Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2   Go Down

Author Topic: Re: Another newbie research question  (Read 6083 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

LDbosca

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 674
Re: Another newbie research question
« on: July 28, 2010, 02:13:16 AM »

Thank you all very much for your help and suggestions!  (:)

Returning the box.
Now as to getting one that I will be able to learn on and eventually use for sessions and ceili music......I haven't had much luck finding a 'replacement' yet. Any pointers on where to go from here?

On my own just wanting to learn this instrument!! (There are no teachers or even players in our area)

Glad you were able to return it. There are many dealers on eBay selling these low cost instruments from China. Here's one with pretty good feedback. You should probably try to get one tuned in A/D/G, which covers the range of English, Irish & Scottish folk tunes pretty well. This dealer has several ADG's in different colors. I have played a couple like these, they're better than the box I started with. Not a big investment here. They have a pleasant sound, if they are in a good state of tune. Prices are pretty much the same, as is the sales pitch, so shop for the dealer that has good feedback. This link will lead to a sample of the sound you can expect from one like this. Here's another. Hope this helps.... ;D

If you really just want to play Irish music find a B/C or C#/D (B/C being more convenient). While there's nothing stopping you playing Irish music on an ADG box, you won't be able to go to workshops, most teachers, or directly copy Irish techniques. Since you've managed to return the C/F box you've got the chance to look for an appropriate instrument and I'm sure if you look around you can find a Hohner in B/C or C#/D for a few hundred quid.

While you could use a cheap ADG to get used to playing button accordion, I'd recommend starting as you mean to go on and picking one of the tried and tested Irish systems of playing.

LDbosca

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 674
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #1 on: July 28, 2010, 02:14:00 AM »

Oops, this isn't meant to be on its own and I can't delete it...

nemethmik

  • Guest
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #2 on: July 28, 2010, 12:08:24 PM »

While there's nothing stopping you playing Irish music on an ADG box, you won't be able to go to workshops, most teachers, or directly copy Irish techniques.
Irish music can be played on any instrument including the saxophone, piano accordion, chromatic button accordion, harmonica, banjo, bouzouki, one-row melodeon.
Playing irish music on a B/C or C#/D accordion are just another options, no better no worse than playing on an ADG box.
Since Riverdance, Irish music is not only for the Irish.
 :D
Logged

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #3 on: July 28, 2010, 12:55:21 PM »

Yes and you could attempt to play Bartók on a kazoo.  >:E.

Luke's recommendation...

Quote
While you could use a cheap ADG to get used to playing button accordion, I'd recommend starting as you mean to go on and picking one of the tried and tested Irish systems of playing.

is entirely reasonable and makes good sense to me.

nfldbox

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 492
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #4 on: July 28, 2010, 01:39:01 PM »

No question, Steve and Luke are right.  Youtube is full of people doing impossible things on unlikely instruments but it is not the choice most of us would make.
Logged
BC Cairdin
BC Hohner Double Ray
Bouchard en Ré

LDbosca

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 674
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #5 on: July 28, 2010, 03:14:39 PM »

While there's nothing stopping you playing Irish music on an ADG box, you won't be able to go to workshops, most teachers, or directly copy Irish techniques.
Irish music can be played on any instrument including the saxophone, piano accordion, chromatic button accordion, harmonica, banjo, bouzouki, one-row melodeon.
Playing irish music on a B/C or C#/D accordion are just another options, no better no worse than playing on an ADG box.
Since Riverdance, Irish music is not only for the Irish.
 :D


It's all too easy for someone to recommend a system of instrument over the internet because it seems to them that it would work. In reality it's very important that someone looking to start out is given the correct advice as purchasing an exceptionally off-beat tuning of instrument could cost them time and money, hamper their initial learning and possibly put them off the instrument. While it's fantastic that people have access to sites like this where people can share their knowledge, it's important to remember that the advice given is unmoderated and is not necessarily good advice.

As an experienced practitioner of Irish music I feel strongly about this. I wouldn't advise someone starting to play English music to pick up a B/C instrument because it can technically play in the necessary keys, there are reasons why the D/G is the preferred choice and the same goes for semitone boxes in Irish music.

