Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: 1 2 3 4 [5] 6   Go Down

Author Topic: how much "making" constitutes "making"  (Read 23124 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

mory

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 752
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #80 on: August 25, 2011, 01:32:54 AM »

I think something is leading you to misinterpret me Andy because we are in agreement , the rules are there yes, its the placement of criteria around the habits of existing practices to define a makers right to bear his own name as the "maker" I am not so sure about  and by that I mean who is defining those criteria and it seems to be you, thats not deflamatory, it just is, maybe a detailed run down on an imaginary box outlining all the aspects you think put a box into one catagory or another would help, it might help the French next year to, I spent about an hour putting together a humourus piece but then felt it might still offend so I scrapped it, the rules you say I seem to be putting on are there, not mine, the consensus being the builders and buyers and associated events over time, not some thing I am demanding, what I am saying to you as kindly as I can is that you seem to be over riding that existing consensus with a set of criteria of your own, defining that, in a way that is actualy quite an insult to the work they do that brings us such joy. I am at peace with myself Andy and with you also, I do feel you've been taking us all on a roundabout of a journey so Good night from me I'll catch you tommorrow. mory
« Last Edit: August 25, 2011, 01:41:07 AM by mory »
Logged

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #81 on: August 25, 2011, 01:41:43 AM »

Personally I think that at heart of this discussion is the nature of value and commodity production in capitalist society. Then again, I would :D

Andrew, I'm with you on the general theory and would make some finer distinctions.  There's very little capitalism involved in the production of melodeons in single-maker and small shops, and even most of the small factories are not, strictly speaking, "capitalist" endeavors. If you're talking about Hohner, then capitalism would be more appropriate; but Gaillard, at least in his melodeon-making endeavor, is not a capitalist. (For those who aren't Marx-heads, making/selling something is not the same as acting as a capitalist.)

I think that your general statement -- that the production is hidden from view -- is right on point here. What do you think about this: Is the problem that there are some individuals engaged in the act of making something in a manner that defies the dominant ways in which production occurs today? And there are pressures that result in some seeking solutions that edge production toward the anonymous/hidden/fungible/etc.?

I've often been amazed at the economics of the small-scale builders like Gaillard --- they do seem to running on more motivational fuel than "money begetting money," don't they?

To GCFMan/Steve: thanks for continuing to post on-point.  Great questions.  Diatosoldo posted a link in the recent Loffet thread -- a French site that attempted to do what you are asking for.  It's tricky -- I already noticed that some of the info on the site is not necessarily accurate, but it is interesting to read it, because it is obvious that they ruffled some feathers as well.  If this kind of info gets posted, I hope that people try to stick with facts that they observed, and if they are referring to a source, citing it so that others can check it out.  Information gets quoted without reference and becomes a further voice that looks like proof in the future.  As an example: the late Jim Coogan used to sell Maugein in the U.S., and stated that the reeds were Binci; Maugein's materials show photos of their own reed production; and that French site mentioned above says that Maugeins contain another brand of reeds.  It could be that all of this info is correct, just not detailed enough (like: perhaps at one time or another, each source was used); or it could all be false.  

(The info on the Oakwood/Baffetti Binci seemed very up-front (to me) and was detailed in another thread.)

Christopher K.

  • Content Manager
  • Hero Member
  • ***
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 894
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #82 on: August 25, 2011, 03:30:18 AM »

The issue in this discussion that is interesting to me is a question of prestige and the problems that arise when broad or uninformed language attributes prestige when none is due.

The awareness that Andy is talking about is important because there is a legitimate measure of pride and prestige associated with the products of craftsmen who complete their work independent of outside contractors. The word "maker" implies the prestige associated with a single-shop, single-origin, handmade instrument of which there are several notable examples available today (I think the grow-your-own-trees counter argument is a hyperbole). Below this, there are several other classes of operation in decreasing levels of self sufficiency, as Andy described.

A problem arises when players and dealers casually use the same language to denote different types of operations without knowing what actually transpires within the shop. The market is very competitive and broad language is especially unfair to operations that do a maximum, if not all of the required work, under their own roofs. Some companies illegitimately benefit from this attribution of prestige via broad language, and I believe some quietly tie themselves to the length of a word that implies they do work which they might not do. On the other hand, including such details on a website might just be an honest oversight, and not always the willful omission of the truth. It might be more of a problem that there isn't an English word (that I can think of) which is specific enough to describe the other classes.

I am skeptical when companies are not forthcoming with the details of what and how they manufacture their products, because I know that prestige is built into the price that I pay. This isn't exclusive to accordions - it's true with practically everything. I'll name coffee and tea as my pet peeve examples of products for which it is difficult if not impossible to get a straight answer from producers about sources, growers, etc.

Just how important it is to know what transpires at the plant, or how much this matters to a consumer of a product that performs in an exemplary manner, is a matter of opinion that is almost irrelevant to the discussion. I think these issues are independent of the consumer's right to know what transpires at the plant, and the craftsman's right to be distinguished as such in a diverse market. I'd love for Congress to require Saltarelle to disclose its sources, I'd love for the Cajun "garage" builders to be turned out to the public, and I'd love for real craftsmen and luthiers in the United States and abroad to be given the respect they deserve by reaping dollars from the market that are proportionate to the prestige built into their instruments.

melodeon

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1732
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #83 on: August 25, 2011, 04:56:29 AM »

Excellent post. !!!  and to the heart of the matter.

Some "makers" are coat-tailing and charging for what really is not there... as an example.. Saltarelle.
Read their website then look at one of their accordeons then add to that the knowledge that the instruments are
made in Italy .. implication is that you are getting an instrument from France that is hand crafted to the highest standard...
Here on Melnet... many die hard Saltarelle owners/players will concede they are not the value of a Castaganri when it comes to
design, material and workmanship. Simply do not live up to the "image" created by marketing hype; and of course, not made in France by Saltarelle.

It is a shame that some true hand builders cannot get the same amount of money for their boxes as some of the big boys, not being able to compete with slick web sites and clever ad copy.

Another example of a product not matching the hype would be the USA marketed Gabbanellis.

I appreciate Hohner for their honesty and solid value boxes as much as I do Castagnari. Both a good value and no BS.

I have another observation.... just as high end mandolins became coveted by the new age yuppie, so did melodeons... perhaps not so much , but I see it as a profiling accessory to some.  Some marketeers know this so cater to it. Not unlike the new wee puntable dogs.
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #84 on: August 25, 2011, 07:29:18 AM »

Quote
  It is a shame that some true hand builders cannot get the same amount of money for their boxes as some of the big boys, not being able to compete with slick web sites and clever ad copy.

Hmmm. The Gaillard and van der Aa websites are actually quite slick. A function of their expensive product, perhaps. Maybe, but that product contains many man hours and I'm not convinced that a maker with larger output of boxes that don't have the perfection factor isn't on a level field of play.

In the end I feel the melodeon market is quite like that for cars. We have our old bangers, our utilitarian models, our top end ones in which there is nothing that'll annoy, but at a significant premium for the labour involved.

I'm not all that hung up on HOW it's made. I think innovation is good. If a particular item can be sourced at the right quality an my maker can stand by that? I'm cool even if its the box. I actually don't see accordion as furniture or art and am far more interested in performance.

Now the car analogy breaks away. Cars depreciate whereas a top maker's melodeon will often appreciate!

So for me it starts with a price/quality/performance thing and reputation is actually a good metric of that.

But they are ALL makers. They optimise in their own ways and target different parts of the market.
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #85 on: August 25, 2011, 02:56:46 PM »

I'm not all that hung up on HOW it's made. I think innovation is good. If a particular item can be sourced at the right quality an my maker can stand by that? I'm cool even if its the box. I actually don't see accordion as furniture or art and am far more interested in performance.

My personal experience is that they tend to line up, hand-in-hand. Gaillards and Castagnaris outperform every other melodeon that I've ever tried (I believe that I've handled and played over 200 melodeons but at some point I lost count -- in any case I have been able to make personal comparisons whenever I've had the chance).  Melodie and Messervier take a seat very close to the top.  I've never played an Oakwood but can imagine they are up in the top ranks.  My positive experience with other melodeons is often qualified to "bang for the buck" ratios.  (Thus, I love Saltarelle Irish Bouebes that I've tried -- I think they are a good value; I also like the Hohner XTreme 3 row boxes.)

Chris, you mentioned in your post above that you know what you like, and I assume you like your Gaillard and your Oakwood, so are you sure that the performance is really divorced from manner of production?

But they are ALL makers. They optimise in their own ways and target different parts of the market.

Are you saying that Saltarelle "makes" melodeons? As opposed to "has them made"?  I'm not arguing against you, I just wonder whether your statement is in direct opposition to the criticism of broad terminology in Chris K's post above?

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #86 on: August 25, 2011, 05:17:11 PM »

Making has to involve more than screwing your badge on? From what I hear Saltarelle may soon get kicked out of the St Chartier Brownies for this. Though interesting that you like their kit!

"What I like"? A quote from a different thread, same day, in the context of one-liners that say nothing.  :Ph
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

sandwich

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 69
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #87 on: August 25, 2011, 05:24:16 PM »

The word "maker" implies the prestige associated with a single-shop, single-origin, handmade instrument of which there are several notable examples available today (I think the grow-your-own-trees counter argument is a hyperbole). Below this, there are several other classes of operation in decreasing levels of self sufficiency, as Andy described.

A problem arises when players and dealers casually use the same language to denote different types of operations without knowing what actually transpires within the shop. The market is very competitive and broad language is especially unfair to operations that do a maximum, if not all of the required work, under their own roofs.
Sounds like you want a single-malt accordion. What you're implying is that a "hand-made" box (which was made in the one shop) is superior than one which wasn't, when this may not be the case at all.

To me, it's about quality control. If the maker is too busy to machine the wood, he gives the specifications to a carpenter (who is an artisan worker anyway). If the work produced isn't up to scratch, it's rejected.

Is there not an element of affectation about the 100% maker in this day and age? Also, I would've thought that all reeded instrument makers get their reeds from third parties.

Quote
I'd love for Congress to require Saltarelle to disclose its sources
Senator Sandwich can disclose this for you RIGHT NOW!  It's Baffetti.

I was there on a USA trade mission with Captain Benjamin Franklin "Hawkeye" Pierce recently.
« Last Edit: August 25, 2011, 05:35:28 PM by sandwich »
Logged

Steve C.

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2075
  • Erica, Morse Anglo
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #88 on: August 25, 2011, 05:30:24 PM »

I know that many of you also follow other groups, and I always get a kick out of the alternative viewpoints one sees (though limited in scope to 3 rows) in reyesforum.

Gabanelli's rock!  Castagnari's overpriced fancy junk! Bass buttons, why even have them!

It's a good group though, lots of stuff for us GCF minorities.

Not to mention the t-shirts.  BTW, if you have a Hohner, you must get the skeleton shirt.  Now THAT rocks!
Logged
Located in Central North Carolina, USA; credit for picture: livingplanet.ca

sandwich

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 69
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #89 on: August 25, 2011, 05:32:31 PM »

Gabanelli's rock!
Are they good? There website is so crappy that I just presumed they weren't up to much.
Logged

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #90 on: August 25, 2011, 05:35:24 PM »

Though interesting that you like [Saltarelle's] kit!

Yes, relative to the price -- so, like I said my praise is limited to the ratio of bang to buck!  I don't need to place that kind of qualification on my praise of Gaillard.

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #91 on: August 25, 2011, 05:42:36 PM »

Is there not an element of affectation about the 100% maker in this day and age? Also, I would've thought that all reeded instrument makers get their reeds from third parties.

Can you explain what the affectation is? Because I'm pretty sure that the same would apply to playing a melodeon (at all) in "this day and age." Viva the unzeitgemaesse Betrachtungen!

As for "all reeded instrument makers," are you serious?  There are a handful of concertina makers who make their own reeds (Suttner, Carrol, Kensington, Dipper, and some others I don't recall off-hand), many harmonica makers who make their own reeds.  I'm not certain what is going on with Maugein but perhaps someone who has actually been in the factory can explain.  Does Hohner make its own reeds (in some factory in China)?
At any rate, I think that we have determined that MOST single-builder and small melodeon shops buy their reeds from one or more of several sources.

sandwich

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 69
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #92 on: August 25, 2011, 05:45:35 PM »

Though interesting that you like [Saltarelle's] kit!

Yes, relative to the price -- so, like I said my praise is limited to the ratio of bang to buck!  I don't need to place that kind of qualification on my praise of Gaillard.

The bias in favour of Gaillard makes the whole discussion sort of lop-sided.

'm sure they are great boxes, but are they any better than Martin Connolly's Kincora which are handmade?
Logged

sandwich

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 69
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #93 on: August 25, 2011, 06:04:22 PM »

Is there not an element of affectation about the 100% maker in this day and age? Also, I would've thought that all reeded instrument makers get their reeds from third parties.

Can you explain what the affectation is? Because I'm pretty sure that the same would apply to playing a melodeon (at all) in "this day and age." Viva the unzeitgemaesse Betrachtungen!

As for "all reeded instrument makers," are you serious?  There are a handful of concertina makers who make their own reeds (Suttner, Carrol, Kensington, Dipper, and some others I don't recall off-hand), many harmonica makers who make their own reeds.  I'm not certain what is going on with Maugein but perhaps someone who has actually been in the factory can explain.  Does Hohner make its own reeds (in some factory in China)?
At any rate, I think that we have determined that MOST single-builder and small melodeon shops buy their reeds from one or more of several sources.

I was talking about orchestral reeded-instruments, i.e. 12 note music.
It's all very well to traipse the earth in search of the purist form of the accordion, but as accordion players, we must accept that we can never be in the same bracket as maestros of the violin, for example.

By "affectation", I meant misguided purists who refuse to use any components not made in their own shed. And that kind of leads onto the "cut down your own tree" point...which is why the prestige bestowed on 100% handmade makers may, in some cases, be misguided.
Logged

Fidjit

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 538
    • my space on My Space
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #94 on: August 25, 2011, 06:07:28 PM »

Excellent post. !!!  and to the heart of the matter.

Some "makers" are coat-tailing and charging for what really is not there... as an example.. Saltarelle.
Read their website then look at one of their accordeons then add to that the knowledge that the instruments are
made in Italy .. implication is that you are getting an instrument from France that is hand crafted to the highest standard...
Here on Melnet... many die hard Saltarelle owners/players will concede they are not the value of a Castaganri when it comes to
design, material and workmanship. Simply do not live up to the "image" created by marketing hype; and of course, not made in France by Saltarelle.



It's a matter of taste. What do you prefer ? Of all the makers. So many are very good.
I would like one of each please.  Still learning about all the differences.
Personally not keen on Castaganari sound. Although a box they stopped doing I would love to have. If Steve is ever willing to sell his. So I compromise with my Conamara II

I went to meet George R. The inventor of Saltarelle boxes. The originals he did then he leased it out to Italians. A business thingy for him.

Cheers  :|glug
Logged

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #95 on: August 25, 2011, 06:19:45 PM »

I was talking about orchestral reeded-instruments, i.e. 12 note music.
In which case, your original statement was incorrect?


By "affectation", I meant misguided purists who refuse to use any components not made in their own shed. And that kind of leads onto the "cut down your own tree" point...which is why the prestige bestowed on 100% handmade makers may, in some cases, be misguided.

Could you be more specific?  Why are such purists misguided? (And where are they -- I don't know of any unless you included the Bruno Priez example -- so if you mean Priez, how is he "misguided")  Why is the prestige (attributed by Christopher K above) "misguided," in your view?
Or are you suggesting that there are no differences? Please elaborate.

As for Kincora, I'd love to try one -- they clearly drew on Gaillard as an inspiration, as far as I can tell from photos.  Would you say they are excellent?  They appear to be made in small numbers in a shop that makes all the wooden components.  Gaillard is simply used as an example above, which along with Castagnari has trumped the performance of all other boxes that I've tried. I'd be happy to learn if there are others in that category; I have also never tried a Briggs.
« Last Edit: August 25, 2011, 06:23:56 PM by Andy in Vermont »
Logged

oggiesnr

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 995
  • Dino BPII, Alfred Arnold Bandoneon, Loffet G/C
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #96 on: August 25, 2011, 06:50:25 PM »


As for Kincora, I'd love to try one -- they clearly drew on Gaillard as an inspiration, as far as I can tell from photos.  Would you say they are excellent?  They appear to be made in small numbers in a shop that makes all the wooden components.  Gaillard is simply used as an example above, which along with Castagnari has trumped the performance of all other boxes that I've tried. I'd be happy to learn if there are others in that category; I have also never tried a Briggs.

This is where it gets tricky.  Not tried a Gaillard, tried lots of Castagnaris and I wouldn't want one if they were half the price, they hold no magic for me and so I cannot see why, as a semi mass produced (not "artisan" box) they command the premium.

Steve
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11154
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #97 on: August 25, 2011, 07:26:37 PM »

Who said "single malt" box?  Very good analogy, and better than my cars.  Yes, BG is just a convenient paradigm. I'm sure there are others.

Happens I've got one and was willing to spend my compo money from a bike accident and wait 3  years for it.I picked BG from among 20 or makers at st chartier.

Only van der Aa came close for something you hold and play, and want to own. I'm off to see Frans on Saturday.
« Last Edit: August 25, 2011, 07:28:53 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

sandwich

  • Good talker
  • **
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 69
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #98 on: August 25, 2011, 07:54:06 PM »

In which case, your original statement was incorrect?
Yep, my mistake

Could you be more specific?  Why are such purists misguided? (And where are they -- I don't know of any unless you included the Bruno Priez example -- so if you mean Priez, how is he "misguided")  Why is the prestige (attributed by Christopher K above) "misguided," in your view?
Or are you suggesting that there are no differences? Please elaborate.
Potentially misguided. I think it's a reasonable assumption that a percentage of a handmade box isn't made by the maker.
As for the differences...I wouldn't really know. Maybe it can't really be known, because - and I think this is what Christopher K was getting at - there are no industry standards.

I don't mean to come across as bashing the purists, I had a look at the cajun maker's website and I think what that man is doing is commendable. Also, was a bit of a learning experience because I thought cajun music was "dukes of hazard" territory.

As for Kincora, I'd love to try one -- they clearly drew on Gaillard as an inspiration, as far as I can tell from photos.  Would you say they are excellent?
I was very impressed with the one I played. A great thing about these one-man-bands, is the personal touch. You know who you're dealing with. There's a lot to be said for that.
« Last Edit: August 25, 2011, 07:56:32 PM by sandwich »
Logged

Andy in Vermont

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 948
  • Mélodie
    • Melodeon Minutes (blog)
Re: how much "making" constitutes "making"
« Reply #99 on: August 25, 2011, 09:04:53 PM »

A great thing about these one-man-bands, is the personal touch. You know who you're dealing with. There's a lot to be said for that.

I agree -- it's one of the reasons why I'm advocating a greater degree of transparency.  "Knowing who you're dealing with" is a good policy for buying meat, malt and melodeons. 
Pages: 1 2 3 4 [5] 6   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal