Lots of laughs reading this thread - laughs of recognition. I'm aware of various facial tics and grimaces when playing, especially during more complicated push-pull/button manoeuvres, and my wife says I never smile. At public performances (informal get-togethers, having been chivvied into playing after the nth pint) I also have a tendency for a 'left-hand corner stare'. Some tunes I can play smoothly with a fairly nonchalant expression (e.g. a Goathland plough stots tune I heard/saw on the telly in 1979/80 - no idea what it's called, but it was on 'Here We Come A-Wassailing', a Christmas programme with an Albion Band soundtrack). I suspect being able to play automatically with the minimum of facial contortions is something akin to achieving a meditative state - certainly, if I catch myself thinking about what I'm doing, the reactions of others, etc., there'll be a bum note or a bit of fumbling.