Below, I've clipped a discussion from years ago, from the old squeezebox forum.
The late Richard Morse, founder of the Button Box, was responding to another accordion repairer's opinion that the reeds mattered more than the qualities of the box. I've redacted the discussion to make reading it practical, but it obviously is missing something -- the thread contained many dozens of posts, so this is the nutshell version:
Richard Morse wrote:
... I absolutely believe that the box makes a much bigger difference than the reeds.
[...]
Certainly one set of reeds can be very different than another set.
Substitute any number of sets of reeds (of different qualities) in that
given box and you can get as many different *sounds* (which is the main
issue in this thread) AND some *response* (which was an additional
observation of mine).
We do not consider our observations (that the quality of reed and box
contributions to sound and response) to be absurd as we have performed
many of these alterations with consistent results. A case in point is
that we routinely install excellent grade Antonelli reeds into 2-row
Hohner button accordions with the result that the sound and response is
marginally improved. We have performed other quality swaps less often
but with similar and consistent results. We have also done extensive
testing of *many* different quality reeds (including many profiles of
ones we have made) in different mounts as a part of our program to mass
produce our own concertina reeds.
Given the diversity and amounts of operations we have performed, I would
hazard a rudimentary comparison that, on a scale of 1 to 10 (with 1
being quite mediocre and 10 being superlative), a comparison of 2-row
button accordions would be about:
Weltmeister Hohner Antonelli
reeds reeds reeds
Weltmeister with = 2 3 3.5
Hohner with = 4.5 5 5.5
Castagnari with = 6 8 9
I do not intend that the above figures are gospel, but that they are an
extrapolated expression of our considerable experiences and far from
being conjectural. The box seems to have a greater affect on the sound
and response than the reeds do. I would very much like to hear of your
operations and experiences which will substantiate your allegation that
my observations are "absurd".
[...] we have performed extensive tone spectrum analyses documenting
intensity and harmonics on a wide range of reed types and mountings. We
also performed simultaneous (to the wave analysis) and separate
subjective tests because it is the sound we *hear* (as well as the
response) which is important - the computer is only a tool that can help
us organize things we hear. The listening tests were not double-blind.
[...]
[Better means f]aster starting, more dynamic range; and more evenness of tone and more
uniform color over the entire set of reeds.
[...]
I think that swapping reeds between a Hohner and Gola instrument would
result in the Gola reeds improving the Hohner box combo measurably, and
the Gola box improving the Hohner reeds much more appreciatively.
-- Rich --
THE BUTTON BOX
http://www.buttonbox.com