In other news, my apologies for accidently splitting this into two threads...

Rob2Hook

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2278
  • Castagnaris, Hohners & Baffetti
Re: Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #6 on: July 29, 2010, 11:46:44 AM »

Yes and you could attempt to play Bartók on a kazoo.  >:E.

Indeed, but being fully chromatic, you could play along with...

Rob ;D
Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #7 on: July 29, 2010, 03:21:34 PM »

While there's nothing stopping you playing Irish music on an ADG box, you won't be able to go to workshops, most teachers, or directly copy Irish techniques.


LDBosca,

I think your advice (and the advice of others here) that beginners may find it easier to learn Irish music on a B/C or C#/D accordion is good advice.  I said the same myself in the first sentence of my first post to the other thread.

Having said that, what's wrong with looking at the big picture? Instead of the average, consider all the options people *have successfully used to learn and play Irish music.* That was the rest of my answer.

There are some folks who only have one particular option -- for example a C/F accordion. It was not at all clear from MissAnnuh's first post in the other thread that she had any option to return the accordion or find another.  Can you learn to play Irish music on such an instrument?

Yes, of course.  I gave as examples many fine musicians who can play all night just on the notes that are available only on the C row of a C/F accordion.

If Alan Morrisroe can play all night, and release a lovely cd of Irish tunes, using only a C/F box, shouldn't the answer to the OP acknowledge this?

The attitude that there's only one kind of instrument, or tuning, that is appropriate for beginners is one perspective. But IMO it is discouraging to innovation, to homemade creativity, to all the unique and quirky aspects that make some of my favorite musicians speak to me.  I'm talking about blues musicians with weird customized 10 string guitars, Libba Cotton who learned to play the guitar on her lap, box players who found beautiful settings of the Flogging reel (etc) in the key of G on a 1-row D melodeon using C# and F# in the scale, harmonica players who took a key of C diatonic instrument and found ways to play in G, bending notes for Bb etc....

In fact the attitude of "learn the right instrument that we all play" would have kept the 1-row players from learning the 2 row box, the D/C# players from learning the B/C, and was behind the discrimination faced by C#/D players in the fleadhs, etc., until recently.

Thank God above that we don't have to get a state license to entertain ourselves playing accordion, that  B/Cs are not the only boxes legal to be sold, that the 5-note-roll police won't arrest us if we choose our own way to ornament the tunes.  I think there can still be some room in traditional music for individual discoveries and unique styles that are not only allowed, but sometimes encouraged, by accidents such as starting to play on an unusual instrument.

Will most players who start on an unusual instrument eventually switch to a more typical one, or possibly not become pro level musicians? Of course.

On the other hand it has to be said that there are plenty of people who never progressed to great musicianship (or even listenability by an honest and knowledgeable ear) despite playing the "right" instrument.

In any case, I stand by my answer for its completeness and general truth.  Most especially, I encourage all beginners to work with a teacher since IMO that is much more important than the instrument.  A good teacher can make a musician out of a kid with a comb and tissue paper (as one of my music teachers used to tell me).  In fact, a lot of great hearty rhythmic dance music has been made by lilters with no instrument at all.

Thanks though for your more focussed advice, which I agree will prove helpful to the OP, even if I must assert it is not the whole picture.

PG


« Last Edit: July 29, 2010, 08:04:25 PM by pgroff »
Logged

LDbosca

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 674
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #8 on: July 29, 2010, 03:38:29 PM »

Paul,
I didn't mean to direct my comments at you, your advice was very good and I understood the context in which you meant it. I was thinking more about the "get a cheap ADG" comment, which I addressed because the situation was that the C/F box was being returned and I felt it was important that since MissAnnuh had the chance to get a box that would have learning material etc. available for it rather than taking the advice of the less informed. I think you would probably agree with me that, given her current situation, it would not make sense for her to pay money for an ADG instrument for which she would then struggle to find teachers and tutor DVDs and so forth.

I agree that innovation is often born of necessity and that there are many fine musicians playing unusual instruments. I think we both understand each other and neither of us want to see the accordion landscape dominated by Paddy O'Brien clones wielding red Paolo Soprani's exclusively!  ;)

All the best,
Luke.

nfldbox

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 492
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #9 on: July 29, 2010, 04:51:22 PM »

I realize this is going to make me sound like a curmudgeon but I see no reason to tell a self-confessed "newbie" that a good player can ultimately play anything on anything.
Back to playing Ste. Anne's Reel on the Glockenspiel--and yes, I am sure there is exactly that somewhere on Youtube.
Logged
BC Cairdin
BC Hohner Double Ray
Bouchard en Ré

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #10 on: July 29, 2010, 05:42:05 PM »

Paul, like Luke I am sympathetic to your point of view, but I don't think it was relevant in the present case, given that the OP was entitled to return the C/F box.

It would be a different matter if she had inherited granddad's C/F and obtaining a more suitable instrument was out of the question.

PS: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TA6fEY1Nl3s
« Last Edit: July 29, 2010, 05:47:19 PM by Steve Jones »
Logged

nfldbox

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 492
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #11 on: July 29, 2010, 06:30:47 PM »

I note in the comments this one:

"A lot of your songs sound the same."

In other words, you can play Irish music on any instrument and those who don't get it still won't get it--and they won't get it in exactly the same way.
Logged
BC Cairdin
BC Hohner Double Ray
Bouchard en Ré

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #12 on: July 29, 2010, 06:34:40 PM »

I realize this is going to make me sound like a curmudgeon but I see no reason to tell a self-confessed "newbie" that a good player can ultimately play anything on anything.
Back to playing Ste. Anne's Reel on the Glockenspiel--and yes, I am sure there is exactly that somewhere on Youtube.

nfldbox

Ah, but it's the new players starting out in all different ways that allow some real innovations to get into the tradition. Again, provided there is the right kind of teacher who can help keep the musical result on track (that is, rhythmically intelligible as dance music) or failing that an immersion in a community of good music.  Without that help, success is rare IMO, especially for adult beginners.

Some newbies do succeed playing unusual instruments, and plenty of those who follow the usual recommendations for the "most popular instrument of the day" do not become good musicians.  

Personally, my ear welcomes music by beginners who (by choice or accident) don't follow the herd mentality. How many poor imitations of the hero of the day do we need?

Do you think there is a "right way" of spending a holiday in a famous city?

Do you follow every detail of a particular travel guide, to try to insure your experience is the "standard" one, staying with the herd as you check off your visits to one landmark after another....

Or might you want to take your own journey, starting where you find yourself ..... and welcoming the unique, non-herd experiences that might come your way.

Just my opinion, of course.  And I truly do respect and welcome the other opinions here that differ from mine.

Best regards,

Paul Groff

Logged

melodeon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1732
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #13 on: July 29, 2010, 07:37:44 PM »

I have often wondered why the B/C box is used most specifically for Irish Traditional music

I have heard some great tunes by Bobby Gardiner (sp)  such as French waltzes... and some fine  non Irish B/C played by a lady I belive from Belgium... good stuff

It is a delight to hear something played on other than the "required" unit.

I think about The Fender Telecaster used for Jazz by Ted Green (e)  or  Carroll  Best playing some fine melodic tunes on an open back
Whyte Lyadie or Tu-ba-phone  in a three finger style with finger and thumb picks.. call out the Old Time Music police !..

Oscar Aleman and a Tri cone....

Guy Van Duser and a classical guitar and a thumb pick playing rags and 19th century classics

Or Jody    Kruskal  ??????????????   using a G/D Anglo Concertina.....
John Nixon and English style concertina jazz....


Be a "break out" musician

or how about a pokerwork for Cajun/Zydeco.. it's being done ...
Logged

pgroff

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1827
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #14 on: July 29, 2010, 07:53:41 PM »

Paul,
I didn't mean to direct my comments at you, your advice was very good and I understood the context in which you meant it. I was thinking more about the "get a cheap ADG" comment, which I addressed because the situation was that the C/F box was being returned and I felt it was important that since MissAnnuh had the chance to get a box that would have learning material etc. available for it rather than taking the advice of the less informed. I think you would probably agree with me that, given her current situation, it would not make sense for her to pay money for an ADG instrument for which she would then struggle to find teachers and tutor DVDs and so forth.

I agree that innovation is often born of necessity and that there are many fine musicians playing unusual instruments. I think we both understand each other and neither of us want to see the accordion landscape dominated by Paddy O'Brien clones wielding red Paolo Soprani's exclusively!  ;)

All the best,
Luke.

Luke,

Sorry I missed this when replying to nfldbox.

Thanks for the kind words, and I agree we seem to understand each other.

Re: playing on a C row, or on an A/D/G for that matter...

I once got to know a man named Mr. Dennehy (RIP).  His son is a fine fiddle player.

Mr. Dennehy was from Co. Kerry and had known famed fiddle master Padraig O'Keefe.  Mr. Dennehy didn't play the accordion much out of the house, to my knowledge, but he enjoyed playing a few tunes in his kitchen on a black Hohner Corona G/C/F.  I heard he had a Paolo or some other more standard "Irish accordion" but I only ever saw or heard him with the Corona.

He played solely up and down the rows, melodeon style.  He would play on one row for a while, then maybe play the same or a different tune on another row.  I think he mostly played on the middle row, the "C" row.  One of his tunes was the hornpipe, "The Plains of Boyle," played without the flattened seventh note we usually hear these days.  Just lovely. Great balance, rhythm, and phrasing.

Similarly, consider the late Kitty Hayes (RIP). I know, she played concertina, but there are many similarities with the box and in this case what is relevant is that she played a C/G concertina on the rows.  She played a lot of "G" tunes in the key of F on the C row, just as a melodeon player would on his or her C row.  Someone could have corrected her when she was a "newbie" but then we wouldn't have her lovely music and style.

Rose Murphy (née Conlon, also RIP), an Irish lass from Co. Galway who emigrated to England, was given an accordion in B/C -- yeah, she got the right kind of instrument! If melnet were around then, this instrument would have met with great approval for someone getting back into playing Irish tunes on the box. But she played it up and down the B row.  Lovely music again, not the least injured by its failure to meet the standards set by some here for "normalcy."

Yes, my tongue is in cheek. :-)

Seriously, you all are right, by your lights .... but I will be here to offer this other perspective, FWIW.

So, who's the curmudgeon now?

Best regards!

Paul

« Last Edit: July 29, 2010, 08:44:52 PM by pgroff »
Logged

Flanna

  • Prêtresse
  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 116
  • Groupe electro folk aux sorcières "Flanna O'Tara"
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #15 on: July 30, 2010, 06:59:41 AM »

I have quite a few Irish music books, including O'Neills Music of Ireland (contains over 2000 tunes and said to be the bible of Irish music). The most commonly used keys in O'Neill''s are D and G. Some of my other Irish music books contain music only in D and G. I believe that O'Neill's was compiled long before the B/C melodeon was invented, so you certainly do not need a B/C instrument to play Irish music. I can play a huge amount of Irish music on a D/G melodeon, with bass notes and chords!

If I wanted a fully chromatic box, I would choose a small CBA not a B/C or C#/D melodeon.

When I see a player playing a B/C melodeon, I notice that the bass side is almost never used. Could this mean that on a B/C melodeon the basses are not suitable for Irish music?

Also, I believe that Sharon Shannon often plays a D/G melodeon.
« Last Edit: July 30, 2010, 07:06:59 AM by Flanna »
Logged
Yvus Pyrénées D/G ~ Wheatstone English Concertina ~ S-Wave Midi Concertina ~ Roland FR3B ~ Axis 64 ~ Roland Synthesizers

Anahata

  • This mind intentionally left blank
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 6767
  • Oakwood D/G, C/F Club, 1-rows in C,D,G
    • Treewind Music
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #16 on: July 30, 2010, 11:53:16 AM »

When I see a player playing a B/C melodeon, I notice that the bass side is almost never used. Could this mean that on a B/C melodeon the basses are not suitable for Irish music?

They don't work as well for playing in D and G as they do on a D/G box. But mostly the lack of basses is just part of the tradition - Irish music is very tune-powered, not about harmony. The typical use of bass buttons by Irish melodeon players, just stabbing at them occasionally at strategic (rather random, to me) points of the tune,  is also reminiscent, I think deliberately, of the use of regulators on Uilleann pipes.
Logged
Слава Україні !
Music recording and web hosting: www.treewind.co.uk
Mary Humphreys and Anahata: www.maryanahata.co.uk
Ceilidh band: www.barleycoteband.co.uk

Stiamh

  • Old grey C#/D pest
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 3611
    • Packie Manus Byrne
Re: Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #17 on: July 30, 2010, 12:58:40 PM »

I have quite a few Irish music books, including O'Neills Music of Ireland (contains over 2000 tunes and said to be the bible of Irish music). The most commonly used keys in O'Neill''s are D and G. Some of my other Irish music books contain music only in D and G. I believe that O'Neill's was compiled long before the B/C melodeon was invented, so you certainly do not need a B/C instrument to play Irish music. I can play a huge amount of Irish music on a D/G melodeon, with bass notes and chords!

If I wanted a fully chromatic box, I would choose a small CBA not a B/C or C#/D melodeon.

When I see a player playing a B/C melodeon, I notice that the bass side is almost never used. Could this mean that on a B/C melodeon the basses are not suitable for Irish music?

Also, I believe that Sharon Shannon often plays a D/G melodeon.


So - reading between the lines here - you like your D/G and can't see the point of a semitone box? If so, you're in good company. * Sigh *

Yes it's true that you can play a very big proportion of the Irish trad. repertoire easily on a D/G box and some people do so very well.

Nobody seriously contends that B/C or C#/D is fully chromatic in the way a CBA is, but these systems have their own advantages and Irish musicians have found them very suitable over many decades.

I had played Irish music for nearly 30 years on fiddle and whistle before taking up the accordion and I did consider D/G for a while before choosing C#/D. A tin whistle is basically restricted to D and G as well (even though a very good player can do lots more than that) and believe me it's a serious restriction in the real world, off the pages of books.  So that's why I decided not to go D/G and I haven't regretted it.

I think it's reasonable to allow those who actually play Irish music seriously on the accordion, rather than own a few books, to guide a beginner who is interested solely in Irish music in their choice of instrument.

BTW I'm pretty certain you're wrong about Sharon Shannon "often" playing a D/G box, or even playing one at all. How did you form that notion?

Flanna

  • Prêtresse
  • Regular debater
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 116
  • Groupe electro folk aux sorcières "Flanna O'Tara"
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #18 on: July 30, 2010, 01:51:47 PM »

I could be incorrect about Sharron Shannon "often" playing a D/G  :|bl. I heard about the D/G a couple of years ago from one of her band members. Perhaps she doesn't use it much on stage now.
Logged
Yvus Pyrénées D/G ~ Wheatstone English Concertina ~ S-Wave Midi Concertina ~ Roland FR3B ~ Axis 64 ~ Roland Synthesizers

nfldbox

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 492
Re: Another newbie research question
« Reply #19 on: July 30, 2010, 02:56:13 PM »

Never seen Shannon with a DG. Not impossible but unlikely.
The BC is a perfect instrument to play in D or G, for reasons too complex to go into here. As to the different benefits of C#D vs BC a good resource is Graeme Smith's "Modern-Style Irish Accordion Playing: History, Biography and Class" Ethnomusicology, Vol. 41, No. 3 (Autumn, 1997), pp. 433-463

The original reason for the absence of the bass is beyond me but you can note the absence of the lower register in all Irish music, including song. I just googled "Great Irish bass" and came up with one response, about rock music. "great Russian bass" came up with 98,600.

Logged
BC Cairdin
BC Hohner Double Ray
Bouchard en Ré
Pages: [1] 2   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal