Hey all,
As I have mentioned elsewhere, I am currently playing for a show in Edinburgh every afternoon for an hour. It is going quite well music wise (I arranged the score, so I have a vested interest) but it is exhausting, since I am playing so continuously that there isn't time for me to do anything for most of the play. In the first week I had a Charango on my arm and if it was uncomfortable I had to grin and bear it as I couldn't break playing to move it. It's challenging stuff then, add to the fact that I can't see all of the stage yet am expected to react to anything that goes on. It is certainly the most difficult (and most fun) musical adventure that I have ever been on.
Until today's performance. I was playing a tune and no sooner had I used the top Fnat accidental, I realised that it had stuck. At first, hearing a high note I looked towards the dusty end, supposing that my strap was pressing against a button, but my ear identified the note quickly and I was immediately terrified. There are two other musicians, but they take my lead from me, I am the only one who knows every cue and I was the only one who could see any of the front of the stage. If I dropped out then the music would collapse, and that would be a big deal, given that this is a play without dialogue. Thankfully, I pressed the offending key and it stopped sticking, but the next tune the next key along started to stick. I did the same thing and it worked and I wasn't bothered again.
Now, when I got home I took the front off, and the fingerboard, and the backplate, as I had no idea what could have gone wrong. I think (hope) that I have worked it out. A few notes. Firstly when the key was stuck it didn't look stuck, it looked to be no further down than any other key, so the gap between the pallet and the soundboard would be slight. Secondly it stuck on both push and pull, so it wasn't a case of a spring being weak enough to let the pallet open when the bellows are pushed in sharply. On first inspection there was nothing at the base of the key to stick and there was no question of it getting caught in any of the rest of the mechanism and there was nothing around under the grille that might have stuck. There was also nothing inside the reedblock, but since two keys were affected that was incredibly unlikely anyway.
However, I did notice that one of the little bits of felt attached to the fingerboard to prevent the buttons from clattering had come off, and indeed that several others were nearly coming off. What I think must have happened is this, that this little piece of felt must have fallen off and been transferred under the grille when I put the box in it's case. When I started playing, the felt was resting on the pallet, so when I played an F, the felt slipped under the pallet and stuck, jamming the key yet not restricting movement. When I pressed it again it fell onto the next pallet, whereupon the same thing happened. When I pressed the B key it must have been dislodged, solving the problem. So I glued the felt bits back onto the fingerboard and hopefully the problem won't return.
If anyone has an alternative explanation then please say! It is quite an interesting problem and not something that I've ever heard of before. It was absolutely terrifying when it happened though.