Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1]   Go Down

Author Topic: What set up is best for playing in G,D, A??  (Read 5913 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Harp2

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 81
What set up is best for playing in G,D, A??
« on: July 28, 2008, 09:34:16 PM »

I have an Erica C,F but play with people who do mostly folk/gospel songs in Keys of G,D or A.
1. What is the best set up for me to have a D/G Box??  or a three row ADG box ?? (would rather stay with a 2 row)
2. How hard is it to change mine to a D/G or something more suited for me??
« Last Edit: July 30, 2008, 05:51:24 AM by Harp2 »
Logged

BruceHenderson

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 262
Re: What set up is best for playing in G,D, A??
« Reply #1 on: July 29, 2008, 01:53:37 PM »

I have an Erica C,F but play with people who do mostly folk/gospel songs in Keys of G,D or A.
1. What is the best set up for me to have a D/G Box??  or a three row ADG box ?? (would rather stay with a 2 row)
2. How had is it to change mine to a D/G or something more suited for me??

    I play very little for song accompaniment so rank comments from others higher but I've found that it's much easier to play in A on a D row than it is to play in C on a G row.  I own a D/G and an A/D/G and have mixed feelings about the A/D/G but a lot of that is that the A row on an A/D/G is an octave lower than fiddler's most played octave (the D and G rows fit with a fiddler pretty well); the A row is also pretty much an octave below the G row.  I don't know how much that bothers song accompanists but it's a fair PITA when playing with fiddlers.

    Do you have to play every note of every song, or can you get by with the occasional chord or harmony note (or even missing a note here and there)?  If the latter, a D/G will probably work well enough for most melodies in A.  As I said, I do little song accompaniment, but just playing tunes with other instruments, I find that the "missing G#" is almost never noticed.  And with a D/G with accidentals, you have at least some opportunity to grab that G# in at least one octave.

    I am not a fan of "changing" a box to alter keys.  There are some opportunities to juggle reeds and move them around and retune others -- it certainly can be done and if it *must* be done (as if you have an old box and replacement reed sets aren't avaialable), then a skilled repairer can do a good job of it.  But unless you buy a new set of reeds ($$$$ and also more $$$$ to fit leathers and tune them), you're almost certain to have at least a few reeds that have been "moved" a fair distance from one pitch to another -- that implies a fair amount of metal removal from the reeds with a resultant chance of damage; there is also the $$$ in parts and labor to rekey the bass side.  I usually encourage someone who has a box in the "wrong key" to find a buyer for that box and then buy a box properly set up in the "right key".  But it certainly is possible (and sometimes more practical) to "rebuild" a box so take that as just a general suggestion or guideline.  Whatever, it's going to not be cheap.

    Again, apologies if my experience mostly playing tunes doesn't translate well to your needs of playing for song accompaniment.
Best wishes, Bruce Henderson NC USA
Logged
I love one-rows!  Four reeds kick butt!!!!

Howard Jones

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1203
Re: What set up is best for playing in G,D, A??
« Reply #2 on: July 30, 2008, 10:45:01 PM »

I also prefer a 2-row, I find a 3-row a bit of a handful.

On a standard D/G you've got all the notes of the scale of A, with the exception of G#.  It's usually possible to fudge this, especially if you're playing song accompaniment and so don't have to play all the notes of the melody. If you make a habit of playing in A you could perhaps retune one of the accidentals to give you G# but it might be a bit awkward to play.

So far as chords are concerned, you've got A maj and D maj, but Em instead of E maj.  That can be solved by taking out the thirds from the chords - some boxes have stops to do this, on others it means permanently stopping that reed.  Or just play the minor chord anyway and glare at anyone who objects :). You'll need to play across the rows to get the A note against the A chord. You'll find that you're mostly playing on the pull, so you need to be handy with the air button.

I disagree with Bruce though, I find it easier to play in C than in A.  I do agree with him that completely retuning your existing box to D/G is probably more trouble (and cost) than it's worth.

DaveCottrell

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 77
Re: What set up is best for playing in G,D, A??
« Reply #3 on: July 31, 2008, 03:31:29 PM »

Would learning a BC setup be out of the question?  It is especially useful in those keys, and there are simple (treble side) chords available in those keys for accompaniment, as well as the basses.
Logged

David Pike

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 10
Re: What set up is best for playing in G,D, A??
« Reply #4 on: August 01, 2008, 11:38:09 AM »

I'm just about to take delivery of a Serenellini D273 in A/D/G. This is a 27 button box in an 8/9/10 set up. Obviously like everything in life it is something of a compromise - the slightly limited range in G for example. However while the layout appears to be similar to the Sarltarelle Cheviot/Nurdsud, this is a three voice box (with three stops and two bass end stops) for less money.

I'm not sure if you are in the market for a new box but a look at the Serenellini site or Jollybox.co.uk will give you all the details. 

regards,


David
Logged

David Pike

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 10
Re: What set up is best for playing in G,D, A??
« Reply #5 on: August 01, 2008, 02:26:05 PM »

I've also sent a message to your personal box

david
Logged

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: What set up is best for playing in G,D, A??
« Reply #6 on: August 02, 2008, 07:17:18 PM »

It all depends on how important the weight of the box is ,, how much 'learning' yu are prepared to do and how much playing in A you are intending to do.  Simplest approach  would  be an ADG box but obviously bulkier & heavier  than a DG. If only limited use of tunes in A then  an ADG (& and a bit more learning) would fit the bill but would need faking of G#. A compromise may be a two& half row with G# for both octaves on half row - different fingering & bellows movement to D & G but everything remaining fairly familier & compromise on weight.  Another option to keep weight down is a BC - need to learn 3 different scales for AD&G & bass not very useful unless heavily modified - but small & light with bonus of C & F easily played & all keys technically possible. Also has all accidentals available for those tunes that they crop up in irrespective of key. Following the latter option logically a small BCC# (hohner trichord) or custom made box    (trichord same size as corona adg)   would provide all the benefits of the BC together with more useful bass & can be played reasonably easily in all   keys ( once thoroughly learned!)

Its all a question of thinking through what you want out of a box & balaancing the benefits & snags of different  set ups.

george

Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: What set up is best for playing in G,D, A??
« Reply #7 on: August 03, 2008, 09:18:40 AM »

It all depends on how important the weight of the box is ,, how much 'learning' yu are prepared to do and how much playing in A you are intending to do.  Simplest approach  would  be an ADG box but obviously bulkier & heavier  than a DG. If only limited use of tunes in A then  an ADG (& and a bit more learning) would fit the bill but would need faking of G#. A compromise may be a two& half row with G# for both octaves on half row - different fingering & bellows movement to D & G but everything remaining fairly familier & compromise on weight.  Another option to keep weight down is a BC - need to learn 3 different scales for AD&G & bass not very useful unless heavily modified - but small & light with bonus of C & F easily played & all keys technically possible. Also has all accidentals available for those tunes that they crop up in irrespective of key. Following the latter option logically a small BCC# (hohner trichord) or custom made box    (trichord same size as corona adg)   would provide all the benefits of the BC together with more useful bass & can be played reasonably easily in all   keys ( once thoroughly learned!)

Its all a question of thinking through what you want out of a box & balaancing the benefits & snags of different  set ups.

george



sorry - 3rd line should read DG not ADG!  (I intended  to say a DG but it came out as ADG! -  :(
george
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Doug Anderson

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 51
  • aka Veloce
Re: What set up is best for playing in G,D, A??
« Reply #8 on: September 12, 2008, 01:36:47 AM »

I am dealing with the same issue, just a little farther down the scale. The three keys I want to play in are C, G and D, in that order of preference. I spent some time experimenting with the key of C on my D/G Bouëbe, and briefly with the key of D on a borrowed G/C Erika. I found it easier to play in D on the G/C than in C on the D/G. And I preferred the sound of the lower pitched box. I ended up with a G/C Lorelei with a stop to remove the third from the Am chord, and the "missing" C# in two octaves. I can play a few tunes in D well, but on many tunes I have trouble finding opportunities to push the bellows.

(The equivalent setup for the keys of G, D and A would be a D/G box with a stop to remove the third from the Em chord and the "missing" G# in two octaves.)
Logged

BruceHenderson

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 262
Re: What set up is best for playing in G,D, A??
« Reply #9 on: September 12, 2008, 02:32:12 AM »

I am dealing with the same issue, just a little farther down the scale. The three keys I want to play in are C, G and D, in that order of preference. I spent some time experimenting with the key of C on my D/G Bouëbe, and briefly with the key of D on a borrowed G/C Erika. I found it easier to play in D on the G/C than in C on the D/G. (snip)

    I've been thinking about why I find it easier to play in A on a D/G box than C.  I guess it's like playing in minor keys (Am, Em, and Bm - if the Bm is played on the D-row) which I'm also very bad at -- I find it very hard to hit the right notes if the "tonic" isn't on the push.  But not practising enough because I don't like it might have something to do with it.   ;)
Logged
I love one-rows!  Four reeds kick butt!!!!

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: What set up is best for playing in G,D, A??
« Reply #10 on: September 16, 2008, 10:38:03 AM »

I am dealing with the same issue, just a little farther down the scale. The three keys I want to play in are C, G and D, in that order of preference. I spent some time experimenting with the key of C on my D/G Bouëbe, and briefly with the key of D on a borrowed G/C Erika. I found it easier to play in D on the G/C than in C on the D/G. (snip)

     

at the end of the day any combination of 2 or 3 diatonic 4th aprt rows cannot be chromatic  eg an ADG box has F#C#&G# but no Eflat or Bflat plus the problem of no F natural, a GCF box will be missing G#C#etc etc. therefore at the end of the day there is only a choice of
1. own  several boxes  tuned in the keys you want to play in
2.learn to fake the missing accidentals (& of course learn to finger different scales & bellows ins & outs as in A on a D row)
3. have a 3 row 'DG 'with a full row of what you havnt got on either the D or G row - fine for playing in D or G but some very odd scales to learn for other keys.but technically chromatic
4. get a 2 row chromatic box - BC fine for BCADGF other keys get progressively difficult- bass in standard form not much use
5. just in case anybody thought I wasn't going to mention it! go for a 3 row chromatic BCC#  which  requires the learning of 5 scales ( one of which is on the row for BCC#) to enable the playing of 12 major keys.   - aand usually with bass for most of it.

george
« Last Edit: September 16, 2008, 11:00:38 AM by Theo »
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

Doug Anderson

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 51
  • aka Veloce
Re: What set up is best for playing in G,D, A??
« Reply #11 on: September 22, 2008, 11:30:48 PM »

at the end of the day any combination of 2 or 3 diatonic 4th aprt rows cannot be chromatic  eg an ADG box has F#C#&G# but no Eflat or Bflat plus the problem of no F natural, a GCF box will be missing G#C#etc etc.
Many (most?) modern 2-row 4th apart boxes have accidental notes on the first buttons of each row. The standard arrangement on a D/G provides G# (push) and A# (pull) on the D row and F (push) and D# (pull) on the G row. The box is fully chromatic over one octave, but not particularly easy to play out of the home keys.
Logged
Pages: [1]   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal