Melodeon.net Forums

Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
Advanced search  

News:

Welcome to the new melodeon.net forum

Pages: [1] 2 3   Go Down

Author Topic: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords  (Read 16179 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Bobtheboat

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 556
  • 'On the cut' near Lichfield, UK
Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« on: October 29, 2011, 04:24:49 PM »

Hello all, I'm working through the Milleret & Pignol tutor books. in the preamble they recommend thirdless chords on the left hand.
 I've heard of people having thirds removed and having doubled up fifths. Could anyone take the time to explain why M&P recommend this together with the pros and cons?
Much obliged, Bob.
Logged
'Rowbotham Erika Extraordinaire' (12 bass + stop G/C/acc), Hohner Liliput Bb-Eb. Castagnari Rik G/C/acc

Bob Ellis

  • Hero?....Where's my medal, then?
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2878
  • Ain't I cute?
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #1 on: October 29, 2011, 05:42:26 PM »

The simplest answer is that removing the thirds makes the chords neutral (i.e. neither major nor minor, but able to be used in place of either). On a D/G melodeon, the chords where I find this most useful are B and A. It avoids having to make the choice of whether to have a B major or a B minor chord and it enables the A chord to be played against a C natural in the melody.

Main advantages: increased versatility of the chords and a reduction in weight because there are fewer reeds in the bass end.

Main disadvantage: the chords sound 'thinner', although in some tunes this can be an advantage.

Others with better theoretical knowledge than me will no doubt provide more academic/complex/detailed answers
Logged
Bob in beautiful Wensleydale, Les Panards Dansants, Crook Morris and the Loose Knit Band.
Clément Guais 3-row D/G/acc.; Castagnari 1914 D/G; Karntnerland Steirische 3-row G/C/F; Ellis Pariselle 2.6-row D/G/acc.; Gabbanelli Compact 2-row D/G with lots of bling, pre-war Hohner Bb/F; Acadian one-row in D.

Bobtheboat

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 556
  • 'On the cut' near Lichfield, UK
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #2 on: October 29, 2011, 06:32:53 PM »

Thanks Bob, so the doubled up fifths is to combat the 'thinness' when the thirds go? Bob.
Logged
'Rowbotham Erika Extraordinaire' (12 bass + stop G/C/acc), Hohner Liliput Bb-Eb. Castagnari Rik G/C/acc

Bob Ellis

  • Hero?....Where's my medal, then?
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2878
  • Ain't I cute?
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #3 on: October 29, 2011, 09:29:35 PM »

I assume so, but I don't personally like chords with doubled up fifths. They seem to me to unbalance the chord.

Of the two main boxes I play, one has the thirds in place and the other has them removed, but without doubling up the fifths. I like the sound of both boxes and I have not found the need to beef up the sound of the one without thirds by doubling up the fifths.
Logged
Bob in beautiful Wensleydale, Les Panards Dansants, Crook Morris and the Loose Knit Band.
Clément Guais 3-row D/G/acc.; Castagnari 1914 D/G; Karntnerland Steirische 3-row G/C/F; Ellis Pariselle 2.6-row D/G/acc.; Gabbanelli Compact 2-row D/G with lots of bling, pre-war Hohner Bb/F; Acadian one-row in D.

george garside

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 5401
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #4 on: October 29, 2011, 10:03:31 PM »

Those boxes that have a bass 'stop'  that is used to block the thirds  as & when required offer the advantage  of being able to face either way.   Without this luxury I would personally go for thirdless ( just tape over the appropriate holes so you can later change your mind!) on the basis that it increases versatility and can, depending on the box & the skill of the player  have the effect of quietening overloud bass. Taking out one set of bass reeds also reduces bass air consumption by ? a third making for less bellows movement being required thereby enabling the bellows to be played 'tight'  for better control.

My main DG box (serenellini salterello)has taped out thirds and  & I have never felt much urge to untape them

george.
Logged
author of DG tutor book "DG Melodeon a Crash Course for Beginners".

ganderbox

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 734
  • Melodeons from Brittany, Italy, Germany* and Leeds
    • www.choughedtobits.co.uk
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #5 on: October 30, 2011, 09:20:50 AM »

I found out about taping off the thirds when I got my first 2.5 row, which didn't have a bass stop, because it made it possible to play in more minor keys (as Bob mentioned). The reason for this is simply that in minor keys, the third note in the scale (which is the "third" in the bass chord) is flattened, and this is the main note which defines whether a tune is in a major or minor key. Removing the third means the chord can be used for either major or minor keys. For a D/G it's probably most useful for playing in Am, but it's also handy if you want to play in Bm, and  for modulating from major to minor keys (A to Am,  G to Gm, D to Dm etc, depending what accidentals you have on the right hand).

Apart from that, though, I found that I much preferred the sound without the thirds (less "boxy"), and proceeded to tape off the thirds on my other melodeons. I now have a 2.5 row which has a bass stop, but I can honestly say I still never ever use the thirds because I just don't like them. It might be just that the thirds make a tune sound too square and defined, but also I wonder if it's possible that when you play without them, you start playing tunes in a certain way which creates chords or harmonies which simply don't work when you put the thirds back in?
Logged
Pauline from Cornwall

*  including a customised Hohner Club from Cornwall (and very nice it is too!).

Tyker

  • Respected Sage
  • ****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 354
  • Cheviot C#DG,Hohners D and G/C
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #6 on: October 30, 2011, 10:22:20 AM »

In Milleret and Pignol volume 3 , the start goes into cross-fingering on the left hand to build chords such as C7M Dm7 Em7 and F6 Csus4 . etc .
Logged
Graeme - North Hampshire,UK

There is no noun that can't be verbed

Bobtheboat

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 556
  • 'On the cut' near Lichfield, UK
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #7 on: October 30, 2011, 10:54:08 AM »

Hi Fellas, thanks for the help.
The reason I ask is because I'm having a new box sorted by Mike Rowbotham. (see my recent thread on G/C/F and G/C/acc).We've bought a lovely wooden Erika as a donor box which Mike is going to change to G/C/acc and add 4 basses! I'm very excited!
Mike's going to start work in a couple of weeks so I'm thinking about set up and layout at the moment. Any thoughts? Maybe I should start a new thread?
@ Tyker,I'm still on volume 1! (And enjoying every minute of it!)
Cheers, Bob.
« Last Edit: October 30, 2011, 01:30:25 PM by Bobtheboat »
Logged
'Rowbotham Erika Extraordinaire' (12 bass + stop G/C/acc), Hohner Liliput Bb-Eb. Castagnari Rik G/C/acc

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #8 on: October 30, 2011, 11:40:52 AM »

M&P started out as children of 60s folkies in the SE France/alps scene and Norbert tells of being put to learn accordion, his sister the Gurdy.  Family holidays were in Anost-en-Morvan, later St Chartier.  They also liked 'rock' and  put a lot of research into chord and scale theory, and the improvised line in general in the early 90's as they moved from being traditional folk musicians into improvisation. eg reading 200 page books on it, in English!

How does this influence their advice on chords?  They see a chord as having a 'colour'  - and the more you extend it by adding notes the more complex its hue becomes.

Notes in a chord are 'numbered' according to their place in the corresponding major scale. Its third (=E v Eb in a C chord) note  is the main denominator for major/minor, but M&P also see 6th v b6th (=A/Ab in a C chord) as adding minor colour.

    An aside on 'extensions'.  
A 'normal' 9th (D in a C chord) sort of adds excitement/zing.
b9th (Db) as gives a certain Balkan/Arab/Flamenco flavour?
#9th (D# in C) is very 'blue' and shrieks that the next chord must be major.  

A #9th chord is "literally" ;) "just lying there"  on a D/G.  Try pulling Pull Abass+ C#/E/GD row+ CG row
You've played A7#9 - musical equivalent of Epsom salts.  Now deconstruct it, finger by finger to A+E ...

.. this is your 'thirdless chord'?  Well, Norbert calls this 'un accord faible'='feeble'.  The 5th note in our diatonic major scale is simply the 3rd harmonic of its tonic. It is very closely related to the vibrations of the tonic reed - it actually shares about half of them. There is no 'colour' content. So it offers a flat musical canvas on which to build improvisation and to play right hand chords.  They are actually seeking a certain banality in this, essentially using left end for bass lines.

Do try their classes on youtube - presently it's  'blues scale' http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XnuAcQEKNKc.  Basically M&P want the freedom to move "from major into minor" as the old song goes. Having a strong 3rd in your left end chord strongly restricts that.
::) "thus endeth the lesson"  
. It might be just that the thirds make a tune sound too square and defined, but also I wonder if it's possible that when you play without them, you start playing tunes in a certain way which creates chords or harmonies which simply don't work when you put the thirds back in?

..in many less words - "yes"  (:)
« Last Edit: October 30, 2011, 12:01:23 PM by Chris Ryall »
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Rob2Hook

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2278
  • Castagnaris, Hohners & Baffetti
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #9 on: October 30, 2011, 01:11:06 PM »

But, "... how strange the change..."

In the UK, I feel there are two main camps of melodeon player.  The first, typified by the Morris musician, plays very stompy dance tunes and wants volume and robustness.  He will probably prefer a box with the full triad in the chord for its roundness and percussive bass.  The second will be venturing into a wider range of music and so will require more accidentals and more adaptable chords, so will prefer the thirds removed. I guess as you're having more accidentals and basses added, you'll be more comfortable in the second category.

I used to play for Morris with a guy who always had the thirds stopped out - it suited his style, yet he said he envied the sound of my identical box with the full chords.  He mostly plays anglo concertina now, so he can play any harmonies he likes!

Rob.
Logged

waltzman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 943
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #10 on: October 30, 2011, 01:33:41 PM »

I would like to point out that what Milleret & Pignol recommend is a box with removable thirds not a box with no thirds.   There is a big difference.  Using the language above the third is the colour for the chord and, to my mind, highly desirable for most of your standard dance repertoire.  I also agree that doubling the fifth would not be desirable.  You want the tonic to be the dominant tone.
Logged

Chris Ryall

  • "doc 3-row"
  • French Interpreter
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 11153
  • Wirral UK
    • Chris Ryall
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #11 on: October 30, 2011, 01:48:54 PM »

Missed that point - yes a thirds-out stop is a top 'extra' for me  - best of both Worlds  8)   Whatever les gars recommend - they both play kit with no thirds whatsoever. The pay-off being a fully chromatic left end.
Logged
  _       _    _      _ 

Bobtheboat

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 556
  • 'On the cut' near Lichfield, UK
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #12 on: October 30, 2011, 02:10:25 PM »

Ah yes, however, I'm having an Erika converted so no 'stop' options I'm afraid!
One day when I'm wealthier (stop laughing!) and a much better player (I said stop!) , I shall splash out on a Castagnari Benny G/C/acc  or similar! Please see my new thread re' the layout of the new project for further chance to influence my choice. Thank again (:)
Logged
'Rowbotham Erika Extraordinaire' (12 bass + stop G/C/acc), Hohner Liliput Bb-Eb. Castagnari Rik G/C/acc

Tufty

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 855
  • Dino Bincis etc
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #13 on: October 30, 2011, 02:45:28 PM »

I have the advantage of a left hand stop but almost always play without thirds, apart from the West Country, Bob Cann style of tune. I don't know the theory, just what sounds best to me.
Logged

waltzman

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 943
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #14 on: October 30, 2011, 04:06:48 PM »

Ah yes, however, I'm having an Erika converted so no 'stop' options I'm afraid!
One day when I'm wealthier (stop laughing!) and a much better player (I said stop!) , I shall splash out on a Castagnari Benny G/C/acc  or similar! Please see my new thread re' the layout of the new project for further chance to influence my choice. Thank again (:)

Milleret & Pignol also say in their tutor books that once you move to a three row G/C/acc it becomes a "different instrument" on which you will play a "different repertoire" than you play on your two row instrument.  So I don't think they are saying that no thirds is optimal for a two row G/C but that the ability to remove the thirds is essential for the repertoire you are likely to want to play on a three row G/C/acc.
Logged

swig

  • Member
  • *
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 31
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #15 on: October 30, 2011, 04:44:21 PM »

Just had my Erica morris box rebuilt by Mike Rowbotham. Thirds out and fifths doubled up. Absolutely great !
Logged

forrest

  • Other Places::
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 1009
  • digits still functioning
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #16 on: October 30, 2011, 05:21:03 PM »

I have not read the tutorial. Just for argument's sake, let's say we only have chords with thirds. Is this not a definite curtailment of the possibilites of the instrument? With the thirds stopped, we then have the full palette of colors, including the thirds, by supplementing with the right hand. It appears to me that the idea of thirds in the chords served as a convenience for simplifying the accompaniment of popular tune patterns on these instruments.....
Logged

Steve C.

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 2075
  • Erica, Morse Anglo
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #17 on: October 30, 2011, 09:37:09 PM »

Pretty much what everyone said.

I do like my Pokerwork even better now with only the Em changed to an open-E no thirds.

Makes the E much more useful, also as a "fake" chord.  It does sound thin(er), I admit.

Best world is stop to remove thirds.  Have that on my Benny and it's a nice option.

When I was starting out, not having much musical training, I thought you could not play minor chords without the minor "built in" to the chord.  But the treble side "adds it in" when you need it.

Have also tried an open B push on the same button, but like it a bit less.
Logged
Located in Central North Carolina, USA; credit for picture: livingplanet.ca

Cooper

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 705
  • Gaillrd G/C/#,Casta Allain8 GC,Lofft CF, giord ad
    • Cooper's homepage
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #18 on: October 30, 2011, 10:12:28 PM »

Missed that point - yes a thirds-out stop is a top 'extra' for me  - best of both Worlds  8)   Whatever les gars recommend - they both play kit with no thirds whatsoever. The pay-off being a fully chromatic left end.

Yeah,.. Gaillard doesnt build them with thirds and stops :-(
W
Logged
Please correct my English, it's been a while, and i like to learn.
And don't be so polite! I know i must be typing tons of stuff that a native speaker would say differently...please enlighten me.

www.wouterkuyper.nl
www.lirio.nl
www.trekzakacademie.nl

Cooper

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Offline Offline
  • Posts: 705
  • Gaillrd G/C/#,Casta Allain8 GC,Lofft CF, giord ad
    • Cooper's homepage
Re: Advantages/Disadvantages of thirdless chords
« Reply #19 on: October 30, 2011, 10:21:07 PM »

Well,..i have played for 20 years without a stop on my thrids. And i dont think i am one of the category "players for dancers need a lot of Oompah all the time". I actually think that when it is harmonically possible it is much prefered to play WITH the thirds. (a dorian tune without the thirds is very often a lot more dull for example). I prefer going for the Xm7 options instead of going for the thirdless-option any time, even now on a box that has no thirds, i opt for the extra colour   coming from the left hand, making sure the third is played somehow, even at the expense of a 7th being played as well.

Without the thirds you have more options, yes, but those options arent that much broadened on a 2row8B. On a 3row-manybase, yes.

W
Logged
Please correct my English, it's been a while, and i like to learn.
And don't be so polite! I know i must be typing tons of stuff that a native speaker would say differently...please enlighten me.

www.wouterkuyper.nl
www.lirio.nl
www.trekzakacademie.nl
Pages: [1] 2 3   Go Up
 


Melodeon.net - (c) Theo Gibb; Clive Williams 2010. The access and use of this website and forum featuring these terms and conditions constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.
SimplePortal 2.3.5 © 2008-2012, SimplePortal