Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 [2]   Go Down

Author Topic: Software sheet music → tablature  (Read 1720 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Thrupenny Bit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 7232
  • happily squeezing away in Devon
Re: Software sheet music → tablature
« Reply #20 on: July 01, 2026, 04:00:43 PM »

Yes Dick of course!
I suppose my broad point is that with so many variables, is it valid to limit it to one option?
Logged
Thrupenny Bit

I think I'm starting to get most of the notes in roughly the right order...... sometimes!

Howard Jones

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1203
Re: Software sheet music → tablature
« Reply #21 on: July 01, 2026, 06:21:42 PM »

But as a melodeon player I can confirmis that the players who can read and write music when thay're told on which row they have to play a note don't need any additional element to the standad score to knowe which nutton they need to play, or in which bellows direction.

But how do you know from the score which row you should be playing on? Of course the chords may give a clue, but often they are not given, and besides the D and C chords (on a D/G box) are available in both directions so that doesn't help much. I agree that an experienced player, whether reading from a score or by ear, will know instinctively the best way to play a phrase, but that is drawing on their experience, not from information on the page.

What a score cannot tell you is explicitly which button to use. Tab can, that is its purpose. You may not feel you need it, but some players find it helpful, especially if they're still exploring the instrument or trying to understand how a particular musician plays the piece. What puzzles me is that you seem to accept that this information can be added to a score, whether by colours, note shapes or symbols, but appear to object to a system which spells it out explicitly. 

Notation is very good at conveying pitch and duration, dynamnics, and much more, but the player must work out the fingering for themselves. Tab shows them this, but most tab systems rely on musical notation, or at least elements of it, to convey other elements. They complement one another.

Quote
I would conclude telling that tthe reason nor my tracriptions nor any tab system cannot offer a satisfactoy portrait od the performance by a real player is that the relevant missing element in all them, that isn't striclty speaking instrument specific is the use of the articulations. That's really the key point: too bad a number of melodeon players aren't aware of it.

Absolutely. All musical notation systems have their limits, and can only convey a small part of what makes music. The notes themselves are only the foundations. Everything else, which I would broadly term "style", can only come from listening.

Dick Rees

  • Neo-Luddite
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1640
Re: Software sheet music → tablature
« Reply #22 on: July 01, 2026, 06:38:23 PM »

https://photos.app.goo.gl/Q8Ufv3dLMsRuD14EA

Combo staff with tab line below.  Create your number system and write the # below the particular dot on the staff, above the line for the inside row, below for the outside. For pull/draw notes simply circle the #.
Logged
"You're making the wrong mistakes."
...Thelonius Monk

"I never made one of my discoveries through the process of rational thinking."
...Albert Einstein

"If Art Tatum took up classical music seriously, I'd quit my job the next day."
...Vladimir Horowitz

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Software sheet music → tablature
« Reply #23 on: July 01, 2026, 09:48:56 PM »

But as a melodeon player I can confirmis that the players who can read and write music when thay're told on which row they have to play a note don't need any additional element to the standad score to knowe which nutton they need to play, or in which bellows direction.

But how do you know from the score which row you should be playing on? Of course the chords may give a clue, but often they are not given, and besides the D and C chords (on a D/G box) are available in both directions so that doesn't help much. I agree that an experienced player, whether reading from a score or by ear, will know instinctively the best way to play a phrase, but that is drawing on their experience, not from information on the page.

What a score cannot tell you is explicitly which button to use. Tab can, that is its purpose. You may not feel you need it, but some players find it helpful, especially if they're still exploring the instrument or trying to understand how a particular musician plays the piece. What puzzles me is that you seem to accept that this information can be added to a score, whether by colours, note shapes or symbols, but appear to object to a system which spells it out explicitly... 

Notation is very good at conveying pitch and duration, dynamnics, and much more, but the player must work out the fingering for themselves. Tab shows them this, but most tab systems rely on musical notation, or at least elements of it, to convey other elements. They complement one another.

Quote
I would conclude telling that tthe reason nor my tracriptions nor any tab system cannot offer a satisfactoy portrait od the performance by a real player is that the relevant missing element in all them, that isn't striclty speaking instrument specific is the use of the articulations. That's really the key point: too bad a number of melodeon players aren't aware of it.

Absolutely. All musical notation systems have their limits, and can only convey a small part of what makes music. The notes themselves are only the foundations. Everything else, which I would broadly term "style", can only come from listening.

Howard, looks like you really haven't read what I wrote!

Yet my point was clear: a player who can read and write music and is aware of the keyboard layout of his instrument just need to be told on which row he has to play a note, and he will figure out on which button and which is the bellows direction.

Then for him there is no need to use fancy graphic staffs and numbers, and tell explicitly the buttons to use, and whether the notes are played on the push or on the pull. The row can be clearly stated in a standard score using different colours or different shapes for the noteheads, in a simple and elegant form, saving the transcribers the boring and time consuming task to create a tablature, and still offering all the informations that a tablature delivers for those who play by ear.

As I can read and write music, I refuse to waste time, and eventually ink and paper, to write and print tablatures to spell out explicitly what for me is already self evident in one of my simple scores. Musically unlettered players can use the tablatures if they like, I do not object to this, although my experience as a teacher back in the nineties showed me that the majority of the beginners who  refused to learn to read music from the start, claiming that first they were interest to play some tunes, remained in the long term tablature dependent. But please, don't tell me that score and tablatures complement each others.

And about the idea that all musical notation system have limitations, and can only convey a small part of what makes music, let me tell than a standard western score can actually tell more or less anything you need to replicate a whole performance to the tiniest level of detail. But that implies a lot of work, and the question is if such complex transcriptions  are really worth the effort.

There isn't a best choice among the different chord progressions you can generally choose for a tune, and many possible combinations of the three articulation that consent an expressive rendition of the melody -  staccato, portato and legato -, and the different ones often depend on the choice to play the notes on one row than rather than on the other(s), that in turn often depends both on  the chords you play and on the choice you make to play across the rows rather than press and draw. And fingerings are in the end easy to add to a score, but in terms of readabilty create more problems that the ones they solve.

The way an experienced player handles a tune is highly individual, and is based on a number of factors. It is partly a matter of musical taste, partly depends on the instrument – weight, number of rows, number of the banks of reeds, amount of vibrato in the tuning, and above all the attack of the reeds -, and partly on the technical skills of the player (or lack of...). Then any experienced player will tailor the way he performs a tune in a unique way.

The software developers are used to say: write a program that even an idiot will be able to use, and only idiots will use it. Put it in musical terms: write a transcription that will enable even  the least experienced player to replicate in details the way you play a tune, and only the less experienced players will choose to really follow it. Then, why bother?

« Last Edit: July 01, 2026, 10:22:13 PM by GBbox »
Logged

Dick Rees

  • Neo-Luddite
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1640
Re: Software sheet music → tablature
« Reply #24 on: July 01, 2026, 10:55:05 PM »

Gb wrote:  " Please don't tell me that score and tablature compliment each others.

Really? REALLY?
Logged
"You're making the wrong mistakes."
...Thelonius Monk

"I never made one of my discoveries through the process of rational thinking."
...Albert Einstein

"If Art Tatum took up classical music seriously, I'd quit my job the next day."
...Vladimir Horowitz

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Online Online
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here
Re: Software sheet music → tablature
« Reply #25 on: July 01, 2026, 11:08:36 PM »

Tablatures provide the fingering, that's their main purpose. An information that the score alone does not provide.
Besides, you can be dependent on any notation system, dots, tabs, or even recordings. Each have their usefulness, I really don't understand the kind of rearguard action towards tablature. You don't use tablatures, that's fine, nobody forces you to.

Howard Jones

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1203
Re: Software sheet music → tablature
« Reply #26 on: July 02, 2026, 11:31:50 AM »

Howard, looks like you really haven't read what I wrote!

With respect, I could say the same. My point is that the score does not tell you on which row you should play the note. Now on melodeon there are usually only two options (other instruments may have more choices) and usually the best choice is the obvious one, so it doesn't much matter. I quite agree that someone who reads music should be able to play from a score easily enough, and an experienced player will know when to use the less obvious option.

I'm not suggesting that tab is better than notation, simply that it serves a different purpose and conveys different information specific to a particular instrument. There are situations where it is useful to be able to record explicitly which combination of buttons to use to play a phrase, or to illustrate how another musician plays a piece. I don't see how you could do this in standard notation, other than by writing on the score which amounts to the same thing.  If you don't have a use for this then you can ignore it - that does not mean tab is pointless or unnecessary. But is seems we are not going to agree over this.

I share your doubt whether tab is the best way to share tunes, although tab allows you to play the piece even if it is not in the same key as your instrument, without having to transpose the score - it just sounds in the appropriate key for your instrument. I don't read music well, and not well enough to play from, but I prefer standard notation for my library of tunes and only use tab occasionally to record tricky fingerings so I don't forget them. However there are several online collections in melodeon tab, so presumably people do find them useful. I appreciate you are not one of them.

However I do believe writing tab needs human input from someone who understands the realities of playing the instrument. Not only are the fingering choices they make more likely to be playable, it can also be enlightening to see how another player approaches them. I do wonder how well a computer program can replicate this.

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Software sheet music → tablature
« Reply #27 on: July 02, 2026, 01:56:58 PM »

Gb wrote:  " Please don't tell me that score and tablature compliment each others.

Really? REALLY?

Ops... complement!

REALLY!   ;)
Logged

GBbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 615
Re: Software sheet music → tablature
« Reply #28 on: July 02, 2026, 04:13:48 PM »


Howard, looks like you really haven't read what I wrote!


With respect, I could say the same. My point is that the score does not tell you on which row you should play the note..


What a frustrating dialogue. Reminds me of... you know how it goes? There is a dumb man who tells to a deaf man: hey, there's a blind man looking at you!

Since evidently my explanations have been useless, let me try to show you with a concrete example what I mean when I say that the standard score and the melodeon tablature actually can serve exactly the same purpose. The former for the players who can read and write music, the latter for those who don't.

In attachment there is one of my own melodeon transcriptions - I call them tablascores, because they contain all the informations usually associated with a tablature but remain plain scores.

The tune is a traditional jig that I learned as a beginner in the early eighties. It was popular at the time thanks to the Oak and The Old swan band records, although I play it in G rather than in D. For those who are not familiar with it, I've added the abc transcription below.

The tablescore fits a standard two row D/G box, and the tune is played mainly press and draw across the rows. Obviously the notes with an orange notehead are played on the G row, and the ones with the black noteheads on the D row. Then a G above middle C with an orange notehead is played on the push on the third button of the inner row, the F below with an orange noteahead on the pull on the second button of the same row, and so on. It might sound intimidating at first, but after having learned four or five tunes the process becomes straightforward. Let's say that to get familiar with the tablascores a player that can read and write music won't need more time than that needed to master any tablature system.

In this transcription I ignore the left hand part, because the tune follows a standard 6/8 pattern, and  the chords above the staff can be followed without problems. BTW,  the tablatures on the web usually offer the left hand notation for the whole tune, since they are generated with software like Harmony assistant or Tabledit. but the Corgeron system tablatures you'll find in print usually give the LH notation just for the first stave.

Under the seventh bars there is what I call a bass line. In tablature fashion I use a capital letter for the basses and a lower case letter for the chords, eventually with an underscore when the are played on the pull.  The bass line comes in handy for non standard left hand patterns, or for instance when the bass I play isn't the root of the chord in the harmonic progression, or I play a block chord, or I don't use the left hand ta all (in this case I use a rest symbol)...

Please note that in this case I use the bass line to show that the seventh bars are played using the D bass-chord couple on the push for the first beat, and th D bass-chord couple on the pull for the second beat. The bass line here isn't mandatory. With the an A and a D note played on the outer row and and an F note played on the inner row there aren't ambiguities. Yet I admit that the use of the D chord first on the push than on the pull  isn't something I would spot at first sight if I had not written the transcription, so I've added the bass line both as a memory aid for myself, in case I had to get back to the tune after a long time I haven't played it, and as a form of courtesy for other players in case  I were sharing it with someone else. Like in fact happens now!

I could  add a number of other details about the potential use of the tablascores for tuition, or for complex transcriptions, but I think I have made my point. What you have here is a simple, in its own right elegant score, that offers all the informations that you would find in a full tablature... just without the tablature at all!

X:1
T:The New Rigged Ship
L:1/8
M:6/8
K:G
D |"G" GFG G2 B | GFG G2 B |"D" AFD DEF | AFD DEF |"G" GFG G2 B |$ GFG G2 B |
"D" AF E2 F |"G" G3- G2 :: B |"G" d z B d2 B | G z G GBd |"C" e z c e2 c |$
"D" A z A ABc |"G" d z B d2 B | G z G G2 B |"D" dcB E2 F |"G" G3- G2 :|


Logged

Howard Jones

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1203
Re: Software sheet music → tablature
« Reply #29 on: July 02, 2026, 07:28:24 PM »

I can now see how we have been at cross purposes. I think our disagreement has been founded on different understandings of the terminology.  My understanding is that the core difference is that a score shows what to play and is universal, while tab shows how to play it and is specific to the instrument.  Most tab systems I am familiar with also include the notation as well as the tab itself.

When I have been referring to "the score" I have in mind the "raw" score with black-head notes, such as you might find on The Session or the Traditional Tune Archive, or printed in a book. I stand by my assertion that this leaves it to the player to make their own choice of which buttons to use.

To my mind, your tablascore system is another form of tablature (of which there are many). The precise method may differ, but I see no fundamental difference between using colours and button numbers to indicate how it should be played. But perhaps you don't see it this way, and perhaps when I referred to tab you had in mind something like Corgeron or CADB and did not include your own system in this. I never meant to imply any particular type.

We both seem to be agreed that it can sometimes be helpful to show specific information about which buttons to use. How to do it, and what to call it, is secondary.  Which makes our entire debate rather pointless (:)  But it has been interesting, and I apologise that it has also sometimes been a bit frustrating!





Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Software sheet music → tablature
« Reply #30 on: July 02, 2026, 07:36:58 PM »

[[ADMIN]]

Let’s call a halt there.  We are now far from the original purpose of this topic.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning
Pages: 1 [2]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal