Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates  (Read 1048 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

rileyismycopilot

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 27
Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates
« on: July 11, 2025, 11:06:01 PM »

Hello gang,

I've done a little experiment in order to compare 2 types of reeds that I have on hand.
First one is a "D" Hohner block from the 1940'. H reeds on Al plates, original (unrestored) condition.
Second one is a "C" Hohner block from the 1930'. H reeds on Zn plates (heavy), same unrestored condition.

The 2 blocks have been put together in a 2 row Pokerwork so that the inside row has the "D" / Al block and the outside row has the "C" / Zn block.

Here are my findings:

I'VE EDITED OUT MY RESULTS BECAUSE THIS EXPERIMENT COMPARES DIFFERENT REEDS ON DIFFERENTS ROWS SO IT'S NOT A ONE TO ONE COMPARISON. I WOULDN'T WANT TO PROPAGATE BS ON THE INTERNET.

Cheers, Victor
« Last Edit: July 18, 2025, 09:30:30 PM by rileyismycopilot »
Logged

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates
« Reply #1 on: July 12, 2025, 12:10:35 AM »

Interesting objective,  but even with identical reeds in each row it’s very common to find tonal differences between the rows, so it could be the differences you hear are influenced by that too.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates
« Reply #2 on: July 12, 2025, 07:12:45 AM »

Experimentation is great, but I regret to say that you're not really comparing al to zinc here, so I wouldn't jump to any conclusions. ;)
In addition to the very obvious likely differences between rows mentioned by Theo, the reeds on those plates are extremely unlikely to be identical. Even if they look the same, one set might be stiffer, another might be looser - there's a surprisingly big variance allowable for reed stiffness for a given shape (shape stays the same but you can profile them differently, which impacts the timbre, or you can use different steel).
Hohner were not known for consistency in production quality and reed tongue steel used even on their top end reeds ("Hohner Germany" prewar and Artiste post war). Off the top of my head I remember seeing 4 different variations of Artiste alone (different steel, aluminium, rivets, quality of fit, quality of profiling), made in 15 years between 1950 and 1965. H plates were Hohner's second-grade reeds, so I'd expect a lot less focus on consistency.
Responsiveness is primarily a product of reed fitting (at manufacturing) & gapping (at set up stage). A crap reed in a brass plate won't to be more responsive than AM-quality reed in Al.

FWIW, my own listening experience points towards heavier plates = warmer sound, but knowing all of the above, I wouldn't claim that I'm confident this relationship is actually there. I hear and read folks making all sorts of claims about timbre, but at the end of the day if I've seen at least one real life example that does not follow the suggested relationship without any obvious reasons for doing so, I'd be reluctant to accept that the said relationship exists.
« Last Edit: July 12, 2025, 07:16:05 AM by mChavez »
Logged

Winston Smith

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4066
  • AKA Edward Jennings
    • "Our Luxor B&B" Luxor life, slice by slice.
Re: Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates
« Reply #3 on: July 12, 2025, 08:52:06 AM »

Speaking as one who is "unlearned", surely all of this (other than response) is entirely subjective? Like tremolo, or the lack of, we all have our individual tastes?
We may all prefer, and aspire to, prime cuts of venison; but when our wallets only allow corned beef or chopped pork, then that's what we have to cope with!
Logged
At last, broken and resigned to accept conformity.
Oh, how I LOVE Big Brother!

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates
« Reply #4 on: July 12, 2025, 09:23:59 AM »

We may all prefer, and aspire to, prime cuts of venison; but when our wallets only allow corned beef or chopped pork, then that's what we have to cope with!

Take out your rifle, go to the forest and get some organic freerange venison saddle yourself?  ;)

There's certainly differences in what we hear (or what our brains interpret from the sound the ears pick up), but there's general dislike for sounds filled with higher partials.  In 99% of cases people would not like to listen to such sounds as they are perceived as "harsh". While terms "warm/smooth" "harsh/sharp" are pretty much useless, we keep using them because for the vast majority of the population they mean similar timbres.

I've said it many times, concerts for clarinet are quite common, but I've never heard of anyone willing to sit through a concert played on a circular saw.
Logged

Disparate Dan

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 329
Re: Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates
« Reply #5 on: July 12, 2025, 11:52:15 AM »

... what our brains interpret from the sound the ears pick up ...

Psychoacoustics.  Now there's a rabbit hole to go down ...
Logged
We're all doomed ...

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates
« Reply #6 on: July 12, 2025, 01:54:48 PM »

Years ago there used to be a free online course based on Janssen's workings. "Psychoacoustics for musical instrument makers" or something along those lines. Very good but I can't find it right now.
There's also a book by David Howard on the subject.

Worth a read.
Logged

Ben

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 61
  • Hohner G/C, Pokerwork D/G, B/E, Club IIIB S C/F,
Re: Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates
« Reply #7 on: July 17, 2025, 05:26:11 PM »

I actually did a minor experiment myself, I had A4 reeds on zn and al from a couple different era boxes (1930s zn, 1950s al, and 1980s al) and played them on my test bench, waxed in.  I could not notice a substantial difference between any of them.    Next step would be to record the tone and analyze with a spectrometer.... ears are great and all, but psychoacoustics are definitely a thing, and I think box resonance has a larger impact to tone than the difference between zn and al.  This is not accounting for reed setup which probably also has a non-trivial impact on tone (esp when it comes to the 'breathiness' of the reed, if you will)
Logged

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates
« Reply #8 on: July 17, 2025, 05:33:58 PM »

I won’t delay that the box has an important effect on sound quality,  but on the whole it’s not resonance.  It’s the opposite,  saviours aspects of the case, blocks, pallet holes, grill are all able to selectively absorb energy from the sound as it passes from the reeds to the outside world. This has the effect of selectively filtering some frequencies.  The number of variables in this system is very large, so the system has only limited potential for rigorous analysis,  so most makers have to use known examples of what works, and intuition as to what might be a further improvement.  Its craft rather than science and engineering.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Winston Smith

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4066
  • AKA Edward Jennings
    • "Our Luxor B&B" Luxor life, slice by slice.
Re: Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates
« Reply #9 on: July 17, 2025, 06:12:59 PM »

"aspects of the case, blocks, pallet holes, grill are all able to selectively absorb energy from the sound as it passes from the reeds to the outside world. This has the effect of selectively filtering some frequencies.

Funnily enough....... I've been looking into the cassotto thing. As far as I've been able to ascertain yet, these seem to be an enclosure around the reedblock with holes to allow enough airflow, but enough wood to absorb/filter higher frequencies. However, these seem to be on the other side of the reeds, i.e. inside the bellows? Is that right?
Logged
At last, broken and resigned to accept conformity.
Oh, how I LOVE Big Brother!

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates
« Reply #10 on: July 17, 2025, 07:00:34 PM »

All the reeds are “inside the bellows” are they not?
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates
« Reply #11 on: July 18, 2025, 06:14:44 PM »

Funnily enough....... I've been looking into the cassotto thing. As far as I've been able to ascertain yet, these seem to be an enclosure around the reedblock with holes to allow enough airflow, but enough wood to absorb/filter higher frequencies. However, these seem to be on the other side of the reeds, i.e. inside the bellows? Is that right?

I'm going to try fitting cassotto into one of my next hromka builds - I think my chassis allows that in a 3-voice configuration. One voice chambered, two outside.

Cassotto is just a chamber around the pallets. Nothing to do with extra airflow. Here's a cross section of it (see the blocks mounted at 90 degrees to the rest of them and the chamber around the pallets). The sound waves come out of the soundholes, bounce about the chamber before coming out to bounce about under the grille.
This bouncing about in the chamber is not just about cutting out the high frequencies (you can do that with a sordina or jalousie), but it seems to cancel some frequencies and add other up, so there's a much bigger change to timber than just filtering out the highs.

I've had 4 boxes with double cassotto and I'd say that you need to be careful with chamber dimensions & shape. Too much cassotto is not necessarily a good thing.

« Last Edit: July 18, 2025, 06:19:59 PM by mChavez »
Logged

rileyismycopilot

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 27
Re: Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates
« Reply #12 on: July 18, 2025, 09:43:05 PM »

Hi folks!

Thanks for your opinions. Great thoughts, especially noticing that I was comparing different reed types placed in different rows, therefore not making a true apple to apple comparison.

So I did the very opposite thing : put some Zn reeds on the inside row, and Al reeds on the outside row.

Guess what?

All of a sudden, I could barely hear a difference in tone between the two banks.
It may just be that row position (outside vs inside) makes equally or more difference in tone than reed type (outside row being punchier and inside row being more muffled).
I still thing that reed plate type makes a difference, but it might be extremely subtle if not inaudible!
Reed gap / response certainly is a much bigger contributor to the general sound of the box.

Therefore, I've edited my original post in order not to propagate wrong info or easy rule of thumbs that are actually untrue.

Thanks to all who've responded and shared their thoughts!
Logged

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: Experiment: Zinc vs. Aluminium reed plates
« Reply #13 on: July 19, 2025, 06:57:32 AM »

All of a sudden, I could barely hear a difference in tone between the two banks.
It may just be that row position (outside vs inside) makes equally or more difference in tone than reed type (outside row being punchier and inside row being more muffled).

Therefore, I've edited my original post in order not to propagate wrong info or easy rule of thumbs that are actually untrue.

Thanks to all who've responded and shared their thoughts!

We most certainly don't want to discourage anyone from experimentation - that's the only way we learn about our instruments. But once you realise the complexity of all the factors that affect the timbre, you become more aware of the red herrings.
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal