Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Digital Melodeon? What do you think?  (Read 468 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

robedney

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4
Digital Melodeon? What do you think?
« on: Yesterday at 12:30:25 AM »

I'm nearly finished doing a full repair/restoration of an old red pre-Pokerwork instrument.  I'm enjoying the process, but it is not a simple task.  Things like bellows repair are straightforward and simple, replacing reed valves is simple, but tweaking reeds to get them to sound properly is iffy and time consuming, not to mention tuning.  I gravitated to the melodeon after a fascination with concertinas.  The melodeon is much more "my" instrument, and I'm glad I found it.  While in the concertina universe I built a couple of digital instruments for the fun of it (YouTube video linked below).  By the time I finished it up I concluded that, although it was a fun project, I wanted to work on good old acoustic instruments.  I'm rethinking that now, and here's why:

There are some beautiful old boxes out there, as anyone who shops the usual sources -- particularly Ebay -- can attest.  These are often lovely bits of work and -- I once thought -- might be good candidates for refurbishing and selling at a reasonable cost to folks new to the instrument who wanted something to play.  I'm retired with time on my hands, so making a fortune at this is not a requirement.  However, now that I've dealt with two Ebay boxes, I can see that this may well be a fool's errand.  There is no way of pre--determining how much work a box will require, and even something in moderately good condition is likely to consume a fair amount of bench time.  Doing one for myself (my current project) is one thing, but making a habit of it is something else entirely.

Then there is the problem of "what key is it?".  It seems that 90% of online listings have no indication of the key(s) the melodion was built to, and the sellers are not likely to figure it out even if asked to.  Depending on the focus of one's musical interested, a nice box, even if working well, may be unsuitable. 

Having gone through the extensive work of building a digital concertina I've solved most of the problems associated with that, and that knowledge/practice directly translates to the melodion.  So I'm rethinking things.  Theres a lot more room in a melodeon box, so the idea of having not only a MIDI based synthesizer inside but also a couple of quality speakers and amps is entirely doable.  That, along with a rechargeable internal battery, creates an instrument that is entirely freestanding, plays like a melodeon, sounds like a melodeon and -- best of all -- looks like a lovely vintage box because it is one.  Add to that the ability to select any combination of keys you like, how wet or dry you want the sound to be, specifically assign any button or combination of buttons, turn off the speakers and plug in a headset to practice/play silently, etc. You get a very flexible system that can be changed on the fly.  The system I've designed uses an air pressure sensor to detect bellows pressure, so the feedback you get from the bellows can be tuned to match what you're already used to.  The buttons use Hall-effect sensors and are nearly entirely trouble and maintenance free, not to mention nearly silent. 

So, what do you think?  Would you play such an instrument?  Here's the YouTube video.  This shows a fully built concertina from parts I 3D printed.  For a melodeon I am proposing retrofitting a nice looking vintage box:  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wICkse5D8Gc&t=1196s 
Logged

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Digital Melodeon? What do you think?
« Reply #1 on: Yesterday at 08:26:25 AM »

Personally I have no wish to play a digital instrument but I’m sure there are many players who would be interested.
I love older Hohners and also old Italian makes.  For me the attraction is the quality of sound that they make.  Digital instruments can only reproduce an approximation to that which I hear as too clean and perfect.  For the same reason I don’t often like to see old instruments fitted with new reeds.  It just takes the heart out of the instrument.

I’d encourage you to persevere with the reed work.  It does take a bit of time to learn,  but with a small number of good tools it can be done.  It’s a skill, and like any skill it just takes a bit of time and perseverance.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Howard Jones

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1203
Re: Digital Melodeon? What do you think?
« Reply #2 on: Yesterday at 12:35:52 PM »

There is definitely some interest in MIDI melodeons. The best known is Streb, and these are quite sought after. Roland also made one but that seems less successful. Roy Whiteley in Cheshire does MIDI conversions, and there was a guy in Scotland (whose name currently escapes me) but he's now retired.

I have a Streb, and it's a lot of fun to play around with different sounds and different keyboard layouts. It's also useful for silent practice.  However, as Theo has noted, the problem is the quality of sound. The inbuilt melodeon samples aren't convincing to my ears (and importantly those of my bandmates), even through good speakers. Most sound modules are for accordions, but despite the similarities in construction melodeons seem to have a their own distinctive sound and accordion samples don't quite do the trick.

The best sound I've found is Michael Eskin's "Vintage Accordion" for Thumbjam on iPhone/iPad (he also has Hohner samples which I must try). However I'm not confident that playing through an iPhone is sufficiently robust for live work. I thought the Streb would be useful as a "melodeon capo" to play in different keys, but in practice the band usually just transposes tunes into keys which are more friendly for me, and I seldom gig with it. If I could find good melodeon samples in an affordable hardware setup suitable for live work it might be a different matter.

I agree with Theo that old instruments, especially Hohners, can sound lovely, and I'd also encourage you to persevere with restoring it as a "proper" instrument. You could perhaps get hold of a scrap instrument to practice reed work on before you tackle this one, or if it seems too much then Theo or one of the other excellent fettlers we have could no doubt do it for you. If the innards were completely shot then reusing the carcase for MIDI might be a good use for it, but that doesn't seem to be the situation here.

Helena Handcart

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2452
  • Saltarelle Nell
Re: Digital Melodeon? What do you think?
« Reply #3 on: Yesterday at 01:18:51 PM »

For me, I probably would although I agree with Theo about the sound of acoustic instruments - also the feel and response you get from them is just a better playing experience.

I have a Streb, number 008, the very first 2.5 row one made.  Although I rarely use it these days I would not wish to part with it. As a (mostly former) software developer and general lover of geekery though, I would probably be easily persuaded to try such a device were you to go ahead with this project.

Logged
Saltarelle Le Romané  | Saltarelle Nuage | Oakwood | various elderly Hohners

Rog

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2525
  • Repair and tuning in Hants
Re: Digital Melodeon? What do you think?
« Reply #4 on: Yesterday at 01:59:16 PM »

A few years ago I was briefly involved with a midi melodeon project..I was a software developer for many years and seemed like a good fit. The hardware involved an onboard Arduino processor, hall sensors etc, hooked up to an external Midi sound module, which was based on a V3 accordion module (see Thomann for these sound modules). It had a few issues. Firstly the developer had a custom V3 module made ..for reasons i could never understand given there is a good production accordion module available. Secondly, this person was not a trained/experienced developer, and unfortunately this showed. The control software was pretty flaky and ..I decided after a while..not resilient enough for production. We disagreed over this and parted ways. But what was blindingly obvious from the outset is that the market for this kind of custom made midi melodeon is minute…so small that there isn’t really a market at all. From a business perspective it made no sense to me…because I was working with a small margin and then expected to 'support' the flaky software without access to the source code or a proper technical manual. On top of which, it wasn't actually that great a product. The underlying idea was good: find a suitable donor instrument, strip out the reeds and convert it. But in the end the flaky software let it down. If you are a gigging musician who needs to switch keys rapidly on a melodeon..then it sort of did the job.  But otherwise it was a solution looking for a problem.  On top of that, having played a couple of Roland digital accordions, the difference was chalk and cheese. The Roland beat it hands down on quality.
The little corner of the 'market' for midi melodeon is occupied by the Streb, which people love.
Finally, midi instruments are an acquired taste, when compared to a regular reeded instrument. They seem like a good idea, but really they are not (in my opinion..same applies to a digital piano when compared to a strung piano).
« Last Edit: Yesterday at 02:01:39 PM by Rog »
Logged

Guy

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 776
  • Not quite enough melodeons....
    • Cats Claw
Re: Digital Melodeon? What do you think?
« Reply #5 on: Yesterday at 02:03:59 PM »

Strebs are certainly sought after, and seem to get snapped up as soon as one appears, so I would definitely say there's a demand for digital melodeons. There's a demand for good tuners as well, so I guess it's up to whatever you'd prefer...

I think the Streb is great, but I'm with everyone else in that there's no substitute for the sound and feel of an acoustic instrument. I seem to remember Squeezy saying in a video that the reason that he stopped playing his Streb live was he didn't get the sound vibrations, feel and touch even in a noisy stage setting, which I get. However, the band I'm in has recently decided to use in-ear monitors, which I think for me has changed how the melodeon feels to play (and I feel distances us a bit from the dancing, but that's for another topic), so I've started using the Streb for live gigs, quite successfully according to the rest of the band and caller.

I guess what I'm saying is that the demand is there, both for general play and silent practice, and I'd certainly like to try another one for comparison. The downside I suppose is that it's a niche market inside another niche market...

Cheers,
Guy
Logged
Guy, in South Wales

Cats Claw, http://www.cats-claw.co.uk

xgx

  • Bagpipes & Musette Boxes... and Banjos, luv 'em!
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1157
Re: Digital Melodeon? What do you think?
« Reply #6 on: Yesterday at 02:08:46 PM »

The digi instrument has its place ... for me that's in the motorhome ... avoids getting thrown off a site for making too much noise*   ;D 
*   (Redpipes, a digi version of Great Highland Bagipes)

I'd love a digi 'tina to complement my Streb
Logged
Graham

Socio-Demographic:   Graduate, Coffin Dodger
 Location: N Cambs/S Lincs - UK

Howard Jones

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1203
Re: Digital Melodeon? What do you think?
« Reply #7 on: Yesterday at 03:47:16 PM »

I've started using the Streb for live gigs, quite successfully according to the rest of the band and caller.

Guy, what are you using to generate the sounds? My bandmates are pretty clear that they don't like the Streb's onboard sounds, and I'm not keen myself.

I tried the V3 accordion module, but for reasons I can't quite put my finger on I wasn't happy with the sounds. The few melodeon samples were from a make I'm not familiar with, and the accordion samples don't quite work for me.  There is a V3 "Celtic" version, which has whistles and uillean pipes etc but I've not tried that and I don't know if the accordion/melodeon sounds are any better.

I have gadget based on a Raspberry Pi which plays soundfonts, which isn't bad but occasionally throws a wobbly, and Thumbjam on iPhone but I've doubtful that the connections are robust enought for gigging.

I quite agree that MIDI is a niche, and a small one at that.  It's fun to complement my real instruments but I wouldn't want the Streb as my main instrument, good though it is.

Rog

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2525
  • Repair and tuning in Hants
Re: Digital Melodeon? What do you think?
« Reply #8 on: Yesterday at 05:22:17 PM »

In the time I was (sort of) marketing it from my website..and I get quite a lot of traffic through there..i only had 2 or 3 enquiries. So my experience is that there is virtually no market, and certainly not one that justifies sinking money into it, as I did. Having a notion that something is a good idea or that it has a market is different from actually testing the theory. Interestingly, the place where there is a small demand is for repairs to midi accordions..I get a few enquiries..per year. My work ratio wise is perhaps 2 accordions to 2 concertinas to 1 melodeon (so about 1 out if 5 jobs).

Guy

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 776
  • Not quite enough melodeons....
    • Cats Claw
Re: Digital Melodeon? What do you think?
« Reply #9 on: Today at 05:12:05 PM »

I've started using the Streb for live gigs, quite successfully according to the rest of the band and caller.

Guy, what are you using to generate the sounds? My bandmates are pretty clear that they don't like the Streb's onboard sounds, and I'm not keen myself.


Hi Howard, I’m afraid I’m not very technically minded, so I’m not sure how much help this will be…sorry!

I’m using the standard onboard voices – this instrument (a 2.5-row, No 13, I think) was checked over and updated by Steve Rouse for the previous owner in 2023/4 so it’s whatever was the norm then. I have for gigs used a couple of the Mory voices and tweaked them using the inbuilt controls to make them sound as reasonable as possible.

I think the magic happens after that. Sam (our superb young guitarist) is also a hugely experienced sound engineer – he does the sound for a lot of visiting bands in the South Wales area and runs one of the smaller sound stages at Glastonbury. We use iPads to control the PA sound and he can adjust the treble/bass balance and the tone quality of the Streb independently of anything else and change the sound so that everyone is happy with it. I don’t know what he does – he tried to explain it to me but lost me in sentence 1 with “adjusting sine wave patterns” (I think) …

It still doesn’t sound or feel like an acoustic instrument, but I have to say that I’m surprised at the result. I wanted to try it as an experiment but didn’t think the others (or me, really) would actually go for it.  It’s early days yet, but I’ll keep it in for some sets for now. And of course it means I can play Christmas tunes on the Church Organ setting…

Cheers,
Guy
Logged
Guy, in South Wales

Cats Claw, http://www.cats-claw.co.uk

robedney

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 4
Re: Digital Melodeon? What do you think?
« Reply #10 on: Today at 05:56:18 PM »

Thanks very much for the responses!  I was unaware of the Streb, and it was informative to have a look at it via the web.  I have to admit that I'm torn at this point.  I'm enjoying my restoration of my Ebay purchase, and part of me wants to spend time finding nice old boxes and bringing them back to life in their original form (acoustically). 

On the other hand, the digital retrofitting is so very tempting because it offers some significant advantages:
It just works.  Tuning is dead on and stays that way.  A wet or dry sound is dirt simple to vary.
The key of the instrument is fully adjustable --- on the fly if needed.
You can play/practice silently -- a huge advantage at times.
It preserves beautiful old vintage boxes that otherwise will just sit on shelves or end up in the bin.

One of the things mentioned here that I fully agree with has to do with the characteristic MIDI sound that we've all heard:  Too perfect, robotic sounding.  However, in developing the concertina, I was able to make good use of AI as a programming assistant and come up with creative ways of giving the sound some real life and authenticity.  Although, in general, I think that AI is something we'd be better off without, it is incredibly versatile in coding.  I can say something like:  "Give me some variance in the higher harmonics to replicate variations from reed to reed", and it will do it -- addressing one note at a time -- something that would take hours of manual coding.  It's a long way from the days of controlling attack, sustain and decay.  Yes, you can sample an acoustic instrument and replicate it's sound, but you can keep shaping the voicing from that point and create something quite real sounding.  You can, for example, vary the voice of a single note based on bellows pressure, the way a physical reed will change its voice when overblown, for example.

I'm not all that concerned with marketability.  I'm old, and building some sort of enterprise is the furthest thing from my mind.  The idea would be to find lovely vintage boxes, do the conversion work and then offer them up for sale -- one at a time -- perhaps a maximum of 20 a year or so.  One of the primary issues is the bellows.  Many of these old instruments have bellows that either need serious refurbishment or replacement, and new bellows tend to be pricey.  Which brings us to the question:  How much do I charge for one of these things?  Assuming that it sounds good and works well, what might a melodeon fan be willing to pay for such an instrument?   
Logged

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: Digital Melodeon? What do you think?
« Reply #11 on: Today at 07:48:28 PM »

20 a year sounds very very ambitious!  That's one complete instrument out the door every two and a half weeks.  To achieve that you would need to have the design and construction completely sorted, and you would have to spend some time getting word out to customers. 

On a practical note you can get new bellows from Italy for around £150 each, or less if you were to order enough for one years production.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

chris hall

  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 246
Re: Digital Melodeon? What do you think?
« Reply #12 on: Today at 10:40:32 PM »

your concertina sounds pretty good to me. A while ago i was asked to join an irish band playing all the classic irish songs. long story short i didnt play a BC or C#D semitone system so ended up playing a DG / a CF/ a GC / and an AD....Every song was in a different key to suit the vocals but carrying four boxes seemed like a lot to carry and keep changing on stage. I had a roland that id previously experimented with for zydeco so i tried that. It kind of worked for zydeco as i could play across the rows and keep the bellows changes smooth but i didnt like the sounds (apart from the organ sound that made the band sound like Booker T and the MG's) needless to say for irish tunes it just didnt work at all. Then i read on Melnet about a system by Roy Hendrie. I was curious so thought it worth a shot. I sent him an old hohner Erica and he did all the internal work to turn it into a midi system. It worked through a celtic sounds V3 interface (mentioned in this thread earlier by Rog)....it was kind of ok but i knew nothing about midi tweaks. I just knew the sounds werent quite right and that it didnt respond well to changes in bellow direction. Roy convinced me to explore how to adjust all the settings through arduino and i'd send him my results. Slowly but surely things improved. At my request he added a digital display so i could see what key it was set to etc. I learnt how to alter the parameters to make it respond better. he changed the chip a couple of times and with each tweak things got better. After about a year it reached a point where it became almost useable on a live gig but alas Roy retired the idea. He was discouraged because piano accordion players were very happy with it and i wasnt. So now it sits on a shelf. It felt like an idea that was ahead of its time but not quite ready for the rigours of gigging. But that was 4 or 5 years ago and now is now. Maybe with AI and a different approach midi melodeon could be made to work. I cant imagine it could ever come anywhere even close to the sound of my hohners, saltarelles. acadians, martins, castagnaris and baffettis and i cant imagine there would be a big demand. twenty a year seems ambitious but my take on it is if you have the knowledge let the creativity flow. An electric guitar isnt an acoustic. A midi keyboard isnt an acoustic piano. A midi melodeon isnt a replacement for one with reeds. Hook up with someone who is an experienced player and work on the system together. Thats the only way you'll really know if it works. 
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal