Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: newbie ramble  (Read 2061 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Andrew Charman-Williams

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 23
newbie ramble
« on: April 11, 2025, 09:39:50 PM »

Apologies if this is in the wrong area. Although it will touch on instrument makes and models and teaching and learning it is mainly just a long-winded ramble of an enthusiastic beginner.

I have had melodeons for 2 years but until recently hadn’t tried to play them in any serious way. A lot of this was that I was spending time learning and improving my mandolin and related 5ths strings (tenor guitar, Irish bouzouki, octave mandolin, mandola). I love being a multi-instrument player (jack of all trades, master of none probably) but it does mean I sometimes prioritise a small range of instruments to play or learn. I have recently started to put the time and effort in to properly learning the accordion. My current boxes (pic attached) are a C/F Pokerwork, third button with accidentals (German with plastic keyboard), an old green Hohner D/G, 4th button start with low notes and a 19 button LMM Paolo Soprano D/G, 3rd button start Anahata layout. I also have a Pigini compact chromatic converter LM with C system. I am thinking about whether to tape ups thirds on the Paolo Soprani or even adding a stop or 2 but will need to open it up and look at how it is laid out before deciding. I may go the non-destructive route of taping thirds. Given the less friendly thirds layout of the Hohners I probably will leave thirds in on them.

I have just pressed the button on an order for a Castagnari 1914 D/G. This will have Paul Young’s suggested layout (attached) which makes sense to me as far as which compromises it has. That is basically a 4th button start Anahata layout with the accidentals as Bb/G#, F/F for chin end and Eb/F, F/G# for the helper row. So F in both directions in 2 octaves G# in 2 octaves but only a single low Bb and high Eb. Additional 4 chord/bass buttons are fairly standard at Eb+/F#- and Bb+/F+. Just have to wait a few months now which hopefully will give me time to improve my playing. I went back and forth in my mind between various keys, brands and models but came down to a choice between the 1914 and the Mory but decided the extra weight of the Mory was not right for me (only $150 more so that wasn’t a major factor). I’m in Australia and in a rural part of Tasmania so no real hope of trying boxes in person. The brands I was tossing up between were Castagnari, Saltarelle, and Beltuna which is what Reedworks deals with. There are very limited shops dealing with diatonic button accordions in Australia and I didn’t want to deal with the hassle of importing one from overseas myself. Plus I do like the Castagnari sound.

I did also recently make an impulse purchase of a second hand McNeela 2 voice wooden C#/D which should arrive within the next week or so. Not expecting it to be a particularly high quality box but I’ll see how it sounds and plays. With that I will certainly look at taping thirds or adding a stop to remove thirds. As it’s a fairly low end box I’ll have far less hesitation about drilling into it to add a stop.

I am starting to get used to playing but especially when playing on the row I do get my hands and brain tied in knots when crossing octaves and having the pull note below the push of the same button rather than above so make silly errors. But I guess that is just a case of practice to make that octave shift stick properly in muscle memory. I am finding I do need to try and change how I go about playing or practicing. With mandolin I generally picked one of my tunebooks and read through playing a tune once or twice through before moving on. That doesn’t work as well for me at the moment on accordion, particularly if adding basses rather than just playing the RH melody. For an inexperienced player some thought has to be put in on when to play on the row and when to cross row and how that relates to bellows management and bass/chord availability. Hopefully I’ll get to the point where it’s instinctive and I can just read through a variety of tunes. So I do have to try and do a more considered approach of learning a tune rather than just reading through dozens of tunes in a playing session. Or at least do a halfway approach of setting up a much more limited tune book so I have the chance to make any annotations on the tunes for how I want to play it.

I may not be much of a poster as I’m not experienced enough to give advice and always try searching before asking about things that have been discussed at length before.
Logged

Brian Wyneken

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 53
Re: newbie ramble
« Reply #1 on: April 12, 2025, 01:41:11 AM »

By way of a welcome to the 1914 community, I purchased mine about a year ago and am very happy with it and with Paul Young's layout. I did read your "ramble" and will reply that for me it took about two years with a tutor before I began to find my own way with respect to what I wanted to work on and what I should be working on. But, I was not already a musician so having some regular tailored guidance was (& is) necessary. Aside from the lessons (which I'm still taking now in my third year), I found the "Brainjo" guy [https://www.brainjo.academy/] to be very helpful with respect to improving technical skills within music education - mainly, how to handle frustration. His "brainjo bytes" on YouTube have a lot of good advice about "how" to practice. Best wishes!
Logged

Andrew Charman-Williams

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 23
Re: newbie ramble
« Reply #2 on: April 12, 2025, 02:58:54 AM »

By way of a welcome to the 1914 community, I purchased mine about a year ago and am very happy with it and with Paul Young's layout. I did read your "ramble" and will reply that for me it took about two years with a tutor before I began to find my own way with respect to what I wanted to work on and what I should be working on. But, I was not already a musician so having some regular tailored guidance was (& is) necessary. Aside from the lessons (which I'm still taking now in my third year), I found the "Brainjo" guy [https://www.brainjo.academy/] to be very helpful with respect to improving technical skills within music education - mainly, how to handle frustration. His "brainjo bytes" on YouTube have a lot of good advice about "how" to practice. Best wishes!

Thanks Brian, good to hear a positive review of Paul's layout on a 1914. The 1914 did appeal as it has the independent helper row buttons plus the LMM with 4 of the 5 combinations available and the couplers for 3rds and bass in or out while keeping it much lighter than the Mory. I'm sure I'll still pick up the other boxes especially the green pre-Erica Hohner which is so beautifully lightweight and full sounding. I doubt if I will take any lessons (even though they might be good for technique) but will continue to look at the forum and Youtube for playing hints. I have what is mainly an advantage though probably some cons of having many years of music playing on other instruments. I can read music on a single staff very well though not as good at fluent reading when it comes to the double stave of a piano as I just play by ear or from lead sheets with piano and I can pick things up fairly well from ear though I need to work on picking up melodies quicker as I'm out of practice on that.

I don't know of any sessions nearby - they would be privately held if there are any near me and I am very unlikely to travel into the nearest city (45 minutes away) or a reasonably thriving folk area 40 minutes the other side of the city where I think there are reasonably regular sessions. And unfortunately the only musicians I know locally are some rock players including ones I play guitar with in a band. So it will just be playing for and by myself as it mainly is with most of my acoustic instruments of which I have too many. Being retired I have a reasonable amount of time to play music though there is never enough time for everything, especially as I will still want to play my other instruments and to continue slowly learning fiddle. Being a specialist in an instrument and genre would probably be simpler but the multi-instrument, multi-genre approach is what makes me happy. But it would be good to become reasonably proficient and instinctive on accordion within a year or two.
Logged

Al Cramer

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 98
Re: newbie ramble
« Reply #3 on: April 12, 2025, 05:04:40 AM »

Hi Andrew --

Sounds like you've got some really nice boxes. If I were in your shoes, I'd work a lot with one of the DG's. Unless you're some kind of genius, trying to learn a quint-box at the same time as learning a semi-tone box seems impossible, if you want to make the left hand work fluently with the right. (I write as a fiddler/guitar player who has been struggling the last 8 months to get there on the box). Anyway best of luck!
Logged

Andrew Charman-Williams

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 23
Re: newbie ramble
« Reply #4 on: April 12, 2025, 05:57:58 AM »

Hi Andrew --

Sounds like you've got some really nice boxes. If I were in your shoes, I'd work a lot with one of the DG's. Unless you're some kind of genius, trying to learn a quint-box at the same time as learning a semi-tone box seems impossible, if you want to make the left hand work fluently with the right. (I write as a fiddler/guitar player who has been struggling the last 8 months to get there on the box). Anyway best of luck!

Thanks. Yes I think I will stick mainly to the quint boxes at first at least. The C#/D just happened to come up in a used instrument shop so was an impulse purchase that I'll try and get used to after I'm suitably comfortable with the others.
Logged

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: newbie ramble
« Reply #5 on: April 12, 2025, 08:36:33 AM »

Hi Andrew,
Lots to digest here from your post...
One thing I noticed is playing the RH melody.
The best advice I had when starting is use both hands at once even at the beginning.
Work on a simple tune or maybe two, but get used to using both hands.
You will find that the left hand basses dictate whether that melody note is pushed or pulled to fit the bass and chord required.

At the beginning it slows you up and creates much brain ache but persevere. After a time you realised you have established a coordination between  your hand and that is necessary on a DG boxes.

Also it does take time.
I remember right at the beginning Theo said this to me when I expressed my frustration at my progress.
I'd gone from being a good English concertina player to being unable to get a tune out of a melodeon and that was a huge shock. It takes time, enjoy your journey!

Others will come along soon and jump in so will leave it there.

I have a Mory with a Paul Young layout and love it!
The Mory is a big beast and it took me a long while to get used to the weight.
It took me 2-3 changes before I found Paul's layout and it is perfect for me. Just wish I'd happened on it from the beginning!
Good luck and enjoy the journey  (:)
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Andrew Charman-Williams

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 23
Re: newbie
« Reply #6 on: April 12, 2025, 09:15:48 AM »

Hi Andrew,
Lots to digest here from your post...
One thing I noticed is playing the RH melody.
The best advice I had when starting is use both hands at once even at the beginning.
Work on a simple tune or maybe two, but get used to using both hands.

Thanks and good to get further confirmation about the layout. The Mory was tempting but it just looked too much and too heavy.

I am trying to discipline myself to stick to a very small number of simple tunes with both hands and being reasonably comfortable and confident with them before moving on. Emphasis though on trying as I seem to fall back into the habit of just playing through a bunch of tunes which tends to drop my LH out much of the time. But yes a good reminder to take it more slowly and deliberately one or two tunes at a time.
Logged

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: newbie ramble
« Reply #7 on: April 12, 2025, 10:05:47 AM »

Yes stick to your plan!
By all means have a little explore and a bit if fun, but really concentrate on getting a couple of tunes up to scratch with both hands. That's your next step.
You'll find it will be like bashing your head against a brick wall but then... it suddenly gives and you've cracked it!
Establishing the relationship between left and right hands is a biggie. Stick at it and it will come 👍
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: newbie ramble
« Reply #8 on: April 12, 2025, 10:05:57 PM »

The Paul Young layout is excellent and if I ever wanted to go back to a 2½ row box I'd choose that. Not just because we favour the same low notes layout - I like his approach to the accidentals row too.

As for problems with learning: yes, on the mandolin there is basically one way to play each note (unless or until you start getting your left hand out of 1st position) whereas there's more than one way to play most notes on a melodeon, and the right choice depends on context. So just reading though tunes in a book is going to be hard work to start with. You need to get used to patterns of notes and really learn your layout. Try taking a tune apart into short phrases and find different ways to play each one. Not only do you often have have the same note on both rows and maybe in opposite push/pull directions, but which finger to use, when to shift your hand when a run of notes goes up or down the keyboard - all this needs experimentation, practice and familiarity.

The fact that the layout is different from one octave to the next is hugely frustrating. The only answer is lots of practice on both the high and low ends of the scale. I'm definitely more comfortable in the lower octave than the higher one, despite many years of playing Anglo concertina where the RH is very like the high octave on a melodeon. I've never really taken to the G/C box, which is mostly played on the higher notes of the keyboard.

"Thrupenny Bit" makes a good point about learning both hands together. It seems like hard work at first but start with simple tunes and get them right - it's worth the struggle because it will remove barriers later.

It looks from your own responses that you've got this anyway, and you know what to do. Don't give up - it's worth it in the end!
« Last Edit: April 13, 2025, 08:13:31 AM by Anahata »
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

Al Cramer

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 98
Re: newbie ramble
« Reply #9 on: April 12, 2025, 11:36:06 PM »

Andrew, looks like you're getting great advice from the Maestro's who post here!

As one beginner to another: have you checked out Paul Young's youtube video where he teaches "Shepherd's Hey"? He shows you how to get both hands working together from the git-go.

Logged

Andrew Charman-Williams

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 23
Re: newbie ramble
« Reply #10 on: April 12, 2025, 11:55:16 PM »

Thanks Anahata. Yes for reading tunes on mandolin I generally stay in first position like fiddlers would so apart from the occasional fingering choice the only decision on note placement is open string vs 7th fret. But decisions on where to play notes is more complicated, particularly with basses in use which I am trying to do all the time. So changing the habit from lots of tunes, improving my reading and sightreading speed to a limited number of tunes so note, bass, chord placement and air management can be considered is important for me to do. And yes with everything it is lots of practice so I’m sure the fingering differences between octaves will graduallly feel more natural.

Al, yes I’ve seen that Paul Young video. Most of the time for simple tunes I have no problems with using bass (though obviously plenty of scope for improvement) so long as I get the RH choice correct. But it is probably one of the simple tunes that would be good to be comfortable playing fluently and with expression and variation.
Logged

Kath Harper

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 67
    • Noise From the Blanket Fort
Re: newbie ramble
« Reply #11 on: April 13, 2025, 11:34:44 PM »

Andrew, looks like you're getting great advice from the Maestro's who post here!

As one beginner to another: have you checked out Paul Young's youtube video where he teaches "Shepherd's Hey"? He shows you how to get both hands working together from the git-go.


As for problems with learning: yes, on the mandolin there is basically one way to play each note (unless or until you start getting your left hand out of 1st position) whereas there's more than one way to play most notes on a melodeon, and the right choice depends on context. So just reading though tunes in a book is going to be hard work to start with. You need to get used to patterns of notes and really learn your layout. Try taking a tune apart into short phrases and find different ways to play each one. Not only do you often have have the same note on both rows and maybe in opposite push/pull directions, but which finger to use, when to shift your hand when a run of notes goes up or down the keyboard - all this needs experimentation, practice and familiarity.

"Thrupenny Bit" makes a good point about learning both hands together. It seems like hard work at first but start with simple tunes and get them right - it's worth the struggle because it will remove barriers later.

As a newbie myself, this makes a lot of sense. The treble buttons used need to correspond to the bass so working both hands out to get that is very useful. Mel Biggs markup of sheet music that adds the button/row numbers and direction is one good way to start when you already read sheet music as I do.

(Of course one may argue with my logic if they stumble on my video in Beginners showcase topic! It is rough going ... with little moments of grace where I get a few things right).
But it is working well (despite all the mis-struck or pulled rather than pushed buttons) and after serious practice I know I am making slow but steady progress learning in that way.
I am still so clumsy with this that a metronome while useful for scales and tempo cues that none of what I practice ends up being on tempo. That will get better over time as my practice improves my muscle memory and skills.
Logged
Goal: "Play tunes I love proficiently, with musicality" | Antique Hohner Fixer-upper in self-training | Melodeons: Saltarelle Gaia GC - Beltuna Sara 2 DG  -  Hohner Pokerwork Vienna with D/G Anahata layout 
Other instruments |  Hohner Club IIIM needing work - Piano accordions - 6 PAs needing a tuning, work, or resto | Tin Whistles and Low Whistles - Wooden and metal flutes | Guitar | Yamaha P60 EP | Assorted diatonic and chromatic Hohner harmonicas | Turkish Meys in G, Eb and A, a D Duduk, and an A Ney
https://www.youtube.com/@kathharper-NFTBF

Al Cramer

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 98
Re: newbie ramble
« Reply #12 on: April 14, 2025, 04:57:43 AM »

Hi Kath --

I have never, ever, been able to work with a metronome. It feels like this horrible metallic clicking robot invading my personal space! But I would be totally lost in time if I didn't tap my left foot. You get that left foot moving, it just sucks your whole body into the tempo. But of course that's just me: whatever works for you, works!
Logged

Kath Harper

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 67
    • Noise From the Blanket Fort
Re: newbie ramble
« Reply #13 on: April 14, 2025, 10:02:56 AM »

I find it marginally useful but not while working a tune out. For scales (I didn't use it in the video at all, because I don't "like" it either, and I don't think anyone "loves" a metronome).
I also replaced the very annoying seiko clack with a gentler Korg one that kind of bings and also has beat settings and voice counter (weird but kind of funny), so it can actually be helpful trying to get to a groove... but not yet as it's irrelevant with my all over the place stops and starts. I intentionally got one that starts at 30 due to my tendency toward mistakes and rushing, and 30 bpm is insufferably slow but understanding that tempo has actually helped me s l o w  d o w n when nothing else did.

That said, I tend to speed ahead when practicing and get myself in a mess, so for the scales and as a reminder of tempo it has actually helped me there a bit. I do still tell the box to shut up when I turn it off!  ;D

The foot tapping yes, mine is there but so subtle it's not pulling me in. I like how the foot tapping becomes a drum part of the tune (Paul Young's playing at dances with a box stand and sets the dance tempo) and one reason I don't do as much is my third floor condo with squeaky floors. Even with moving blanket padding my wood floor would be squeaking in time for my downstairs neighbor (which at some point might be pleasant once my playing is more competent) but right now likely just more annoying. Neighbors are great though, one actually I hear snoring while I play (oblivious, in other words, or I actually help him sleep but that's less likely) and downstairs one I have agreement with on practice hours. She plays sax so understands the musical motivation and that practice isn't musical until it is.
Logged
Goal: "Play tunes I love proficiently, with musicality" | Antique Hohner Fixer-upper in self-training | Melodeons: Saltarelle Gaia GC - Beltuna Sara 2 DG  -  Hohner Pokerwork Vienna with D/G Anahata layout 
Other instruments |  Hohner Club IIIM needing work - Piano accordions - 6 PAs needing a tuning, work, or resto | Tin Whistles and Low Whistles - Wooden and metal flutes | Guitar | Yamaha P60 EP | Assorted diatonic and chromatic Hohner harmonicas | Turkish Meys in G, Eb and A, a D Duduk, and an A Ney
https://www.youtube.com/@kathharper-NFTBF
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal