Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: Another newbie research question  (Read 3415 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

JimJ

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 59
Another newbie research question
« on: July 05, 2010, 06:31:44 PM »

Hi again all,

I am having a great time working through the various tutorial books with my D/G pokerwork. The input I have gotten from this site has proved to be very helpful as well. But, wandering around youtube, I have made a discovery. Since I don't actually come from either an English traditional, or Irish traditional background the tunes you guys grew up with a quite foreign to me. I seem to be very attracted to the songs I hear being played on youtube, even more so than the traditional tunes, I guess because they are more familiar.

So, while I greatly enjoy learning the traditional tunes (it would be boring to only learn music I am familiar with), I can see me someday wanting to get involved more with songs. I can picture playing singalong music for Sunday School, or in a rest home environment. The question then becomes what is a good key range for this type of playing. I have read that the keys of C and F are particularly well suited to singing, but I was wondering if a there is enough of a difference between a C/F box and a D/G box to be noticeable, or if a move down to a G/C box might better suit this kind of a project.

I understand that many people find the high end of a D/G box to be almost unusable, to the point that D/G boxes get played almost exclusively in the lower octave, while G/C boxes use mostly the upper octave. The C/F boxes seem to be closer to the D/G end of the spectrum, so I was wondering how useful the upper octave is on a C/F box. Seem to be running out of room, better leave any questions for another time. Thanks all ---- JimJ

ps -- yes, I know the obvious answer is a PA, but I'm stuborn (:)
Logged

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #1 on: July 06, 2010, 01:25:34 AM »

Jim,
The lower range of a G/C is beautiful!
The choice of a box for song accompaniment will depend on the comfort zone of your vocal range, though not necessarily on the octave of the instrument.
-Andy

melodeon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1732
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #2 on: July 06, 2010, 07:04:43 AM »

I find D/G most enjoyable with a 3 reed configuration LMM.   
This makes the G row not only tolerable but enjoyable.
A 2 reed "almost tuned" Hohner in D/G is fingernails on a chalkboard.
A Lilly in D/G a tinnitus (sp) "a" bomb.

I find all areas of the keyboard on a G/C enjoyable.

I very much like Bb/Eb  but do not currently own one.

C/F is one of the least popular key systems in the US , I like it as well, but
I prefer the distance between G/C and D/G  for ownership of 2 boxes.

I don't, and cannot sing, so my input may be of limited value.
Logged

Simon

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 449
  • Serenellini Selli C/F and Gold98 G/C
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #3 on: July 06, 2010, 08:30:35 AM »

I have read that the keys of C and F are particularly well suited to singing, but I was wondering if a there is enough of a difference between a C/F box and a D/G box to be noticeable, or if a move down to a G/C box might better suit this kind of a project.
In the Netherlands C/F is the standard, with G/C a popular second box. And everyone thinks A/D is the best for singing. It's true that you have different playing styles for C/F (like D/G mostly the low end) and G/C (using the higher end). Personally I don't think there's a 'best box' for singing. For each tune you just have to pick a key so that the song is within the range of a singer. So if Bb is the best key for a particular song/singers combination you're pretty far of with a D/G. Don't worry too much about the high notes, since you can always use a box with a lower octave.
Logged

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #4 on: July 06, 2010, 08:56:02 AM »

as others have said it depends very much on the key(s) that you or those you are accompanying are comfortable singing in. many guitar tune books seem to pput a lotof tunes in the flat keys as do many song books. I find the BCC# very useful for song accompanyment & the DG much less so.  

A CC# may be worth considering as they are not particlarly popular & therefore can be had fairly cheaply. the keys of C,F,Bflat,Eflat & A flat are fairly easy which is a lot of keys from a small 2 row box.  However the standard bass will be of  very limited use for anything - but then fiddles & flutes accompany song perfectly well without any bass

george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

HallelujahAl

  • Guest
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #5 on: July 06, 2010, 09:09:42 AM »

OK JimJ here's your chance for MAD to really take hold - have a C/F; D/G & G/C box to cover most eventualities!

On a more serious note - I thought long and hard about this very issue, as I use my melodeon to lead a lot of singing etc in my church setting. I eventually decided that although having C/F & D/G boxes was a must for me personally, what I really needed was a three-row which would cover most situations in one box. I plumped for a Hohner 'El Rey del Vallenato' which is a lovely sounding 3 voiced box in  F/Bb/Eb. Not only is it brilliant for accompanying singing - but I can also play along with my brass band as well. So take a look at a three row - perhaps an A/D/G or G/C/F?
AL
Logged

nemethmik

  • Guest
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #6 on: July 06, 2010, 01:01:48 PM »

playing singalong music
The best range for singing for most people is C - up to (high) g, that is C, Db, D, Eb, E, F, Gb are the best for singalong music. Ladies can sing songs in G, Ab, A, Bb. Here I mean that the lowest note is the tonic; that is, a song in G major is perfect for singing if the notes range from low C up to high g.
Logged

ganderbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 734
  • Melodeons from Brittany, Italy, Germany* and Leeds
    • www.choughedtobits.co.uk
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #7 on: July 06, 2010, 03:24:28 PM »


I understand that many people find the high end of a D/G box to be almost unusable, to the point that D/G boxes get played almost exclusively in the lower octave, while G/C boxes use mostly the upper octave. The C/F boxes seem to be closer to the D/G end of the spectrum, so I was wondering how useful the upper octave is on a C/F box.

The high end of a D/G isn't necessarily unusable. It depends on the box, how well the reeds are set up, and whether they have been played. Often the high reeds will be very thin when they are new, but will get better with playing....if given a chance.
A C/F is better - I've just been playing my C/F Erika in the top octave, and it's not bad at all.

As for singing - we have 2 main singer/guitarists in our morris side, one who sings in C, Cminor, Bb minor, F#minor and F (and probably some other obscure keys), another who sings in D and D minor, and a melodeon player who sings quite happily with his D/G box.
 
Singers who don't accompany themselves on any instrument sometimes sing in keys you won't find on any melodeon!
« Last Edit: July 06, 2010, 03:28:19 PM by ganderbox »
Logged
Pauline from Cornwall

*  including a customised Hohner Club from Cornwall (and very nice it is too!).

JimJ

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 59
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #8 on: July 06, 2010, 04:36:46 PM »

Thanks for all the great info guys.

One thing that struck me last night while trying to get to sleep. Am I correct in assuming that a C/F box is only a half one step lower than a D/G box? This would seem to indicate that the high end would not actually be that much lower.

And yes George, I have thought about a BCC# for singalongs. The extra basses  and chromatic treble would allow much more variety. I did get a personal message the other day, trying to warn me off one of those. They guy said he tried picking one up at age 40 something, and decided that if your weren't Scottish or Irish, and started at a young age, they were hopelessly complicated.

Thanks again all ---- JimJ
« Last Edit: July 06, 2010, 05:15:58 PM by JimJ »
Logged

LDbosca

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 674
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #9 on: July 06, 2010, 05:00:25 PM »

Thanks for all the great info guys.

One thing that struck me last night while trying to get to sleep. Am I correct in assuming that a C/F box is only a half step lower than a D/G box? This would seem to indicate that the high end would not actually be that much lower.

And yes George, I have thought about a BCC# for singalongs. The extra basses  and chromatic treble would allow much more variety. I did get a personal message the other day, trying to warn me off one of those. They guy said he tried picking one up at age 40 something, and decided that if your weren't Scottish or Irish, and started at a young age, they were hopelessly complicated.

Thanks again all ---- JimJ

I'm no expert on quint boxes but C/F is a full tone lower than a D/G - a C#/F# would be a semitone lower.

JimJ

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 59
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #10 on: July 06, 2010, 05:13:05 PM »

right -- just came back to change that last post -- shows what happens to your brain at 3 a.m. when you can't get to sleep.  (:)
Logged

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #11 on: July 06, 2010, 11:02:44 PM »

Thanks for all the great info guys.

 .

And yes George, I have thought about a BCC# for singalongs. The extra basses  and chromatic treble would allow much more variety. I did get a personal message the other day, trying to warn me off one of those. They guy said he tried picking one up at age 40 something, and decided that if your weren't Scottish or Irish, and started at a young age, they were hopelessly complicated.

Thanks again all ---- JimJ


don't believe everything you read Jim!  I am neither Scottish or Irish  & can manage to play the BCC#   despite being an Englishman! .  Their is a lot of unnecessary mystique surrrounding this system  but in reality it is easier to play than a BC, the extra row makes life easier not more complicated & of course anybody with BC experience is already two thirds the way there!  . To get an idea of the basic BC(C#) feel try playing in A on the D row of a  DG box, using a tune that is without G# notes or using the   g# accidental at the chin end if provided.    The fingering & bellows movements are the same as those required to plain G on a BC box. (all on the C row exept for F# which is on the D row if required.  On the BCC# its exacty the same  exept that you have the choice of an F sharp on the inside row in the opposite direction to the one on the outside row. 


george

george


george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

JimJ

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 59
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #12 on: July 06, 2010, 11:11:31 PM »

thanks for the encouragement -- the guy that messaged me claimed that with all the repeated notes things got really complicated. From my point of view -- extra choices can only be good in the long run
Logged

Gandy

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 407
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #13 on: July 07, 2010, 09:00:06 AM »

My take on B/C/C# (based on very limited fiddling around) is that the notes all seem to be to hand, but not necessarily in the direction that suits you.  I think you just have to get used to that.  (For example Bb, A, D are only on the pull, G only on the push).   Compared to a Club at the other extreme where most notes can be found in either direction, but in funny places.    Accidentals are easier on the B/C/C#, as they're always right next to the normal note.
Logged
Tony S

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #14 on: July 07, 2010, 12:14:26 PM »

The important thing with the BCC# is really not any differeent from the important thing on most instruments - it is knowing the keyboard layout i.e. how to produce each note and in order so to do having a thourough knowledge of the keyboard and being able to play notes consequtively which is down to fingering & scales i.e. developing manual dexterity.

 Seems far simpler to me than playhing a wind instrument where two or three rates of blow aare required together with the manipulation of various knobs & handles to produce a note (& being able to do it in quick succession to get various notes!) ,or a string instrument  where strange combination of fingers on frets , or in the case of a fiddle not on frets, together with rubbing or twanging a veriety of strings is required.  The trombone seems totally illogical & to me very difficult as it relies on rates of blow plus sshoving the thing in and out the required distance with absolutely no guide to how far in or out for a particular note.- is D out 4 and a half inches or in 6 and seven eigth inches from where ryou have just been???!!

in comparison the BCC#  dead simple! 
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Marje

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 486
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #15 on: July 07, 2010, 09:12:03 PM »

Miklos, you're right up to a point in that the right key for a song depends on the whether the song corresponds to the range of the voice: but a song is just as likely to range from the dominant (soh) of the home key to the dominant an octave above it as tonic-to tonic. Or it may extend further than an octave, or not as far. It depends entirely on the individual melody. Many folk melodies do have the fifth (dominant) of the key as their top note, while others have the tonic, making the required range several tones higher (or lower!). So it's impossible to generalise about which keys are suitable for particular voices. There are three variables - the range of the voice, the range of the tune, and the chosen key, and they all have to be taken into account.

And even if you want to give an approximate range for a female voice, very few folk/traditional singers ever get near a high G. That's a note that true sopranos and some trained altos can sing in a choir, but it's much higher than you normally hear in a folk/traditional repertoire. A more realistic female top note would be a D, which is fine for many soloists but still a bit high if you want people to join in choruses.

Sorry to bang on about his but it's something that people who want to accompany others or themselves don't always understand. I once went out doing some folky carol-singing with a melodeonist who really couldn't understand why we couldn't just sing everything in G.
Logged
Marje
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal