Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Dimensions of popular Québécois and Cajun accordions?  (Read 502 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Ross Dubois

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 144
Dimensions of popular Québécois and Cajun accordions?
« on: August 30, 2026, 03:29:06 PM »

I've noticed that most of these companies (Melodie, Acadian, Bon Tee, Martin, Messervier, etc) never list the basic dimensions of their instruments. I found through a lot of digging that the keyboard dimensions are a little different between Acadian and Martin, but that the button spacing is the same.

Anyway, I'm curious about the general height of many of these boxes. As far as Cajun boxes go, it seems they are commonly based off Monarch and Globe boxes (pretty much the same thing) so I imagine they're around 28cm tall (not including stops), but have nothing to actually confirm that.

Melodie accordions look a little narrower but again, visual is all I have to go off of.

Can anyone confirm, deny, or elaborate on any of this? Thanks!
Logged

MikeSchway

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11
Re: Dimensions of popular Québécois and Cajun accordions?
« Reply #1 on: August 30, 2026, 04:54:30 PM »

Dimensions from my 90s Acadian (Marc Savoy):

Overall:  12.75 high (with stops extended) x 6.25 deep x ~12.5"wide (including keyboard and bass strap) (32.4 x 15.9 x 31.8 cm)

Main box (less keyboard, bass block and register stops): 
11" high, 6.25" deep, 7" wide from outside of treble frame to outside of bass frame.  (28 x  16 x 17.8 cm)
Add 1.25 to 1.75" (3.2-4.5 cm) to the box height for the register stops.

Bass block:  8" high x 2.25" deep x 2" wide (increase w to 3.25" for strap.) (20 x 5.7 x 5cm)
Keyboard:  10" high x 15/16 deep x 2.75 wide. (25.4 x 2.4 x 7cm) 
Button spacing: 6.75" (17cm) center to center for 10 buttons.

Weight (for a C box) 6lbs 13 oz in African Mahogany, 6lbs 15oz for big-leaf flame maple. (3.1kg)

With the possible exception of the height of the register knobs, Marc has been very consistent over the years.  My recollection is that the Melodie is more compact...certainly the keyboard is.  I don't remember details about the Melodie's button spacing.

Let me know if you need more specs.

Cheers--


Logged
--Mike Schway
Bellingham, WA US

Personal arsenal:  Marc Savoy Acadian (C,D, wet D), Corona II (60s GCF, newer GCF and FBE), Far, FAR too-many pokerworks (GC, AD, DG), Erica GC, Castagnari Dinn3 C#D, Merlin DG, Lisheen C#D

mselic

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1683
Re: Dimensions of popular Québécois and Cajun accordions?
« Reply #2 on: August 31, 2026, 02:44:52 AM »

Ross, are you concerned and/or looking for a one-row that is smaller in size than the average cajun box?  I saw recently that you were looking for an older, smaller Castagnari "Max", but now also for a (Savoy) Acadian.  I used to play one-row exclusively, and living in Quebec I've worked on and played many, many handmade one rows as well as Louisiana-made Cajun boxes.  I also used to own a Melodie and one of the older, smaller Castagnari Max boxes (apologies that I no longer have either to be able to measure them for you)  I'm assuming you may not have had much opportunity to try any of the above? The boxes you have described could hardy be more different from each other in terms of how they feel, sound and play, so it's something to bear in mind.

Most Louisiana-made Cajun boxes are pretty consistent in terms of overall design and size.  They're almost all copies of the Savoy Acadian which in turn was a copy of the Monarch/Sterling boxes.  They're pretty industrious.  Mike has given you some dimensions and most Cajun boxes won't vary much from that.  Messerviers are comparable in size.  Melodies are smaller.  The older Maxes smaller and shorter.  The latter two have pinned belows whereas the others all have two end frames that need to be wide enough to be screwed together. Keyboard spacing on Melodies and Maxes is closer together than on Cajun boxes. The length of the lever (distance from button to axle) is longest on Cajun boxes, shorter on Melodie and shortest on Max.  The longer the lever - the nicer the action! But, once again, apart from the overall dimensions, they are all VERY, VERY different from one another.  It's a point that I really want to stress if you're shopping around for a one-row and haven't had a chance to try any of them.
Logged
C#/D player

Winston Smith

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4066
  • AKA Edward Jennings
    • "Our Luxor B&B" Luxor life, slice by slice.
Re: Dimensions of popular Québécois and Cajun accordions?
« Reply #3 on: August 31, 2026, 10:03:57 AM »

Thanks for that explanation mselic. If I was in the market for an expensive 1 row, that is the exact sort of info which I'd find most helpful!
Logged
At last, broken and resigned to accept conformity.
Oh, how I LOVE Big Brother!

Ross Dubois

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 144
Re: Dimensions of popular Québécois and Cajun accordions?
« Reply #4 on: August 31, 2026, 03:18:49 PM »

Thanks for all that info Matt! And thanks Mike for the details

I have an opportunity to buy either an Acadian, a very old Max small model, and a Melodie. I have owned a Martin before and found the action a little on the stiffer side and the volume intense. I don't actually enjoy the super powerful volume of Binci Cajun boxes but I play Irish trad specifically so I was leaning more toward the max. The reedblocks are easier to deal with for me and takes off some of that super intense volume. I also have a thing for small boxes, like concertinas, I have a very old Tommy, and a strange one off Melodeon from Herbert Svoboda, so it makes the max extra appealing.

There's something to be said for the power and speed Diarmuid has and the sound he gets out of the Acadian but also I'm not remotely Diarmuid and I prefer a bit less volume in general as I end up practicing around my toddler a lot in the mornings before my partner wakes up, haha

The melodie is gorgeous. The clips I've heard are rather bright sounding which isn't a negative. I play a Hohner 113 from 1952 and really enjoy the bright edge that one has, especially because Johnny Og Connolly played some tunes on one and really sold me on the sound.

But yeah, I have struggle to make a concise decision but size, volume, serviceability, button feel and pressure, as well as rarity also matter to me, so here I struggle
Logged

rees

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5055
  • Windjammer
    • Wesson Accordions
Re: Dimensions of popular Québécois and Cajun accordions?
« Reply #5 on: August 31, 2026, 07:05:22 PM »

Johnny Connolly also played a Castagnari Max as does his son, Johnny Og.
Maybe the Max is the one to go for.
Logged
Rees Wesson (accordion builder and mechanic)
Gungrog, Welshpool, Wales, UK
www.melodeons.com

MikeSchway

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11
Re: Dimensions of popular Québécois and Cajun accordions?
« Reply #6 on: August 31, 2026, 08:29:59 PM »

...
I have an opportunity to buy either an Acadian, a very old Max small model, and a Melodie. I have owned a Martin before and found the action a little on the stiffer side and the volume intense. I don't actually enjoy the super powerful volume of Binci Cajun boxes but I play Irish trad specifically so I was leaning more toward the max. The reedblocks are easier to deal with for me and takes off some of that super intense volume. I also have a thing for small boxes, like concertinas, I have a very old Tommy, and a strange one off Melodeon from Herbert Svoboda, so it makes the max extra appealing.

If you're playing Irish I'd advise you to give the Acadian a serious tryout before plunging in.  Marc is a huge fan of stiff pallet springs.  Even though it seems that should make for slower action, it actually yields quicker response, or rather, more distinct which is a real plus for staccato playing, but may slow you down on faster reels and such.  Also Marc's tuning coming out of the shop is based on Just-temperament, only more so.  ;) His thirds and 7ths are "sweetened" more than most folks' and if you ever play with a piano, it might yield some "surprising" results.  Now that his insanely-talented son, Joel*, is stepping into more of the accordion building, there may be the opportunity to request more novel temperaments on new boxes.

* True, Joel is "insanely talented" but so the rest of that family! <3


--Mike
Logged
--Mike Schway
Bellingham, WA US

Personal arsenal:  Marc Savoy Acadian (C,D, wet D), Corona II (60s GCF, newer GCF and FBE), Far, FAR too-many pokerworks (GC, AD, DG), Erica GC, Castagnari Dinn3 C#D, Merlin DG, Lisheen C#D

-Y-

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 896
  • Handry 18 (G/C), Mélodie (D), Club IIb (A/D)
    • a database of nearly 500 melodeons here
Re: Dimensions of popular Québécois and Cajun accordions?
« Reply #7 on: August 31, 2026, 10:37:04 PM »

One of my main boxes is a Mélodie (I got it new in 2019 I think), and I'm quite loving it. I didn't try many one-row boxes, one from Eric Martin, one from Manu Pariselle (maybe it was a workshop one) and also a Beltuna.
One thing that I particularly like about the Mélodie is that the bass block is narrower than what there was on the Cajun-styled boxes I tried. I find it easier to play, the larger bass blocks feel more bulky to me. Also, I find the Mélodie quite 'nimble' in comparison of say, the Martin, which felt more 'rugged', so to speak. I should say that it is not thought of as a flaw, it's just that Cajun-style boxes and the Mélodie are different beasts altogether. They are good boxes but definitely do not feel or handle exactly the same.
I'm usually not a big fan of Binci reeds with higher-pitched instruments (especially with newer Bincis) as I often find it too shrill, but for some reason I don't have this feeling with the Mélodie. I find it very easy to play (the keyboard action is neither too stiff nor too supple), the dynamic range is very good, and it's well suited to speedy music (in my case fast-paced reels for set dancing).
I'd love to try the Max to compare, I expect it'd be more 'gentle' than the Mélodie.

mselic

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1683
Re: Dimensions of popular Québécois and Cajun accordions?
« Reply #8 on: September 01, 2026, 01:34:40 AM »

Thanks for letting us know what your options are.  I'll give you my personal experiences and thoughts with the three types of box you're considering (take it for what it's worth, or disregard!).

First of all, it's worth remembering that things like button tension can always be adjusted to your preference, so you're not limited by how a box is currently set up.

The one-row that I ultimately settled upon as my main player for many years was the Mélodie.  I owned two; the first had fixed stops, and the second had working stops.  That second one is now owned and played by Diarmuid O Meachair! At the time he told me it was his favourite melodeon.  Mélodies with fixed stops (no actual sliders) have larger sound holes and are absolute monsters - big and powerful sound, loud and strong.  The one that I had with working stops was still a powerhouse, but maybe not *quite* as mighty as its stopless counterpart.  I found these boxes to be best suited for the music that I played, which was primarily Newfoundland and Irish trad.  The button action was nice and low (and was easily lowered if desired), spring-tension nice and light by default, and the buttons themselves had rounded edges.  It was just so EASY to play, and easier than any Cajun box or the Max.  And, from a woodworking perspective, no other one-row comes even close.  Sylvain Vezina has gotten it down to an art, so that the only fasteners of any kind that you will see are the four bellows pins.  Even the pallet arms attach to the levers seamlessly.  A friend of mine took his Mélodie on a road trip to Louisiana and showed it to Clarence Martin Jr. and his daughter when he visited Martin Accordions - he said both of them were blown away by the build quality, with the daughter turning to Clarence and exclaiming "do NOT expect me to make that!" (no offence intended to Martin Accordions - many find theirs to be the best of the cajun builders!)

I owned one of the older Castagnari Max boxes before I started trying any of the handmade Quebec boxes.  It was a great little box, but it had plenty of flaws (for me).  The first thing I did was have the air button moved from the top of the growl box to where it 'should' be in the middle.  It's definitely an odd duck in the melodeon world.  The pointed edges on all sides could be uncomfortable, depending on how one held or braced the box.  It was quite loud, but it definitely did not have the bright sound that a Binci-reeded box has.  Unlike Bincis, I also found the H bank of reeds in the Max didn't quite *pop* or stand out in the way that I liked with LMMH reeded one-rows.  I also found it didn't play as easily or as nicely as Binci-reeded instruments.  One thing that's nice about the Max compared to just about every other one-row is that the keyboard travel was limited with padding under the buttons.  I actually padded/limited the keyboard travel on my Mélodie, but that's definitely not an easy process on that particular instrument.  I had fun with the Max but I remember how much more I liked the Quebec-made box I got afterwards.

The Acadian...I have many friends who own (Savoy-made) Acadians (not to be mistaken for the Italian-made versions that carry the same name and logo, but have different design elements).  I've also worked on quite a few of them, many of them brand-new instruments.  Now, I'm going to tread lightly here, as I do not wish to offend anyone, but from my experience they all needed a lot of work to get them up to playing speed.  The Acadian is a very industrious box - it's big, bulky, has lots of fasteners and metal hardware, enormous stop knobs, heavy button action.  I've found the overall construction to be pretty basic and rough, and reed setup (and newer instruments) often very poor.  Buttons are large with squared-edges and button height is often very high.  Keep in mind that these instruments are generally designed and set up for Cajun music, and cajun box players generally love the feel of them.  I don't think most Cajun box players would like a Mélodie, Messervier or a Max.  For someone like me, playing fast-paced Irish music with plenty of notes, I did not find the Acadian a good fit.  Now, of course, there are some amazing Irish melodeon players who love playing on Cajun boxes (Johnny Connolly, Diarmuid O Meachair)...but it's also worth noting that these guys could make a cardboard box sound good! One thing Cajun boxes do have going for them is the sound - the box *rumbles* as it speaks, like a machine coming to life!  Again, it's very industrious - in feel as well as sound. Horns blaring!  I used to be heavy truck driver, so I'll use this as a metaphor - a Mélodie would be like a Volvo (refined, elegant) whereas an Acadian is like a big, long-nose Kenworth (badass)! A cajun box is best played loud, rather than for more nuanced, soulful playing.  I found the Mélodie was good for both.

Of course, your mileage may vary and all that.  Certainly there will be folks with experiences at odds with my own.  Not all instruments of a particular brand or make are created equal.  It's always best to try before you buy, but for many of us in North America, that's often not possible.  Anyhow, I'm only sharing the above in case it's helpful data with your decision making.  I'll stress that my conclusions were based on what was a best fit for ME, rather than me suggesting a particular make was inherently good or bad.

Good luck!
« Last Edit: September 01, 2026, 01:43:42 AM by mselic »
Logged
C#/D player

tirpous

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1403
Re: Dimensions of popular Québécois and Cajun accordions?
« Reply #9 on: September 03, 2026, 06:18:27 PM »

Dimensions from my 90s Acadian (Marc Savoy):

Overall:  12.75 high (with stops extended) x 6.25 deep x ~12.5"wide (including keyboard and bass strap) (32.4 x 15.9 x 31.8 cm)

Main box (less keyboard, bass block and register stops): 
11" high, 6.25" deep, 7" wide from outside of treble frame to outside of bass frame.  (28 x  16 x 17.8 cm)
Add 1.25 to 1.75" (3.2-4.5 cm) to the box height for the register stops.

Bass block:  8" high x 2.25" deep x 2" wide (increase w to 3.25" for strap.) (20 x 5.7 x 5cm)
Keyboard:  10" high x 15/16 deep x 2.75 wide. (25.4 x 2.4 x 7cm) 
Button spacing: 6.75" (17cm) center to center for 10 buttons.

Weight (for a C box) 6lbs 13 oz in African Mahogany, 6lbs 15oz for big-leaf flame maple. (3.1kg)

With the possible exception of the height of the register knobs, Marc has been very consistent over the years.  My recollection is that the Melodie is more compact...certainly the keyboard is.  I don't remember details about the Melodie's button spacing.

Let me know if you need more specs.

Cheers--

Late to the game, as I was away from home, Internet and my notes. Here are some measurements from a 4-voice Mélodie, for comparison:

Main box: 28.2 x 15.6 x ? cm
Bass block: 22.5 x 4.8 x 5.6 cm
Keyboard: 23.6 x 2.3 x 6.8 cm
Button spacing: 17.1 cm

These were taken some time back on an instrument I was repairing for a friend, so unfortunately I do not have the number for Main box width. Other than that, the numbers seem to be fairly close to the Acadian. But numbers are not everything, for instance the Melodie keyboard has relieved rather than square ends, which will maybe feel more compact. And the Acadian bass block is 5.7cm 'deep' at its base but the sides are scalloped and the top is 5cm, so it feels more like 5cm than 5.7 to the hand.

Ideally you could try the instruments to see and hear how they feel to -you-. If you're into smaller size and less volume, maybe a Mélodie 3-voice would be of interest. It measures 26.7 x 14.3 cm or so.




Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal