Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2   Go Down

Author Topic: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics  (Read 1878 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Sharon

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 165
Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« on: October 24, 2025, 05:05:45 PM »

Would it be possible to have a separate discussion area for advanced theory stuff? I don't think it's appropriate to be delving into super obscure scales/modes/jazz theory for most discussions and I think it can just get overwhelming for anyone not familiar with - or interested in - looking at these topics in more detail.
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #1 on: October 24, 2025, 06:11:56 PM »


  Good idea.
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

rees

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5055
  • Windjammer
    • Wesson Accordions
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #2 on: October 24, 2025, 06:53:15 PM »

Definitely.
Logged
Rees Wesson (accordion builder and mechanic)
Gungrog, Welshpool, Wales, UK
www.melodeons.com

Winston Smith

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4066
  • AKA Edward Jennings
    • "Our Luxor B&B" Luxor life, slice by slice.
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #3 on: October 24, 2025, 07:31:55 PM »

Oh, I don't know! I read all the posts, and often find myself utterly befuddled. Which makes me laugh that such a simple instrument (I'm talking mainly 1 row here) can become soooo complicated in the right hands.
Logged
At last, broken and resigned to accept conformity.
Oh, how I LOVE Big Brother!

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #4 on: October 24, 2025, 07:59:10 PM »

I see two problems.

FIRST, the threads aren't usually started to discuss the theory in itself, but about a tune. Then, if someone wishes to make a comment that involves some music theory, he/she should actually start another thread using the same topic adding eventually to it ATT (advanced theory topics)?

SECOND, when actually a music theory comment becomes obscure?
Telling the dominant 7chord resolves on the tonic is to be considered bscure? I hope not!
Telling the minor 7 chords resolve usually down a fifth/up a fourth, or otherwise you need to resolve the seventh, the note that creates the instability, and the sevenths always resolve down a tone on the scale, is obscure? I can see a lot of people scratching their heads.
Or, for the matter, telling that you never add the seventh to the tonic chord because it would loose its tonic function, that's a pillar in the tonal harmony theoty, is obscure?
Not for me, but I remember Chris once  challenged the statement telling in jazz harmony this in is not the case.
What should we do then? Check before posting with the moderators? Or maybe appoint Sharon, Chris and Rees as a committee to sort things out?   ;D

« Last Edit: October 24, 2025, 08:07:17 PM by GBbox »
Logged

Squeaky Pete

  • Squeaky Pete
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1327
  • Re-hohn a Hohner
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #5 on: October 24, 2025, 08:08:12 PM »

As soon as it goes off topic with a big paragraph, I'm out. Especially if I see the next post is even longer.
Logged
Poker work DG.
Pariselle 2.6 DG, Ex-Club IIIBS CF,
Matching Liliputs in CF and DG,
Lots of sickly Hohners needing TLC,
Bassoon, Various Bagpipes........

Helena Handcart

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2452
  • Saltarelle Nell
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #6 on: October 24, 2025, 08:20:30 PM »

As soon as it goes off topic with a big paragraph, I'm out. Especially if I see the next post is even longer.

Yup, I guess it's the same as for any other part of the forum, posts that stray too far off-topic can be moved to a different section for those that wish to continue the discussion. I think it would work.
Logged
Saltarelle Le Romané  | Saltarelle Nuage | Oakwood | various elderly Hohners

Ignatius Blumenfeld

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 20
  • I need another melodeon...
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #7 on: October 24, 2025, 08:54:25 PM »

SECOND, when actually a music theory comment becomes obscure?
Telling the dominant 7chord resolves on the tonic is to be considered bscure? I hope not!
Telling the minor 7 chords resolve usually down a fifth/up a fourth, or otherwise you need to resolve the seventh, the note that creates the instability, and the sevenths always resolve down a tone on the scale, is obscure? I can see a lot of people scratching their heads.
Or, for the matter, telling that you never add the seventh to the tonic chord because it would loose its tonic function, that's a pillar in the tonal harmony theoty, is obscure?
Not for me, but I remember Chris once  challenged the statement telling in jazz harmony this in is not the case.

I personally think it to be very obscure as I really don't know what you mean. I just play the melodeon...I don't delve into stuff like that even if it intrigues me. It's just pretty confusing.  (:)
Logged
Hohner Pokerwork G/C, M. Hohner one-row F, old Novitat Accordeon (parts),

Sharon

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 165
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #8 on: October 25, 2025, 03:28:38 AM »

What should we do then? Check before posting with the moderators? Or maybe appoint Sharon, Chris and Rees as a committee to sort things out?   ;D

Do you deliberately set out to be obnoxious? You obviously enjoy winding people up but what you are actually doing is spoiling what could be a really nice place for people to ask for help and advice and to give encouragement to people learning box. They need help which is appropriate to their current level - this shouldn't be seen by you and others as an opportunity to show off about how much music theory you know. It's really not impressive - it's boring. Take it somewhere else.
Logged

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #9 on: October 25, 2025, 09:19:35 AM »


I personally think it to be very obscure as I really don't know what you mean. I just play the melodeon...I don't delve into stuff like that even if it intrigues me. It's just pretty confusing.  (:)

It's an attitude I understand and respect. I can't tell I share it, as far as the melodeon is concerned, but I do about my car. I am a competent driver, but I have no clue at all about what happens under the hood.  (:)

But please note, when I have a problem I knock on the door of my trusted mechanic, and I pay respect to his knowledge.

Logged

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #10 on: October 25, 2025, 09:26:36 AM »


Do you deliberately set out to be obnoxious?


No, definitely I'm not. I simply consider myself entitled, when someone say something that sounds ridiculous, to replay with a joke.

The Ignatio Blumenfeld's post demonstrates that you can't simply draw a line and decide than until you reach it a musical theory topic is clear, and then becomes obscure. Then, should we consider the idea to ban any reference to any musical theory concept outside a dedicated section of the forum? This for me would be meaningless.

And no, I don't think that  those looking for advice should just receive suggestions “that are appropriate to their current level”. It's showing what they could do more when they grow to an higher level that can help them improving.

And finally no. I'm not interested to show how much music theory I know to impress anybody. I aam ctually willing to share my music knowledge with anybody who might be interested in learning. Those who aren't can simply behave as the adults we are all supposed to be, and ignore what I write. I surely won't mourn about that. There are tons of posts about matters I don't give a damn about, and I find definitely boring, but as far other members of the forum evidently find those matters relevant, I have no reason to pretend they avoid to discuss them.

And these will be the last words I will post in this thread.


Logged

xgx

  • Bagpipes & Musette Boxes... and Banjos, luv 'em!
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1157
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #11 on: October 25, 2025, 11:05:57 AM »

KISS Principle:
No separate place, there's no need ... keep the forum open as is.



Logged
Graham

Socio-Demographic:   Graduate, Coffin Dodger
 Location: N Cambs/S Lincs - UK

penn

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 574
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #12 on: October 25, 2025, 11:37:23 AM »

I’m not in favour of anything that discourages members with knowledge to post. My music theory is not great and I am very much a “by feel” player of all types of music, but a lot of what I’ve learnt about theory has come from these pages and it can sometimes be interesting to hear aspects that “sound nice” being explained more analytically.
I tend to filter posts as I read them, & I may come back to some at a later date if the topic is one I wish to explore in more detail. I usually whizz past the posts about screw sizes, bellows gasket thickness etc. but I may come back to them later if they become relevant. The forum is also a knowledge base.
I don’t mind a bit of sniping and banter. As you read these pages you can sense characters coming thru the posts and it allows me a small chuckle to see “X having a go at Y again”.

If you feel the forum is being dominated by too much detail on a particular topics then would it not be good to post something of more interest to provide balance?

Gren
Logged
Hohners, Dino Baffetti, Lilly, Benny + a lot of junk.

Mike Hirst

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1433
  • Black Dot B/C, Bastardo C#/D, Corona II GCF
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #13 on: October 25, 2025, 11:45:11 AM »

FWIW I am pro theory, but I am totally against pointless pontification.

I would strongly reject the idea of eradicating useful theory from meaningful discussion - also I love a good argument, but too much of the theoretical discussion on the forum is in my opinion half arsed and poorly presented.

"Theorie und Praxis sollten Hand in Hand gehen und sich gegenseitig ergänzen."
« Last Edit: October 25, 2025, 11:56:28 AM by Mike Hirst »
Logged
Semper idem, sed non eodem modo

Mike Hirst

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1433
  • Black Dot B/C, Bastardo C#/D, Corona II GCF
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #14 on: October 25, 2025, 11:54:13 AM »

On a practical level I would suggest that it might be useful to share favoured resources  - books, websites, apps and other tools amongst forum members. I'd by happy to contribute. I have a good library of theory books. Most of which I find awkward  and inappropriate in the context of melodeon technique, but there are some that I would recommend without hesitation. Also some useful starting points for self education. My own journey towards wider understanding of music theory has been thwarted by unnecessary diversions and poor navigation.
« Last Edit: October 25, 2025, 11:55:56 AM by Mike Hirst »
Logged
Semper idem, sed non eodem modo

Sharon

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 165
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #15 on: October 25, 2025, 12:04:18 PM »

On a practical level I would suggest that it might be useful to share favoured resources  - books, websites, apps and other tools amongst forum members. I'd by happy to contribute. I have a good library of theory books. Most of which I find awkward  and inappropriate in the context of melodeon technique, but there are some that I would recommend without hesitation. Also some useful starting points for self education. My own journey towards wider understanding of music theory has been thwarted by unnecessary diversions and poor navigation.

That would be useful - there are a couple of youtube channels I really like watching which I will share. I was looking for some decent theory books a while ago - really on harmonising relatively simple melodies and making the harmony more interesting - but couldn't find much focussed around trad music rather than classical. I know the 'theory' is the same - but I know what you mean about 'awkward and inappropriate'. When I did A level music, I found harmonising Bach Chorales really pretty boring at the time - I do love a lot of Bach's music but it just didn't really grab me so I found it hard to get into it. I've mostly just listened to folk musicians I really like and figured out what they do and applied that.
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #16 on: October 25, 2025, 01:09:46 PM »


  It is definitely a diversion in otherwise "practicability" threads. And I have found it very awkward to have someone pursuing and constantly correcting me when I tried to point out the "why" of a certain note or chord. 

  It is about less "about" the tune itself than helping folk to internalise why, something sounds good and  to experiment with that in other melodies

  What about it, Clive and Theo. Layout issues could perhaps go in there too?

  @Sharon i'd be interested in your views on some of the weird notes that Appalachian hillbillies sing… cos they work!
            Here's a Nicholas Boulerice song, that breaks all the rules wrt accompaniment!  I love it!!

            https://youtu.be/7gBhK57K7vo
« Last Edit: October 25, 2025, 01:16:54 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Becci Pamely-Bast

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 122
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #17 on: October 25, 2025, 01:33:14 PM »

FWIW I am pro theory, but I am totally against pointless pontification.

This is the crux of it for me. By all means, touch on some relevant theory, but as soon as the thread veers away from the original topic into pontification, I’m out. Either a separate forum for discussing theory, or more moderation to prevent thread drift works for me.

Being as this is a forum for players of the melodeon, I’m interested in discussing the instrument and the many ways to approach playing it, not generic music theory. I’m also in the habit of vetting contributors. If I admire their playing, I’m much more inclined to take their advice, and recommend that others do the same.
Logged
Find me playing on YouTube

Sharon

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 165
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #18 on: October 25, 2025, 03:21:16 PM »

  @Sharon i'd be interested in your views on some of the weird notes that Appalachian hillbillies sing… cos they work!
            Here's a Nicholas Boulerice song, that breaks all the rules wrt accompaniment!  I love it!!

            https://youtu.be/7gBhK57K7vo

Oooh I like that a lot! Very nice. There aren't really any rules anyway - just conventions, which as you well know, vary depending on where in the World you are. 'Rules' are there to be broken  ;D The thing I love about music is the endless variety - I listen to and enjoy a very wide variety of music. I do prefer music with more interesting harmonies and the occasional surprise!
Logged

Disparate Dan

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 329
Re: Separate place to discuss advanced theory topics
« Reply #19 on: October 25, 2025, 06:08:22 PM »


... Telling the dominant 7chord resolves on the tonic is to be considered obscure? I hope not! ...

Oh dear.  Perhaps we could also have a separate section for lost causes such as myself who haven't the faintest idea what that means.  As far as I'm concerned, the tonic goes with the gin.
Logged
We're all doomed ...
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal