Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?  (Read 4538 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Microbot

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 345
Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« on: April 10, 2010, 11:37:39 AM »

I wonder if I might start a thread on melodeons set up for irish music?
The long and short is a simple question - has anyone proposed/built a
C/C#/D system?

I've recently set up a few instruments in C#/D for players of irish
music, including a 3-voice and a couple of Liliputs. I've grown to quite
like the system myself, though I normally use a D/G melodeon. I play a
fair bit of irish stuff but I usually use the C/G Anglo for this. But
irish music on the C#/D really works - at least playing in D and A. The drawback is
playing in G on the C#/D has some awkward patterns that leave you with
bellows-work that often doesn't fit the tune you're playing. This is
particularly in the middle and upper registers. I've noticed threads in
Melnet advocating the C#/D/G melodeon to overcome this and make playing in
G more satisfactory.

But I find this a bit baffling. To me, the logical additional row would be
in C - this would leave you playing G tunes 'off the fifth' of that C row
- which is how its done on a B/C, how its done cajun style on a 1-row C
and exactly the same patterns you would use for playing in A on the C#/D.

To me, the G row added onto a C#/D is like bolting a bit of England onto
County Clare. Playing irish tunes in G on the G row ends up with those
tunes being a bit 'obvious' and clumsy, without the flow... I know Tim
Edey makes them sound great on a D/G ... But for me, playing off the fifth on a C row
gives more fluency and fits better with the tunes I know and the way I
play them...

well that's my experience coming from an anglo background... So why not a
C/C#/D system? D, G and A and all related minors would be a piece of cake.
You'd also have all the benefits of 3 rows a semi-tone apart with
fantastic cross-over potential.

I guess I must now prepare to be assailed by countless brilliant exponents
of irish music on C#/D and B/C systems telling me I'm an absolute
moron...!

Mike Rowbotham
Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #1 on: April 10, 2010, 12:27:07 PM »

Hi Mike,

I think it's a great idea. Like any system it would have its advantages and disadvantages.

I guess a nay-sayer would try to shut down the exploration by pointing out that a C/C#/D  would be more than beginners need to learn to play a few tunes well, and that very advanced players can play in many keys with ease on a "mere" 2-row C#/D or B/C box (or 3 row anglos).

I really enjoy C#/D boxes and don't mind playing G tunes on them (or many G tunes on a one-row in D, for that matter).

But I am one person who has tried a C#/D/G box and I think it has some nice features (as would the transposed versions in B/C/F, A/Bb/Eb. etc.). I did play some tunes up and down the G row (a little squeaky unless you have a bassoon reed), but mostly I liked that one box would allow both the quint-box and the semitone-box fingering styles without switching instruments. At least 12 basses would be needed to get the chords I want in the directions I want.

If I had a C/C#/D, I would use it as a C#/D box, and as a C/C# box played in the same style a semitone lower (this would suit some very early 1800s flutes, fiddlers who like to tune down a whisker, and C# pipes). The C row would add to a C#/D box the reversed direction buttons C and F natural, which would be handy for right-hand chords.

But mainly I think I would use a C/C#/D to add in some nice old "outside-in" settings of tunes in the styles of some of the early 20th-century box players (based mostly along that C row, with accidentals grabbed from the other row or not) in nice keys like C, G, A minor, and D minor.

In fact a friend of mine used to have two big stradella-bass Paolo 3-rows in different keys --  one a typical B/C/C#, but I think the other was either in C/C#/D or possibly C#/D/D#.

So your idea may already have been tried.

Another related experiment is the B/C/D system that is now available for sale in a converted Hohner Morino Club, by my friend Ted McGraw (see his ad here in this forum). In fact, if you could find matching top-quality Hohner reeds for the C# row, his accordion would be easy to convert to your proposed C/C#/D!

Disclaimer: I like trying and using all concertina and accordion systems and can get a little music out of them all, especially some "minority interests" these days like D/C#, A/D/C#,  and G/C/B. Once you can play a lot of tunes on a single row in several keys, and are willing to find and remember accidentals on other rows, you can find advantages in all these systems.

Paul Groff


edited to fix a couple of mistakes (probably not all of them, yet)


« Last Edit: April 10, 2010, 01:04:31 PM by pgroff »
Logged

mikesamwild

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 638
  • Melodeon, Button Accordion, Anglo Concertina
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #2 on: April 10, 2010, 01:11:13 PM »

I've been thinking about it too.  I play C/G Anglo mostly nowadays and have wondere whether an accidental row that was more of a scale  a semitone apart rather than the 'random' notes wouldbe useful.

I come from a D/G melodeon background and still like it and my Connemara III special D/G has  a third inside row of 9 accidentals which could be modified.

I also have a 2 row Saltarelle C#/D which I like a lot and can get most of the keys I want for Irish music, and was wondering about something with a G row or a C row added

I also like  to have C handy for some tunes and songs.  so I suppose I'm thinking of a sort of hybrid.


I think Chris Ryall who posts on melnet has an Oakwood  with 3 rows but I can't remember which (I met him at whitby a few years back) but he was playing French and English full chordal tunes not Irish.


I have a nice old 3 row 3 voice Hohner which I could experiment with so would be glad to hear of other people's views.




Logged
Mike in Sheffield

If music be the food of love -who finds the time?

EeeJay

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 642
  • Old Grey Paolo
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #3 on: April 10, 2010, 01:21:43 PM »

Speaking as a user/advocate of C#/D/G...

Indeed like you say, you're coming from an Anglo 'tina mindset... jeez, now there's a perverse rig for playing fast flowing music on... >:E

To me, the G row added onto a C#/D is like bolting a bit of England onto County Clare.

I've never seen it helpful to pigeonhole whatever system as 'x', 'y' or 'z'. I follow the Poutoux doctrine... think outside the box... :|glug

Playing irish tunes in G on the G row ends up with those tunes being a bit 'obvious' and clumsy, without the flow...

And I've never regarded the D/G system as clumsy. OK so an awful lot of folks do play clumsily (jeez, like I know already ::)), but with practice/crossrowing, it's a piece of cake. Likewise, G on the draw of a C#/D. Like falling off a log when you know how.

C#/D/G maintains a general 'Melodeon-y' feel in my mind... something which I feel the three row semitone systems distinctly lack (the temptation to graft a Stradella bass end on etc.). Not as I'm suggesting this is bad (I own a B/C/C#), but it feels like a different instrument to me. Not better/worse - just different.

I know Tim Edey makes them sound great on a D/G ...

That said, Speedy Edey's new toy is a C#/D/D#...

Ed J
Logged

Microbot

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 345
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #4 on: April 10, 2010, 02:09:41 PM »

replying to Paul groffs posting and kind PM... and other postings above!

... first off, many thanks for these responses - much food for thought...

The reason for the posting is that I quite fancy making a C/C#/D and was wondering, first what if any prior experience exists. I've had a PM message from another member pointing out that the idea is discussed by Mallinson in his Absolute Beginners book, so its certainly not a new notion... whilst Paul and others have given me an insight into the merits of C#/D/G, and further pointers.

The 'rationale behind the idea' I gave in my original posting is from a personal players angle. I was trying to explain why, for me, I thought the idea has merit. but I certainly didn't want to suggest there's anything 'wrong' with C#/D/G - as Paul points out it gives you the benefits of a fifth-box, cross-rowing a la D/G - and also a semi-tone box. But still, for me, on the D/G melodeon, I find tunes in G less satisfactory than tunes in D... whilst playing off the fifth in G on a C-row is just so much fun, and rolls better. I think that's the point I'm trying to make, and the reason for asking. And I'm only too happy to admit it is a personal view and underlines my style/limitations as a player.

Going further and seeking to tap into Melnet wisdom ... If I did make a C/C#/D, and if this were a 12-bass instrument, what basses might be useful in addition to the standard 8 you get with a C#/D? A bass/chord in C major suggests itself, and possibly some minors?

thanks for all the responses and apologies if these are not discussed directly...

Mike R
Logged

Keithypete.

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 917
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #5 on: April 10, 2010, 02:22:15 PM »

I'm sure you're aware of the existence of a C#/D/D# system.
Logged
Beltuna Sara II - B/C flavour.
Borsini - G,D,A.
Pokerwork B/C.
PRIMATONA IV, B/C.

LDbosca

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 674
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #6 on: April 10, 2010, 02:54:05 PM »

The drawback is
playing in G on the C#/D has some awkward patterns that leave you with
bellows-work that often doesn't fit the tune you're playing. This is
particularly in the middle and upper registers.

Mike Rowbotham

I can't say I've noticed this at all, what way doesn't it fit? I play in F on B/C a good bit (same as G in Csharp/D) and while there's slightly more bellows work because one can't use the B on both directions to smooth things out I think it adds to the rhythmic effect. Isn't Csharp/D meant to be about the pushing and drawing? Not to shoot down your idea, I just think that maybe some of the limitations of the system have a positive effect musically...or something!

Microbot

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 345
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #7 on: April 10, 2010, 04:32:53 PM »

Hi LDBosca, thanks for that... I'll readily agree that I'm not so proficient on the C#/D. I also agree that the limitations of an instrument are part of its character.

I suppose what started me thinking in this direction was, in looking through past forum chats about C#/D for info, I came across the C#/D/G and the idea of a C/C#/D just seemed to me 'a better 3-row'. In fact, from other players its clear that the C#/D/G is far more than a 'bolt on' G row to make G playing easier. It has great cross-over potential. But so also would the C/C#/D, with 3 rows a semi-tone apart.

I'm not pushing the idea, but exploring it. And yes KeithyPete - thanks for that - the C#/D/D# system. I'll see what I can find out about basses on the C#/D/D# and see if that might help in guiding me towards an appropriate layout for C/C#/D

For me as a player, the major downside of C/C#/D would be that it would be a 3-row box. I do prefer 2 rows. But I also like making up novel instruments - hence the MBE 'Melnet Brainstrust Enquiry'.

cheers Mike R




Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #8 on: April 10, 2010, 04:53:32 PM »

Hi again Mike,

Back to your query about bass options for a hypothetical C/C#/D.

Players who actually use the basses a lot in Irish music seem to divide into a couple of groups:

1)  those who start from the traditional bass layouts for the Hohner, Paolo (etc.) B/C, C/C#, C#/D, and D/D# boxes, which have the bass and harmony buttons change their configuration in different bellows directions for most buttons.

2) those who have moved to many, most, or all bass and harmony buttons tuned to give the same notes in both bellows directions.

I fall into the first category because I like the feel and sound of the basses changing naturally with the bellows direction while I keep the fingers "at home" mostly on a few buttons. I actually don't find it hard to move my left hand around the bass buttons very independently from the right hand, and the bellows, probably because I play piano and organ and fretted instruments. But I just like the old-fashioned sound this layout gives me. I wouldn't usually go as far as the sound Gene Kelly got, staying constantly on one pair of buttons "no matter what," but I actually like that sound sometimes.

The second category would include the customized layouts I have seen attributed to John Williams, Joe Derrane, and other players.

Back to my suggestions, you will see they reflect my personal preferences:

For a C#/D 12-bass, I like the top 8 buttons to be laid out "traditionally:"

F#/B    A/E
D/G     D/A

but since I love minor triads for the great Em tunes, and like chords when playing in G major and D mixolydian I add these on the lower 4 buttons:

G/C   B major/E minor

For your proposed C/C#/D I would suggest this modification:

F#/B   A/E
C/G    D/A
G/F     B major/E minor

Or, those G/F buttons could be G/D if the key of G major is more of an interest than C major when playing on the C row.

If you remove the thirds from the triads, you might like this layout which would be especially nice for D minor:

F#/B   A/E
A/D     D/A
G/F     C/G

Or if you anticipate playing at all in C# pitch, maybe to replace the F#/B with a C#/G#

I actually think a 1930s Hohner 3 -row with 16 basses would give you better options though. These do get heavy on the left side, especially with zinc plate reeds.

Now I'm sure the advocates of stradella basses, or just 12 basses most of which don't change pitch with bellows direction, will make their points about less duplication with their system.

Just some thoughts,

PG
« Last Edit: April 10, 2010, 05:11:00 PM by pgroff »
Logged

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #9 on: April 10, 2010, 05:12:34 PM »

as many people on this forum know I can't see  an;y advatage in hybrid systems such as C#d  or even less so CC#D.  Why not just go for a logical BCC# which is not difficult to play in all 12 keys. learn 5 scales & get 7 free of charge!BCC# are usually larger than 'melodeons' & do have stradella bass which is very useful BUT any small 3 row box can be tuned to BCC# and there are bass possibilities that are no more limiting than on aa BC wwith 8 bass.  eg ;you could have 12 stradella  fcgdae ( even if not laid out in offset pattern) or paaerhaps 12 thirdless major chords ( i.e. just ums without any pah's) or for that matter  12 single basss notes so you can make up your own chords. The smallest BCC# I have tried was a acastagnari benny - the treble was brilliant but unfortunately the bass was as made for an adg.

george ;)
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

LDbosca

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 674
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #10 on: April 10, 2010, 05:15:12 PM »

For your proposed C/C#/D I would suggest this modification:

F#/B   A/E
C/G    D/A
G/F     B major/E minor

PG

If this is for ITM, would a Bminor not be more useful than a B major?

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #11 on: April 10, 2010, 05:29:01 PM »

LDbosca,

I usually do have B minor on the draw or a thirdless harmony interval for the F#/B buttons of a C#/D.

But for the 12-bass layout I do like B major on the press coupled with the E minor on the draw. It adds a great hearty option for backing to E minor reels, jigs, waltzes and songs played on the D row. You can use the D press chord sometimes to alternate with the Em but sometimes the B major is just what I want. Sort of the way you might hear a ceili band piano driver use the B major in some Em tunes....

But that's just me!

PG
Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #12 on: April 10, 2010, 05:38:48 PM »

.  eg ;you could have 12 stradella  fcgdae ( even if not laid out in offset pattern)
george ;)


George,

I have in my stored, leftover shop inventory a Wilkinson's Diaton V, 5-voice LMMMH B/C/C# with 12 basses set up exactly that way.

PG
Logged

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #13 on: April 10, 2010, 06:22:00 PM »

wow! 5 voice treble  is something I haave never come accross on a  12 bass BCC#, it usually being the ,still rare,province of the huge paino accordions that require a stand so loved by the classsical brigade. More like a strap on organ than a box - or should I rephrase that!

george ;D
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #14 on: April 10, 2010, 06:33:12 PM »

wow! 5 voice treble  is something I haave never come accross on a  12 bass BCC#, it usually being the ,still rare,province of the huge paino accordions that require a stand so loved by the classsical brigade. More like a strap on organ than a box - or should I rephrase that!

george ;D

George,

It's an oddball for sure, and this particular one, although it has a lot of top-quality features, has some construction details that were not well-executed (the buttons were put on the levers so that they tend to catch on the keyboard plate), so in fact it was never played. It isn't that big though, about the size of a 4 voice 2 row Paolo, and very light on the bass end. Red Celluloid body. Next time I am working in the leftover inventory I will photo it for melnetters.

I figure the "Wilkinson's Diaton V" is a late (1970s?) version of the lineage that started with the 1920s Hannah Model Wilkinson's Excelsior, a 2 row box with 24 (12 X 2) stradella basses. My example of that kind is a 2 voice box about the size of a Hohner Pokerwork, looks just like the one Hannah is playing in the picture shown on "Melodeon Greats," and is a B/C (if the pitch is A 452) or a C/C# (if the pitch is A 435)!

Now back to the topic....

PG



Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #15 on: April 10, 2010, 07:31:40 PM »

To echo a bit of what Luke and Paul said above, adding a C row to a C#/D purely because you find playing in G difficult on the D row seems very misguided to me. A bit of careful study of fingering patterns and few months of intensive practice will fix that problem, save you a lot of money, and keep you playing a lighter, more compact box. (You'd need quite a few more months of intensive practice to make D minor easy on C#/D though, which the C row would make a piece of cake.)

If you must have a three-row, I'd find it much more sensible to put the D row in the middle. There is the C#/D/D# that Tim Edey plays, as mentioned above, but I wonder whether C#/D/C wouldn't be a better layout than C#/D/G.

BTW, Québec box player and Joe Derrane aficionado, André Bouchard, now plays a 3-v D/C#, but the box he had before it was D/C#/C, the reverse of what you are proposing!

PS - about basses: I love having a B chord on the press, but mainly for playing against a D natural. I like everything thirdless anyway.

I happen to think that 12 basses are essential on a C#/D, or 10 basses anyway! I like G/G on an 8-bass layout, and I could make do with one extra pair - F/C.

C is vital for playing tunes in G of course. The F chord is a wonderful luxury for all kinds of tunes, esp. ones in D dorian, G mix, and A minor (true A minor).

It's a bit of a toss-up what to do with the other pair. Jackie Daly uses E/C#, I've tried both B/C# and E/F#. I now reckon that B/F# (reversing the normal top inside pair) is the most useful for me.
« Last Edit: April 10, 2010, 07:48:47 PM by Steve Jones »
Logged

Microbot

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 345
Re: Irish Music - how about a C/C#/D system?
« Reply #16 on: April 10, 2010, 11:33:56 PM »

hi Steve, Paul and others,

Im really grateful for the thoughtful responses on this. I'll consider them carefully in what I do and appreciate the time taken over the replies. As regards playing in G on the C#/D, I'm not averse to a bit of practice to get on top of a system.

As I said in a PM to Paul, I'm interested in the concept of a C/C#/D instrument for all the reasons I gave. But for my own playing I'd probably come at things from a different angle. I agree with Steve on the advantages of a 2-row box and really prefer them. I believe some players make minor alterations to the C# row, and there's the option perhaps of a 2.5 row with some reversals?

I also found the posts on basses very interesting and valuable - I really have missed having a C bass/chord. Paul - I'll be in touch when I've digested your remarks on basses - but I prefer diatonic basses rather than piano-accordian style as I sense you do.

can I also express amazement at the LMMMH 5-voice box - and can I ask, as a tuner, that nobody asks me to do one for them!

With grateful thanks to all ... This is the first topic I've started and all I can say is - its like a wild beast kicking off in many directions! I really appreciate the inputs

Mike R

Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal