Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning  (Read 1345 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

rileyismycopilot

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 27
Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning
« on: July 20, 2025, 10:42:05 PM »

Hi gang,

I'll have some fettling to be done on a 2915 / Pokerwork soon, and I've been reading about the various tuning options.

The viennese tuning (aka Dedic) seems like an interesting idea and some folks swear by it.
BUT.....
The whole concept behind this method of tuning assumes that human ear / brain "calculates" the mean frequency between the two closely pitched sounds.
Example: if reed 1 sounds at 440 Hz and reed 2 sounds at 444 Hz, the brain will hear a 442 Hz pitch.

But is it really how it works? Was it ever proved by studies and empirical proofing?


In my experience, the brain tends to hear the higher pitch of the two as a "base sound" or reference sound, the rest being considered flat.
Example: in a session, when an instrument that is higher pitched comes in (tin whistle tuned to 442+ Hz come to mind), it seems like all the other players sound flat in comparison.

According to this reasoning, having the two MM banks of reeds in an accordion tuned MM- would make sense (the M bank would be the base sound, in tune with the other instruments, while the M- bank would add some thickness to the sound).

What do you think? Have you ever conducted some experiments of this kind?

Thanks!
Victor
Logged

Squeezebox Of Delights

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 81
Re: Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning
« Reply #1 on: July 20, 2025, 11:24:11 PM »

I have a large and lovely professional-level Frontalini PA, LMMH tuned, from the late 30s. Each voice is controlled by an on/off toggle switch, built into the edge of the keyboard. The order is L, M-, M, H, and it took me a bit of getting used to! I'm pretty sure all my other boxes with two middle reeds are tuned MM+. Still, nothing about the tuning jumped out at me as being different to an MM+ box. It's swing tuned, which I imagine makes a difference - If it had a big fat German style tremolo the effect would probably be a lot more noticeable. Then again, I haven't played it for a while, so maybe if I picked it back up I'd notice!
Logged
Oops! All Hohners

tirpous

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1403
Re: Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning
« Reply #2 on: July 21, 2025, 12:32:17 AM »

In mathematics there is a 'trigonometric identity' that shows that the sum of 2 sinewaves of frequencies A and B is the same as a sinewave of frequency (A+B)/2 whose amplitude varies at a frequency (A-B)/2 .

This is not about the brain or ear imagining things: record a note from an MM melodeon and look at the soundwave, you can see it (the 442 Hz wave) for yourself.
Logged

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning
« Reply #3 on: July 21, 2025, 08:13:49 AM »

Almost any box with triple M will have M0M-M+, and you can sometimes toggle between M0M+ M0M- (as sometimes the Ms are de-tuned by different amounts - not necessarily a good idea). I can't say that I could hear a difference when I had a M0M+10M-10 box.
On many higher end accordions you can also pick M-M+ but it does not tend to sound nice (because of the amount of musette on two reeds rather than the averaging itself) I.e. on the mentioned box instead of 10c musette you'd get 20c on two reeds (ouch, my ears!).
There's certainly a huge difference between M0M+ and M0M+M-, i.e. 3-voice musette vs 2-voice musette. At higher de-tunings (say, 14-20c. We're not talking Scottish 25c here >:E) 3-voice sounds like a wave rolling to the shore, while 2-voice sounds like a butterfly bashing itself violently against a glass.

I wondered about our interpretation of MM pitch myself - I guess as long as our brain can hear the master M, it interprets the other one as tremolo effect, regardless of whether it's higher or lower.

You can try averaging the pitch on an MM box, but throw in L0 or H0 and at moderate musette, then your box will be out of tune and play like, say, LM-M+, or even worse, LM+ (Which is also a possible option on 5-voice accordions by the way).
« Last Edit: July 21, 2025, 08:20:36 AM by mChavez »
Logged

Rog

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2525
  • Repair and tuning in Hants
Re: Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning
« Reply #4 on: July 21, 2025, 09:53:40 PM »

If a musette M-, M, M+ is tuned asymmetrically, and has enough register buttons, it's possible to get a selection of tremolo sounds. If for instance the M- is 7cents flat of A=440Hz and the M+ reed is 14 cents sharp, you can get a nice swing tremolo with M- and M selected, and a more pronounced tremolo with M and M+ selected. And obvs a rough warble with M- and M+ selected, and then the full musette experience with all three selected. And I'm not making this up…it's quite common on big PAs, and takes a little bit of time and thought to get the tuning right.

rileyismycopilot

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 27
Re: Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning
« Reply #5 on: July 23, 2025, 12:20:56 AM »

I have a large and lovely professional-level Frontalini PA, LMMH tuned, from the late 30s. Each voice is controlled by an on/off toggle switch, built into the edge of the keyboard. The order is L, M-, M, H, and it took me a bit of getting used to! I'm pretty sure all my other boxes with two middle reeds are tuned MM+. Still, nothing about the tuning jumped out at me as being different to an MM+ box. It's swing tuned, which I imagine makes a difference - If it had a big fat German style tremolo the effect would probably be a lot more noticeable. Then again, I haven't played it for a while, so maybe if I picked it back up I'd notice!

Wow, I'd love to hear this box. Please let us know if you can compare the tuning to a more conventional MM+ accordion.


In mathematics there is a 'trigonometric identity' that shows that the sum of 2 sinewaves of frequencies A and B is the same as a sinewave of frequency (A+B)/2 whose amplitude varies at a frequency (A-B)/2 .

This is not about the brain or ear imagining things: record a note from an MM melodeon and look at the soundwave, you can see it (the 442 Hz wave) for yourself.

This is very interesting and certainly would give the nod to the Viennese / Dedic tuning system.

However, this seems very theoretical to me, and if the 2 sine waves can be added up / combined through a maths function, it does not necessarily mean that 2 notes from 2 different reeds add up to a "middle one" in the real world.
Case in point 1. If I play a C note and an E note together, the two notes won't combine into a D note.
Case in point 2. I have a 1 row with stops and MM+ arrangement. My electronic tuner app can certainly "hear" the M frequency, then the M+ frequency. However, when I play the 2 together, my app can't stick to a single frequency, the needle moves from one to the other constantly. It certainly does not stay in the middle.

This last little experiment leads me to think that a MM+ read arrangement is heard as a "thicker sound" PLUS an oscillation between the M and M+ pitches.
AFAIK, an oscillation between an M (reference frequency) and M+ (higher frequency) is no good at all. This is why violonists never do vibrato going up-pitch. THey start on the note, then go down, then up to the note, then down again and so on.

All this really makes me want to try an MM- accordion :)

BTW Tirpous, I'm just trying to understand things, and not at all dismiss your data, which is very interesting.



If a musette M-, M, M+ is tuned asymmetrically, and has enough register buttons, it's possible to get a selection of tremolo sounds. If for instance the M- is 7cents flat of A=440Hz and the M+ reed is 14 cents sharp, you can get a nice swing tremolo with M- and M selected, and a more pronounced tremolo with M and M+ selected. And obvs a rough warble with M- and M+ selected, and then the full musette experience with all three selected. And I'm not making this up…it's quite common on big PAs, and takes a little bit of time and thought to get the tuning right.

Rog, that would be an ideal basis of comparison. Have you ever had the chance to compare the two? Which (MM+ or MM-) sounds more in tune to you?
« Last Edit: July 23, 2025, 12:31:34 AM by rileyismycopilot »
Logged

Rog

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2525
  • Repair and tuning in Hants
Re: Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning
« Reply #6 on: July 24, 2025, 07:44:08 AM »

“ Which (MM+ or MM-) sounds more in tune to you?”

Interesting question, tbh I can't remember (it’s a while since I thought about it). It depends on the size of the offset, obvs. I have a feeling the flat tuned tremolo sounded sweeter/more in tune when combined with a L reed, and I wondered why more boxes aren't tuned that way. I once encountered a two reed M- M tuning on a 1930s Hohner PA.
What I can say though is that Dirk's Accordion tuner has a facility to set up an asymmetric MMM tuning. You can select which is the concert reed (to have M M+ M++, or M- M and M+, with a % offset (which is a bit annoying because if you want a particular cent offset at A5 for instance, you have to monkey about with that % to find it, rather than just set it). But this kind of tuning is an 'edge case' I think, so it's does the job but isn't too sophisticated.

Microbot

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 345
Re: Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning
« Reply #7 on: July 24, 2025, 09:40:29 AM »


 This is why violonists never do vibrato going up-pitch. THey start on the note, then go down, then up to the note, then down again and so on.


That’s actually not the case! Traditional violin instruction is indeed that vibrato should be pitch/below pitch, however there is lots of violin discussion available - based on recordings of great players - that observes and recommends a balance between below and above pitch for good vibrato technique... Ie the Viennese/Dedic balance.

I was once asked to work on an M- Mo BC with about 10 cents offset …it was a small Cairdin with Cicarelli reeds as I recall … it had a beautiful tone, but was perceptibly flat against the chords, which were at concert pitch, just as many Mo/M+ boxes are perceptibly sharp against their chords! None of which is very surprising.

I am not a fan of all aspects of Dedic tuning - however when a box has its treble pitch matched to the basses and chords on the basic principle of Dedic/Viennese tuning - boy, does it sing!

Cheers!

Mike R
« Last Edit: July 25, 2025, 07:04:48 AM by Microbot »
Logged

rileyismycopilot

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 27
Re: Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning
« Reply #8 on: July 24, 2025, 10:35:50 PM »


 This is why violonists never do vibrato going up-pitch. THey start on the note, then go down, then up to the note, then down again and so on.


That’s actually not the case! Traditional violin instruction is indeed that vibrato should be pitch/below pitch, however there is lots of violin discussion available - based on recordings of great players - that observes and recommends a balance between below and above pitch for good vibrato technique... Ie the Viennese/Dedic balance.

Very interesting Mike. I'll have to look into this.


I was once asked to work on an M- Mo BC with about 10 cents offset …it was a small Cairdin with Cicarelli reeds as I recall … it had a beautiful tone, but was perceptively flat against the chords, which were at concert pitch, just as many Mo/M+ boxes are perceptively sharp against their chords! None of which is very surprising.

That's one data point. Good to know.

I am not a fan of all aspects of Dedic tuning - however when a box has its treble pitch matched to the basses and chords on the basic principle of Dedic/Viennese tuning - boy, does it sing!

The Dedic constant tremolo thing sounds plain weird to me, as if the lower notes have way too much musette and the higher notes only a light swing.
However, I'll definitely have to try for myself and have my next MM box retuned to viennese (not Dedic) tuning.

Are tuning tables available for the viennese tuning?
I guess in my neck of the wood, accordion techs have never heard of it.

Thanks for sharing, cheers!
Logged

Microbot

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 345
Re: Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning
« Reply #9 on: July 24, 2025, 11:12:55 PM »


The Dedic constant tremolo thing sounds plain weird to me, as if the lower notes have way too much musette and the higher notes only a light swing.
However, I'll definitely have to try for myself and have my next MM box retuned to viennese (not Dedic) tuning.

Yes, that’s one issue …. the constant tremolo-rate principle creates an imperative that doesn’t square with the way reeds ‘behave nicely’ up the octaves… but that doesn’t mean you have to have a rabid top-end …

When you next fine-tune, Just work to ‘what sounds right’. Use your ear …

 â€¦ then assess/analyse what you’ve done

Mike
Logged

Squeaky Pete

  • Squeaky Pete
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1327
  • Re-hohn a Hohner
Re: Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning
« Reply #10 on: July 25, 2025, 09:18:52 AM »




The Dedic constant tremolo thing sounds plain weird to me, as if the lower notes have way too much musette and the higher notes only a light swing.
However, I'll definitely have to try for myself and have my next MM box retuned to viennese (not Dedic) tuning.

Are tuning tables available for the viennese tuning?
I guess in my neck of the wood, accordion techs have never heard of it.

Thanks for sharing, cheers!
Steve Freereeder posted his tuning curve. It's at the bottom of a reply he made on this thread.
https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=26461.0
This does actually work very well, particularly for Hohners.
Logged
Poker work DG.
Pariselle 2.6 DG, Ex-Club IIIBS CF,
Matching Liliputs in CF and DG,
Lots of sickly Hohners needing TLC,
Bassoon, Various Bagpipes........

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning
« Reply #11 on: July 26, 2025, 05:24:38 PM »


 This is why violonists never do vibrato going up-pitch. THey start on the note, then go down, then up to the note, then down again and so on.


That’s actually not the case! Traditional violin instruction is indeed that vibrato should be pitch/below pitch, however there is lots of violin discussion available - based on recordings of great players - that observes and recommends a balance between below and above pitch for good vibrato technique... Ie the Viennese/Dedic balance.

Very interesting Mike. I'll have to look into this.


I was once asked to work on an M- Mo BC with about 10 cents offset …it was a small Cairdin with Cicarelli reeds as I recall … it had a beautiful tone, but was perceptively flat against the chords, which were at concert pitch, just as many Mo/M+ boxes are perceptively sharp against their chords! None of which is very surprising.

That's one data point. Good to know.

I am not a fan of all aspects of Dedic tuning - however when a box has its treble pitch matched to the basses and chords on the basic principle of Dedic/Viennese tuning - boy, does it sing!

The Dedic constant tremolo thing sounds plain weird to me, as if the lower notes have way too much musette and the higher notes only a light swing.
However, I'll definitely have to try for myself and have my next MM box retuned to viennese (not Dedic) tuning.

Are tuning tables available for the viennese tuning?
I guess in my neck of the wood, accordion techs have never heard of it.

Thanks for sharing, cheers!

The most important thing is to have the mean pitch of the two reeds (M- M+) at concert pitch all along the keyboard, so octaves are true and all are in pitch with the basses.

The exact amount of tremolo is then personal preference -- I prefer it to be (roughly!) constant (about 4bps) all the way along, others (including Martyn White who tunes my boxes) prefer a bit lower rate at the low end (3bps?) and a bit higher at the top end (5bps?). Both work just fine... ;-)

The reason for a reasonably fast tremolo is to get maximum punch/audibility without sounding too warbly, and this is a tradeoff. Various research papers looked into tremolo rates for both opera singers and violins in the pre-amplification days and concluded that they mostly used quite fast tremolo (about 7bps) regardless of pitch because this got the absolute maximum perceived volume (like the old Scottish accordion tuning!), but this does sound rough to modern ears. I tried out different beat rates with synthsized reeds and decided I like about 4bps as a good compromise between volume and sounding nice, the exact number isn't that critical -- however less than 3bps definitely decreased volume/audibility, and more than 5bps started to sound that bit too warbly... ;-)
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses

rileyismycopilot

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 27
Re: Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning
« Reply #12 on: July 27, 2025, 11:18:33 PM »

Steve Freereeder posted his tuning curve. It's at the bottom of a reply he made on this thread.
https://forum.melodeon.net/index.php?topic=26461.0
This does actually work very well, particularly for Hohners.

Got it! Thanks so much Pete (and Steve).

How should I proceed if I want more musette?
BTW what would be the highest amount of acceptable musette for a 2 voice instrument?
(measured in cents at A440)
Logged

IanD

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1703
  • Too many melodeons...
Re: Has anyone ever tried MM- tuning? + Viennese tuning
« Reply #13 on: August 09, 2025, 05:19:53 PM »

Thinking of musette detuning in cents isn't very helpful, beats per second is what the ear actually perceives with two detuned reeds, not absolute pitch perception which is where cents come in.

Like I said above it's all a matter of personal taste and whether you want to prioritise apparent volume or musical sweetness. Apparent volume increases up to about 7bps, beyond this is doesn't get any louder but sounds unpleasant -- in fact to most modern ears 7bps (what some of the old 2v accordions seemed to use going by 1930s recordings) is too fast.
Logged
Oakwood Model 4 D/G, Castagnari Dony D/G/#, Castagnari Tommy G/C, Baffetti Binci D/G, Hohner Preciosa D/G, Melos Bb/Eb, Lightwave SL5 and Kala California fretless basses
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal