through the reed chamber & soundhole to come out of the fondo. The grille acts as an acoustic filter: waves bounce off it and some frequencies get attenuated.
If it's an "open" grille design that mainly consists of holes, there will be close to zero effect on sound compared to no grille at all.
If it's an almost solid grille, there will be a lot of filtering.
A "cheesegrater" design (where there is no direct path for the sound to go through the grille) will filter the frequencies in a different way to an open grille or a solid grille.

Where we fail, is trying to predict how given changes in grille design are going to affect a given box with given reeds. I don't believe anyone can model that, so we're limited to a general idea that "open grille sounds brighter", and it does.

The grille design definitely affects the sound: if you close a sordina or a jalousie on an accordion (turning a semi-open grille into a closed one) the effect is very audible and will easily pass a blind test.
Similarly, the "boxed" bass side of a bandoneon sounds noticeably different from the open treble grille.

I think hole area vs solid area, straight vs kinked sound path, hole placement and shape all matter, but I've got close to zero thought on how exactly (and to what extent) they impact the sound. So my thinking is purely to split them in 4 groups: solid, cheesegrater, semi-solid and open designs. Even then, I think cheesegrater & semi-solid might not be distinguishable in a blind test.
Logged

Steve C.

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2075
  • Erica, Morse Anglo
Re: do melodeons have "projection"?
« Reply #8 on: March 06, 2025, 10:30:56 AM »

On my microbot bandoneon DG Erica the Red (sweet XMAS special thanks MIKE) he especially installed some layers of fine linen inside the treble and bass grills that have (in my opinion) cut out some of the more irritating overtones but left the sweet ones.

This obviously is not possible but I am telling you and people who have played it say "where did you get this thing"?

Partly it's the bandoneon tune + the low G scale (Anahata-style) that makes for the sweet top end and growly low end but to speak to the OP it does have an unusual projection especially in the treble.  Sings.

I will try and post a humble sample and see if it can reproduce.

-- S
Logged
Located in Central North Carolina, USA; credit for picture: livingplanet.ca

mselic

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1683
Re: do melodeons have "projection"?
« Reply #9 on: March 06, 2025, 12:55:36 PM »

Steve, I tried something similar with a Paolo that I had in an effort to ‘temper’ some of the harshness of the tone, and cut down on volume. I ended up putting several layers of thick felt across the underside of the grill - completely covering it - and I found it barely made a difference! It was a very loud box, and the layers of felt only marginally helped reduce volume, but the overall tone or ‘timbre’ remained the same.

I think sometimes the terms we use regarding the ‘sound’ may also mean different things to different people. When I suggested that I’ve not found the grill to make a difference on tone I’m generally referring to the overall quality/colour/timbre of an accordion that’s coming out of the box, regardless of the pallet lift, grill, etc. There’s a certain tone unique to that accordion that, as MChavez has pointed out, people have not been able to explain. It’s this tone/timbre that I’m suggesting - to my ear - that isn’t really impacted by grill, but rather it’s the ‘clarity’ of that sound that is affected. It’s like the sound of someone’s voice standing next to you or speaking to you through a door. The quality/character of their voice is the same (you will recognize the person’s voice) but how clearly you hear it depends on the medium in the way (the door).  I find it to be the same with accordions and grills.
Logged
C#/D player

Open_G

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 55
  • Hohner Erica, Hohner 1 row, Tommy, Mignon
Re: do melodeons have "projection"?
« Reply #10 on: March 06, 2025, 05:32:50 PM »

There’s a guitar maker that create a sound hole in the side of the guitar facing the player’s chin for exactly the reason of trying to show the player what the listener hears. I’ve not owned one but have played a few and it’s definitely an interesting idea.
Logged
Squeezing with varying degress of success since 1995. -Clive

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: do melodeons have "projection"?
« Reply #11 on: March 06, 2025, 06:04:42 PM »

There’s a guitar maker that create a sound hole in the side of the guitar facing the player’s chin for exactly the reason of trying to show the player what the listener hears. I’ve not owned one but have played a few and it’s definitely an interesting idea.

It's called a "soundport".

A guitar's sound radiates from the vibrating soundboard & not from the soundhole though  ;D
So you can drill as many holes in the sides as you like, but it does not get you any closer to hearing what the audience hears.
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal