Boxlad,
To me that box is absolutely beautiful, in a home-made and humble way. I love the colors.
Some of the Walters that I think were made in New York do have that general keyboard shape, including the one belonging to the late Tom Doherty and the Tom Gallagher box.
But it is very surprising to me that any box actually sold by F. H. Walters would not have his name on it. Like many other accordion dealers past and present, he was not shy about putting his mark on instruments he sold, though they seem to have come from several different sources (some of the Italian-made ones are indistinguishable from models sold by Baldoni Bartoli & Co). That's why I suspect that this aqua blue accordion may have been purchased not exactly from Walters, but rather from someone who made accordions that were also sold by Walters.
PG
Returning to this thread after learning much more about these accordions, I may have to correct myself. Or at least qualify my comments a little differently.
For decades now, I've been encountering unlabeled accordions that resemble those that were labeled with "manufacturer's" -- or at least, retailer's -- names. Often you can pair these up, a labeled one with an unlabeled one, in a way that suggests they were "littermates" (came from the same shop and same production series).
Not too surprising if you know a little bit about the music instrument business . . . subcontracting, outsourcing, sharing parts are all very common and have been for centuries. But retailers often find it best not to share all this information with their customers.
In trying to figure out what might have happened in the past, I think we need to be very clear about what we know and don't know. So in my response to Ray above I didn't want to call the blue (surf green) "O'Brady" 1-row box a "Walters" -- I reserve that identification for instruments actually labeled with Walters' name.
But here's a wrinkle -- photos were recently sent to me of a "littermate" of the O'Brady box. I'm hoping to see better photos eventually but the ones I have show the other one as lime green and with a fancy Walters logo applied to the surface.
I have the O'Brady box here now and see no evidence that it ever had a Walters logo applied. But it is possible that there was an externally applied logo like the one on the lime-green box, that it fell off and that any glue residue was polished away.
Interim pics attached below, with permission of the photographer:
PG