Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2   Go Down

Author Topic: C#DG vs DG+accidentals  (Read 1781 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Joe G

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7
C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« on: September 18, 2025, 02:34:24 PM »

I'm theory crafting at the moment, wondering about things beyond my budget, but for some time I've thought my dream box would be a Castagnari Mory using Paul Young's cunning layout for playing in different keys. However, I've more recently become aware of Tim Edey's equally cunning C#DG shenanigans.

For basses, I thought that using Paul's layout, but reversing the Eb/F# and Bb/F pairs would allow a C#DG to come to the best of both worlds. I was unable to find out what Tim's basses are, if he even has a standard favourite layout.

I'm hoping that those with more experience of such things might be able to advise on the relative strengths and weaknesses. Thus far my squeezy experience, apart from starting on Bayan and a little dabbling here and there has been purely with DG standard layout with accidentals.
Logged

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #1 on: September 18, 2025, 04:14:39 PM »

I modified my Mory twice before I moved to Paul Young's layout.
Before moving I kept realising I couldn't play what I wanted to, but Paul's layout would solve whichever problem in the tune I was currently looking at.
I just wish I'd have gone to it straight away, but hindsight is a great thing.

As ever it boils down to what tunes you want to play.
I want to play some of the tunes found in older manuscripts, 'John of the Greeny' etc. in mainly flat keys.
Paul's layout enables me to do this quite well and also have a Low G keyboard layout similar to my 2 row for normal DG tunes.
If your musical direction is towards tunes such as these I can recommend Paul's layout.
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #2 on: September 18, 2025, 04:27:39 PM »

  I followed the latter path. Bought an Oakwood C#DG in 2004 reckoning that C# would be a fantastic source of accidentals.
   It is a semitone away from D, and a triton away from G.  And so it proved! It was also fantastic in C

  incredibly one of the most fluid scales is B flat. major, minor, blues, bebop, whatever. So there are decisions is to be made on the left end.
 
  The previous owner was using it to play Irish in C#D mode, but still being able to join in English sessions and play for Morris.

   After about 18 months I filed a couple of notes on the outer row to get pull F, and D, and I've been playing that way ever since.

   It is fully chromatic on the pull apart from Ab , but that lies on a common button with B flat so you can often work around with
   a flick of the Bellows if you want to planes e.g. C minor.    I subsequently ordered an F#GC "same system" for when I'm in France.

  Highly recommended.(There is no rule that you have to have your accidentals on the in a row)?
  They lie very easily under the fingers,  and  you can essentially flatten any note on the D row "at will" 🙂
« Last Edit: September 18, 2025, 04:29:56 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #3 on: September 18, 2025, 04:44:40 PM »

I can understand folks who have played diatonic for years wanting to expand into non-native keys, so they try out different layouts that build on their accumulated experience. But if you already play the bayan and want to play in different keys, why not persevere with the bayan?
Personally, I've switched from bayan to diatonic because I don't have time to practice and diatonic provides tonnes of fun in home keys without the need to spend 2 hrs a day practicing scales and arpeggios, but if I wanted to venture into non-native keys, I'd just pick up the bayan again.

Imho the whole point of a diatonic is that it's a walk in the park to play in home keys it's designed for. But playing in more keys is unnatural and requires a lot more effort than doing it on a CBA that only requires you to learn 2 fingering patters for all 12 keys if it's a 5-row.
« Last Edit: September 18, 2025, 04:46:39 PM by mChavez »
Logged

Joe G

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #4 on: September 18, 2025, 04:52:46 PM »

Thanks for the insights! It's interesting to see arguments for both ways of doing things.

In part, my problem is that I'm trying to futureproof with my choice, as I want to end up with a box that will do whatever I will want, when I'm not sure what that might be, rather than a number that will do it between them.

But if you already play the bayan and want to play in different keys, why not persevere with the bayan?
You make an excellent point. I like the idea of playing CBA, but in reality, the simple physicality of it means I haven't played my Bayan for more than a few minutes here and there since I started playing lovely (comparatively) light melodeons. The result of that is that I'm more used to diatonic at this stage. Not that I don't still lust after things like the Saltarelle Chaville :)

I also want to be able to keep playing for Morris with whatever I choose, so a DG variant seems the way to go.

Before moving I kept realising I couldn't play what I wanted to, but Paul's layout would solve whichever problem in the tune I was currently looking at.

That's promising - definitely a sign of an effective system :)

  incredibly one of the most fluid scales is B flat. major, minor, blues, bebop, whatever. So there are decisions is to be made on the left end.

Interesting - yes, I find the basses are not easy to decide on! It's always going to be a compromise, so I'll need to have a clearer picture of which keys I want to prioritise.
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #5 on: September 18, 2025, 05:43:29 PM »


 If you can afford it, the Grenoble system 18 bass is fantastic. You get 12 chords with C and D both ways. But there are then enough spare buttons to have all 12 bases in both directions. 

  Any music, the bass is critical to your ears' interpretation  context (meaning) of the lyrical line being played. Which is why all jazz Trios have a bass player. You can experiment for yourself by playing the favourite tunes on the right without touching any chords on the left. It still works? 👍

   Castagnari now do the Grenoble base, notably on their mass model.

 If you go for a 12 base there are lots of systems at work. We need to make a decision whether you want to play keys that are "flat' of DG. i.e C, F, Bb and their modes?  or go sharp … A, E and their modes.  But the 18 bass works with both.
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

richard.fleming

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 556
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #6 on: September 18, 2025, 06:03:12 PM »


  "
  "the previous owner was using it to play Irish in C#D mode, but still being able to join in English sessions and play for Morris"

 Playing Morris tunes on a C#D box is of course straightforward, frequently easy.

 
Logged
Old Paolo Sopranis in C#/D and D/D#

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #7 on: September 18, 2025, 08:26:38 PM »


  I'm sure it is, but I had learned my Morris tunes on a staightforward D/G. and I'd never mastered a  B/C or C#/D machine.

  I'm saying that you can use a C# row as a superb and sytemic  source of accidentals.
  And in filing my pull C# to D … I think I lost what is generally called the magic button?

   What I get from my approach is a whole load of scales, generally on the pool or playable with a flick, (that have to be learned).
   And a very large gambit of right hand chords. That suits me particularly because I mainly use my melodeon to company song.

  "it depends on your repertoire" … as always with decisions on diatonic instruments.
 
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #8 on: September 19, 2025, 10:28:41 AM »


In part, my problem is that I'm trying to futureproof with my choice, as I want to end up with a box that will do whatever I will want, when I'm not sure what that might be, rather than a number that will do it between them.


Sorry to say it, but to me, honestly, this sounds as an unrealistic goal.

All the melodeon based instruments have limitations. Even the pretty flexible ones like the G/C/B with Stradella basses played by Emil Vacher – plenty about him in a recent thread – were quickly replaced by the cba and the piano accordions when the early musette developed into the popular ballroom dance music we know today.

You can only chose to conceive a keyboard layout that works very well in a limited number of contests.

Given this, as far as my experience goes, a 2 1/2 instrument can definitely be played in a few keys outside the home ones, but at a price. You won't be able to play it like a real melodeon!

On my 2 ½ row G/C box I'm able to play in F, Bb and Eb, and I think in the related modal scales, although I haven't seriously explored that option. And for the tunes in an harmonic minor scale I've learned a few in A minor, G minor, E minor, C minor and D minor.

The problem is that, except for the F scale and the A harmonic minor scale – that on a D/G based box transposes to C and E minor -, I can't rely on the fingering patterns I've developed along the years playing in the home keys, and that work pretty well on a three row box in three key like my A/D/G too.

While to learn to play correctly the melodies, in itself,  it's just a matter of practice, most of the embellishment and the minor variations that I automatically throw in plying in the home keys don't work any more.

A couple of matters of fact I've found out on my G/C 2 ½ row.

First, a five button half row is too short. I realised after a while that six additional buttons were a game changer, and I never had a reason to regret to change my instument. But on a D/G based box, unless maybe it's a fourth button start, things might be different.

Second: even if most of the ready made layout offered by the makers, that reflect the choices of an handful of widely respected players, the additional basses are added at the top of the LH keyboard, which is good if you wish to play tunes in the home keys that use accidentals,  I've opted for adding them at the bottom, and that's definitely a more functional choice to play outside the home keys.

But of course I have no doubt that other players that have an experience with boxes with different keyboard layouts, and/or play different kinds on music on them, will fiercely disagree with me.  And the best for it!  ;)

Then the suggestion I can give you, an that I gave before in other threads, considering the price of a new good quality instrument and the time and the costs in case you wish to change afterwards the keyboard layouts, is to find a midi instrument. A Roland  FR-18 isn't an acceptable replacement for a real box, but I've found it's good enough to practice late at night avoiding the risks of a divorce and to be murdered  by the neighbours, and will offer you the chance to experiment with any different keyboard layout you could think of. A second hand FR-18 shouldn't be too expensive, and in case could be resold more or less at the price you pay for it.


Logged

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #9 on: September 19, 2025, 10:56:47 AM »

Further to GBbox's initial comments:
I had no idea where my musical journey would take me. It took several years of indecision and lots of chats with friends, many on here, before I moved from a 2 row 8 bass box to explore different tunes for my own pleasure.

At the start, I just wanted to play common English tunes with others, still do in fact. Also along the way other influences and getting to know my instrument better has pulled me in other directions.

I'm not sure if you can plan ahead and get a melodeon to fit *all* your future requirements.
Better to plan for your immediate future maybe?
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #10 on: September 19, 2025, 11:48:47 AM »


In part, my problem is that I'm trying to futureproof with my choice, as I want to end up with a box that will do whatever I will want, when I'm not sure what that might be, rather than a number that will do it between them.


Just to emphasise what the previous two contributors have said.

The diatonic box is a limited instrument whatever way you modify it.  Many people have thought about this and tried to design a universal note layout, but I cant think of anyone who has done it. 
A more fruitful approach is to start off with a relatively simple instrument and an open mind and enjoy the process of learning and making musical discoveries.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #11 on: September 19, 2025, 12:09:49 PM »


  Don't lose too much sleep about 'the future". By the time you come to those problems your skills will have improved and you will find the easy fixes.

  An extremis. If some note in the tune is impossible to do in for some mechanical reason just miss it out. I once sat under a Sycamore tree
  in the gounds of St Chartier castle, watching the Quebec master Philippe Bruneau and instructed a French protégé. I think he had just moved
  to metropolitan France.

  He played in 6 different keys and it sounded absolutely fine. Not a note wrong? Except the notes weren't there. He was on a D 1-row!
« Last Edit: September 19, 2025, 06:16:01 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Fionn

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 194
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #12 on: September 19, 2025, 12:46:33 PM »


 An extremis. If some note in the tune is impossible to do in for some mechanical reason just miss it out.

As a whistle player I agree. You either take a detour around the notes you can't play – which becomes almost automatic after a while – or you reach for a different whistle.

There isn't another satisfactory way to do it, not without turning it into a wholly different instrument. Its limitations are an essential part of its character.
Logged
Vintage Double Ray C#/D

penn

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 574
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #13 on: September 19, 2025, 01:24:53 PM »


I also want to be able to keep playing for Morris with whatever I choose, so a DG variant seems the way to go.


I would buy a small & cheaper 2 row d/g for morris ie like a pokerwork. I wouldn’t want to be hauling an expensive and heavy 3 row box around a morris day event. A pokerwork would be louder too.

Then keep your three row for playing at home, sessions etc where volume and size are less of a consideration.
Just my 2p worth  (:)
Gren
Logged
Hohners, Dino Baffetti, Lilly, Benny + a lot of junk.

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #14 on: September 19, 2025, 04:23:39 PM »


 An extremis. If some note in the tune is impossible to do in for some mechanical reason just miss it out.

As a whistle player I agree. You either take a detour around the notes you can't play – which becomes almost automatic after a while – or you reach for a different whistle.

There isn't another satisfactory way to do it, not without turning it into a wholly different instrument. Its limitations are an essential part of its character.

I think you're right, for the reasons I've explained in my previous post, when you say that adding a number of reversals and accidentals to a two row melodeon in other to play in a number of different keys turns it into a wholly different instrument, although it could help with a couple of them.

But the detour around notes you don't have might work with the whistles, or with the one row melodeons – Kimmel and the Wyper brothers were mastering the technique well before Bruneau, but they all usually played with a piano accompanist in charge of the chord progressions.

On 2 ½ or 3 row instruments to avoid using the left hand for me makes little sense. An Irish button box played using just the RH keyboard would probably be a better choice... but wouldn't sound as a melodeon at all!

Logged

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #15 on: September 19, 2025, 09:54:20 PM »

Regarding the question of whether or not persevere with the bayan (or any fully unisonoric instrument) compared to playing a bisonoric (irrespective of the layout) instrument : for playing accordion from the one-row melodeon to the CBA, there are some aspects of playing that are difficult to reproduce on the CBA (that is, on paper, a superior instrument on many intellectual regards). On the whole, I think playing CBA is more demanding mentally. Even on keys far from the home keys. For instance I have to think constantly about managing rests in the music, whereas on a diatonic accordion I have no choice but to have breaks in the phrasing for organlogical reasons. Similarly, I constantly have to think about how the music is constructed, whereas on a diatonic accordion it's all more of an organic/instinctive approach.

What I'm trying to say is that it does not sum up as a list of rational pros and cons. Wanting to have an "all-terrain" melodeon is not necessarily a bad option, and it is a legitimate concern. I often compare the diatonic accordion (especially the 3-row models) to the clarinet. It's most comfortable on the home key, but it can also play in other keys, and people usually work on their instrument to make it happen; if that's becoming excessively hard they sometime use clarinets in other keys for some pieces. I feel that the same goes for the melodeon.
I often play tunes in G#, Bb minor or C# on my G/C, it's a bit of work, but honestly not that more than a piece in the home keys (what's difficult is making music out of any given tune), it's a different note pattern and so forth, but it's part of playing that instrument all the same. Obviously it will not sound the same as the same piece played in a pull-push style on a one-row, but I don't really mind: in the end if the music is enjoyable and you like it, it's all that matters. That the same music would be, for some aspects, perhaps easier to play (that point is highly arguable, imo) on another instrument (be it a CBA or a melodeon in another key) doesn't seem really important to me.
« Last Edit: September 19, 2025, 09:56:44 PM by -Y- »
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #16 on: September 20, 2025, 12:37:35 PM »


  One of the pleasures of our instument (for me) is that so often when you give the bellows a little shake … something musically rather nice happens

  Many of the more rumbustuous 2-row players geniuses as this method of ornamentation, and it is sort of built into the instrument you are playing in the main row keys/modes.

  As I have moved progressively onto three rows since 1984 I've been amazed at how often that works, or can be made to work on the larger instrument. I tend to play flat keys and I use my helper row Ac/Bb and F/F buttons a lot to achieve that. I would get so far to say that I wouldn't be without an F/F!

  The CBA and Bayan have that axiomatically. But the fun comes out of the change of notes against the constant F? 

  Lots of other little tricks that you discover as you go along. And yes, it's all a bit idiosyncratic.  But the bellows is on a CBA or PA are so heavy that you can't use them to generate music at all. And to my ear the  results can sometimes sound rather flat,  unless the player is skilled.
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Joe G

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #17 on: September 20, 2025, 06:54:35 PM »

Wow, thank you all so much for all this insight! I'm very glad I asked this question, this has been an interesting read, and it's clear that there's far more to it than I first thought.

He played in 6 different keys and it sounded absolutely fine. Not a note wrong? Except the notes weren't there. He was on a D 1-row!

This certainly drives that point home. In dreaming of fancier instruments I feel I might be missing the more important point - that musicianship wins out, and if someone really knows what they're doing on a two row DG, they'll quite possibly do a better job than someone with less knowledge on a CBA. I do want to be able to accompany what I play with the left hand, so more basses would eventually be necessary, but the point definitely stands.

I wouldn’t want to be hauling an expensive and heavy 3 row box around a morris day event. A pokerwork would be louder too.
A very good point - even if I found the magical box that would do it all musically, it wouldn't necessarily be wise to do it all with it!

As for my original quandary - if I'm sensible, it's moved a few miles further down the road now!
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #18 on: September 22, 2025, 09:42:17 AM »


   It's been quite a long journey for all of us and you never stop learning.

   The old Irish joke that "I wouldn't start from here" does not apply.

   Melnet is an incredible resource. Try using its search facility for specific problems. It will almost certainly be there …
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

TomB-R

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 598
Re: C#DG vs DG+accidentals
« Reply #19 on: September 23, 2025, 05:14:14 PM »

..... I often compare the diatonic accordion (especially the 3-row models) to the clarinet. It's most comfortable on the home key, but it can also play in other keys, and people usually work on their instrument to make it happen; if that's becoming excessively hard they sometime use clarinets in other keys for some pieces. I feel that the same goes for the melodeon.
"Up to a point Lord Copper." It's true that the clarinet has been the only mainstream orchestral instrument to exist in two transposing versions, the "Standard" Bb and the A, one semitone lower. On the other hand, many orchestral players are now so fluently chromatic that they play everything on the Bb, even though that means they are transposing music written for the A instrument. Some professional level Bb clarinets are now made with an extension down one semitone at the bottom of the range so that they can play the bottom note of an A clarinet. As an "intermediate" at best clarinet player I'm fairly OK from four flats to four sharps and all the keys between.
Anyway, back to melodeons with apologies!
Logged
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal