Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6   Go Down

Author Topic: how much "making" constitutes "making"  (Read 23152 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Theo

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 14475
  • Hohner Club Too
    • The Box Place
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #60 on: August 24, 2011, 04:32:50 PM »

I'm amazed at how much interest this discussion has generated.  It is really nothing new. In the 19th century Wheatstone concertinas were made by many craftsmen many if whom were outworkers or subcontractors.  Nobody seems to have been worried by this as it's probably been the norm on manufacturing of all sorts from the early industrial revolution. The only thing that isxduffetent today is that cheap transport means that the subcontractors may be on the other side if the planet, instead of being a few streets away.
Logged
Theo Gibb - Gateshead UK

Proprietor of The Box Place for melodeon and concertina sales and service.
See my YouTube channel  for videos on repair and tuning

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #61 on: August 24, 2011, 04:36:27 PM »

Hmm. Interesting. How far back should one go to make something? First plant the seed for the tree ? Dig out the ore for to smelt to steel for the reeds ? Process the pulp to cardboard for the bellows ?


Chas, this has been previously discussed.  If you read my first post, I refer to 'norms' that are established in practice. If someone went to the lengths you describe, they would simply be exceeding the expectations that normal practice has established.  

I've encountered the same issue in woodworking (with hand tools). I have a small table in my workshop that is nearing completion.  I started with 'rough' boards from a sawmill.  I dimensioned and flattened the boards with handsaws and various bench planes.  I used various joinery saws, specialized joinery planes, and chisels to make all the joints -- mortise & tenon joints, 'half-blind' dovetails (for the drawer front), dovetails (drawer back), grooves (for the drawer bottom). When the table is finished, I can say that I made it without power tools.  I know that powered saws were used to take down the tree and to saw the rough boards at the sawmill.  Since it is not within the norm of furniture-making to fell a tree and process rough boards, I think it is fair for me to say that I made the table "with hand tools."  I do think that it would be ridiculous if someone was to assemble a table of the same design from parts that they received from a kit supplier and then claim that there was no difference.

I thoroughly enjoyed my time assembling some and MAKING MOST of the parts on the two courses I was on with Emmanuel. All I can say is, "If you haven't tried it don't knock it"

The process that occurred at those workshops most resembles a small workshop where the course participants are workers, making accordions under the supervision and guidance of a master (Pariselle).  There is nothing wrong with that of course! (I would love to take one of these courses!)  

As to Chris's mention of Gaillard's 'external' tuning/reedwork -- this compares to having someone IN his shop doing the work, as far as my description in the original post; it is simply a different economic arrangement, which is certainly NOT comparable to branded instruments etc.  For this reason, Gaillard's system of production falls into the most favourable category that I described above, regardless of whether the tuning is in-house.  The production style  that falls below the norm (for single-maker shops) is where pre-made (and generic) chassis, reedblocks, and keyboards are assembled in a shop; in which case, 'assembled and finished' is a more appropriate label.

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #62 on: August 24, 2011, 04:59:36 PM »

I'm amazed at how much interest this discussion has generated.  It is really nothing new. In the 19th century Wheatstone concertinas were made by many craftsmen many if whom were outworkers or subcontractors.  Nobody seems to have been worried by this as it's probably been the norm on manufacturing of all sorts from the early industrial revolution. The only thing that isxduffetent today is that cheap transport means that the subcontractors may be on the other side if the planet, instead of being a few streets away.

There are finer distinctions being made here; and no representation of novelty was made.

The scenario with Wheatstone, as you described it, would receive high marks from me.  If Wheatstones were instead constructed with major components being fungible parts (such as reedpans, the bodies, and the fretwork 'ends'), that would resemble the kind of shops that fall 'below the norm' in the rubrics that I described. 

At any rate, Wheatstone simply would not be in the 'single-maker' or 'small shop' categories; more like a large (albeit spread out) workshop or small factory -- something comparable to Castagnari but spread out into piecemeal home workshops rather than being made in a single building.  And that itself could be something to strive for.

For the record, I'm not "worried" by the manners of production described -- what I find problematic (but certainly not "worrisome') is the lack of awareness.  But God help us if we yearn for 19th c. standards of public awareness of production processes, yikes!

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #63 on: August 24, 2011, 05:06:23 PM »

Bee's, Bonnet's and One particular personnel crusade as far as I can tell, someone's enjoying the attention though  ;) it got boring when it was on the last post ZZZZZZZZZ

{above post flagged for moderators}.

If people don't want to read a thread, they need not read it, and if they don't want to participate, they are free to read without posting (for any number of reasons).
« Last Edit: August 24, 2011, 05:33:20 PM by Andy in Vermont »
Logged

Steve C.

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2075
  • Erica, Morse Anglo
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #64 on: August 24, 2011, 05:11:20 PM »

It really is a crazy thread, getting a little bit circular, but, you do have to love the folks (any folks) who do something you can't do, and do it well.
Logged
Located in Central North Carolina, USA; credit for picture: livingplanet.ca

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #65 on: August 24, 2011, 05:29:05 PM »

I'd personally give the little comment above  a "1" out of 10 on the internet personal attack scale, and that purely on its "attention" gambit, speculative at best.

Up to the Mods. To be fair I've always mused as to why honourable members bother to make posts in the "this is to hard/boring/exotic for this forum/a wet Wednesday/my small brain" genre. When others are making argued, or even researched points  ???
« Last Edit: August 24, 2011, 09:44:57 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #66 on: August 24, 2011, 05:43:05 PM »

To be fair I've always mused as to why honourable members bother to make posts in the "this is to hard/boring/exotic for this forum/a wet Wednesday/my small brain" genre. When others are making argued, or even researched points  ???

.. well they must get something from it  ;)

Right, Chris, I recall something like this happening to a theoretical thread on which you provided some very useful information. (And thanks for putting it on your website.)

Unlike our moderator, I'm not actually surprised at the interest in this topic.  If one looks in the archives (including the old forum), there is quite a bit of "fetishism" regarding the circumstances under which melodeons are made; lots of borderline worship of the builders (as well as awe for semi-mysterious/magical ways of the "tuner"); lots of loyalty to a particular maker or brand (I'm most interested in the Oakwood fixation -- I've always wanted to play one after reading so many glowing reports -- they sound wonderful -- but a recent post -- was it Ian Dedic? -- mentioned several that sounded like they had some serious design flaws?); and so on.  I've been part of it as well, with pleasure!

blafleur

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 530
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #67 on: August 24, 2011, 06:11:53 PM »

 I do think that it would be ridiculous if someone was to assemble a table of the same design from parts that they received from a kit supplier and then claim that there was no difference.


But also to be considered by the end user, if it is not the "maker", is to what quality was that "maker's" work.  It cannot be assumed that because a particular crafts person made everything himself, that both he and his customer wouldn't have been better served if some items had been purchased from a better source, at least until he gets better at it. 

You may build an awesome table from hand tools, but some others might make a wobbly gap jointed mess without power tools.  I do agree that the more craftsmanship a person exhibits with his own hands, the more impressed I am, but for someone buying a product, the end result is usually the most important thing ( but i do concede not always).  So if a person puts together an accordion with products he made himself to a fair standard (the best he can with his skills) and made a fair accordion, and the guy across town made few if any components, but bought most from quality sources and ended up with a great accordion because of his skill in putting together those components, which accordion would the average player want?   

Like you, Andy, I enjoy making things with my own hands, out of pure personal satisfaction, and I only hope that what I do is worth being appreciated by at least some, and if not now, hopefully in time.  But I also know that many will never care what parts I made with my own hands, I just know that I will. ;)

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #68 on: August 24, 2011, 07:22:20 PM »

You may build an awesome table from hand tools, but some others might make a wobbly gap jointed mess without power tools.  I do agree that the more craftsmanship a person exhibits with his own hands, the more impressed I am, but for someone buying a product, the end result is usually the most important thing ( but i do concede not always).  So if a person puts together an accordion with products he made himself to a fair standard (the best he can with his skills) and made a fair accordion, and the guy across town made few if any components, but bought most from quality sources and ended up with a great accordion because of his skill in putting together those components, which accordion would the average player want?   

I understand your point, Bryan, and I agree -- there are plenty of examples where a single-maker shop puts out instruments that are sub-par in quality, both in terms of playability and aesthetics.  That's really another topic altogether --- and I believe it is touched upon by the post above, which referred to "hobbiests."

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #69 on: August 24, 2011, 07:28:07 PM »

I guess its not the subject matter, more the domineering viewpoint and the manner of expression and dismissal of others views that erks, still each to their own and I guess that includes me. mory (brain the size of a planet) ;D still not making assumptions

Anything to contribute to the topic, Mory? Or just insults? You might not find it interesting, but the thread has been viewed nearly a thousand times within a brief period of time, and there have been many participants. You could easily have written an off-list message rather than derailing the thread, since what you had to say had nothing to do with the topic that the rest of us are discussing.

« Last Edit: August 24, 2011, 07:35:10 PM by Andy in Vermont »
Logged

mory

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 752
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #70 on: August 24, 2011, 08:34:57 PM »

since you ask Andy I do. there is no such thing as a hand made box. the lineage of production surely includes the tools one may class as hand tools etc and without over simplifying (first cut down a tree etc) all processes suggest an element of cooperation from other humans, we didn't make all the elements of human achievement by individual endever but by consensus, some times to our good and sometimes to our detriment, we have consensus in box making and it precedes this debate in the form of all the box's here before this debate, the production and methods employed being a conglomeration of those elements discussed that have become a set of rules to construct "a Box", now they can vary but the rules exist because that's how our boxes are made, what this thread is witnessing is an attempt to draw those rules under a new banner, but who is defining these new rules, it doesn't feel consensual, as many posts by others seem to be dismissed, so who is the rule maker and who is defining those rules, I agree with various aspects you bring up but that doesn't make them any more "right" than it makes others "wrong" just take a read back over the whole thing back to the Loffett post etc lots of hard words and if it were possible you could almost feel the anger in some of your responses were not all in agreement and that's good but rules are arrived at in a developing thing like this gradually, gently, as a process of time and event, so as I've said before Andy peace brother peace. mory


sorry for the delay I timed out lost the lot and had to start again
« Last Edit: August 24, 2011, 08:39:12 PM by mory »
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #71 on: August 24, 2011, 08:55:37 PM »

I was of course generalising and the ""too much for my brain" is a simple and AFAIR straight quote from a "non contributary" contribution to a discussion about a year ago. As I say I remain mystified why people post such things and see no reason why anyone in this thread should take anything personally

Someone felt attacked, I really thought the comment not worth an emotion. Please see my posts in other threads. If I've got nothing to say - I try to keep my council (barring the occasional bad joke) Chris
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

mory

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 752
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #72 on: August 24, 2011, 09:32:38 PM »

your alright Chris no worries (:)

removed "offending" posts out of deference to Andy's feelings.          mory
« Last Edit: August 24, 2011, 09:39:47 PM by mory »
Logged

mory

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 752
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #73 on: August 24, 2011, 09:47:17 PM »

with so many eminently playable and beautiful sounding box's out there a few tunes would surely suffice. I wonder when the question first raged or were players just happy to be playing, is it just a "more, more" thing? are we really just talking about elitism here, mines better than yours, I have my suspicion's  (:)
« Last Edit: August 24, 2011, 09:59:09 PM by mory »
Logged

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #74 on: August 24, 2011, 10:29:35 PM »

since you ask ... I do. there is no such thing as a hand made box. the lineage of production surely includes the tools one may class as hand tools etc and without over simplifying (first cut down a tree etc) all processes suggest an element of cooperation from other humans, we didn't make all the elements of human achievement by individual endever but by consensus, some times to our good and sometimes to our detriment, we have consensus in box making and it precedes this debate in the form of all the box's here before this debate, the production and methods employed being a conglomeration of those elements discussed that have become a set of rules to construct "a Box", now they can vary but the rules exist because that's how our boxes are made, what this thread is witnessing is an attempt to draw those rules under a new banner, but who is defining these new rules, it doesn't feel consensual, as many posts by others seem to be dismissed, so who is the rule maker and who is defining those rules, I agree with various aspects you bring up but that doesn't make them any more "right" than it makes others "wrong" just take a read back over the whole thing back to the Loffett post etc lots of hard words and if it were possible you could almost feel the anger in some of your responses were not all in agreement and that's good but rules are arrived at in a developing thing like this gradually, gently, as a process of time and event, so as I've said before ... peace brother peace. mory

Again, this is a manner of personal attack. You condemn me for expressing disagreement.  I looked back over the Loffet thread and stand by my comments there.  Because the Loffet thread, early on, took a direction away from Loffet, and yet some posters continued to post regarding Loffet, I created this thread because I thought it was appropriate (and should have been done sooner, to avoid misunderstanding).  In the new thread, I attempted to delineate a line of inquiry on a topic that interests me (as it interests at least some other posters here as well). In keeping the dialogue going, I have responded to specific points in many posts; the only time I "dismissed" a statement was my response to Chris's citation of Pignol -- it is a point of fact that there makers out there who do make their own bellows, including Maugein in France and at least three builders in Quebec. I also cautioned that a several topics were off-course -- such as the violin-building topic -- although they are certainly interesting and could be a great (and separate) thread. In doing so, I was accused by a single poster of seeking attention and "boring" him; meanwhile, the thread that I started attracted around 1000 views.

At least your last post addresses the topic.  You seem to be expressing your own "rule" that there be consensus; if I follow your argument (and I apologize -- I don't intend this as a criticism, but it is difficult for me to follow your argument because of the lack of punctuation), you believe that one should not hope for an accordion built by one set of hands, let alone a "handmade" accordion.  To that, I can only say that I'm trying to articulate a different idea than what you are opposing -- I never proposed a single set of hands, nor implied that a melodeon should be built by hand tools only, nor have I stated that a melodeon should be built without cooperation.  However, calling all "multiple-hands work" cooperation fails to distinguish Gaillard (who employs a tuner for reedwork) from Saltarelle.

There has been no privileging of the "single-builder (or small) shop" over the small factory, simply a distinction made between the two; I made observations about single-maker shops because I believe that many melodeon players place special value on the artisans, yet there are different levels of work being done by the shops. (And since you brought it up: I believe that Bruno Priez has actually built melodeons completely by hand with the exception of reeds and some recycled parts.) It also seems like you think that I made "rules" for melodeon builders, when my posts above refer to norms that the practices of melodeon builders themselves have established -- the only "rules" that I'm proposing are ways for us to distinguish where the practices lie in relation to the norm.

Again, I think that these are great topics: 1. Can a melodeon be made completely by hand(tools)? 2. What are the differences between single-builder shops and factory-made instruments? and 3. how are these differences important to different players/mel.net participants?
And to Chris: this "I know what I like" is exactly what I would like to get to, ultimately, and first I felt it necessary to make this foray into distinctions in production processes/relationships/methods.

Andrew Wigglesworth

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1101
  • 07
    • My website
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #75 on: August 24, 2011, 10:38:15 PM »

Personally I think that at heart of this discussion is the nature of value and commodity production in capitalist society. Then again, I would :D

There is no natural process that says a particular melodeon is worth £1,000. This is a value that humans assign to an inanimate object because it has become that magical and mysterious thing, a commodity.

In reality a Melodeon is an accretion of a web of social interactions and relationships that are mostly hidden from us. It's commodity value is arrived at by a set of social forces and interactions that are mostly hidden from us.

There may be a dire need for shoes in a certain area. The social value of and need for shoes may be immense, but if the commodity value is not right, then the objects will not be manufactured. The real human, social interrelationships are obscured by layers of custom, attitudes and primitive adherence to precepts of private property and the belief in such things as the knowing nature of "the market". Have you ever noticed the BBC news reports where after some event the presenter will ask a reporter, "what do the markets think?". The "markets" themselves think nothing in reality but we have reduced layers of human relationships into a process of commodity trading.
 
I would say the true social value can only be brought out from an understanding of the social relationships (and social solidarity) that makes a melodeon possible and nessesary ... but that's not how Capitalism works. Capitalism obscures the human process and makes a fetish of the commodity and the supposedly natural market forces and property relationships that determine commodity value. So, in our Capitalist system, this discussion is never ending and always unsatisfactory.

jb

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 250
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #76 on: August 24, 2011, 11:52:53 PM »

Wow. So much to disagree with in that old marxist hocus-pocus. It's hard to know where to start.
( btw ... "shoes"?)
Logged
there ain't no such thing as a free reed

Andrew Wigglesworth

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1101
  • 07
    • My website
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #77 on: August 25, 2011, 12:00:23 AM »

Wow. So much to disagree with in that old marxist hocus-pocus. It's hard to know where to start.
( btw ... "shoes"?)

150 years and still haunting you eh   ;)

Um, shoes. I presume you've seen shoes or are you claiming that as a Marxist invention?   :P

mory

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 752
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #78 on: August 25, 2011, 01:06:08 AM »

Will some one just tell us what we think !
Logged

Steve C.

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2075
  • Erica, Morse Anglo
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #79 on: August 25, 2011, 01:27:38 AM »

Not to get back to close to Andy's original post, but I find myself more naive than usual about who makes what and how.

My own bias is that tuning is a red herring, does not matter who does it as long as they do it to your specification (free reeds being the unusual musical instrument that comes to you "already tuned")

But everything else, well, I guess I really don't know who does what and how.

Always assumed that most "manufacturers" bought springs and pallets and buttons and reeds and straps, a lot of other parts, from companies that specialized in the manufacture of those parts.

Then the manufacturer/builder built there own frames and reedblocks and keyboards and soundboards and grills, etc. pretty much from free stock and put them all together in their own methods of screwing and gluing.

Pretty much what the recent photo show from Lester's Blog looked like.

But, apparently, this is the exception, not the rule.

Since it's apparent from the posts that many members have pretty detailed knowledge of who does what, could you give me/us some outline:  who's doing it all (growing the trees! no one probably) but who comes close, who has the middle ground, who is "badge engineering" "renaming" someone else's work, etc.

Especially interested in the facts/opinions regarding Castagnari, Saltarelle, Dino Bafetti, Beltuna, a lot of the Italian makers I get all confused about (Serenellini, Serenelli?)

Also, Van der AA and the Dino Oakwood Binci (who exactly makes it and why is it so expensive?)

Not looking for snark or dirt, just some honest opinion and insight.

Thanks, Steve
Logged
Located in Central North Carolina, USA; credit for picture: livingplanet.ca
Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 6   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal