Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Apologies me again. Am considering a tuning layout, but not sure if it's mad...  (Read 1635 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Sebastian Trudgian

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 124
  • DG Pokerworks and also play Irish Whistle/Flute

Hello,

I posted a while ago about an old Saltarelle Nuage I fell in love with and bought at Sidmouth (DG, normal basses (with third stop), 4th button start)

There was one tiny niggle and decided in the end (as I love it) to get it completely overhauled by a well known tuner I know.

As part of this, I have the option to change the layout below it's 4th button start... and am a little confused about what to do.

A background on me...


4ish year player (normally a whistler), but love it, played live in an amateur band etc. Don't have an aptitude for musical theory/don't understand it or read music (despite trying) = tend to play just what sounds nice or follow other people's finger patterns.
Like all sorts of music, but particularly interesting held chords, delicate waltzes and cross rowing to make things accordiany sometimes (have a seperate DG I'd use for Morris).
I don't currently play in non standard keys other than very occasional accidentals for needed tunes (Gsharp for jump at the sun etc, and don't think I'd be particularly interested in doing so (just want to be amazing at the natural scales).
I've never knowingly played notes below the D before.

... I also have a very strong habit in life of finding out what the "normal" thing is and then, for some reason, choosing some odd different option... and then later realising why the "normal" option is what everyon picks and now being limited!

---

The tuner has been super helpful and friendly, but I think my lack of musical knowledge re. how I play is hampering my decision a little...

They've recommended the Anahata layout (essentially a G scale below D) and I have agreed on option 1 in the attached.

Option 1: Anahata but with the push D on the G row changed to a push E.
- I have this setting on my other melodeon already and I love it, as I don't lose anything (still have the push D on the D row), but can now do a D E F run all on the push without needing to change bellows direction if I want.

However... I'm also considering

Option 2: Anahata + above BUT the pull C on the G row changed to a Pull D. The Pull C is moved to the D row, replacing the Pull A (see image).

In my head this would be really useful as I'd now have DEF (and some above) as a run on both the pull and push. As I mainly play only these notes and above, it would give me lots of held chord options in waltzes etc without needing to interupt with a belows change.
I would still have all the notes of the Anahata G scale, BUT I'd lose a pull A.

I don't particularly understand why this would be an issue, but the tuner very patiently tried to explain to me (that whilst it’s a very valid option) how it would break a useful pattern anahata has about playing in different octaves.

---

I wonder if you could very kindly, considering my (about me) background, suggest which Option I should go for.

I'm leaning towards Option 2 (as I don't currently play below the Low D and having a D on the draw seems so useful), but really concerned about my history of choosing stupid oddball options in life that tend to be limiting and not sure if I should just go for a regular Anahata (and if my oddball layout would mean I can never sell it in future if I need to.

Thanks for your time and any ideas :-)
« Last Edit: November 28, 2025, 02:52:01 PM by Sebastian Trudgian »
Logged

Sebastian Trudgian

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 124
  • DG Pokerworks and also play Irish Whistle/Flute

 ::) Reflecting on this typically monstrous essay I've just written... I think my question actually can be much much shorter!

I know I'll like having the pull D Option 2 gives me.

However, as I don't currently play below D, I'm not sure how bad of a sacrifice moving the pull C from the G row to the D row and losing the pull A on the D row could be for the future.

- Is it a disaster, due to some unknown dark magic about patterns over octaves that future me will hate present me for... or merely an inconvenience I can easily learn around if necessary (technically all the notes are still there, just A is only on the push)?
- Is it likely to make my melodeon impossible to sell in the future if circumstances require it, or not really a big deal?
« Last Edit: November 28, 2025, 02:08:29 PM by Sebastian Trudgian »
Logged

Helena Handcart

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2452
  • Saltarelle Nell

Hi Seb,

Your option A is pretty much how I have my boxes and I totally agree that a push E removes reduncancy and requires very little re-learning.

For me, your option two has one clear drawback. As someone who does use these low notes a fair bit I find that runs on those B-C-D buttons are really quite common, certainly I believe I use the B and C notes together probably most of the time I find myself in this region of the keyboard. For this stuff, your option two would be markedly less comfortable than leaving the B and C on a button together - and with no D on the adjacent button on the G row what was a simple and common run of notes becomes a bit of a faff.

If you want a pull D and you are happy to lose the low A then why not just put the D in its place*. This would seem to meet your case without too much interruption to those common B-C-D finger patterns.

That Nuage you have is a beauty, I played it a fair few times at Sidmouth. Fortunately I already have a beautiful Nuage, but I am glad that it went to you.



*just when I though I'd found my perfect 19+5 layout....
Logged
Saltarelle Le Romané  | Saltarelle Nuage | Oakwood | various elderly Hohners

Helena Handcart

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2452
  • Saltarelle Nell

... but really concerned about my history of choosing stupid oddball options in life that tend to be limiting and not sure if I should just go for a regular Anahata (and if my oddball layout would mean I can never sell it in future if I need to.

That box would sell in a heartbeat, but I would be very surprised if you want to part with it for a very long time. In any case,  what you are a proposing is at most two notes away from a very standard layout with the push E modification becoming increasingly common and so likely not an issue for an increasing number of people.

Logged
Saltarelle Le Romané  | Saltarelle Nuage | Oakwood | various elderly Hohners

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place

... I also have a very strong habit in life of finding out what the "normal" thing is and then, for some reason, choosing some odd different option... and then later realising why the "normal" option is what everyon picks and now being limited!

In that case it might be wise to make only the changes you are sure of, and leave other options till you have a better idea of how your repertoire and style may develop.  It is very much an individual thing.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Sebastian Trudgian

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 124
  • DG Pokerworks and also play Irish Whistle/Flute

Thankyou both that’s really helpful!

@Helena, that’s intriguing… I hadn’t considered the ease of BCD runs (not that I do them currently but they’re very common in leadups to Irish music).

My thinking of putting the D on the G row was purely for proximity to the other D for substituting (otherwise it’s a whole 2 buttons away + whatever I’m stretching to the D from but I’d never considered that, it does make a few things similar. I’ll have a go making the transition on another melodeon tomorrow and see how it works, thankyou.

@Theo, yes I get your point entirely but I do really think I want a pull D/think I’ve got to the point that I know I want one, just trying to work out if there’s a “non stupid” way of doing it. Thankyou though that has helpfully reminded me of my very common theme when making these choices so will ponder more!
Logged

Arnold

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 711

Another option (of many options), is to follow the logic of the G row back one button, so you get G/C, B/D etc, and then the 2 accidental buttons can be moved to the D row, with the higher accidental button moved marginally closer to the action!..

Edit: that arrangement wouldn’t fit the reedblocks as they are.
« Last Edit: November 28, 2025, 08:37:59 PM by Arnold »
Logged
Dancing about architecture since 1997

Fionn

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 194

Idle thought: is there any connection between not having tunes below D in your repertoire and being a whistler?

There is in my case, but now I have an accordion it's a joy to see a low B on a stave and not have to read G as a substitute. But there were some tunes not worth attempting, they'd just sound naff on a D whistle. Farewell to Erin and Maudabawn Chapel are were for the fiddlers.

If you might still be thinking like a whistler, maybe don't rule out the possibility of wanting to explore further?
« Last Edit: November 28, 2025, 05:44:10 PM by Fionn »
Logged
Vintage Double Ray C#/D

Sebastian Trudgian

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 124
  • DG Pokerworks and also play Irish Whistle/Flute

Thanks both these are both very good thoughts…

I do think I have been a little limited by being a whistler (I’ve recently started learning the fiddle and using that low string occasionally is magical…

I’m going to spend a morning with my pokerwork this morning and try and decide, but (now the enormity of possibilities has opened up and remembering my history!) I am leaning back towards the simplicity of option 1, although it does feel a shame to not have a draw D, but maybe that’s just one of the melodeon foibles to learn to love ❤️
Logged

tirpous

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1403

Quote
I am leaning back towards the simplicity of option 1

Why not ? I mean, you can start with option 1 and see how it goes, change later if you feel a need to.

Only fools never change their mind, I've always said so.  8)
Logged

Helena Handcart

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2452
  • Saltarelle Nell

Why not ? I mean, you can start with option 1 and see how it goes, change later if you feel a need to.
Only fools never change their mind, I've always said so.  8)

There's certainly wisdom in this. For Seb who already knows that the low E mod is a keeper but doesn't currently play tunes that stray below D there's opportunity to make the one change, then learn some tunes that use those low notes and see if any other changes would then be beneficial.
Logged
Saltarelle Le Romané  | Saltarelle Nuage | Oakwood | various elderly Hohners

Gena Crisman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1108
  • 🇬🇧

I've met a G/C + B/D box or two.

Pull D is really neat and very powerful, but, your choice here is, proverbially, a fork in the road towards two big hills with flags on that likely people already on said hills will receive a lot of reinforcement that the hill they're on is very big tall and green.

The pleasing convinience of the push E right where you want it is a similar vibe of the convinience of the pull D. So, it will allow you to change how you play melodies in a similar way the push E has changed how you play.

The mild inconvenience of the (regular) D E F# run is along the same lines as (melodies played with the) low g scale, where as playing melody across the gc+bd procession is much more of a tongue twister, with a lot of press. Also your A note and A bass may never meet, very sad.

So you pick your poison, I suppose. That's why I've gone with another D# instead of a push E
« Last Edit: November 30, 2025, 12:21:33 PM by Gena Crisman »
Logged

Sebastian Trudgian

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 124
  • DG Pokerworks and also play Irish Whistle/Flute

I wrote another essay (including lots of individual thanks, I really do appreciate all your thoughts), but decided to delete it due to brevity/already wasting too much internet space with my indecision.

In summary, for various reasons, and after a lot of melodeon playing this morning, I’ve decided to go for Option 1 (standard anahata with the G row D changed to an E)

Incase any other future people, with similar dilemmas, discover this in the future, what swung it for me (other than the very useful reminders of my predilection of picking weirdo options, and how this is all changeable anyway), was that the reason I originally picked a DG system (a similar dilemma as a whistle player who mainly played Irish and occasional Cornish music) was because people with DG melodeons seemed to play the kind of music I vibed with and wanted to learn.

So, I decided if I don’t know what I want, it (hopefully) can’t be a bad idea to just pick a system a lot of them have choosen to use.

Thanks sincerely again everyone for your help and best festive wishes :-)
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall


  Melnet voted on several options for D/G 4th start about 10 years ago and Anahata's layout won, by a mile!

  It should therefore be considered the standard "British" box. We had already voted by a large margintgat 3rd start … made no sense.

  I had a single voice D/G Lilly And commissioned Thea to convert it to 4th start. We also "clubbed" it.  = D/D in the middle of the in inner row. It's very "non stupid" and you will be very quick to get used to it 👍

  The two combined  … give you an fantastic gamut of right-end chords (and so … arpegio's). You say that you are happy to cross-row,  and in that context, that is a layout I would personally recommend. Enjoy!

 [edit] Changing Dpush to an E is a bad idea IMHO.  The reason is that 90% of cross row musical phrases are on the pull, and you're already have an E pull.  It might suit your music, but it's a very idiosyncratic choice. I think clubbing to D/D will be far more flexible. If you are desperate for an Epull then go for an E/D "Dutch inversion".  That solves both problems and is very logical. But be warned. It will mean you relearning every tune in your repertoire. If you get it wrong … it sounds awful!
« Last Edit: November 29, 2025, 06:08:30 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Sebastian Trudgian

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 124
  • DG Pokerworks and also play Irish Whistle/Flute

Thankyou!

And I suspect you’re probably right about the push E and D/D options, but last night I had my first blissful sleep with no kafkaesque nightmares about accidentals, so am going to stick with it now 🤣
Logged

Helena Handcart

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2452
  • Saltarelle Nell

... last night I had my first blissful sleep with no kafkaesque nightmares about accidentals, so am going to stick with it now 🤣

That's always a good sign Seb. As long as you accept there will always be one more change you might think about making and you'll always wonder what you could do with just one more button....

Honestly, it is a silly instrument, but we're here now so we might as well make the best of it.
Logged
Saltarelle Le Romané  | Saltarelle Nuage | Oakwood | various elderly Hohners

Lester

  • MADman
  • Mods and volunteers
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 9327
  • Hohners'R'me
    • Lester's Melodeon Emporium and Tune-a-Rama


Melnet voted on several options for D/G 4th start about 10 years ago and Anahata's layout won, by a mile!
It should therefore be considered the standard "British" box.
Not sure that the 19 voters from what is probably a small subset of British box players have it in their gift to define the "standard "British" box"

Gena Crisman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1108
  • 🇬🇧

Well, also bear in mind Chris is talking about an entirely different push E button than your initial inquiry was remotely related to, also.
Logged

Sebastian Trudgian

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 124
  • DG Pokerworks and also play Irish Whistle/Flute

"It is a silly instrument, but we're here now so we might as well make the best of it."

Would make a fantastic title for a melodeon tuition book/workshop 😂
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal