Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: What instrument to start with?  (Read 1139 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

mbnaegle

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
What instrument to start with?
« on: April 22, 2026, 11:19:23 PM »

I'm new to playing Accordion/Melodeon, and have a single row button melodeon, a 2 row button melodeon, and a piano style accordion. The accordion is the only one that is working right now as the two melodeon's need repairs, but I wonder if it's best to become familiar with a specific style before moving onto the other? In other words, is it easier to learn on a 2 row melodeon first before picking a a single row?

I started playing trumpet in school and switched over to the euphonium(baritone) my senior year, which was easy as they both play the same just with different parts. Kinda like speaking two dialects of the same language, and I wonder if the same is true between accordions and melodions, if one is easier for beginners, and how hard is it to switch back and forth while you are learning?
Logged
"Beware of permanent solutions to temporary problems"

"We do this not because it is easy, but because we thought it would be easy!"

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: What instrument to start with?
« Reply #1 on: April 22, 2026, 11:32:45 PM »

If you already have both instruments, why not play them both?
You'll probably favour one box or the other depending on the tune.
But I'd have thought it's easier to start with the 1-row if you really want to choose one. The basic scale along the row is something you can take to the 2-row, but when you start on the 2-row you add a whole lot of new skills using both rows and fitting the basses to tunes.

Is your 2-row box in two keys a fourth apart like D/G or C/F, or a semitone apart like B/C? That make a big difference in how you approach playing it.
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

Dick Rees

  • Neo-Luddite
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1640
Re: What instrument to start with?
« Reply #2 on: April 22, 2026, 11:48:08 PM »

Regardless of which instrument you choose, you will benefit from working on ear training.  Familiarizing yourself with the various intervals inherent in arpeggios and chords. Learning how to listen is often overlooked.
Logged
"You're making the wrong mistakes."
...Thelonius Monk

"I never made one of my discoveries through the process of rational thinking."
...Albert Einstein

"If Art Tatum took up classical music seriously, I'd quit my job the next day."
...Vladimir Horowitz

mbnaegle

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
Re: What instrument to start with?
« Reply #3 on: April 23, 2026, 03:48:26 PM »

Thanks for the input. I do want to learn to play all of them though I'm a little more inclined towards the melodeons. Just want to be sure I start at the right end of things. I don't know anyone who plays, so am having to teach myself with books and videos.

When I learned to play trumpet in school, I made the mistake of learning the fingering for each note without actually learning the notes names, which made it hard to progress. I'm trying to do better at it now and one mental hurtle I'm working on is remembering the diatonic aspect of getting different notes out of the same keys. The piano accordion is easier in that aspect that you can play up and down scales easily, but it seems to be a lot of instrument for someone just getting started. There are some specific songs or genre's I want to become familiar with, but want to learn to play by ear as there's a lot of songs I think would sound nice on an melodeon, but no one makes sheet music.

Similarly, I like figuring out how to play Punk Rock songs on my trumpet and euphonium. I find they transfer over very well sounding a bit like ragtime or similar brass ensemble, while not fitting the usual jazz or ska sound. You have to be able to play be ear though as that crossing of instruments over genre lines doesn't offer much written music to follow.
Logged
"Beware of permanent solutions to temporary problems"

"We do this not because it is easy, but because we thought it would be easy!"

mbnaegle

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
Re: What instrument to start with?
« Reply #4 on: April 23, 2026, 04:46:26 PM »

......

Is your 2-row box in two keys a fourth apart like D/G or C/F, or a semitone apart like B/C? That make a big difference in how you approach playing it.

I'll have to get back to you on that part, as it's on the bench getting worked on at the moment. It's not marked so I'll need to test it and see.
Logged
"Beware of permanent solutions to temporary problems"

"We do this not because it is easy, but because we thought it would be easy!"

Fionn

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 194
Re: What instrument to start with?
« Reply #5 on: April 23, 2026, 05:42:15 PM »

If you do mean songs, piano accordions tend to be more sympathetic as accompaniment than button boxes. One person might sing the same song in different keys, depending on how their voice is that day, and that's easier to navigate with a PA.

But as some people in the US use 'songs' to describe tunes with no vocal element at all, that might be useless information!  ;)
Logged
Vintage Double Ray C#/D

mbnaegle

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
Re: What instrument to start with?
« Reply #6 on: April 23, 2026, 06:43:39 PM »

If you do mean songs, piano accordions tend to be more sympathetic as accompaniment than button boxes. One person might sing the same song in different keys, depending on how their voice is that day, and that's easier to navigate with a PA.

But as some people in the US use 'songs' to describe tunes with no vocal element at all, that might be useless information!  ;)
Understood. I appreciate the insight! My experience in creating music has all been between orchestral (brass and woodwind), marching band, and choir with piano accompaniment. I'm still learning how to establish parts when writing music myself. I'm using 'songs' to describe any music, but I imagine I'll do both solo and accompaniment work. I don't plan on doing any vocal parts, but it helps to know how to play along with someone else.

The solo work I'm interested in would be more traditional folk music, while the music I'm interested in making myself will likely involve accompaniments in a small ensemble with brass, violin, and piano. There might be an occasional solo part for the accordion, but it would mainly be a bass/supporting roll to the others, just not as light and upbeat as traditional Polka, Latino, or other typical band accompaniments for accordions. At any rate, it sounds like the Melodeon would do better on its own, while the accordion would do better for accompaniments.

Logged
"Beware of permanent solutions to temporary problems"

"We do this not because it is easy, but because we thought it would be easy!"

mbnaegle

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
Re: What instrument to start with?
« Reply #7 on: April 23, 2026, 07:56:56 PM »

If you already have both instruments, why not play them both?
You'll probably favour one box or the other depending on the tune.
But I'd have thought it's easier to start with the 1-row if you really want to choose one. The basic scale along the row is something you can take to the 2-row, but when you start on the 2-row you add a whole lot of new skills using both rows and fitting the basses to tunes.

Is your 2-row box in two keys a fourth apart like D/G or C/F, or a semitone apart like B/C? That make a big difference in how you approach playing it.
Ok I just figured out it IS marked, (I just didn't know what I was looking at). It's tuned as a D/G
Logged
"Beware of permanent solutions to temporary problems"

"We do this not because it is easy, but because we thought it would be easy!"

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: What instrument to start with?
« Reply #8 on: April 23, 2026, 08:08:40 PM »

Ok I just figured out it IS marked, (I just didn't know what I was looking at). It's tuned as a D/G

So that means it's ideal for playing in those major keys and E minor, and playing in D and G is basically the same as playing the 1-row instrument, in D on the outer row and G on the inner row, until you start borrowing notes from the "other" row to make the best use of the left hand basses and chords.

The advantage for you is that the boxes are broadly similar from a beginner's point of view, and that in those keys you do get reasonably good bass and harmony support on the LH. It also means your tuning is familiar to many members of this forum.
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

mbnaegle

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
Re: What instrument to start with?
« Reply #9 on: April 23, 2026, 09:50:46 PM »

Ok I just figured out it IS marked, (I just didn't know what I was looking at). It's tuned as a D/G

So that means it's ideal for playing in those major keys and E minor, and playing in D and G is basically the same as playing the 1-row instrument, in D on the outer row and G on the inner row, until you start borrowing notes from the "other" row to make the best use of the left hand basses and chords.

The advantage for you is that the boxes are broadly similar from a beginner's point of view, and that in those keys you do get reasonably good bass and harmony support on the LH. It also means your tuning is familiar to many members of this forum.
Good to know. Thank you!
Logged
"Beware of permanent solutions to temporary problems"

"We do this not because it is easy, but because we thought it would be easy!"

mbnaegle

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
Re: What instrument to start with?
« Reply #10 on: May 04, 2026, 03:30:17 PM »

This weekend I made some enough repairs on my 2 row DG that I was able to practice "Shepherds Hey" on it. As I've been learning more about what's involved with these instruments and watching artists like Paul Young, it looks like the 2 row DG and my other 1 row melodeon will do most of the music I want to learn to play. At least at this point I'm veering more towards traditional English and Scottish music.

I think my 120 base piano accordion will be useful to learn, but mainly to fill in for everything else that can't be played on the button boxes. I'm enjoying the button boxes more (The PA is just so big, like playing a refrigerator, and doesn't have quite the charm as these old melodeons) so I think a 3 row DG with 12 or 16 bases will be in my future, and maybe a BC box as well for traditional Irish, AFTER I've become comfortable and familiar with the DG and 1 row. The romantic in me is leaning more towards finding other antique project button boxes to save, but I also have my eye on a new McNeela BC.

I'm finding that for me, learning the notes and buttons are only half the battle. I've gotten so accustomed to playing orchestral type sheet music that always has fixed time signatures and parts to play, that the rhythm and pace of folk music is taking some getting used to, but I'll get it. My kids are also getting into playing instruments (including the trumpet, piano, guitar, and violin) and I think being able to hear different keys, learn the different playing methods, and learn how they fit together will be beneficial for all of us.
Logged
"Beware of permanent solutions to temporary problems"

"We do this not because it is easy, but because we thought it would be easy!"

Fionn

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 194
Re: What instrument to start with?
« Reply #11 on: May 04, 2026, 09:00:37 PM »

You can play Irish on your DG, specially if it's only going to be a small part of your tune repertoire.

You'll be missing a G# for Amaj tunes, but some don't contain a G at all and it's perfectly possible to play around it in others. Fnat pops up as an accidental in some tunes, but not all that many. You can certainly get through a decent part of the repertoire without either note, and that adds up to thousands of tunes. I'm rubbish at half holing G# and Fnat on my D whistle now due to bent arthritic fingers, so I've got pretty good at dodging them even when they are present.

I'm not sure learning the note names and buttons by rote is crucial, by the way. If you asked me to point to any note except D on my box, I couldn't – but my back brain and my ears know where they are and that seems to be enough.

Learning from notation's quite easy, as half the keyboard has all the pull notes on the staff lines and the push notes in between, and vice versa for the other half. I learned music by ear originally and am still a poor reader, so I was surprised to find it so much easier to read for a button box I hadn't even learned to play yet than for a whistle I've been familiar with for 50 years.
Logged
Vintage Double Ray C#/D

mChavez

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 713
Re: What instrument to start with?
« Reply #12 on: May 06, 2026, 07:44:42 AM »

Fwiw, I really don't think it matters much what you start on. You want to learn hand coordination and bellows control first. Switching between instruments later on is easy.

However, the smaller & lighter the instrument, the more you can get away with in terms of bellows technique errors - bigger instruments punish you harder for them.
Also, the bellows action is very different on the smallest boxes (small single rows, smallest 2-rows, Anglo or English contcertina, smallest Chemnitzers) and large boxes (PA, CBA), with middle-sized ones falling closer to the bigger boxes, than the smaller ones.

Since the full-sized PA is the one that works, I'd start with the PA and build proper bellows technique.

From personal experience:
Coming from guitar & mandolin, I've started on a full-sized CBA and underestimated just how different these instruments really are. A couple years into CBA I went on a mad journey to try bandoneon, diatonic melodeons, Hromka garmoshka and full-sized converter PA.

I've had absolutely no problem adapting full-sized CBA technique to a large unisonoric bandoneon, hromka of any size & mid-sized diatonics. In fact, I think I benefited a lot from trying them all, but, obviously, at the expense of CBA skills, which degrade lightning fast when you're not practicing every day.

I've settled on the hromka, but recently started picking up the CBA again to play with my daughter - it's a 7-octave range (Ok, almost 7. Lowest fb is E1 and highest treble piccolo is C8. I don't think they make reeds higher pitched that that) 5-voice converter box that sounds like a church organ and weighs like one.
Well, 3 years of playing lightweight boxes have killed my technique and it took me a week to start squeezing the 16.5kg concert CBA without getting tired after 20 minutes.
But the bellows technique came back quickly (can't say that about fingerings!), so as long as you build the right foundation, you'll be fine with a box any size.

And I love playing that CBA monster. Picking it up and carrying it up & down the stairs is a different matter, but playing it is great - and it's probably double size of your PA that you think is too big to be fun.
« Last Edit: May 06, 2026, 07:50:56 AM by mChavez »
Logged

mbnaegle

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 42
Re: What instrument to start with?
« Reply #13 on: May 07, 2026, 09:39:39 PM »

Thanks! All really helpful information!
Logged
"Beware of permanent solutions to temporary problems"

"We do this not because it is easy, but because we thought it would be easy!"

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: What instrument to start with?
« Reply #14 on: May 08, 2026, 08:16:02 AM »


 I'm very close to what Dick says above. When you're playing in a group, and especially when you are singing a big part of melodeon play is using right hand chords. Yes, we do have a set on the left, but you can't do all that much with them?  And they can become quite dull as endless |: dum cha cha :| 😳

  The French call it "un accordion, and that's because it was originally designed to play in chords! It became very popular amongst Paris "salon" society in the late 19th century, playing for dance, or singing.   In a modern group there are usually lots of folk playing Melody and you can find a real niche for yourself by learning the right-end chords. There are extensive diagrams on this website to help you.

 The advantage of the right hand is that you don't have to play dum-cha style. You can add extra notes e.g. a Sus4/9, usually as a transient. You can "chew" your chord by movingyour fingers, or changing bellow pressure. You can transition effortlessly e.g Am=>C by just moving one finger to a different row!

   You can fade notes … right down to silence!  (easier with more expensive reeds). Vibrato?  Just waggle a finger (either hand)!

   And it's amazing how a simple reversal of the bellows direction produces a useful further chord, without moving your fingers 🤔 But that works  best when you're playing in the instruments main row home keys (or their minor modes)

   Nuanced play: is much easier than on a piano accordion, because our instrument is so much lighter. The drawback is that a melodeon isn't fully chromatic so you are restricted to … certain keys.  A lot of people lug 2, or even 3 melodeons around at festivals!  I've done that!

   I eventually went to different way and moved onto a 3-row instrument, which has far more scope. They ain't cheap, but my 18-bass Van der Aa weighs only about 4½kg. It sits effortlessly on my shoulder festivals, and I can suspend it on a single finger! 

  One weekend in Wales they played in every key except Ab, and I was able … to play along. Albeit sometimes that was just "chording" 🙂

  We all start with a simple 2-row instrument, often secondhand, and resale values are … quite good, especially if you use the facility here on melnet. The tonality chosen will depend on what music you play. See advice from other people as to tunes, as I don't get to pub sessions anymore.
 
« Last Edit: May 08, 2026, 08:26:28 AM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal