Hi everyone,
My name is Owen, I’m a BC player from the Isle of Man and I’m new to the forum as a member, although I’ve read posts for advice a number of times in the past. Mostly I play Manx and other Gaelic styles, but also Breton and Welsh (went to uni yng Nghymru) and any style from over the world that I can find.
I was wondering if anyone had any advice about an air button issue. I received a new BC Darwin from Marc Serafini about two months ago and I’m very happy with it in every way, apart from an issue of the air button.
When playing the new Darwin the first few times, I noticed that the air button was much more responsive than my previous box (Mengascini) - the new Darwin would release/take in a lot more air than the old box, and much more suddenly.
This led to a sudden drop in air pressure inside the bellows, and therefore a sudden drop in volume followed by a sudden spike/jolt in the sound when the air button was released. I realised that the air hole is much bigger on the new Darwin than on my old box.
I tested the advice that I found here on the website (feathering the air button, just getting used to it etc.) but I don’t think it’s a case of poor technique - I’ve been playing the box since the age of 10 and I’m in my twenties now and it’s never been an issue on any other box I’ve played.
I understand that this bigger size is probably normal for 4th-apart boxes (which is Mr Serafini’s usual area of expertise I believe), since air button use can be balanced against bellows reversals. However, for us BC players, generally I think the air button might need to be used more often, and more slightly, meaning that a smaller air hole is more suitable.
Mr Serafini agreed in his correspondence and was very helpful in his advice. I taped over the hole from the inside and the results are much more natural sounding.
Nonetheless, despite the air button releasing the right amount of air, I still notice a quite audible jolt in the sound when the button is released. I suspect this is due to the pallet closing against the air hole very quickly, with the knocking motion causing the bellows to quiver a bit.
Some might suggest that I need to develop more sensitive technique with the air button and I would be receptive to this advice, except for a few issues:
1. The jolt still happens even when the air button is released from an only-slightly-open position,
2. The jolt still happens when attempting to close it gradually at low volumes,
3. I often need to be able to take a quick, sharp intake of air during play - during a faster tune or a tune where the majority of the notes are on the pull, being subtle isn’t really possible. I need to open and close the air button in very quick succession.
I have tried ‘feathering’ the air button, but there isn’t really time for the gradual movement required to do this when there’s only one brief push note to get the bellows back in a bit.
Does anyone have any advice on how I can make the pallet close more softly? I’ll keep trying to feather the air button but I’m skeptical that it’s really possible in the case of a quick tune in A major, where only E and F# are on the push.
Many thanks indeed,
Owen