Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Club III M - Help me diagnose weak treble sound when certain bass notes played  (Read 3514 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Kath Harper

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 67
    • Noise From the Blanket Fort

Posted a few days back and removed, think I should have a) posted as its own topic and b) introduced self first!

Am owner of a few accordions one of which is the Hohner Club III M, all acquired since 2020.

I am learning to play the Club III M with some help from Mel Biggs' patreon resources and tutorials (and likely will book her if possible for live lessons/diagnoses of my technique).
The modality for training is much more methodical for the Club as I have no prior experience on a button box and went down the self-taught mostly noodling road for the keyboard accordions (which ended in frustration as a few too many bad habits got "baked in" before I found a live (Zoom not in person) instructor. Gave up in frustration (to be revisited at some point) with apologies to the instructor and dropped accordion for a few months to reset.

I am learning repair and maintenance on my own (with help from YouTube videos by Lester Bailey and similar) so that I can make minor repairs/tweaks on my instruments, all of which were acquired at fair price as all are used instruments in varying states of playability.
Currently the only box I've tinkered with is an old Hohner keyboard accordion parts-only box that I'm very slowly reworking with new valves - so it's unlikely if a critical repair is needed I'll try it myself. Just not yet at the point I want to accidentally butcher a playable instrument!

I also don't yet know what I don't know about playing, particularly with the Club box... so a lot of what is below may be down to my lack of proper/effective technique.
All that said, I have a few questions:

1.) What do I need to look at to figure out why on the Hohner Club III M - which has what seems a good bellows without leaks - gets the "wheezies" when trying to play the bass and treble together?
I suspect a few things but have so little maintenance experience that my theories thus far about what may be going on with is just a wild guess.

2.) I'm trying to figure out what's causing the issue with air. Of course it could always just be me, it's very early days and getting the diatonic bellows movement right is fairly different from that of my keyboard accordions. The bellows seems good and doesn't easily open when lifting the treble side with the accordion sat on its feet and the bellows and taping looks sound. There is a super-thin bellows gasket but it isn't worn and again, it seems pretty tight. It's just when I am playing both bass and treble that the wheeziness happens.

I also had a look inside at the bass reeds which seem fine except for one or two low reeds where valve was standing a bit proud - and the plastic bit atop the valve had a little convex curl to it. Could those gaps be causing too much air to get through? I didn't think to look at the pallets on the bass side while I had it open so it could also be those need new soles. The pallet sole material there seems quite thin but pallets seat and close ok...and since compression feels fine it could just be my lack of proper technique.

3.) The treble side has a pallet noise issue that I hadn't noticed until I fixed a bass button squeak that was distracting me from the subtler clunking of the treble side.
When I removed the grille and keyboard cover and had a look. It looks to me like they also have a super thin sole material. The clunking is fairly loud now that the bass button squeak is gone. Every pallet makes a clunk as it closes on the aluminum plate.
Is sole material just different for the Club? From what I've seen in Hohner parts catalogs that doesn't seem likely but the Club appears to be a late 1950's model.

Anecdotally, I noticed Paul Young on YouTube playing The Abbess on a 3 row Hohner model that I didn't recognize and which made a similar noise. So... would replacing this with thicker sole material cut down or eliminate that noise?

Any thoughts would be very welcome!
Logged
Goal: "Play tunes I love proficiently, with musicality" | Antique Hohner Fixer-upper in self-training | Melodeons: Saltarelle Gaia GC - Beltuna Sara 2 DG  -  Hohner Pokerwork Vienna with D/G Anahata layout 
Other instruments |  Hohner Club IIIM needing work - Piano accordions - 6 PAs needing a tuning, work, or resto | Tin Whistles and Low Whistles - Wooden and metal flutes | Guitar | Yamaha P60 EP | Assorted diatonic and chromatic Hohner harmonicas | Turkish Meys in G, Eb and A, a D Duduk, and an A Ney
https://www.youtube.com/@kathharper-NFTBF

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713

It's hard to diagnose anything over a forum message, but initial thoughts here:

1) Reed set-up (aka gapping) is very important. The reeds can be poorly gapped, which increases air consumption and reduces response. Poor set-up can render the world's best reeds unplayable.
2) I think Club III M was a mediocre box at best, probably with uninspiring reeds (T or H plates). Them reeds probably have some serious fitting gaps, so even if you get them gapped by a fettler during an overhaul, they will have mediocre performance.
3) There's a slight chance that the reedblocks have warped and there's leakages where blocks join the fondo.

If you're really into Club, get yourself a first generation German-era Hohner Morino. Best squeezebox I ever owned.
Hard to find one in good nick though as they were made in the 50s, and when they moved their production to Italy the Italians never quite matched the original Morinos with their versions (produced by Excelsior I believe).
The only reason I sold mine was because I switched to a unisonoric hromka.
Logged

Ben

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 61
  • Hohner G/C, Pokerwork D/G, B/E, Club IIIB S C/F,

As a fellow Club III player (though a B S, not an M), I may be able to comment on the wheezies.  I know mine certainly sounds wheezie if I am accidentally pushing the air button... You probably aren't ... but you never know till you check :)  Also, the III's multi-octave bass set up with these reeds certainly does drink air.  Not as bad as some, but certainly not Casnagnari (but also... not with Casta price either).  Thankfully, the Club has a massive air button, so it is easy to quickly recover from the large air usage, especially with both sides play chords.  That is a lot of air going through those reeds, regardless of how closely gapped they are.
Logged

Kath Harper

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 67
    • Noise From the Blanket Fort

Thanks for the responses... I don't think I'm accidentally pushing the bellows release button and will pay attention to what my left hand is actually doing on that pull of Bb and C bass buttons that is most wheezy.
I am beginning to think it's not only my inexperience as the bellows really are sound.
As I get to really know the instrument at least a little, I'm finding other issues.
There are some reeds with real tuning issues in the three voices on treble as well and one low treble that is even rudely "farty" ... so I'm wondering whether the seller actually did the EDIT 1: "overhaul" and tuning properly as stated or something got jostled (it seemed well packed on receipt but it came to US from Germany so who knows what transpired along its way). Fortunately the box was not expensive (but that also may be part of the problem) EDIT2: And I am seeing the same somewhat hyperbolic description (one user low miles equivalent) in that seller's other listings so now I'm skeptical despite their good ratings from buyers.
And the "rarely used" high treble reeds are very recalcitrant to play... they do, but only with persistence.
As to the quality of the reeds mentioned in the first response... mediocre is probably fine for me as a beginner, but only if they sound as they are supposed to. In other words mediocre describes my playing at present, so... appropriate :-)
In further "other words" at this point my seeking out a Morino would be both fraught with risk of getting one in good nick AND possibly a waste of money on a good accordion should I find one and still be unable to play better as I learn and practice.
However it does make me wonder if I should get a smaller diatonic on which to learn and one that is new and from a reliable source. Are affordable DG or CF boxes out there that would be recommendable to a beginner?
I am finding that I enjoy playing folk tunes along with other traditional and popular tunes and yet consistently frustrated by not being able to play even the simplest tunes without "accordion problems" getting in my way.
Or would it be more "economically feasible" if I had all the reeds professionally replaced with better ones (or an expensive folly)?
EDIT 3: Is this a typical road the newfound lover of instruments with bellows follows in their search for "affordable but playable" instruments?
« Last Edit: March 13, 2025, 01:00:43 PM by Kath Harper »
Logged
Goal: "Play tunes I love proficiently, with musicality" | Antique Hohner Fixer-upper in self-training | Melodeons: Saltarelle Gaia GC - Beltuna Sara 2 DG  -  Hohner Pokerwork Vienna with D/G Anahata layout 
Other instruments |  Hohner Club IIIM needing work - Piano accordions - 6 PAs needing a tuning, work, or resto | Tin Whistles and Low Whistles - Wooden and metal flutes | Guitar | Yamaha P60 EP | Assorted diatonic and chromatic Hohner harmonicas | Turkish Meys in G, Eb and A, a D Duduk, and an A Ney
https://www.youtube.com/@kathharper-NFTBF

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place

Oh that’s such a sad story.  Speaking as a repair technician myself I’m always disappointed to hear stories like yours.
Terms like “overhaul and tune” cover quite a range of possible processes. From your description I don’t believe that you need to get a new set of reeds, it seems more like that wheezy and farty noises are a result of the way the reeds have been “overhauled”.
To fix those you need a technician who is skilled at diagnosing and fixing those problems.  Typically the things you have described are caused by valves that are old, damaged, or badly installed.  And of faulty wax and reed setting that needs adjustment.  Unfortunately none of those things are amenable to a quick and easy fix.
If you are already thinking of getting another instrument my suggestion would be to get something simpler, for example a 2 row 8 bass .  I’d also strongly recommend not buying off eBay. Anyone who sells restored older instruments should have a good enough reputation to sell on their own merits and not have to use a platform like eBay and to sell on low price.

Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Kath Harper

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 67
    • Noise From the Blanket Fort

The eBay experience is definitely problematic... that said, a fixer for cheap to learn on was got off ebay, along with a Titano (problematic but eventually at no cost to me due to seller's lies - guy actually gave post office a fictional address for return and left accordion unclaimed so it was returned to me by the post office with eBay's "blessing" and refund in full) taught me that lesson.

EDIT can apparently not write complete coherent sentences today: My other instruments were purchased from music stores in person or online (Liberty Bellows, a solid little Bellcordion) still without sufficient experience to actually judge their entire playability, but also low cost so no fault there.
The Hohner was online, came off a Reverb site seller with good feedback... but I intend to go back and let them know that I'm having issues with the instrument as I get to know it.

And yeah... in my fixer-upper efforts I am finding out how fiddly the process is. It is fun though, and I'm making very slow process but have fixed one problem the fixer had and am in process replacing the valves. No expectation that it will be perfect but one starts somewhere, where better than a simple old 1930's Hohner to muddle my way through that?

If I could find a reliable local accordion tech (I have two but one's too proud of his tech and overpriced for how he does it... the other takes longer than reasonable (months rather than weeks) to service and also found their repairs on the Titano were actually too cheap for them to have done what the tech did. EDIT: Though the Titano repair might have been a kind gesture and what I wrote initially was not necessarily the case. (both sides of the iffy accordion repair world in two different techs. Sigh.

...and the risks of shipping an instrument ruining the work done make me hesitant to go that route.

Only possibly reliable accordion dealer in the region is Liberty Bellows, and I have suspicions they aren't actually all that, either. (laughing at the whole situation, of my own making...)
So I don't really know what I should do next. I am glad for this forum though.

« Last Edit: March 13, 2025, 09:28:29 PM by Kath Harper »
Logged
Goal: "Play tunes I love proficiently, with musicality" | Antique Hohner Fixer-upper in self-training | Melodeons: Saltarelle Gaia GC - Beltuna Sara 2 DG  -  Hohner Pokerwork Vienna with D/G Anahata layout 
Other instruments |  Hohner Club IIIM needing work - Piano accordions - 6 PAs needing a tuning, work, or resto | Tin Whistles and Low Whistles - Wooden and metal flutes | Guitar | Yamaha P60 EP | Assorted diatonic and chromatic Hohner harmonicas | Turkish Meys in G, Eb and A, a D Duduk, and an A Ney
https://www.youtube.com/@kathharper-NFTBF

tirpous

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1403

Is it the same Club III M as in this video ?? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UqGqh1Y6Qqs
Logged

Kath Harper

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 67
    • Noise From the Blanket Fort

Yep that's the one. (typical n00b demo too :||: :||: :||:
Logged
Goal: "Play tunes I love proficiently, with musicality" | Antique Hohner Fixer-upper in self-training | Melodeons: Saltarelle Gaia GC - Beltuna Sara 2 DG  -  Hohner Pokerwork Vienna with D/G Anahata layout 
Other instruments |  Hohner Club IIIM needing work - Piano accordions - 6 PAs needing a tuning, work, or resto | Tin Whistles and Low Whistles - Wooden and metal flutes | Guitar | Yamaha P60 EP | Assorted diatonic and chromatic Hohner harmonicas | Turkish Meys in G, Eb and A, a D Duduk, and an A Ney
https://www.youtube.com/@kathharper-NFTBF

Dick Rees

  • Neo-Luddite
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1640

In your opening post you state (in issue 2):

"... getting the diatonic bellows right is fairly different from that of my
 keyboard accordions. "

I'd say this is a massive understatement. Diatonic bellows are the lungs of the instrument requiring an organic familiarity with the breathing of the instrument (more like bowing a violin) whereas the air supply for a chromatic unisonoric box can be had by hooking it up to a vaccuum cleaner.

They are COMPLETELY different systems though they appear visually to be the same.  My guess is there's nothing at all wrong/broken on the instrument. A large Club like yours is also different from a Pokerworks or Erica.

Good luck!  If you stick to it I think you'll find the Club system has a lot going for it.
« Last Edit: March 13, 2025, 06:12:01 PM by Dick Rees »
Logged
"You're making the wrong mistakes."
...Thelonius Monk

"I never made one of my discoveries through the process of rational thinking."
...Albert Einstein

"If Art Tatum took up classical music seriously, I'd quit my job the next day."
...Vladimir Horowitz

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713

Food for thought:

Squeezeboxes are all about set-up. Set-up = time and time = money.
You get a fettled pokerwork, you're paying £70 for the box and £700 for the fettling labour.
You get a box off ebay for £50, you get what you paid for.


The real problems with ebays arise when you're looking to buy a £2k box and get a £50 dud, and that's where you need to be extra careful. Or, for newbies, paying £350 for a £70 dud.
Ebay has been quite bad recently both in terms of sellers and buyers, but I wouldn't write it off completely. Not great for newbies though.

Food for thought 2:
You'd really struggle to find a squeezebox that is perfectly set up. Most of them have glitches and the cost of fixing them rises exponentially the closer you want to get to perfection.

Food for thought 3:
You keep mentioning bellows quality. Most boxes are fine, even if the bellows are 100 years old. Even if the bellows are shot, most of the time the box is playable after some patching up. It's all about reed set-up, valves and wax condition, mech set-up.
Logged

Kath Harper

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 67
    • Noise From the Blanket Fort

Thanks all for the input here!

Yesterday's practice was better, as I have read through the responses so far and that is helping me understand what this instrument does differently from a piano accordion.

I found that it works better when a balance of compression is achieved!

Practice is often a series of running through a couple scales on the treble and separately warming up on the bass.
This time I incorporated bass while running the scales and worked with that until both sides sounded better.

This helped me figure out I may have been too actively pulling on the pull notes rather than keeping sufficient compression by "letting" rather than "forcing".
I was also sort of hunching over the instrument (which was causing right shoulder pain, from crochet bad habits I was able to see I needed not to do that) so made a point of paying attention to my posture as well.

Reveals something I am (finally!) beginning to understand about myself, I often tense up and try to force things rather than let things progress at their pace by relaxing into the process and going with the flow.
Analagous to learning how to deep breathe as a human without forcing, as if you're all tensed up it's harder to do.
Am getting better at the latter... slowly.

Baby step progress, but I was actually able to get through my tiny practice set (2 + 2 measures of a tune I'm using for practice) with improvement and playing bass and treble together.

I still have many things to learn about this box (thus the flurry of questions...) and yesterday's practice with all that has been written in responses taken to heart is encouraging.
I think I may start recording the practices so my "practice only" videos may start again at some point. To record both the flaws and the breakthroughs, if nothing else.

Also taking the practice and play "Melinar" videos as a guide on beginner practice strategies... as Mel's process is closer to my own.
Logged
Goal: "Play tunes I love proficiently, with musicality" | Antique Hohner Fixer-upper in self-training | Melodeons: Saltarelle Gaia GC - Beltuna Sara 2 DG  -  Hohner Pokerwork Vienna with D/G Anahata layout 
Other instruments |  Hohner Club IIIM needing work - Piano accordions - 6 PAs needing a tuning, work, or resto | Tin Whistles and Low Whistles - Wooden and metal flutes | Guitar | Yamaha P60 EP | Assorted diatonic and chromatic Hohner harmonicas | Turkish Meys in G, Eb and A, a D Duduk, and an A Ney
https://www.youtube.com/@kathharper-NFTBF

Kath Harper

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 67
    • Noise From the Blanket Fort


Food for thought 2:
You'd really struggle to find a squeezebox that is perfectly set up. Most of them have glitches and the cost of fixing them rises exponentially the closer you want to get to perfection.

Food for thought 3:
You keep mentioning bellows quality. Most boxes are fine, even if the bellows are 100 years old. Even if the bellows are shot, most of the time the box is playable after some patching up. It's all about reed set-up, valves and wax condition, mech set-up.

Yes. I understand the above.
So perhaps my approach should be to let the box show me. Then as I learn how to properly make it sound, note which reeds aren't sounding right in concert with the others, over time, then have spot work done at least on those, by a professional.
Logged
Goal: "Play tunes I love proficiently, with musicality" | Antique Hohner Fixer-upper in self-training | Melodeons: Saltarelle Gaia GC - Beltuna Sara 2 DG  -  Hohner Pokerwork Vienna with D/G Anahata layout 
Other instruments |  Hohner Club IIIM needing work - Piano accordions - 6 PAs needing a tuning, work, or resto | Tin Whistles and Low Whistles - Wooden and metal flutes | Guitar | Yamaha P60 EP | Assorted diatonic and chromatic Hohner harmonicas | Turkish Meys in G, Eb and A, a D Duduk, and an A Ney
https://www.youtube.com/@kathharper-NFTBF

Dick Rees

  • Neo-Luddite
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1640

"... a balance of compression is achieved..."

Excellent, and well said!
Logged
"You're making the wrong mistakes."
...Thelonius Monk

"I never made one of my discoveries through the process of rational thinking."
...Albert Einstein

"If Art Tatum took up classical music seriously, I'd quit my job the next day."
...Vladimir Horowitz

Kath Harper

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 67
    • Noise From the Blanket Fort

Oh that’s such a sad story.  Speaking as a repair technician myself I’m always disappointed to hear stories like yours.
Terms like “overhaul and tune” cover quite a range of possible processes. From your description I don’t believe that you need to get a new set of reeds, it seems more like that wheezy and farty noises are a result of the way the reeds have been “overhauled”.
To fix those you need a technician who is skilled at diagnosing and fixing those problems.  Typically the things you have described are caused by valves that are old, damaged, or badly installed.  And of faulty wax and reed setting that needs adjustment.  Unfortunately none of those things are amenable to a quick and easy fix.
If you are already thinking of getting another instrument my suggestion would be to get something simpler, for example a 2 row 8 bass .  I’d also strongly recommend not buying off eBay. Anyone who sells restored older instruments should have a good enough reputation to sell on their own merits and not have to use a platform like eBay and to sell on low price.



I fortunately learned the eBay experience can be iffy early on (without too much impact to my finances.) The Club and I are getting to know one another and though I still know it has some reed issues, it is playable in certain registers and I'm coming to terms with the bellows motion... so it's a good "for now" learner box. Did come to conclusion I need a better-condition box though, it is frustrating to attempt to practice methodically and learn on a non-optimally set up instrument.

That written, it is fun to explore even that kind of instrument and see what I am actually able to do. But might be more fun if the sounds coming out were nicer and it wasn't in need of care I'm not qualified or experienced enough to provide.
Logged
Goal: "Play tunes I love proficiently, with musicality" | Antique Hohner Fixer-upper in self-training | Melodeons: Saltarelle Gaia GC - Beltuna Sara 2 DG  -  Hohner Pokerwork Vienna with D/G Anahata layout 
Other instruments |  Hohner Club IIIM needing work - Piano accordions - 6 PAs needing a tuning, work, or resto | Tin Whistles and Low Whistles - Wooden and metal flutes | Guitar | Yamaha P60 EP | Assorted diatonic and chromatic Hohner harmonicas | Turkish Meys in G, Eb and A, a D Duduk, and an A Ney
https://www.youtube.com/@kathharper-NFTBF

hickory-wind

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 627
  • Lives in NY USA near the Erie Canal
    • Bellingers' Button Boxes

Kath-
Are you in the States? I am offering a 2 day button accordion restoration workshop in western NY state sometime this summer. I could help you diagnose all the issues and help you get started on your quest for accordion maintenance at home. I encourage folks to bring their own instruments to work on.

Details here: https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=31300.0

For transparency, I am ramping down my 'hobby' so you won't have the option to leave it with me to do the restoration. I remain quite busy continuing to restore & tune my own inventory. I always have lots of instruments for you to test drive since changing instruments is one of the options you are considering including smaller 2 voice, no switches boxes. I share others' opinions above that a simpler button accordion is more desirable as a first restoration candidate. If you want to stick with a 3 or 4 voice club I also have some of Hohner's high end club accordions so your efforts would be applied to a better chassis. Here are some examples of them after restoration:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cu8JADe3Izg&t=62s

https://youtu.be/DJ_5FQ0MSb4?si=EciJq801C9slr9Qv

https://youtu.be/sbA4_mnTFF4?si=Z8mBOaF8hEPL-7Fc


Scott
« Last Edit: March 19, 2025, 02:34:41 PM by hickory-wind »
Logged
too many boxes...please buy one, or two, or

Kath Harper

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 67
    • Noise From the Blanket Fort

Sounds like a fantastic opportunity! No idea what my future schedule looks like yet as things are changing rapidly where I work.  I will keep it in mind.
Logged
Goal: "Play tunes I love proficiently, with musicality" | Antique Hohner Fixer-upper in self-training | Melodeons: Saltarelle Gaia GC - Beltuna Sara 2 DG  -  Hohner Pokerwork Vienna with D/G Anahata layout 
Other instruments |  Hohner Club IIIM needing work - Piano accordions - 6 PAs needing a tuning, work, or resto | Tin Whistles and Low Whistles - Wooden and metal flutes | Guitar | Yamaha P60 EP | Assorted diatonic and chromatic Hohner harmonicas | Turkish Meys in G, Eb and A, a D Duduk, and an A Ney
https://www.youtube.com/@kathharper-NFTBF
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal